무료

수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.

PT712E Church Finance in Practice: Budgets, Records and Safeguards

Lecture 6-2: When You Find a Problem

목차 25
PT712E Church Finance in Practice: Budgets, Records and Safeguards
제 0 장 · Introduction: Money That Was Entrusted
  1. Introduction: Money That Was Entrusted
제 1 장 · Week 1: Entrusted Money
  1. Lecture 1-1: Entrusted Money, Entrusted People
  2. Lecture 1-2: Who Does What with the Money
  3. Lecture 1-3: Why Openness Matters
  4. Lecture 1-4: Practice Lab: Mapping Our Money
제 2 장 · Week 2: The Budget
  1. Lecture 2-1: A Budget Is a Ministry Plan
  2. Lecture 2-2: Building the Budget
  3. Lecture 2-3: Reserves, Cash Flow and the Seasons
  4. Lecture 2-4: Practice Lab: A Year's Budget for an Invented Congregation
제 3 장 · Week 3: Receiving, Spending, Recording
  1. Lecture 3-1: Receiving and Counting Gifts
  2. Lecture 3-2: Spending: Request, Approval, Payment, Receipt
  3. Lecture 3-3: The Ledger and the Monthly Check
  4. Lecture 3-4: Practice Lab: Balancing an Invented Month
제 4 장 · Week 4: Safeguards and Checks
  1. Lecture 4-1: Never Leave It to One Person
  2. Lecture 4-2: Accounts, Cards and Cash
  3. Lecture 4-3: Checking: Audits and Warning Signs
  4. Lecture 4-4: Practice Lab: Finding the Gaps in a Procedure
제 5 장 · Week 5: Reporting and Special Funds
  1. Lecture 5-1: Reporting to the Congregation
  2. Lecture 5-2: Designated Gifts, Charity Funds and Missions
  3. Lecture 5-3: Pay and Expenses for Ministers and Staff
  4. Lecture 5-4: Practice Lab: Reading and Writing a Year-End Report
제 6 장 · Week 6: Hard Times and Responsibility
  1. Lecture 6-1: Shortfalls and Debt
  2. Lecture 6-2: When You Find a Problem
  3. Lecture 6-3: Law and Tax: Ask Locally
  4. Lecture 6-4: Practice Lab: A Review of Our Financial Practice

핵심만 먼저 보기 ↓

28분

A bookkeeper is preparing the monthly check. The bank statement and the ledger should agree, and this month they do not. The difference is small. She looks again, and the difference is still there. She knows what the usual answer would be: ask the treasurer. But the treasurer is also the person who made the entries that do not match, and he is away for two weeks. She has the sense that she knows something, and she does not know what. (an invented example)

Almost everyone who handles a congregation's money will meet a moment like this one. Most of the time the cause is an honest mistake: a figure typed wrongly, a payment entered twice, a receipt filed in the wrong month. Rarely, it is something worse. What the person does in the first hour and the first week can protect the congregation, protect the person who made the mistake, and protect the person who found it. It can also do the opposite.

This lecture gives a way through. The central claim of this course says the money was given to God and entrusted to a few. When something goes wrong with it, the few owe the many the truth, kindly told. The treasurer, the bookkeeper and the counter are not detectives, lawyers or judges. The ethic of this lecture is the same as in the whole course: keep, show, check, and pass on. Keep careful notes. Show what you have to the right person. Check only what you have the right to check. Pass the matter on to those whose task it is to decide.

이 28분으로 얻는 것

  • Tell an honest mistake from possible wrongdoing, and explain why the first steps are the same for both.
  • Describe what to do first when you notice something that does not add up, including what not to do.
  • Say whom to tell, and what to do when the person you would normally tell is the person concerned.
  • Explain how to protect a person who raises a concern, and why keeping records matters.
  • Explain why a possible wrong about money is kept separate from a private quarrel, when to ask a professional or an authority, and why care and fact-finding are given to different people.

If your brother sins against you, go, show him his fault between you and him alone. If he listens to you, you have gained back your brother. But if he doesn’t listen, take one or two more with you, that at the mouth of two or three witnesses every word may be established. If he refuses to listen to them, tell it to the assembly. If he refuses to hear the assembly also, let him be to you as a Gentile or a tax collector." — Matthew 18:15-17

World English Bible

The integrity of the upright shall guide them, but the perverseness of the treacherous shall destroy them." — Proverbs 11:3

WEB

He who gives answer before he hears, that is folly and shame to him." — Proverbs 18:13

WEB

Brothers, even if a man is caught in some fault, you who are spiritual must restore such a one in a spirit of gentleness; looking to yourself so that you also aren’t tempted." — Galatians 6:1

WEB

The first passage gives a pattern for a wrong between two people: go alone, then with others, then to the assembly. The second says that integrity guides, and its opposite destroys. The third warns against answering before hearing. The fourth asks for gentleness toward someone caught in a fault, and for care for oneself while doing it.

1. Begin by not knowing

The most useful sentence in this lecture is a modest one: "I do not know yet." A figure that does not match is a fact. The reason for it is not yet a fact. Between the two lies a space where people fill in what they fear. A bookkeeper who says "something is wrong" has said more than she knows. A bookkeeper who says "these two numbers differ by this amount, and I cannot explain it" has said exactly what she knows.

Proverbs 18:13 is a hard saying for anyone who finds something odd: answering before hearing is folly and shame. Most differences have ordinary causes. A cheque that has been written but not yet paid by the bank, a deposit made late on a Sunday and shown on Monday, a payment entered in the wrong category: these are the daily facts of bookkeeping. Lecture 3-3 explained how to match the ledger to the bank statement and what the usual reasons for a difference are. Work through those first. Many differences end there, and no one is troubled.

2. A mistake, or something worse?

Two cases should be kept in mind, and the difference is mostly intention.

A mistake is an honest error. A person did not know the rule, was tired, was rushed, was working alone with no one to check, or simply made a slip. Mistakes are the ordinary business of every office in the world.

Wrongdoing is deliberate. Someone knew and acted anyway: took what was not theirs, hid something, or misled others about it.

At the beginning, you cannot tell which it is. That is why the first steps are the same for both. In both cases, the facts must be written down carefully, the right person must be told, and no one should be accused or condemned before the facts are known. A treasurer who made an honest mistake deserves to be corrected and helped. A person who did wrong deserves to be treated fairly while the matter is sorted out. Both are served by the same careful path. If you treat every difference as a crime, you will wound innocent people. If you treat every difference as nothing, you will leave a danger in place. The path in between is slow, and it is the right one.

Notice also what this lecture does not describe. It does not describe how money can be taken. A person who handles money needs to know what a good check looks like, which is the work of chapter 4, and does not need a list of methods. The topic here is what to do when something looks wrong.

3. The first steps

When something does not add up, the following order serves well. It is a list of habits, not a legal procedure.

1. Stop and write it down. Note what you saw, the date, the document, the figures and what you did. Write facts, not conclusions. "The bank balance on the statement is 3 units lower than the ledger" is a fact. "Someone has been taking money" is a conclusion you cannot yet support.

2. Do not change anything. Do not correct the ledger, move a receipt, delete an entry or make a payment to "balance" things. A correction made in a hurry can destroy the evidence that would explain the difference. If a correction is truly needed later, it is made openly as a new, dated entry, as lecture 3-3 teaches, and not by rubbing out the old one.

3. Ask a plain question, if it is safe to do so. Often the quickest and kindest step is to ask the person who made the entry: "Can you help me understand this line?" Ask it in the tone you would use for any routine question. Many problems end here with a simple explanation. But if you think the person may be involved in wrongdoing, or if you would not be safe, or if asking might lead to the destruction of records, skip this step and go to the next. The question is a courtesy, and it is not a duty.

4. Tell the right person. The next section is about whom.

5. Say nothing more to others. This is as important as the rest, and it is the step that is hardest.

4. Do not accuse, and do not publish alone

The temptation, when you find something, is to talk. You may tell a friend in the congregation, because you are troubled and need to speak. You may post something. You may say something at a meeting. These are the steps that do the greatest damage.

A rumour about money spreads quickly and can never be fully taken back. If it proves false, a person's name has been marked for years. If it proves true, a rumour may warn the person to hide the evidence, and it may spoil a fair process. In either case the congregation learns about its finances from gossip and not from its leaders, which is the opposite of the openness chapter 1 taught.

So do not accuse, either the person or the group. An accusation says what you do not know. Do not publish alone: no message to the whole membership, no social media, no announcement from the front of the room, no letter to the denomination written in anger. You may tell the right person, quietly, and you may ask what to do next. You may also speak with a pastor, priest or trusted counsellor about how you feel, without naming the matter, if you need that support.

A good phrase to keep is: "I am not accusing anyone. I have found something I cannot explain, and I am bringing it to you so that it can be looked at properly."

5. Whom to tell

Every congregation should have an answer to this question before a problem arises. Ask: if I found a problem with the money, who is the person I would go to? In many settings the answer is the chair of the finance committee, the churchwarden, the pastor or priest, or the treasurer. In a parish, there may be a diocesan or regional office that expects to be told. In a free church, there may be an board or a trustee body.

Two difficulties follow, and they are real.

The person you would tell is the person concerned. Perhaps the treasurer made the entry, or the pastor approved the payment. Then go one level above, to the person or body that oversees them: the finance committee chair if the treasurer is involved, the board or the regional office if the pastor is. If there is no level above, as in a house church where one person does everything, seek a trusted adult outside the day-to-day work: another leader, an outside accountant who checks the books, or a trusted member of the denomination's office. The principle is simple. Tell someone who is not themselves part of the problem.

There is nobody obvious to tell. This is a sign that the congregation has not yet decided. When the matter is over, one of the best things the congregation can do is to write down, in one paragraph, who receives a concern about money and who receives it if that person is involved. Lecture 4-1 argued that nothing should depend on one person; this is the same principle applied to concerns.

6. Protect the person who raises a concern

The person who finds a difference and speaks is, in a sense, the one who has done the congregation a service. In most communities they are also the one at risk. They may be told they are disloyal. They may be treated coldly. They may lose a role. Even if their concern proves to be a mistake of their own, they acted in good faith.

Protection is simple to describe and difficult to do.

  • Receive the concern with thanks. The first response is "Thank you for telling me", not "Are you sure?" and not "Who else knows?"
  • Do not ask who told, and do not tell. Handle the information so that the source is known to as few people as possible. If the source cannot be hidden, say so honestly and do not promise confidentiality that cannot be kept.
  • No punishment for a concern raised in good faith. The person should not lose a place on a rota, a role or a friendship because they spoke. A written statement, agreed by the governing body, that this is the congregation's rule is worth having before it is needed.
  • Report back what can be reported. The person should hear, in time, that the matter has been received and is being looked at, even if the details cannot be shared.

A concern can also be mistaken. When it is, the response is the same: thank the person, explain what was found, and make it plain that raising it was right.

7. Keep the records

From the first moment, keep a small file. Put into it your dated notes, copies of the documents that matter, and a list of who was told and when. Keep it somewhere safe and private, not on a shared drive that many can open. Do not alter any original record. If you need to copy a document, leave the original where it was.

This file protects three people. It protects the congregation, because it shows what was known and when. It protects the person the concern is about, because a careful record can clear someone as easily as it can show a problem. And it protects you, because you can say exactly what you saw and did. A treasurer is not asked to be a detective, but a treasurer who has kept good notes has done most of what faithfulness requires.

8. When professionals or authorities are needed

The hardest question is when a matter should go beyond the congregation. There is no single answer that is correct in every country, tradition and case. Three points help.

First, some conduct is a crime, and some places require certain matters to be reported. The law differs between countries and over time, and this course cannot say what yours requires. The right step is to ask. The first people to ask are usually the denominational office or the diocese, and a lawyer who knows the local rules. Lecture 6-3 says more about asking locally.

Second, do not decide this alone. A single person's judgement, however good, about whether to involve outside authorities should be tested. The finance committee chair, the pastor or priest and the overseeing body can consider it together, with advice.

Third, some matters need professionals for other reasons. An accountant may be needed to examine the books. An insurer may need to be told within a set time under the policy; ask when you take the policy out, and not afterwards. A person's employment may raise questions that only someone with legal knowledge can answer. If the matter touches the safety of children or vulnerable adults, follow your congregation's safeguarding policy at once, and do not wait for the financial question to be resolved. This course does not teach that policy.

What the treasurer should not do is to play the investigator. Confronting a suspect, searching a person's belongings, demanding a confession and holding an informal trial are all outside the role. The treasurer's part is to keep, to show, to check what is hers to check, and to pass on.

9. A possible crime is not a private quarrel

Matthew 18:15-17 is often the first passage that comes to mind, and it is a good one. It describes how to deal with a wrong done to you: go to the person alone, then take one or two others, then bring it to the assembly. The pattern teaches patience, privacy first, and a path that goes wider only when needed.

It is also easy to misapply. The passage speaks of a brother who sins against you. That is a wrong between persons, and a gentle conversation can often heal it. A shortfall in the congregation's funds is different. The money was not yours, and the wrong, if there is one, is not against you alone. It is against everyone who gave. A treasurer cannot forgive a debt that is not hers, and cannot promise secrecy about something that belongs to the whole body. Nor does the passage settle whether civil authorities should be told. Christians differ on that. Some say the church should settle its own matters and shield its own people from the courts. Others say that a church that hides a possible crime protects the wrong and harms the weak. This lecture asks only that the question be put honestly, to people who know the law, and not decided by embarrassment.

In practice this means keeping two things apart. A private quarrel (a rude remark, a slight, a disagreement about how something should be done) belongs to the Matthew 18 pattern. A possible wrong about the congregation's money belongs to the careful path of this lecture: notes, the right person, advice. A congregation that mixes the two will treat a theft as a misunderstanding or a misunderstanding as a theft.

10. Care for the person involved

Behind every difference in the accounts there may be a person, and a person is more than the problem. A volunteer who made a mistake may be mortified. A person who did wrong may be in distress, in debt or in fear. Their family may be members of the same congregation.

Galatians 6:1 asks that someone caught in a fault be restored in a spirit of gentleness. The verse has a second half that is easy to miss: the one who restores must look to himself, because anyone can be tempted, and the mood of the one who restores should not be superiority.

Two practical points follow. Care and fact-finding are given to different people. The pastor or priest who cares for a person should not also be the one who examines the books, because the person will not know which hat is being worn, and the care will be mistrusted. Let the finance committee or an outside examiner look at the figures, and let a pastor or counsellor sit with the person. Care does not replace the process. A person who is being supported pastorally still needs the matter looked at properly, and the congregation is owed an honest account. Gentleness and truth go together.

If the matter ends in a mistake explained, the care is simple: a word of thanks to the person who raised it, and a word of reassurance to the person who made it. If the matter ends in wrongdoing, the care continues, but so does the process, and the congregation's life goes on with truth told as widely as is fair and no wider.

11. In a parish and in a free church

In a cathedral parish, the diocese may have a process for concerns about money and an office whose task is to receive them. The bookkeeper's task is to know that the office exists, and to use it. In a small assembly or house church, the principle is the same but the path is shorter. Everyone knows everyone, which makes silence more tempting and gossip more dangerous. The habit that serves both is the same: a written note of who receives a concern, a person outside the daily work to turn to, and a promise that nobody is punished for speaking in good faith.


Diagram 1. The path when something does not add up

When Something Does Not Add Up Keep, show, check what is yours to check, and pass on 1. Stop and write down the facts Date, document, figures. No conclusions. 2. Change nothing No erasing. No hurried corrections. 3. A plain question, if it is safe "Can you help me understand this line?" Explained? Record it and close it Thank the person. Correct by a new entry. 4. Not explained: tell someone The named person. If that is the person concerned, go one level above. 5. Decide together, with advice Accountant? Lawyer? Denominational office? An authority? Not one person alone. Protect the one who spoke Thanks. No hunt for the source. No punishment for good faith. Care for the person involved By a pastor or counsellor, not by the one who examines the books. What not to do Do not accuse. Do not publish alone. Do not play the detective. Do not promise secrecy you cannot keep. A possible wrong about the congregation's money is not a private quarrel.

핵심 요약

  • Begin with "I do not know yet": a figure that does not match is a fact, and the reason for it is not yet known.
  • The first steps are the same for a mistake and for wrongdoing: write down the facts, change nothing, ask a plain question if safe, and tell the right person.
  • Do not accuse and do not publish alone. A rumour about money can never be fully taken back.
  • Tell someone who is not part of the problem; if the usual person is involved, go one level above, and keep dated notes safely.
  • Protect the person who raises a concern: receive it with thanks, do not hunt for the source, and do not punish good faith.
  • A possible wrong about the congregation's money is not a private quarrel; ask a professional or the denominational office, and give care and fact-finding to different people.
Front Back
First sentence to say "I do not know yet." State what you saw, not what you fear.
First steps Write the facts, change nothing, ask a plain question if safe, tell the right person.
If the usual person is involved Go one level above, or to a trusted person outside the daily work.
Care and fact-finding Give them to different people, so the person cared for knows which role each one holds.

One sentence to remember When something goes wrong, keep notes, tell the right person early and gently, and never accuse or publish alone.

This week's action Write one paragraph that says whom a concern about money goes to in your congregation, and whom it goes to if that person is involved.

이 과목 요약 전체 보기 →

스스로 확인해 보세요

읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.

묵상 및 토론

  • In your congregation, if a bookkeeper found a difference she could not explain, who would she tell? Who would she tell if that person were involved? Is the answer written anywhere?
  • Why are the first steps the same for a mistake and for wrongdoing? What would go wrong if they were different?
  • What is the difference between "I have found something I cannot explain" and "someone has been taking money"? Why does the difference matter?
  • How does your congregation treat a person who raises an uncomfortable question? What would make it safer to speak?
  • Matthew 18:15-17 describes a path for a wrong between two people. Why is it not enough, by itself, for a concern about the congregation's money?
  • Why should the person who cares pastorally for someone not also examine the books? What are the costs of keeping the two roles apart, and of joining them?

로그인하시면 여기에 답을 적고 보관하실 수 있습니다

다음 단계

여기까지가 강의입니다. 아래는 읽은 사람들이 남긴 글입니다.