Lecture 2-1: A Budget Is a Ministry Plan
목차 25
- Lecture 1-1: Entrusted Money, Entrusted People
- Lecture 1-2: Who Does What with the Money
- Lecture 1-3: Why Openness Matters
- Lecture 1-4: Practice Lab: Mapping Our Money
- Lecture 2-1: A Budget Is a Ministry Plan
- Lecture 2-2: Building the Budget
- Lecture 2-3: Reserves, Cash Flow and the Seasons
- Lecture 2-4: Practice Lab: A Year's Budget for an Invented Congregation
- Lecture 3-1: Receiving and Counting Gifts
- Lecture 3-2: Spending: Request, Approval, Payment, Receipt
- Lecture 3-3: The Ledger and the Monthly Check
- Lecture 3-4: Practice Lab: Balancing an Invented Month
- Lecture 4-1: Never Leave It to One Person
- Lecture 4-2: Accounts, Cards and Cash
- Lecture 4-3: Checking: Audits and Warning Signs
- Lecture 4-4: Practice Lab: Finding the Gaps in a Procedure
- Lecture 5-1: Reporting to the Congregation
- Lecture 5-2: Designated Gifts, Charity Funds and Missions
- Lecture 5-3: Pay and Expenses for Ministers and Staff
- Lecture 5-4: Practice Lab: Reading and Writing a Year-End Report
A finance committee meets in January. The treasurer hands out a sheet with thirty lines and a number beside each line. Someone asks, "Why is the children's line smaller than last year?" The treasurer says, "That is what the spreadsheet gave." Nobody in the room has said what the congregation hopes to do this year. The numbers came first, and the work was left to fit them. (an invented example)
This lecture argues for the opposite order. A budget is a plan for ministry written in numbers, not a lid. The plan comes first: what will we do this year, for whom, and with whom? Then the numbers say what that plan will cost, and what we expect to receive in order to pay for it. A budget made in this order is a tool for faithful work. A budget made the other way round is a fence that nobody chose.
This week follows one road. Lecture 2-1 explains what a budget is and how to start. Lecture 2-2 builds one, step by step. Lecture 2-3 looks at the seasons of the year, the reserve and the cash that must be there each month. Lecture 2-4 is a Practice Lab with invented numbers. Behind all four stands the claim of the course: the money was given by people to God and entrusted to a few, so planning its use in the open is part of keeping faith with the givers.
이 21분으로 얻는 것
- Explain why a budget begins with a plan for ministry and not with numbers.
- State three jobs a budget does: it guides decisions, it tells the congregation what is intended, and it gives a measure to look back on.
- Describe a line-item budget and a ministry budget, and say what each does well.
- Use last year's actual results, and not last year's budget, as the starting point for a new year.
- Explain why a budget is neither a promise that money will arrive nor a lid that cannot be moved.
For which of you, desiring to build a tower, doesn’t first sit down and count the cost, to see if he has enough to complete it? Or perhaps, when he has laid a foundation, and is not able to finish, everyone who sees begins to mock him, saying, ‘This man began to build, and wasn’t able to finish.’" — Luke 14:28-30
World English Bible
The plans of the diligent surely lead to profit; and everyone who is hasty surely rushes to poverty." — Proverbs 21:5
WEB
Jesus uses the builder to speak about the cost of following him, and the main point of the passage is , not accounting. But he builds the picture from an ordinary piece of wisdom that his hearers already knew: a sensible person sits down and counts before building. We borrow only that small, shared wisdom. The proverb says something similar about plans. It does not say that planning brings wealth by itself. It sets the careful plan beside haste, and it says that haste does not end well.
1. Plan first, then count
Every congregation already has a plan, even if nobody has written it down. It is shown by what happens: a service on Sunday, a room opened for children, a visit to the sick, a gift sent to people in need far away, a roof kept sound. These things cost money. A budget makes the connection plain between the work that the people believe they are called to do and the money that the work needs.
Begin, then, with questions that have no numbers in them.
- What did we do last year that we want to keep doing?
- What did we leave undone that we should have done?
- What is new this year: a new person on the staff, a new room, a new need in the neighbourhood?
- What must we pay for whatever else we do: the building, the insurance, the pay of the people we employ?
When these questions are answered, the numbers have something to measure. A line that reads "children and young people: 100" means something if the committee has first said what it hopes to do for children and young people. A line that reads "children and young people: 100" with nothing behind it is only a guess about how much to take away from somewhere else.
This order also protects the people who decide. A committee that argues about numbers first argues about money. A committee that argues about the work first argues about what matters, and money follows. The second argument is harder and it is better.
2. What a budget is, and what it is not
A budget is a written statement, for a stated period, of what the congregation expects to receive and what it intends to spend, and for what. The period is usually a year, though some bodies use a different year-end. Three jobs follow from this.
It guides decisions. When a request arrives in March for something not in the budget, the budget tells the committee what the congregation said it would do, and what would have to give way.
It tells the congregation what is intended. The people who give have a right to know what is planned (this follows from lecture 1-3). A budget that is shared in the open invites questions before the money is spent, which is much better than questions afterwards.
It gives a measure. At the end of the year the congregation can set what happened beside what was planned. The difference is not a verdict on anyone. It is a piece of information, and the next budget will be better for having it.
Now say what a budget is not.
A budget is not a prediction that cannot be wrong. Income may be higher or lower than expected, and an unexpected repair may come. A budget is a considered intention.
A budget is not a promise to givers that a particular sum will be spent on a particular thing, unless the gift itself was given for that purpose. Gifts given for a stated purpose are another matter, and lecture 5-2 deals with them. A general budget describes how the general funds are intended to be used.
A budget is not a lid. The picture of a lid suggests that its main work is to keep things in. A budget is closer to a map made before a journey. A traveller may change the route when a bridge is down, but the map did the work of making the traveller think about the road. It can be changed by the right people in the right way, which lecture 2-3 explains.
3. Two ways to draw the same plan
Congregations draw their budgets in two main ways, and both have honest defenders.
The line-item budget lists costs by what they are: pay, utilities, insurance, repairs, printing, music, travel. Its strength is that it matches the way the money is recorded in the books (lecture 3-3 comes to this) and the way a bank statement reads. A treasurer can check each line easily, and an outside examiner knows at once what each line means. People who prefer it say that it is plain, that it leaves little room for confusion, and that it is hard to hide anything in it. Its weakness is that it hides the work. A committee reading "printing: 12" cannot tell whether the printing is for the children's course or for the weekly sheet.
The ministry budget lists costs by what the congregation is doing: worship, children and youth, care and visiting, outreach and mission, training, the building that makes the rest possible. Its strength is that members can read it and see their own congregation in it. People who prefer it say that the people who give should see work, not invoices, and that a committee weighing priorities must weigh work against work. Its weakness is that it needs decisions about where shared costs belong (does the electricity count against worship or against the whole building?) and that it can drift away from the books if nobody keeps the link.
This course asks for both, joined. Plan by ministry, because that is how people think and decide. Keep a line-item layer underneath, because that is how the money is recorded and checked. Each ministry area then has a total, and the total is made up of lines that the books can match. A small table can hold both:
| Ministry area | What we hope to do | Lines it contains |
|---|---|---|
| Worship and music | Weekly services, a festival | Music supplies, printing, hall costs |
| Children and youth | Weekly class, a summer week | Materials, snacks, travel |
| The building | Keep the place safe and usable | Utilities, repairs, cleaning, insurance |
A very small assembly, or a house church with one account, may need only five or six lines and one sentence of purpose beside each. That is a real budget. Size does not decide whether a budget is honest.
4. Start from what actually happened
When a congregation sits down to make next year's budget, it usually has two documents for last year: the budget it made and the actual results. Start from the actual results.
The reason is simple. Last year's budget shows what people hoped. Last year's actual results show what happened. A committee that copies last year's budget and adds a small percentage will carry last year's hopes into this year, including the ones that were wrong. A committee that starts from the actual results begins with the truth.
A useful sheet has three columns for each line:
| Line | Last year's budget | Last year's actual |
|---|---|---|
| Utilities | 20 | 24 |
| Children and youth | 10 | 7 |
| Special offering received | 8 | 11 |
(an invented example, in plain units)
Look at what the columns say. Utilities cost more than planned. Perhaps a cold winter, perhaps a rise in the supplier's price; the committee should ask. Children and youth spent less than planned, and the committee should ask why: did the work not happen, or did it cost less? These are the questions a budget exists to raise.
Do not copy last year's actual figures blindly either. Remove what will not return (a repair done once, a special gift that was a one-off) and add what is certain to come (a price rise already announced, a new member of staff). Write each change on the sheet with a short reason. Then a member who asks "why did this line change?" has an answer in writing.
If the congregation has no usable records for last year, because they were kept loosely or not at all, say so plainly. Take the bank statements and the receipts that exist, build the best account you can, and mark the sheet "estimated". The first honest budget will be rough. The second will be better. Lecture 3-3 shows how to keep the records that make this easier next time.
5. A parish and a free church
The same ideas hold across very different structures, but the details differ.
In a parish that belongs to a diocese or a similar body, part of the budget is not chosen locally. The parish may owe a fixed contribution to the central body, may receive grants, or may have its accounts held and approved by the diocese. The parish budget then has some lines set from outside. The local committee still plans its own work, and the central body's rules decide what must be sent, who must approve, and in what form the budget is submitted. Ask what your own body requires, and do the planning that remains yours.
In a free church that governs itself, the congregation or its elected body adopts the budget, and no outside office needs to approve it. That gives freedom, and it also means that nobody outside the congregation will notice if the budget is never made. In such a church the discipline must come from within.
In a house church with a single account, the budget may fit on one page. What matters is that the plan is written, that more than one person has read it, and that the people who give know in outline what it says.
Wherever you are, the useful question is the same: who must hear this plan, and who must agree to it, before it counts? The answer is written in your own rules. If it is not written, write it.
6. A budget and openness
Lecture 1-3 argued that the people who give are owed an account of what was done with their gifts. A budget is the first half of that account. It says what is intended. The year-end report (lecture 5-1) is the second half and says what was done. If the first half is missing, the second has nothing to be measured against, and a report of "what we spent" can mean very little.
This does not require that every member see every private detail. The budget can show the pay of the staff as a single line, as many congregations do, and still be a true budget. Readers will not all agree about how much detail to give, and lecture 5-3 takes up that matter. What this lecture asks is smaller: that the plan exist, that it be written, and that the congregation be told its outline.
7. Where to go next
This course does not teach the theology of giving or of the tithe; that belongs to LM302E, Money and . It does not teach staffing or whole-church leadership; PT702E, and Leadership, surveys those. Our task is the treasurer's weekly work, and the next lecture takes up the work of building a budget from the first request to the final vote.
Diagram 1. The yearly circle of a budget
핵심 요약
- A budget is a plan for ministry written in numbers: the work is decided first, and the costs follow from it.
- A budget does three jobs: it guides decisions, it tells the congregation what is intended, and it gives a measure to look back on.
- A budget is not a lid, not a perfect prediction, and not a promise that money will come.
- A line-item budget matches the books; a ministry budget matches the work; this course asks for both joined.
- Start the new year from last year's actual results, remove one-off items, add certain changes, and write a reason for each change.
- In a parish some lines are set from outside; in a free church the discipline must come from within.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Which comes first? | The plan for ministry comes first; the numbers say what it costs and how it will be paid for. |
| Three jobs of a budget | It guides decisions, tells the congregation what is intended, and gives a measure to look back on. |
| Line-item and ministry budgets | Line-item follows the books; ministry follows the work; join them with totals made of lines. |
| Where to start a new year | From last year's actual results, adjusted for one-off items and certain changes, each with a written reason. |
One sentence to remember A budget is a map for the year's ministry, drawn before the journey and open to change by the right people.
This week's action Write three sentences about what your congregation hopes to do this year, before you look at a single number.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- In your congregation, which comes first when the year's money is discussed: the work or the numbers? How can you tell?
- Think of one thing your congregation does every year. Can you say, in a sentence, what it costs? If you cannot, who could?
- Would a line-item budget, a ministry budget or a joined one suit your congregation best? What would be lost with each of the others?
- What documents exist for last year's actual results? Who keeps them, and who has read them?
- When your congregation's budget changes during the year, who must agree? Is that written anywhere?
- What would the people who give want to know about the budget, and how could they be told without exposing private matters?