무료

수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.

STEL8E Bioethics and Technology: Genetics, Life Extension and the End of Life

Lecture 3-3: When Does Death Occur?

목차 31
STEL8E Bioethics and Technology: Genetics, Life Extension and the End of Life
제 0 장 · Introduction: Why Think Theologically About Bioethics?
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Why Think Theologically About Bioethics?
제 1 장 · Week 1: Seeing Bioethics
  1. Lecture 1-1: Questions Before the Bedside
  2. Lecture 1-2: Principles, Virtues and Story: Three Ways to Judge
  3. Lecture 1-3: What Scripture and Tradition Say and Do Not Say
  4. Lecture 1-4: Persons in the Room: Cases and Judgement
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Grounds of My Judgement
제 2 장 · Week 2: The Beginning of Life
  1. Lecture 2-1: IVF and the Status of the Embryo
  2. Lecture 2-2: Genetic Testing and Prenatal Diagnosis
  3. Lecture 2-3: Gene Editing: Between Healing and Enhancing
  4. Lecture 2-4: Parents, Children and the Gift of Life
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Questions at the Start of Life
제 3 장 · Week 3: The Body, Organs and the Definition of Death
  1. Lecture 3-1: Whose Body Is It?
  2. Lecture 3-2: Organ Donation and Transplant
  3. Lecture 3-3: When Does Death Occur?
  4. Lecture 3-4: Dying and Rising: Death in Christian Hope
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: My Body, Entrusted
제 4 장 · Week 4: Prolonging Life and the Limits of Treatment
  1. Lecture 4-1: Two Faces of Life-Saving Technology
  2. Lecture 4-2: Not Starting and Stopping: Judging Life-Prolonging Treatment
  3. Lecture 4-3: Palliative Care and Hospice
  4. Lecture 4-4: Decisions Made Together: Patient, Family, Clinicians, Church
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Care I Hope For and Entrust
제 5 장 · Week 5: Euthanasia and the Theology of Suffering
  1. Lecture 5-1: Words and Map
  2. Lecture 5-2: The Strongest Arguments
  3. Lecture 5-3: Where Is God in Pain? Job, the Cross and a Theology of Care
  4. Lecture 5-4: Care That Does Not Abandon
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: What I Say in the Face of Suffering
제 6 장 · Week 6: Justice, Disability and the Community That Discerns
  1. Lecture 6-1: Who Receives Care? Justice and Access
  2. Lecture 6-2: Seeing Through Disability: Wholeness and the Dream of Enhancement
  3. Lecture 6-3: What the Church Does: A Community That Discerns Together
  4. Lecture 6-4: Questions for Any New Medical Technology
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: My One Page on Faith and Bioethics

핵심만 먼저 보기 ↓

25분

For most of history, the question “Has this person died?” was answered by looking and listening. The breath stopped. The heart stopped. The body grew cold. Modern medicine changed this. Machines can now keep the breath and the circulation of the blood going in a body when other parts of the person’s life have stopped. This has raised a question that is both medical and deeply human: when a person’s heart is still beating because a machine is helping, has the person died?

This is a hard lecture. Some readers will have stood at a bedside where this question was real, and some may be standing there now. If that is you, please read gently, stop when you need to, and speak to your care team and your pastor or priest. This lecture does not give medical advice and it does not tell any family what to do. It does not describe medical tests or procedures. Its task is to help you understand the question, the main positions, and why sincere Christians answer it differently.

이 25분으로 얻는 것

  • Explain in general terms what is meant by the heart-lung criterion and the brain criterion of death, without medical detail.
  • Say why machines that support breathing made the question of death more difficult.
  • State the argument for accepting the brain criterion and the argument for doubting it, each with its weak point, so that a holder of each view would accept your account.
  • Explain how the question connects to organ donation, and why it needs to be answered before donation after death can be considered.
  • Describe how a pastor or priest may stay with a confused family, and say why laws and criteria differ from country to country.

Yahweh God formed man from the dust of the ground, and breathed into his nostrils the breath of life; and man became a living soul.” — Genesis 2:7

World English Bible

and the dust returns to the earth as it was, and the spirit returns to God who gave it.” — Ecclesiastes 12:7

WEB

So teach us to number our days, that we may gain a heart of wisdom.” — Psalm 90:12

WEB

Genesis 2:7 tells how the human being came to life: dust from the ground and the breath of life from God. Ecclesiastes 12:7 describes the end in matching terms: the dust goes back to the earth and the spirit goes back to God. Psalm 90 is a prayer about the shortness of human life and the wisdom of knowing it. Readers have often used the first two verses to think about death as a kind of undoing of what Genesis 2:7 describes. That is a reading and not a plain statement of the text. The verses say nothing of machines, brain function or tests, and they do not tell us at what moment the breath of life is gone. A Christian who says that “the Bible defines death as the stopping of the breath” and a Christian who says that “the Bible defines death by the brain” have both gone beyond the text.

1. How death used to be known

Take the long view first. In nearly every culture, and for most of the history of the church, death was recognised by a few plain signs. The person no longer breathed. The heart no longer beat. The body did not respond. Soon it grew cold and stiff. People did not need a theory to know that someone had died, and a family could sit with their dead without a doctor.

In the language of medicine this is called the heart-lung criterion (some say the circulatory criterion): a person has died when breathing and the heartbeat have stopped for good. Nothing in this understanding is foolish. It rests on the visible fact that without breath and blood, nothing else lasts.

2. What changed

In the middle of the twentieth century, medicine learned to do things that earlier generations could not. A person whose own breathing had stopped could be helped to breathe by a machine, and a heart could be supported. Many people lived who would once have died. This is a gift, and families are grateful for it.

But there was a new kind of case. For some patients, a severe injury had destroyed the working of the brain in a way from which, doctors judged, there would be no return. Yet the machine kept the lungs moving and the blood flowing, so the body stayed warm and the chest rose and fell. To someone at the bedside, this person looked asleep. And the doctors said, in effect, “The person has died.”

This is a hard thing to hear, and it is easy to see why. How can someone who is warm and breathing, even with help, be dead? It is the question this lecture exists to answer, and the honest answer is that thoughtful people differ.

In the late twentieth century, many countries and medical bodies came to accept a second way of recognising death: the brain criterion, often called brain death. The idea, in general terms, is that when the whole brain, or the part of it on which the person’s basic life depends, has stopped working and will not work again, the person has died, even though machines may keep other organs working for a time. The exact definition, and the tests used, differ from one country and one medical body to another. Some places accept both criteria. I will not describe tests or details, because they differ, because I cannot give medical advice, and because a family in this situation should hear these things from the doctors who care for them.

3. The theological questions this raised

For Christians, this is not only a medical matter. It touches what we believe about the human person. Several questions arise.

What is a person, and what is death? A common Christian way of speaking is that death is the separation of the soul from the body, and the picture is close to Ecclesiastes 12:7. If that is the picture, when does the separation happen? Doctors can say when certain functions have ended. They cannot, by their instruments, observe the soul. So there may be a gap between what medicine can say (these functions have stopped for good) and what theology means by death (the separation of soul and body). Different Christians fill the gap in different ways.

Is death a moment or a process? Some writers say that death is an event that happens at a point, and the question is only how to recognise it. Others say that dying is a process in which different parts of the body stop at different times, and that to name one moment is to simplify. Both want to be faithful to the facts. The difference matters because if death is a process, then a statement such as “the person died at 3.00 p.m.” may be a decision made for practical reasons, and not a discovery.

Who decides, and for what purpose? If criteria for death are set by a society, what keeps them from being shaped by other needs, including the need for organs? This is one of the questions that has made some Christians uneasy. We will return to it.

4. What traditions say, with care

I describe the traditions only where I am fairly sure, and I mark the rest.

The Catholic Church has taught that it is for medicine to describe the signs of death, and that the Church does not itself set the medical criteria. Over recent decades, Catholic teaching has accepted that the brain criterion can be used to determine death when it is applied carefully and with full certainty, and it has also asked for care that no one’s life is cut short in order to obtain organs. At the same time, some Catholic scholars have argued that the brain criterion is not well founded. In other words, within the Catholic world there is both an official openness and a lively debate.

Among Protestant churches, there is no single position. Many accept the medical criteria and leave the judgement to doctors and families, while some Protestant writers raise doubts. Some Orthodox writers and communities have expressed caution about the brain criterion, stressing the mystery of the departure of the soul and the danger of deciding too quickly; others accept the judgement of medicine. I say this with less confidence, and a reader from the Orthodox tradition is the right person to speak for it.

If you want to know what your own church holds, ask your pastor or priest, or look at what your church has said in its own words. Do not assume that your tradition has one answer.

5. The positions, fairly

This is a point where readers will not agree. The disagreement is not between people who care about the dying and people who do not. It is between people who each want to tell the truth about a person at a bedside.

The case for the brain criterion. Those who hold it argue that the body of a living person is more than a collection of working parts. What makes it a living human body is that the parts are held together and act as a whole under the direction of the brain. When the brain’s part in this has ended for good, what remains is a set of organs that machines keep moving, and not the life of the person. On this view, the heartbeat in such a case is like the movement of a limb: it goes on without the whole. They add that to keep a body going in this state is to prolong a kind of appearance, and that it is a mercy to the family to say plainly that the person has died, so that they may begin to grieve. The strongest form of this view is that it takes the unity of the person seriously. Its weak point is the claim that the brain is the part that holds the body together: some say this is not as clear as it seems, because in some cases the body continues to carry on activities that look like the functions of a living whole, and because the argument may not be easy to prove. Another weak point is the worry that this criterion became widely accepted at the same time as transplantation made it useful, so that its defenders may be thought to be too ready to find a reason that serves the need. Those who hold the view reply that the questions were raised for the sake of the patient too, because the machines had created the question whether to go on, and that the criteria were set for reasons that did not depend on donation.

The case for doubting it. Those who doubt it argue that the person at the bedside is warm, with a beating heart, and looks as a sleeping person looks. If the heartbeat, the circulation and other functions are still there, they say, it is a large step to say the person is dead. They also hold that Christian tradition respects the body as the person, and that we should be slow to declare death while the body still shows signs of life. They add that the criterion appeared when organs were needed, and that this should make us cautious. Some in this camp say that death is better described as a process, and that the heart-lung criterion is a safer one. The strongest form of this view is that it errs on the side of the vulnerable, because if we are uncertain whether someone is dead, we should treat them as living. Its weak point is that it has to explain what is meant by being alive in a case where, by all medical accounts, the brain’s functions have ended and cannot come back, and where the machine, not the person, keeps the body going. It also faces the question of what would then be asked of families and carers: how long, and for what end. Those who hold the view reply that this is a hard question, and that the answer is to let the dying be cared for, and not to redefine death.

Many people hold a position between these two. A person may accept the brain criterion as the best medical judgement, while being unsure about its theology. A person may hold that the criterion is sound, but feel strongly that it should be applied with the greatest care. A person may refuse to decide, and say that the question lies beyond what we can know, while still trusting the doctors’ care. This course does not ask you to choose. It requires that you can state each view fairly, say where each is weak, and see that each is trying to protect the person.

There is a close link between this question and organ donation, and it should be stated plainly. Many organs that are used for transplantation work best when the person’s blood is still flowing at the moment of removal. That is why the question of when death has come is so pressing for donation after death. The rule that is widely held in medicine and in the churches is that organs should be taken only from a person who is truly dead, and that no one should be hastened to death in order to give organs. This is called the dead donor rule, and it is the reason why the criteria of death matter so much for donation.

A person who doubts the brain criterion may therefore be troubled about donation, because they worry that it is being asked of someone who may not be dead. A person who accepts the criterion may see no difficulty. Both are acting from conscience. Some systems also allow donation after a person’s heart and breathing have stopped, under rules that differ from place to place, and this approach is described differently from the brain criterion. I mention it only to show that there is more than one way in which this question is handled, and the laws and the practices differ by country. If you are facing a real decision, ask your care team to explain the rules where you live, and speak with your pastor or priest and a legal adviser.

7. The confusion of families

Most of this lecture has been about arguments. But the people who meet this question are not usually reading arguments. They are in a hospital, tired, afraid, and being told something that they cannot make sense of.

(An invented example.) A father’s daughter has been in an accident, and doctors say she has died by the brain criterion. But her chest is rising and falling, her hand is warm, and the monitor shows a heartbeat. The father cannot take it in. A relative says, “We should wait for a miracle.” Another says, “The doctors know.” The father asks the hospital chaplain, “Is my daughter alive?” He does not want a lecture. He wants someone who will not leave him.

What can a pastor or priest do? Listen first. Do not argue about definitions in the first hour. Do not say that those who accept the criterion lack faith, and do not say the same of those who question it. Be honest about what you know, and do not pretend to a medical certainty you do not have. Help the family to ask the care team questions, and to get the answers explained in plain language, in their own language if possible. Offer prayer in a way that does not decide what the family should do. Stay. A family that has been given time and company is often better able to hear the news and to say goodbye. This course does not cover the care of grieving families. If that is your , your own pastor or priest or a chaplain’s training will help you, and a family in need should be pointed to them and to local help.

8. What this course requires

We began with the verses. Genesis 2:7 and Ecclesiastes 12:7 give a picture of life and death as breath and return. They do not tell us at what moment the breath has gone. The Christian tradition has not ruled that one medical criterion is the only faithful one. It has asked that death be recognised honestly, that the dying be treated with respect, that no one be hurried towards death for the sake of another, and that families be accompanied. These are the points on which most Christians agree, and the course asks you to hold them.


Diagram 1. Two criteria, two arguments

When does death occur? Two ways medicine recognises death, and two ways readers weigh the second Heart-lung criterion Breathing and heartbeat have stopped for good. The long-standing way of knowing death. Visible to anyone at the bedside. Brain criterion Brain function has ended and will not return, though machines may support other organs. Tests and rules differ by country. For accepting it The brain holds the body together as a whole; what machines keep going is not the person. Weak point: is the brain really the unifier? Did the need for organs shape the criterion? For doubting it A warm body with a heartbeat looks alive; in doubt, protect the vulnerable. Weak point: what does "alive" then mean where the brain has ended and a machine keeps going? Link: donation after death needs an honest answer to "has death come?" (the dead donor rule). Laws and criteria differ by country. Ask the care team, a legal adviser and your pastor or priest.

핵심 요약

  • Death was long recognised by the stopping of breath and heartbeat; machines that support breathing made the question harder.
  • The brain criterion says that when brain function has ended for good, the person has died even if machines keep other organs going; criteria and tests differ by country.
  • Christians ask what a person is and whether death is a moment or a process; the Bible’s breath-and-dust verses do not name a moment.
  • Readers differ: one view stresses the brain’s unifying role, another warns against declaring death while the body shows signs of life; each has a weak point.
  • Donation after death needs an honest answer to when death has come; families need company and plain explanation, not a test of faith.
Front Back
Heart-lung and brain criteria Death recognised by the end of breathing and heartbeat; or by the end, for good, of the brain’s functions even when machines support other organs.
The case for the brain criterion The brain holds the body together as a whole; what machines keep going is not the person. Weak point: the unifying role is debated, and the need for organs may have shaped the criterion.
The case for doubting it A warm body with a heartbeat looks alive; in doubt we protect the vulnerable. Weak point: what “alive” means where the brain has ended.
The dead donor rule Organs are taken only from a person who is dead, and no one is hastened to death to give them.

One sentence to remember Sincere Christians answer the question of death differently, and each answer should be heard with its weak point and with care for the family.

This week's action Practise saying, in two plain sentences, why a person might accept the brain criterion and why another might doubt it, without saying who is right.

이 과목 요약 전체 보기 →

스스로 확인해 보세요

읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.

묵상 및 토론

  • How did machines that support breathing make the old question “Is this person dead?” harder to answer?
  • State the case for the brain criterion and its weak point so that a holder of the view would accept your account. Do the same for the case for doubting it.
  • Why do Genesis 2:7 and Ecclesiastes 12:7 not settle the question, even though readers have often used them to think about it?
  • Why does the question of when death has come matter for organ donation after death, and what is the dead donor rule?
  • If a family were confused by what doctors told them, what would help them from a pastor or priest, and what should be avoided?
  • Why is it unwise to say that someone who accepts, or someone who doubts, the brain criterion lacks faith?

로그인하시면 여기에 답을 적고 보관하실 수 있습니다

다음 단계

여기까지가 강의입니다. 아래는 읽은 사람들이 남긴 글입니다.