Lecture 5-2: Speaking Responsibly: Sermons, Prayers, Notices and Posts
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: What a Crisis Is and What a Church Can Do
- Lecture 1-2: People in Crisis in Scripture, and God's Nearness
- Lecture 1-3: The Caregiver's Own Steadiness and Safety
- Lecture 1-4: Preparing Before It Happens
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: A Readiness Sheet
- Lecture 2-1: Safety First and Steadying
- Lecture 2-2: Listening, and Words to Leave Unsaid
- Lecture 2-3: Prayer and Scripture Beside Someone
- Lecture 2-4: Differences in How Crisis Is Shown: Culture, Age, Setting
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Reading and Rewriting a Conversation
- Lecture 3-1: Warning Signs and Common Myths
- Lecture 3-2: Asking Directly: The Basic Questions
- Lecture 3-3: General Principles of a Safety Plan
- Lecture 3-4: Staying With Someone: Presence, Handover and Follow-Up
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Practising the Question
- Lecture 4-1: How People React to Overwhelming Events
- Lecture 4-2: Safety, Choice and Trust
- Lecture 4-3: Avoiding Further Harm in Church Life
- Lecture 4-4: Faith, Trauma and "Where Was God"
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A Check of Our Practices
- Lecture 5-1: Beyond Stigma
- Lecture 5-2: Speaking Responsibly: Sermons, Prayers, Notices and Posts
- Lecture 5-3: After a Death by Suicide: Beside the Family
- Lecture 5-4: The Congregation as a Whole: Community After a Loss and Ongoing Prevention
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Checking What We Say
A church speaks in many voices: from the pulpit, in prayers, in the weekly notices, on a screen, in a printed bulletin, in a message group, in a social post, in an obituary or a memorial card. Most of these are written quickly. Most are read by people the writer cannot see, including some who are in pain tonight. Careful speech about suicide is called safe messaging. It rests on a simple idea: how a death or a struggle is talked about in public can help or harm people who are already at risk, and especially young people.
This lecture is about the public voice of the community. It does not teach what to say to one person in crisis (weeks 2 and 3 did that) or how to sit with a family (lecture 5-3 does). It teaches what to leave out of public speech, what to put in, and how to check before anything is said or posted. The week's thread holds: the caregiver is not the therapist but the person who stays beside, and the community's public words should make it easier, not harder, for someone to reach a person who will.
This course gives no diagnosis, no treatment, no medication advice and no medical advice, and it does not replace professional care. It also names no telephone number, website or service. Research your own country's and region's crisis lines and emergency services beforehand, keep the list where the people who answer the phone can find it, and, in public speech, point to that list and not to your own wisdom. If someone may be in danger now, stay with that person and contact emergency services at once.
이 23분으로 얻는 것
- State what must be left out of public speech about suicide, and why.
- State what can be put in: help, recovery, hope with honesty, and where to find the researched list.
- Rewrite a careless notice, a sermon line and a social post into responsible form.
- Explain why a death by suicide must not be used as a sermon illustration.
- Describe a simple check that a team can use before anything is published.
There is one who speaks rashly like the piercing of a sword, but the tongue of the wise heals." — Proverbs 12:18
World English Bible
Let no corrupt speech proceed out of your mouth, but such as is good for building up as the need may be, that it may give grace to those who hear." — Ephesians 4:29
WEB
Let your speech always be with grace, seasoned with salt, that you may know how you ought to answer each one." — Colossians 4:6
WEB
Joy comes to a man with the reply of his mouth. How good is a word at the right time!" — Proverbs 15:23
WEB
The proverbs say that words can wound or heal. Ephesians 4:29 gives a test: does this speech build up "as the need may be" and give grace to those who hear? In public, "those who hear" includes people the speaker does not know. Colossians 4:6 asks the speaker to think about each hearer. None of these verses is a rule about suicide. They are a way of thinking about all public speech, and this lecture applies them to one hard subject.
Who is reading and listening
When a pastor stands to speak, or a volunteer presses "post", the audience is wider than the people the speaker imagines. Among them may be someone who is quietly in despair. Among them may be a young person who has read about the subject online and is looking for any sign of how adults treat it. Among them may be a person who has lost someone, whose grief is still raw. Among them may be a person who is perfectly well today and who will remember a sentence for years.
Young people deserve special care. They tend to read widely online, to share quickly and to look closely at how a community responds to hard things. A careless post on a church page can be copied and carried far from the community that wrote it. It can stay a long time. Write each public word as though a young person who is struggling is reading it, because one may be.
What to leave out
Safe messaging asks the speaker to leave out certain things. These are not matters of taste. They are widely recognised in responsible prevention guidance, which you should check against what your own national and local bodies advise.
Leave out any method, any means, any place and any timing. Do not say, hint, or suggest how anyone harmed themselves, with what, where or when. Do not describe a scene. At most, say that someone "died by suicide" or "took their own life", or say "a way of harming oneself" if you must refer to the matter at all. Detail does not help the mourners. It can give an idea to someone who is vulnerable.
Never present suicide as a solution, as courage, as heroism, as peace or as an answer to a problem. A death is a loss. It is not an achievement, and it did not solve what the person was facing. Phrases such as "he is at peace now", "she has finally found rest" or "he was so brave" may sound kind. They can suggest to a listener in pain that this is a way out. Say instead that the person is missed and that their pain was real.
Leave out simple reasons. People often ask "why?" and a speaker may be tempted to offer a single cause: a failed exam, a lost job, a broken relationship. Suicide is almost never about one thing. Offering one cause is usually untrue, and it teaches the audience that a single bad event can lead there. It can also assign blame to a person, a family or a school.
Leave out the sensational. Do not use dramatic language, headlines or pictures meant to shock. Do not dwell on the last days. Do not speculate.
Leave out stigma. Do not use words that blame. The four phrases from lecture 5-1 do not belong in public speech either.
Leave out the person's private details. The family may not wish others to know. Ask them. Do not publish what they have not agreed to.
What to put in
Careful speech is not silence. A community that never speaks of the matter teaches that it cannot be spoken of. Put in:
- Help is real, and people recover. Say it without a number. Many people who have thought of ending their life find a way through. Say that help exists and that asking for it is a sign of sense, not weakness.
- Where to find the list. Point the listener to the list the community has researched beforehand: the local crisis lines, the emergency services and the professionals. In public speech, do not print a number or name a service here in this course, but in your own community, a notice may say, "A list of people and services who can help is kept at the front desk, and our pastoral team will go through it with you." Check that the list is current. A wrong number is dangerous.
- Who in the community will listen. Name a role, such as the pastor or the team, so that a person knows whom to approach.
- What to do if you are worried about someone. Stay with them, ask them plainly, and do not carry it alone. Say that anyone in danger now should have emergency services contacted at once.
- Warm, plain language. The tone that fits is quiet and respectful, not dramatic.
The sermon
A sermon is public speech, and it is easy to say too much from the pulpit. Some rules:
Do not use a death by suicide as a sermon illustration. Not a famous one, not one from the community's past, not a composite. Whatever the point, the story of a death becomes the thing the listeners remember. A person in the pews who has lost someone this way may hear their own loss turned into an example. A person at risk may hear a story with a death at the end of it. Find another way to make your point.
Do not preach about it in passing. A careless remark ("they say that people who do this are only seeking attention") is worse than silence. If you speak about the subject, plan the words in advance, read them to a colleague and keep them short.
If the subject is the message, prepare as a team, with the researched list in hand, and, where possible, with a trained person. Speak of hope, of help, of the nearness of God to the broken-hearted, and of the community's readiness to listen. Do not argue about the theology of the matter in front of the congregation. That discussion has its place in private, in teaching and with leaders, and not in a message heard by those who are bereaved or at risk. Lecture 5-1 set out why.
Use Scripture gently. A verse read aloud as comfort is different from a verse thrown at a person. Read what comforts, such as Psalm 34:18, without pointing it at anyone.
Prayers
Prayers in public are heard by everyone. A prayer may include the grieving and the troubled. It should be simple. Pray for people who are in great pain, for those who care for them, for those who work to help, and for those who mourn. Do not name a cause or a method. Do not pray as though the matter were a failing. Do not use a prayer to send a message to a particular person.
If the congregation knows of a specific loss, the family should decide how much is said. A prayer of the kind "we hold this family in our care" is enough.
Notices, bulletins and announcements
Notices are short and are read without a sermon around them. They need extra care for that reason.
(an invented example) Before: "It is with great sadness that we tell you that our dear brother Kwame took his own life. He had been struggling and nobody knew. Let this be a lesson to us all to watch the people around us."
This breaks several guidelines. It makes the manner of the death the headline. It speaks of the matter as if the community failed. It draws a "lesson" from a death. It speaks of the family's loss without having asked them. It also says "nobody knew", which can wound those closest.
After: "We are very sorry to tell you that Kwame has died. Our hearts are with his family and friends. The family has asked for privacy at this time. The pastoral team is available to anyone who would like to talk. A list of people and services who can help is available from the church office, and the pastor will go through it with anyone who asks."
The second version says what is true, asks nothing of the family beyond their wishes, names no cause or timing, draws no lesson and tells readers where to go. The family should agree to the wording before it is read or posted. If they would rather it said "died after an illness", the community should ask what they are able to say honestly, and should not say anything untrue. If the cause is not to be stated, say only that he has died.
Obituaries, memorial cards and tributes
The same rules apply to printed and spoken tributes. Speak of the person's life: what they loved, whom they served, the way they laughed, what they gave. Do not speak of the manner of death, and do not describe the pain as if it were a decision that made sense. Let the tributes be about the whole life.
A memorial service, which lecture 5-3 takes up, is a place where speakers need guidance. Give the speakers a short note in advance, and ask the family to approve the outline.
Social media, comments and messages
Posts can be shared, and comments grow. A few habits help:
- Two people check every post on a sensitive subject before it goes out.
- Do not post a photograph that suggests a place or a method.
- If a post draws comments, someone is assigned to read them and to remove any that give detail, blame the family or speculate. Say so to the person who posted, kindly.
- If someone posts a message that suggests they are in danger, do not reply in public. Make contact privately, as the pastoral team would in person, and if there seems to be danger now, contact emergency services. Do not ignore it because it is online.
- Do not use hashtags, trends or dramatic images to draw attention.
- Remember that what is posted stays. A kind post can still be found years later by a child in the family.
Different sizes of community
(an invented example) A rural parish of about forty people, served by a priest who also covers three other villages, has no staff and no office. When a member of the parish died by suicide, the priest took on the notice himself. He asked the family what they wished to say. He wrote two sentences. He read them at the end of Mass. He said he would be at the church hall on Thursday evening for anyone who wished to sit and talk, and that he had a list of helpers. He did not preach about the cause. He asked an to read any messages sent to the parish phone, so that he was not the only one.
(an invented example) A large city congregation with a media team of six had a different problem: its social page drew a fast, public flow of comments after a notice of death. The team had written a short note in advance for such cases and had two people on call. They removed comments that speculated, answered those that were kind and sent a private note to one person whose comment suggested they were struggling. The pastor was told at once and rang that person.
The tools differ; the care is the same. A parish with a phone and a printed sheet and a city congregation with a media team both owe the neighbour the same respect.
Advance work
The best time to prepare is before anything happens. A community can write, in an ordinary meeting:
- A short statement the leaders agree on, for use when a death has occurred and the family permits it.
- A checklist for sermons, notices and posts on this subject (see the diagram).
- A role for each task: who talks to the family, who writes, who approves, who watches comments, who rings the person who has posted something worrying.
- The researched list of local help, kept where the people who answer the phone can find it.
The checklist is short, and it is for the team, not for the grieving.
This course does not give legal advice. Rules about reporting, about publishing the names of people who have died, about children and about records differ by country and region. Check locally, and follow the church's own written policy.
5-3. What goes out, what stays out
5-4. A check before anything is published
핵심 요약
- Public speech about suicide is heard by people at risk and by the bereaved; young people read closely.
- Leave out any method, means, place or timing, and never present suicide as a solution, peace, courage or an answer.
- Do not offer one simple reason, do not sensationalise, do not blame, and do not publish private details unasked.
- Put in that help is real and people recover, where the researched list is kept, and who in the community will listen.
- Never use a death by suicide as a sermon illustration.
- Two people check every sensitive notice or post, and the family agrees the wording.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Safe messaging | Speaking about suicide so that it does not harm people at risk or the bereaved. |
| What to leave out | Method, means, place, timing; solution or heroism language; single reasons; blame; sensation. |
| What to put in | Help is real; recovery happens; the researched list; a role who will listen; danger now means emergency services. |
| Before publishing | Two people check; the family agrees; read it as a struggling young person would. |
One sentence to remember Say what helps, leave out what harms, and point to the people who can listen.
This week's action With one other person, draft a short, agreed statement for your community to use if a death occurs and the family permits it, and agree who would check it.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Think of a sermon, prayer or notice you have heard on a hard subject. What did it leave out, and what could a vulnerable listener have taken from it?
- Why is a death by suicide not suitable as a sermon illustration, even for a good purpose?
- Which of the "leave out" items would be hardest in your community? Which would be easiest?
- Who in your community would check a sensitive notice before it went out? Who would be the second person?
- How might the advice in this lecture look in a very small community with one volunteer, and how in a large one with a team?