무료

수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.

STEL8E Bioethics and Technology: Genetics, Life Extension and the End of Life

Lecture 2-1: IVF and the Status of the Embryo

목차 31
STEL8E Bioethics and Technology: Genetics, Life Extension and the End of Life
제 0 장 · Introduction: Why Think Theologically About Bioethics?
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Why Think Theologically About Bioethics?
제 1 장 · Week 1: Seeing Bioethics
  1. Lecture 1-1: Questions Before the Bedside
  2. Lecture 1-2: Principles, Virtues and Story: Three Ways to Judge
  3. Lecture 1-3: What Scripture and Tradition Say and Do Not Say
  4. Lecture 1-4: Persons in the Room: Cases and Judgement
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Grounds of My Judgement
제 2 장 · Week 2: The Beginning of Life
  1. Lecture 2-1: IVF and the Status of the Embryo
  2. Lecture 2-2: Genetic Testing and Prenatal Diagnosis
  3. Lecture 2-3: Gene Editing: Between Healing and Enhancing
  4. Lecture 2-4: Parents, Children and the Gift of Life
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Questions at the Start of Life
제 3 장 · Week 3: The Body, Organs and the Definition of Death
  1. Lecture 3-1: Whose Body Is It?
  2. Lecture 3-2: Organ Donation and Transplant
  3. Lecture 3-3: When Does Death Occur?
  4. Lecture 3-4: Dying and Rising: Death in Christian Hope
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: My Body, Entrusted
제 4 장 · Week 4: Prolonging Life and the Limits of Treatment
  1. Lecture 4-1: Two Faces of Life-Saving Technology
  2. Lecture 4-2: Not Starting and Stopping: Judging Life-Prolonging Treatment
  3. Lecture 4-3: Palliative Care and Hospice
  4. Lecture 4-4: Decisions Made Together: Patient, Family, Clinicians, Church
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Care I Hope For and Entrust
제 5 장 · Week 5: Euthanasia and the Theology of Suffering
  1. Lecture 5-1: Words and Map
  2. Lecture 5-2: The Strongest Arguments
  3. Lecture 5-3: Where Is God in Pain? Job, the Cross and a Theology of Care
  4. Lecture 5-4: Care That Does Not Abandon
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: What I Say in the Face of Suffering
제 6 장 · Week 6: Justice, Disability and the Community That Discerns
  1. Lecture 6-1: Who Receives Care? Justice and Access
  2. Lecture 6-2: Seeing Through Disability: Wholeness and the Dream of Enhancement
  3. Lecture 6-3: What the Church Does: A Community That Discerns Together
  4. Lecture 6-4: Questions for Any New Medical Technology
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: My One Page on Faith and Bioethics

핵심만 먼저 보기 ↓

28분

For many people the wish for a child is among the deepest wishes they have. For some of them the wish is not met, and the waiting brings real pain. Medical technology now offers some of these people a way forward. The best known of these ways is in vitro fertilisation, usually called IVF. "In vitro" is Latin for "in glass": the egg and the sperm are brought together in a laboratory dish and not inside the woman's body.

IVF is a good place to begin the second week, because it shows in one procedure both of the things the central claim of this course names. It can be a gift to people who long for a child. And it creates something that did not exist before: human embryos that live outside a body, for a time, in the hands of other people. What is an embryo? What do we owe it? Christians do not give one answer. This lecture sets out the main answers, each in its strongest form with its weak point, and then asks how a congregation can care for people on every side of the question.

The lecture neither urges nor forbids any treatment. It does not give medical advice. Laws, medical practice and the teaching of churches differ from country to country, and a reader who is facing a real decision should talk to a care team, a legal adviser where it matters, and a pastor or priest.

이 28분으로 얻는 것

  • Describe in general terms what IVF is, and name the questions about embryos that it raises (making, storing, choosing and discarding).
  • State three main positions on the moral status of the embryo, each in its strongest form, and name the weak point of each.
  • Describe, only as each tradition would say it, how Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant communities approach IVF.
  • Explain why the debate about abortion is close to this one and why it is not the same debate.
  • Describe how a congregation can care for people who are infertile, who have lost a pregnancy, or who are making a decision now, without judging any of them.

For you formed my inmost being. You knit me together in my mother’s womb." — Psalm 139:13

World English Bible

I will give thanks to you, for I am fearfully and wonderfully made. Your works are wonderful. My soul knows that very well." — Psalm 139:14

WEB

Your eyes saw my body. In your book they were all written, the days that were ordained for me, when as yet there were none of them." — Psalm 139:16

WEB

Before I formed you in the belly, I knew you. Before you came out of the womb, I sanctified you. I have appointed you a prophet to the nations.”" — Jeremiah 1:5

WEB

Behold, children are a heritage of Yahweh. The fruit of the womb is his reward." — Psalm 127:3

WEB

What the text says. Psalm 139 is a prayer of thanks. A person looks back on his or her own beginning and says that God knew and shaped it, and that the body is a wonder. Jeremiah 1:5 is a word of God to one prophet about his own : before his birth, God knew him and set him apart. Psalm 127:3 calls children a gift from God.

A tradition's reading. Many Christians read these passages as showing that God is present and active in human life before birth, and some read them as a ground for treating the unborn child with great seriousness. Others note that the passages are poetry and personal testimony and are not definitions of when a human life begins or what rights it has. Readers differ here, and the difference is real.

Our judgement. None of these verses mentions IVF, embryos in a dish, or any modern medicine. They tell us that life is a gift, that God cares for each person from the start, and that childlessness and children are both held in God's sight. They cannot settle by themselves the questions this lecture asks. A reader who says that a single verse decides the matter, in either direction, asks more of the verse than it can give.

1. The longing for a child

Begin with the people. In Scripture the wish for a child, and the grief of not having one, are given a great deal of room. The stories of Sarah, Rachel, Hannah and Elizabeth are stories of women who longed for a child and waited. They are told with respect and without blame. The same Scripture that calls children a gift in Psalm 127:3 also records the sorrow of those who did not receive that gift in the way or at the time they hoped.

Today, people may be unable to have a child for many different reasons, and sometimes no reason is found. Some wait for years. Some spend large sums or travel far. Some feel shame that they should not feel, because others have spoken carelessly to them. A pastor or a friend who begins with the longing, and not with a verdict, begins in the right place.

2. What IVF is, in general terms

We describe it only in general terms. In IVF, eggs are taken from a woman's body, and they are joined with sperm in a laboratory, so that fertilisation takes place outside the body. If it succeeds, one or more embryos begin to grow in the laboratory. An embryo is the human being in the earliest stage of development, from fertilisation onward; the word is used in different ways at different stages, and we use it here for the early stage. After a few days, one or more embryos may be placed in the womb of a woman, in the hope that a pregnancy will begin.

Several features of this are important for ethical thought. They are not features of every case, and they are not the same in every country, but they are common enough to name.

More embryos than are used. Often more embryos are made than are placed in the womb at one time. The rest may be kept by freezing for later use, given to another couple, given for research, or discarded. What becomes of these embryos is a question that some families and some clinics face.

Choosing. Embryos can sometimes be tested before they are placed in the womb. A choice may then be made between them. We come back to the larger question of testing in lecture 2-2.

The embryo outside a body. Before IVF, the earliest stage of a human being was always hidden inside a woman. Now it can be seen, held in a laboratory, stored and counted. That makes new questions possible, and it makes some old questions sharper.

Other ways in which others may be involved. Sometimes eggs, sperm or a womb are provided by a person other than the couple who will raise the child. We note this, and do not follow it further. The questions it raises (about parenthood, about payment, about the child's knowledge of origins) deserve their own study.

Success rates, costs and risks differ and change; we give no figures, and a reader should ask the care team for current information.

3. The question under the question: what is an embryo?

If an embryo is only a cluster of cells, then storing or discarding some of them is much like discarding other biological material, and IVF raises few questions of its own. If an embryo is a human person from the start, then discarding or risking embryos is the loss of a human life, and IVF is a very serious matter. Most Christians hold something between these two statements, or hold one of them with some hesitation. The disagreement is about the moral status of the embryo: what kind of regard, protection and rights it has.

This is a point where readers will not agree. Three main positions are found among Christians. We give each in the form its own holders would recognise.

First position: full status from fertilisation. Those who hold this say that a new, distinct human life begins when the egg is fertilised. From then on, the embryo is a member of the human family with its own direction of growth, and what it will become is the same being that it is now. A human being does not become a person at some later point by passing a test of ability; it is a person from the start, and its worth is the gift of God, and does not depend on size, age or usefulness. The strongest form of this view says that if we draw a line later in development, we have no principled reason not to draw it later still, and the weak and the dependent, the newborn and the severely ill, are then at risk. The weak point named by critics is this. The view needs a sharp line at fertilisation, but fertilisation is a process that takes time and not a single instant. A very high proportion of early embryos, by the natural course of things, do not continue to develop, and critics ask what this means for the claim that each is a person with full protection. Holders of the view answer that death from natural causes does not cancel the worth of a life, as we see in the case of infants who die; but critics find the question a real one.

Second position: developing status. Those who hold this say that the embryo deserves respect from the beginning, because it is human life and because it may become a child, but that its claim grows as it develops. In the earliest days, it has less claim than a later fetus or a born child, and the weight of other goods (the relief of childlessness, the cure of serious disease through research, in some views) may be set against it, though never lightly. The strongest form of this view says that it fits how we actually act and feel: most people grieve the loss of a pregnancy at twelve weeks more than the loss of an early embryo, and they do not treat the two as the same, and a view should not ask us to feel what we do not. The weak point named by critics is that the view needs to say where, and why, the status grows, and no point of development has been found that all agree on as the right one. A line drawn at a point of development can seem arbitrary, and the view can seem to rest on what people feel, and not on a reason.

Third position: a relational understanding. Those who hold this say that being a person is not a property that can be measured in the cell, but a matter of relationship: a being is treated as a person when it is received, welcomed and loved, first by God and then by a family and a community. The wanted embryo in a mother's womb, and the embryo that a couple has made in hope, stand within a web of care in a way that an embryo with no one to receive it does not. The strongest form of this view says that God's love for each person comes before anything the person can do and that human welcome is a sign of it. The weak point named by critics is that the worth of a human being then seems to depend on whether other people choose to welcome it, and that sits badly with the belief that worth is given by God and cannot be taken away by human choice. Holders of the view say that they do not make worth depend on welcome, but that they ask how a community should treat those placed in its care.

Several things are worth saying about all three. All three agree that the embryo is human life, and that it is not an object or a product. All three agree that it matters morally. They differ about how much it matters, and why, and how that weight stands against other weighty goods. All three can be held by faithful, thoughtful, prayerful people. What this course requires is that you can state each fairly, say where each is weak, and give reasons for your own judgement, if you have one. It does not require you to decide.

4. How the traditions speak

We name only what we are sure of, and we speak in broad strokes. A reader should consult the teaching of their own community directly.

Catholic teaching. The Catholic Church teaches that human life is to be respected from fertilisation. It has also taught that the beginning of a child should come from the loving union of husband and wife, and that a child should not be made in a way that separates the act of love from the making of a child. Two documents often named are Donum Vitae (1987), on respect for human life at its beginning, and Evangelium Vitae (1995), on the value of human life. On these grounds, the Church has not approved IVF, while holding that couples who long for a child deserve compassion and support, and that a child so conceived is a gift, and has the same worth as every other. Catholic teaching supports medical help that heals or assists the natural act, and calls couples to consider other forms of fruitfulness, such as and service.

Orthodox teaching. Orthodox Christians speak of life as a mystery and a gift, and of the human being as made for communion with God from the beginning. Many Orthodox writers urge great caution about technologies that make or discard embryos. We say only this in general, because the detailed positions are discussed within the Orthodox churches, and a reader should ask a priest of their own tradition.

Protestant streams. Protestant Christians differ more among themselves. Some, in several streams, hold that the embryo has full status from the start and have grave concerns about the way IVF is usually done, while some accept IVF where all the embryos created are placed in the womb and none are discarded. Others in the Reformed, Lutheran, Evangelical and Pentecostal families regard IVF as a legitimate use of medical skill in the service of a longed-for child, and give weight to the care of embryos without holding that a human person is present in the earliest days. Anabaptist communities may add concerns about cost and about what the church can offer to those who are childless. No stream speaks with a single voice.

5. The debate about abortion, touched with care

The question about the embryo is close to a larger one, which is the debate about abortion. We will touch on it briefly, because many readers will wonder how the two are related, and because some who read this have lived through it.

The two debates share a question: what is owed to human life in its earliest stages? But they are not the same. IVF is about making, storing and choosing among embryos, and most people who undergo it are hoping for a child. Abortion is about ending a pregnancy that has already begun, and it involves a woman's body, health and life, her circumstances, and often those of others. Within the church, the same people may hold different views on the two. Some hold that abortion is the ending of a human life and that the church must speak for the unborn; some hold that the decision belongs to a woman in her own conscience and circumstances, especially in cases of danger to her life, or rape, or grave illness in the child; some hold views between these. Traditions have spoken on it with different degrees of strictness. We do not argue the question here. Laws differ widely between countries, and so do the circumstances in which women make their choices.

What we say is this. A reader who has made this choice, or who has grieved a pregnancy that ended in any way, or who is deciding now, is in this room. So are readers whose convictions are strong in each direction. A good course does not describe any of them with words of judgement. A person in pain does not need an argument first. She or he needs someone who will listen, and who will not speak of sin or shame before the person has been heard.

6. Caring for the infertile and for those who have lost a pregnancy

Some of the most important pastoral work here is not about positions. It is about people.

For those who cannot have children. A community can listen without advising. It can avoid the careless remarks that wound: "Just relax", "It will happen when God wills", "You can always adopt." It can remember that the childless are not less whole, and that they have a place in the family of God that does not depend on bearing children. Some couples choose not to use IVF, and some choose to. Neither choice shows faith or its lack. A congregation can make Mother's Day and Father's Day, and the language of "blessed with children", easier for those who find them hard.

For those who have lost a pregnancy. Miscarriage and stillbirth are losses, and are often unspoken. A family may grieve a child no one else saw. A pastor or friend may simply say that the loss is real, that the child mattered, and that the family is not alone. Some traditions offer a prayer or a service for such losses; a reader may ask a priest or pastor what is available. This course does not cover grief and bereavement care. A reader who is grieving should speak with a pastor or priest and, where they are available, with local support services.

For those making a decision now. People who are considering IVF, or who have embryos stored and must decide what to do with them, are carrying a heavy load. A congregation can tell them that they are not judged, can offer to pray with them, and can leave the decision to them, with their care team and their own conscience. A church that insists on one answer in public and leaves the family alone with it in private has not cared for them.

7. What the course requires

Not every Christian will agree with the conclusions of this lecture, because it does not offer a conclusion. What it offers is this. IVF can be received as a gift, and it also gives us choices and burdens we did not have before. The question of the embryo's status is real, and thoughtful Christians answer it differently. The way to hold the question is to listen to the strongest form of each position, to know the weak point of each, and to stand beside the people who are living inside the question, with care and without judgement.


Diagram 1. Three positions on the embryo, each with its strength and its question

What is an embryo owed? Three positions among Christians, none called the correct one Full status from the start Developing status Relational understanding Strongest argument A new human life begins at fertilisation; worth is given by God, not earned by ability. A later line has no principled stopping place and puts the weak at risk. Strongest argument The embryo deserves respect from the start, and its claim grows as it develops. This matches how people grieve a loss early and later. Strongest argument Personhood is lived in relationship: God's love comes first, and human welcome is a sign of it. A community must ask whom it has received. Weak point named by critics Fertilisation is a process, not one instant; many early embryos do not continue to develop. What does that mean for full protection? Weak point named by critics Where, and why, does the claim grow? No point of development is agreed, and any line may seem arbitrary. Weak point named by critics Worth may seem to depend on whether others choose to welcome, which sits badly with worth given by God. All three say the embryo is human life and that it matters. They differ on how much, and why.

핵심 요약

  • IVF joins egg and sperm outside the body; it can be a gift to the childless, and it raises questions about making, storing, choosing and discarding embryos.
  • Christians differ on the embryo's moral status: full from fertilisation, developing, or understood in relationship; each has a strong argument and a weak point.
  • All three positions say the embryo is human life and that it matters; they differ on how much and why.
  • Catholic teaching does not approve IVF, while Orthodox and Protestant communities differ among themselves and within themselves.
  • The abortion debate shares the question of the embryo but is a different debate; readers in this room may have made hard choices.
  • Pastoral care begins with listening and without judgement, for the childless, the bereaved and those deciding now.
Front Back
IVF Joining egg and sperm in a laboratory so that an embryo may be placed in the womb; it raises questions about storing, choosing and discarding embryos.
Moral status of the embryo The kind of regard, protection and rights it is owed. Three Christian views: full from fertilisation, developing, relational.
Why Psalm 139 and Jeremiah 1:5 do not settle it They speak of God's care at the start of a life, in poetry and personal testimony; readers differ on what follows for the embryo.
How to care for the childless and the bereaved Listen first; avoid careless remarks; do not judge any choice; point to a pastor, priest or local support.

One sentence to remember The question of the embryo is held with its strongest argument and its weak point, and the people inside the question are held with care.

This week's action Write down one careless remark a person who longs for a child might hear, and one sentence you would say instead.

이 과목 요약 전체 보기 →

스스로 확인해 보세요

읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.

묵상 및 토론

  • Why does IVF raise questions that earlier ways of having children did not? Name two of them.
  • State one of the three positions on the embryo in a form that someone who holds it would accept. Then name its weak point without mocking it.
  • What do the three positions agree on? Why is it useful to begin with what they share?
  • Psalm 139 and Jeremiah 1:5 are often quoted in this debate. What do the texts themselves say, and what are they not able to settle?
  • What would you want a congregation to say, and not say, to a couple who long for a child? What would you want it to say to a person who has lost a pregnancy?

로그인하시면 여기에 답을 적고 보관하실 수 있습니다

다음 단계

여기까지가 강의입니다. 아래는 읽은 사람들이 남긴 글입니다.