Lecture 2-3: Gene Editing: Between Healing and Enhancing
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: Questions Before the Bedside
- Lecture 1-2: Principles, Virtues and Story: Three Ways to Judge
- Lecture 1-3: What Scripture and Tradition Say and Do Not Say
- Lecture 1-4: Persons in the Room: Cases and Judgement
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Grounds of My Judgement
- Lecture 2-1: IVF and the Status of the Embryo
- Lecture 2-2: Genetic Testing and Prenatal Diagnosis
- Lecture 2-3: Gene Editing: Between Healing and Enhancing
- Lecture 2-4: Parents, Children and the Gift of Life
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Questions at the Start of Life
- Lecture 3-1: Whose Body Is It?
- Lecture 3-2: Organ Donation and Transplant
- Lecture 3-3: When Does Death Occur?
- Lecture 3-4: Dying and Rising: Death in Christian Hope
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: My Body, Entrusted
- Lecture 4-1: Two Faces of Life-Saving Technology
- Lecture 4-2: Not Starting and Stopping: Judging Life-Prolonging Treatment
- Lecture 4-3: Palliative Care and Hospice
- Lecture 4-4: Decisions Made Together: Patient, Family, Clinicians, Church
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Care I Hope For and Entrust
- Lecture 5-1: Words and Map
- Lecture 5-2: The Strongest Arguments
- Lecture 5-3: Where Is God in Pain? Job, the Cross and a Theology of Care
- Lecture 5-4: Care That Does Not Abandon
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: What I Say in the Face of Suffering
- Lecture 6-1: Who Receives Care? Justice and Access
- Lecture 6-2: Seeing Through Disability: Wholeness and the Dream of Enhancement
- Lecture 6-3: What the Church Does: A Community That Discerns Together
- Lecture 6-4: Questions for Any New Medical Technology
- Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: My One Page on Faith and Bioethics
Genes are the units of inheritance that sit in almost every cell of the body. Scientists have developed tools that can, in principle, change them: remove a change that causes illness, or alter a gene in other ways. This is called gene editing. The hope is that some serious inherited illnesses might one day be treated or prevented at their root. The fear is that the same tools might be used to shape children to order, to widen the gap between rich and poor, or to change the human family in ways that cannot be undone.
This lecture introduces gene editing in general terms, in the conditional. It does not say what can be done now, because the field changes quickly and a lecture is a poor place for news. It asks a question that will help whatever the state of the science: where is the line between healing and enhancing, and who can draw it? It sets out the argument that editing is "playing God", with its strength and its weakness, and it asks about the poor and about inequality. It describes, only in outline, how Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox writers approach the matter.
The lecture neither urges nor forbids any technology and gives no medical advice. Laws and rules about gene editing differ from country to country and change over time; a reader should not take anything here as a description of what is allowed or possible in a given place.
이 25분으로 얻는 것
- Describe in general terms what gene editing is, and explain the difference between editing body cells and editing the germline.
- Explain why the difference between healing and enhancing is hard to draw, and give an example of how it blurs.
- State the "playing God" argument in its strongest form, and name where it is strong and where it is weak.
- Explain why questions of justice and inequality are part of the ethics of gene editing.
- Describe in outline how different Christian traditions approach the matter, without ranking them.
God blessed them. God said to them, “Be fruitful, multiply, fill the earth, and subdue it. Have dominion over the fish of the sea, over the birds of the sky, and over every living thing that moves on the earth.”" — Genesis 1:28
World English Bible
When I consider your heavens, the work of your fingers, the moon and the stars, which you have ordained;" — Psalm 8:3
WEB
what is man, that you think of him? What is the son of man, that you care for him?" — Psalm 8:4
WEB
For you have made him a little lower than God, and crowned him with glory and honor." — Psalm 8:5
WEB
For the creation waits with eager expectation for the children of God to be revealed." — Romans 8:19
WEB
For the creation was subjected to vanity, not of its own will, but because of him who subjected it, in hope" — Romans 8:20
WEB
that the creation itself also will be delivered from the bondage of decay into the liberty of the glory of the children of God." — Romans 8:21
WEB
What the text says. Genesis 1:28 gives humankind a blessing and a task of dominion over the earth, and Psalm 8 wonders at the place of humans: small beside the heavens, and yet crowned with honour and given rule over the works of God's hands. In Romans 8:19-21 Paul says that creation itself has been subjected to decay and waits in hope to be set free.
A tradition's reading. Many Christians read these passages as saying that human beings have a real to care for and shape the world, including the human body in medicine, and that this calling is exercised under God and answerable to him. Others read them as a warning: the same dominion can be turned to pride, and the "decay" of Romans 8 is not something that humans can remove by their own work. Readers also differ on whether the "creation" of Romans 8 includes the human body and its illnesses, and on how far the hope of Romans 8 shapes what we may attempt now.
Our judgement. Scripture does not mention genes. These passages cannot tell us whether a particular edit is right. They give us two truths to hold at once: we are called to work and to heal, and we are creatures who do not make ourselves. How to weigh the two in a particular case is the work of judgement, and Christians do it differently.
1. What gene editing is, in general terms
We begin with a plain picture, without detail that may go out of date.
A gene is a section of the instructions that the body's cells carry. Some illnesses come from a change in a gene that is passed down in families. Gene editing is the name for a set of methods that, in principle, can alter those instructions at a chosen place: remove a harmful change, correct it, or switch something on or off. In this lecture we speak of the methods in the conditional. They might be used for this. They could in the future be used for that. Whether and how well they work in a given case is a question for scientists and care teams, and we do not claim to know.
Two points are important for ethics. The first is that editing is different from selecting. In prenatal testing, or the choosing of embryos that we met in lectures 2-1 and 2-2, a family chooses among existing possibilities. In editing, a change is made. The second is that editing always carries uncertainty. Altering one thing in a body that is a web of linked parts may have effects that are not intended and not seen at once. The more we can imagine, the more careful we need to be about what we claim.
2. Two kinds of editing
The most important distinction in the whole subject is between editing the cells of a body and editing the germline.
Body-cell editing (often called somatic editing, from a Greek word for "body") changes cells in a person who already exists, perhaps to treat an illness that person has. The change stays in that person. It is not passed to their children. In ethical terms it is close to other medical treatments, though each treatment has its own risks and costs. Many people, from many traditions, see this as acceptable in principle where it heals, while asking the usual questions about safety, consent and fair access.
Germline editing changes the cells that are passed on: the egg or the sperm, or an embryo at its earliest stage. The change then reaches every cell of the person who grows from it, and it can be passed on to that person's children and their children's children. It is heritable. This makes germline editing different in kind. It affects someone who cannot consent, because that someone does not yet exist. It affects descendants who are not yet imagined. And it may be impossible to reverse once it has spread through a family line. For these reasons many writers, including many who accept body-cell editing, are far more cautious about the germline. Some hold that it should never be done; some hold that it might be justified later, under tight conditions, to prevent a grave illness; some say the question cannot be answered until more is known. They differ in what they ask and how they weigh the risks.
Editing an embryo is also tied to the questions of lecture 2-1. An embryo that is edited is an embryo made or used in the laboratory, and a reader's view of the embryo's status will affect how they see the matter.
3. Healing and enhancing
The most discussed question about gene editing is the difference between healing (treating or preventing an illness) and enhancing (improving a trait beyond what is normal or needed for health: strength, height, memory, appearance, and the like). Many people say that healing is permitted, even good, and that enhancing is something else, and perhaps should not be done.
The difference seems clear at the ends. A change that would remove a gene that causes a painful inherited illness looks like healing. A change that would give a healthy child extra height for sport, or a trait for beauty, looks like enhancement. In the middle, it blurs.
What counts as normal? Health is not a single measure. If a trait raises the chance of illness a little, is reducing that chance healing or enhancing? If a person is short and unhappy about it, is making them taller healing? Where there is a spectrum, the line can shift depending on whom we ask.
What counts as an illness? Societies have often called conditions "diseases" and later changed their minds. Some conditions are seen by the people who have them not as illnesses but as part of who they are, and this is a view that disabled people and Deaf communities have argued with force. It raises the question of who decides what needs healing. We return to this in lecture 6-2.
Preventing and improving blur. A change that makes a person less likely to fall ill with a disease might also be described as an improvement. If many people were given it, would it have become the new "normal", and would those without it be thought of as lacking?
None of this means that the distinction is useless. It means that the distinction needs care and humility, and that it should not be treated as though it settles everything. A tradition may hold that healing is a Christian vocation, as the Gospels show Jesus healing, and still see that people will disagree about what counts as healing.
4. "Playing God"
Many people say, when they hear of gene editing, that it is "playing God". It is worth taking the claim seriously, in its strongest form, and asking what it can and cannot carry.
This is a point where readers will not agree. One group says that the claim names a real danger. In its strongest form, the claim is not about a forbidden area of knowledge. It is about pride: the temptation to take the place of the one who gives life, to treat what has been given as a thing we own and design, and to think that we are wise enough to decide what kind of human being is good to have. Scripture's stories of Babel and of the first temptation warn about this reach. This group may add that a world in which parents design children has changed what a child is: from a gift received to a product ordered, and a child who is a product may be loved on conditions.
The weakness of the claim, according to those who doubt it, is that it proves too much. Human beings have been shaping nature from the beginning, by farming, by breeding animals, by medicine. We do not say that a doctor who removes a tumour or sets a bone is "playing God", but we are glad of the doctor. If the phrase condemned all intervention in the body, it would condemn healing too. It may also work as a slogan that stops a conversation, when what is needed is an argument that tells us which acts are prideful and which are acts of care. Some who doubt the phrase add that to refuse to heal when we could is also a way of deciding, and that Christians are called to relieve suffering.
The other group, then, says that the phrase is too crude, and that the real work is to say which interventions serve life and healing and which grasp at control. They may hold that dominion in the Bible is a care-taking rule under God, and that gene editing, used for healing, can be a form of love for the neighbour.
The strongest form of the first group's position has a weak point: it needs a way to tell pride from care, or it condemns everything. The strongest form of the second group's position has a weak point of its own: it needs to say what would count as going too far, or it permits everything. What this course requires is that you can state each position, say where it is weak, and give reasons for your own view. Many readers will hold that the answer lies in the question of what an act is for, and in who is helped and who is left out. These are the questions we turn to next.
5. The poor, and inequality
Questions of justice are never far from technology, and they are close here.
If editing, or any other genetic technology, were to become available, it would probably cost a great deal at first. If so, the wealthy would be able to use it and the poor would not. We speak in the conditional, and we do not claim that this is how things will be. But history gives reason to ask. If the wealthy could give their children advantages that were built into the body, and these advantages were passed on, the gap between the rich and the poor might become a gap in the human body itself, a difference that no amount of effort could close. This is a question about justice, and it is also a question about the human family: whether we are one family with one shared nature, or whether we might become something else.
A second concern is for those who bear the burden of the research. Some people, in some places, may be asked to take part in experiments because they have few other options. And a third is for the child who may one day be born into a world where "choosing" has become expected. If parents come to feel that it is irresponsible not to use every available means, the freedom of a family to welcome the child they have may be reduced.
Scripture has much to say about justice for the poor, and we turn to it in lecture 6-1. Here we note only this. A technology that would heal many but be used by few has an ethical weight that the technology itself does not carry. Questions about who has access, who decides, and who is left out are part of the ethics of gene editing from the start.
6. How the traditions approach it
We name only what we are sure of. These are broad strokes, and a reader should consult the teaching of their own community.
Catholic teaching. Catholic teaching holds that medicine that heals is good and that human beings share in God's care for creation. It also holds that the human being is not a product, and it speaks with great caution about any technology that treats a child as something to be designed, or that makes or destroys embryos. The distinction between therapy (treating illness) and manipulation (altering a person for other ends) is important in this tradition. A reader should consult official Catholic teaching documents for detail.
Orthodox teaching. Orthodox writers stress the human being as made in God's image and for communion with God, and they often speak of the risk of a technological attitude that forgets the mystery of the person. Many urge caution toward interventions that alter what is passed on to future generations. Positions are discussed within the Orthodox churches, and a reader should ask a priest of their own tradition.
Protestant streams. Protestants differ. Many in the Reformed, Lutheran, Evangelical and Pentecostal families stress that medicine is a good gift and a way of loving the neighbour, and so are open in principle to body-cell therapy for serious illness. Many are far more careful about the germline, about embryos, and about enhancement, and give the reasons already named: consent, uncertainty, pride and justice. Anabaptist writers often stress the community and the poor. As in the other streams, there is no single Protestant view.
All of these traditions can say two things together. We should heal where we can, and we should be wary of the desire to remake the human being. The question is how each weighs the two, and what each takes to be the line.
A final note. Some people hold that if many human abilities could be improved, people might one day wish to remake themselves in ways that go far beyond medicine. That question, about the human person and the dream of remaking ourselves, belongs to AI and the Human Person (STEL6E). This course does not cover it.
Diagram 1. Where editing can happen, and where the lines blur
핵심 요약
- Gene editing, in principle, alters the instructions in cells; we speak of it in the conditional and make no claim about what exists now.
- Body-cell editing stays in one person; germline editing is heritable, and affects those who cannot consent and may be hard to reverse.
- Healing and enhancing are clear at the ends and blurred in the middle; what counts as normal or as illness is disputed.
- "Playing God" names a danger of pride but proves too much if it condemns all healing; its strength and weakness both matter.
- Justice is part of the question: a costly technology could widen the gap between rich and poor.
- Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant writers all value healing and are cautious about remaking the human being, and they weigh the two differently.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Body-cell vs germline editing | Body-cell changes stay in one person; germline changes are heritable, affect those who cannot consent, and are hard to reverse. |
| Healing and enhancing | Clear at the ends, blurred in the middle; what counts as normal or as illness is disputed. |
| "Playing God" | Strong as a warning against pride and treating children as products; weak because it may condemn all healing and does not say which acts are pride. |
| Why justice belongs here | A costly technology could be used by the rich and not the poor, and widen the gap in the human family itself. |
One sentence to remember We are called to heal and not to grasp at control, and the work of judgement is to tell the two apart, together and with the poor in view.
This week's action Write one sentence naming a change you would call healing and one you would call enhancing, and note where you were unsure.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- What is the difference between editing body cells and editing the germline? Why do many people treat the second with more caution?
- Give an example of a change that seems to be healing and one that seems to be enhancing. Then give one where the two blur. What makes it hard?
- State the "playing God" argument in a form that someone who holds it would accept. Then say why others find it too crude.
- Why does it matter whether a technology could be used by the poor as well as by the rich?
- Both Genesis 1:28 and Romans 8:19-21 are sometimes quoted in this debate. What do they say, and what can they not settle?