Lecture 2-4: Parents, Children and the Gift of Life
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: Questions Before the Bedside
- Lecture 1-2: Principles, Virtues and Story: Three Ways to Judge
- Lecture 1-3: What Scripture and Tradition Say and Do Not Say
- Lecture 1-4: Persons in the Room: Cases and Judgement
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Grounds of My Judgement
- Lecture 2-1: IVF and the Status of the Embryo
- Lecture 2-2: Genetic Testing and Prenatal Diagnosis
- Lecture 2-3: Gene Editing: Between Healing and Enhancing
- Lecture 2-4: Parents, Children and the Gift of Life
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Questions at the Start of Life
- Lecture 3-1: Whose Body Is It?
- Lecture 3-2: Organ Donation and Transplant
- Lecture 3-3: When Does Death Occur?
- Lecture 3-4: Dying and Rising: Death in Christian Hope
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: My Body, Entrusted
- Lecture 4-1: Two Faces of Life-Saving Technology
- Lecture 4-2: Not Starting and Stopping: Judging Life-Prolonging Treatment
- Lecture 4-3: Palliative Care and Hospice
- Lecture 4-4: Decisions Made Together: Patient, Family, Clinicians, Church
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Care I Hope For and Entrust
- Lecture 5-1: Words and Map
- Lecture 5-2: The Strongest Arguments
- Lecture 5-3: Where Is God in Pain? Job, the Cross and a Theology of Care
- Lecture 5-4: Care That Does Not Abandon
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: What I Say in the Face of Suffering
- Lecture 6-1: Who Receives Care? Justice and Access
- Lecture 6-2: Seeing Through Disability: Wholeness and the Dream of Enhancement
- Lecture 6-3: What the Church Does: A Community That Discerns Together
- Lecture 6-4: Questions for Any New Medical Technology
- Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: My One Page on Faith and Bioethics
The first three lectures of this week were about technologies: IVF, testing, editing. This lecture steps back from the technologies and looks at the people they touch most: parents and children, and the family that holds them. It asks what the Christian tradition means when it calls a child a gift and not a product, what a family is for, and how a congregation can speak with couples and families at the start of life without pressure and without judgement.
This is the place where the argument of the week is gathered. The central claim of the course says that life is a gift of God and that technology can serve that gift, while also handing us choices and burdens we never had before. In the family, the gift is received, and the burdens are carried, and both are felt in a real house with real people. The lecture offers ways of thinking, not a rulebook. It gives no medical advice and neither urges nor forbids any treatment or test.
이 22분으로 얻는 것
- Explain in your own words what it means to call a child a gift and not a product, and say what risks the word "product" names.
- Describe what Scripture says about children and the family, and what it leaves unsaid about technology.
- Explain how the question of the future of a family is shaped by technology and by pressure, from within and from outside.
- Describe how a congregation can speak with couples and families without pressing them in any direction.
- Say what a congregation should avoid saying to those who have used technology, those who have not, and those who could not.
Behold, children are a heritage of Yahweh. The fruit of the womb is his reward." — Psalm 127:3
World English Bible
They were bringing to him little children, that he should touch them, but the disciples rebuked those who were bringing them." — Mark 10:13
WEB
But when Jesus saw it, he was moved with indignation, and said to them, “Allow the little children to come to me! Don’t forbid them, for the Kingdom of God belongs to such as these." — Mark 10:14
WEB
He took them in his arms, and blessed them, laying his hands on them." — Mark 10:16
WEB
What the text says. Psalm 127:3 calls children a heritage, a gift, from the Lord. In Mark 10, people bring children to Jesus, the disciples try to send them away, and Jesus is angry. He welcomes the children, says that the kingdom belongs to such as these, takes them in his arms and blesses them.
A tradition's reading. Christians have read these passages as saying that children are received and not earned, that they have a place in the community of faith, and that the community must not turn them away. Some traditions draw from Mark 10 a reason for ; others draw from it a reason for blessing children and for welcoming them to worship. Many read Mark 10:15 as saying that all of us enter the kingdom as children receive, with open hands, and not by achievement. These readings differ in their practice; they share the belief that a child is welcomed.
Our judgement. These passages do not mention technology, testing or any way of having a child. Psalm 127:3 does not mean that a couple without children has been denied God's favour, and Mark 10 does not tell us how a family should decide about treatment. They tell us how a child should be regarded. Applying them to the questions of this week is a work of judgement.
1. A gift and not a product
When Scripture calls children a "heritage" or a "gift" it is making a claim about how they come to us. A gift is something that is received. It is not owed to us, it is not made to our specification, and it cannot be bought. A gift comes with surprise: we do not know in advance who the child will be. And a gift is received with gratitude and with responsibility: it is to be cared for, not owned.
The opposite word, in much of modern talk, is product: something made to order, to a design we choose, in return for what we pay, which we may return or reject if it does not match what we wanted. Nobody who writes about children in medicine says that a child is only a product. But the language of choice and quality can drift in that direction. If a family speaks of the "right" child, or of a child "who turns out well", the child begins to stand under a condition: she is welcome if she measures up.
Some Christian writers see this as one of the main spiritual risks of reproductive technology. They do not say that every use of technology makes a child a product. They say that the habit of thought that goes with it, in which we plan and select and expect results, can change how we receive a child. A family that has used a technology with love and gratitude may receive a child perfectly well. A family that has used none may still be anxious to control how the child turns out. The question of gift and product is not settled by the method. It is a matter of the heart, and a matter of the culture around the family.
This should be said just as clearly in the other direction. To call a child a gift does not mean that the one who longs for a child, and who seeks medical help, has set aside the gift. Wanting a child, working for a child, and receiving a child with thanks all belong together. A gift can come through the hands of a doctor as well as through other ways. Many Christians, in all traditions, say with thanks that their child came through medical help. Others hold that some methods change what is being received. These are real differences, and we described them in lecture 2-1. What most of them share is the sense that the child, once there, is simply the child, and is welcomed.
2. What a child is not: some quiet pressures
A congregation is likely to know several kinds of pressure on a family, some of them quiet.
The pressure to have children. In some communities, a married couple who do not have a child are asked about it, or prayed over, or quietly pitied. This pressure may fall most heavily on women. It can hurt those who cannot have a child, those who have chosen not to, and those who are waiting.
The pressure to have a certain kind of child. In some places, a boy is more welcome than a girl, or a healthy child more welcome than a child who has a disability, or a child who fits the family's hopes more than one who does not. We name this plainly, because testing and choice make such pressures easier to act on. A Christian community that says "every child is a gift" has to look at where it lets such pressures speak.
The pressure to use every technology. As more is possible, it can start to seem that a responsible family must do all that can be done: test, screen, treat. A family may feel that not to do it is negligent, or that it will be blamed afterwards. Where this happens, freedom is lost. A family that decides, after prayer and with good information, not to use a test or a treatment has made a choice that deserves respect. So has a family that decides to use it.
The pressure of cost. Not every family can pay for what is offered. Some are shamed by that. Some are pressed into debt. It would be a failure of love for a congregation to treat a family's ability to pay as a measure of their faith or their love of the child.
3. The family and the future
A family is not only a couple and their child. It is parents and grandparents, brothers and sisters, a household, a village or a congregation. In Scripture, the family is the place where life is handed on: stories are told, faith is taught, the old are cared for and the young are raised. When Psalm 127 speaks of children as a gift, it is speaking within a view of a family as a line that goes forward and backward in time.
Technology alters the view in several ways. It may delay having children, by making it seem possible to wait. It may extend the possibilities for those who thought they could not have a child. It may bring knowledge of what a child may become, or what may come to be in a family's line, and with it fear. It may make the family a place of planning, and put weight on the decisions of the parents. And it may leave some parents to carry choices alone that earlier generations met as a matter of fate or of .
The Christian tradition can offer something in answer. It can say that the future of a family is not secured by control, and also not left without care; that the love of parents is real and so is the love of God for the child; that a family is part of a larger family, the church, which stands beside it. It can say that a child's life is not a project that parents must get right. A child is a person, with a life of her or his own before God, whom parents serve and do not own.
None of this takes away the weight of the choices that parents have to make. It may put them in a different light. A decision made out of love, in prayer, with the best help available, is a decision that a family can carry, even if it is hard, and even if the outcome is not what was hoped.
4. How a congregation speaks with couples and families
Here is a pattern of how a congregation might speak with those at the start of family life. We give it as an invented example (an invented example), and the family in it does not exist.
A couple in a parish, whom we shall call Daniel and Marta, have been married for several years. They have no children and have wanted them. They have been to see doctors, and are now asking whether to try a treatment that the clinic has described. They are tired, and they are not sure. They have told their pastor, a woman named Anna, only that they are "thinking about something".
The pastor does not begin with her own view. She asks, "What would help most to talk about today?" Marta says that she is afraid of being judged, whichever way they choose, because some people in the church had said unkind things about those who had used medical help, and others had said unkind things about those who had refused. Anna listens. She says that she has no wish to judge, that she will pray for them, and that the decision belongs to them, with their doctors and in their own conscience. She asks whether they would like to hear what their church's teaching says, and also what other traditions say, so that they can weigh it, and they say yes. She gives it plainly, including where it is hard.
She does not promise that all will be well, and she does not say that this must be God's will. When they leave, she tells them that whatever they decide, and whatever happens, they are welcome. She offers to meet again, or to find them someone who has walked a similar road. She also keeps what they have told her to herself.
Several things are worth noticing in the example, and they carry a general pattern.
She began with a question and not a position. The couple were not examined. They were asked what would help.
She named the choice as theirs, with their doctors and their conscience, and offered the church's teaching as a resource and not as a verdict.
She did not say what could not be known. "God's will" and "all will be well" are claims that no one can honestly make for a particular outcome.
She promised welcome without conditions. That is what a congregation can truly promise.
She kept a confidence. What a family tells a pastor is not for the prayer chain.
A congregation in a different country, or a different tradition, may do this in a different form. A priest in an Orthodox parish, a pastor in a small assembly, a lay leader in a house church, a senior woman who is trusted by the young wives: any may do it. What matters is the pattern.
5. What the church must not say
It can help a congregation to name some things that should not be said, because they are said often, with good intentions, and do harm.
- "It's just not God's plan for you to have children." No one knows this.
- "God will give you a child if you have enough faith." This puts the childless under suspicion of unbelief, and ignores the many faithful people who have not had children.
- "You should be grateful for the child you have." This silences grief.
- "At least it happened early." This minimises a loss.
- "You're wrong to use this." / "You're wrong not to use this." A pastor may state the church's teaching. To use it as a stick is not pastoral.
- "I'm sure the baby will be fine." Nobody can be sure.
And some things that can be said without harm:
- "I'm glad you told me."
- "I don't know what to say, and I am with you."
- "Whatever you decide, you are not alone."
- "I will pray for you and your family, and I will not ask what you decided."
6. What the course asks of you
The point of this week has been that the start of life is a place of hope, and also a place of choices and burdens. The question of the embryo, the testing of the unborn, the possibility of editing: each is a place where technology gives something and asks something. What a Christian community can offer is not a single answer. It is a way of standing: to receive each child as a gift, to hear the strongest form of each argument, to know where each is weak, and to stand beside the people who have to decide, who have lost, or who wait.
Diagram 1. Gift and product: two ways of receiving a child
핵심 요약
- Scripture calls children a gift, which is received, not owed or ordered; "product" names a risk in the habit of mind.
- The method alone does not settle gift or product; a child can be received with thanks after medical help or without it.
- Families feel quiet pressures: to have children, to have a certain kind, to use every technology, and to pay for it.
- A family is a line through time; the future is not secured by control, and a child is a person and not a project.
- A congregation begins with a question, names the choice as the family's, keeps confidences and promises welcome.
- It avoids claims no one can know, such as "God's plan" or "all will be well", and does not blame those who chose differently.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| A child as gift | Received, not owed or ordered; welcomed before any test of worth; a person with a life of her or his own. |
| A child as product | A risk in the habit of mind: welcome depends on measuring up. It can occur with or without technology. |
| Quiet pressures | To have children, to have a certain kind, to use every technology, to be able to pay. |
| How a congregation speaks | Starts with a question, offers teaching as a resource, keeps confidences, promises welcome, claims nothing it cannot know. |
One sentence to remember Every child is received as a gift, and every family at the start of life is met with a question, a welcome and no pressure.
This week's action Write two sentences you could say to a family at the start of life, and one sentence you would take care never to say.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- What does it mean to call a child a gift and not a product? Why might the second word name a real risk?
- Why does the course say that the method alone does not settle whether a child is received as a gift?
- Name two quiet pressures on a family at the start of life. How might a congregation add to them, and how might it lift them?
- In the invented example, which things did the pastor do that you think were helpful? Is there anything you would add?
- Why is it better to say "I will pray for you" than "It must be God's will"?