Lecture 6-2: Seeing Through Disability: Wholeness and the Dream of Enhancement
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: Questions Before the Bedside
- Lecture 1-2: Principles, Virtues and Story: Three Ways to Judge
- Lecture 1-3: What Scripture and Tradition Say and Do Not Say
- Lecture 1-4: Persons in the Room: Cases and Judgement
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Grounds of My Judgement
- Lecture 2-1: IVF and the Status of the Embryo
- Lecture 2-2: Genetic Testing and Prenatal Diagnosis
- Lecture 2-3: Gene Editing: Between Healing and Enhancing
- Lecture 2-4: Parents, Children and the Gift of Life
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Questions at the Start of Life
- Lecture 3-1: Whose Body Is It?
- Lecture 3-2: Organ Donation and Transplant
- Lecture 3-3: When Does Death Occur?
- Lecture 3-4: Dying and Rising: Death in Christian Hope
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: My Body, Entrusted
- Lecture 4-1: Two Faces of Life-Saving Technology
- Lecture 4-2: Not Starting and Stopping: Judging Life-Prolonging Treatment
- Lecture 4-3: Palliative Care and Hospice
- Lecture 4-4: Decisions Made Together: Patient, Family, Clinicians, Church
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Care I Hope For and Entrust
- Lecture 5-1: Words and Map
- Lecture 5-2: The Strongest Arguments
- Lecture 5-3: Where Is God in Pain? Job, the Cross and a Theology of Care
- Lecture 5-4: Care That Does Not Abandon
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: What I Say in the Face of Suffering
- Lecture 6-1: Who Receives Care? Justice and Access
- Lecture 6-2: Seeing Through Disability: Wholeness and the Dream of Enhancement
- Lecture 6-3: What the Church Does: A Community That Discerns Together
- Lecture 6-4: Questions for Any New Medical Technology
- Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: My One Page on Faith and Bioethics
Much of this course has asked how Christians should use medicine at the edges of life. A great deal of medical technology aims at a goal that sounds obvious: to repair what is broken and to make the body whole. This lecture asks a question that is easy to skip. Who decides what counts as "broken", and who decides what counts as "whole"? For many disabled people, the answer has too often been decided by others, and decided in a way that left them out.
This lecture listens to disabled people's own voices. It describes general ways of thinking about disability, sets out the critiques that disabled people and their families have made of screening, cure and enhancement, and reads two passages, 2 Corinthians 12:9 and John 9:1-3, that have often been used badly. It does not say that disability is good or that it is bad, and it never treats a disabled person as a burden or as an example for an argument. Disabled people are among the readers of this course, and some of them are its teachers.
이 22분으로 얻는 것
- Describe in general terms two or three ways of understanding disability and say why the choice between them matters for medicine and for the church.
- State fairly the critiques disabled people have made of screening, cure and enhancement, and the replies of those who hope for treatment, each with its weak point.
- Explain how 1 Corinthians 12:22-26 speaks of weakness and the body of Christ, and how it has been misused as well as used well.
- Describe the different readings of 2 Corinthians 12:9 and John 9:1-3, and why neither should be used to explain a person's disability.
- Say in one sentence how the dream of enhancement connects to this course, and where to read more.
No, much rather, those members of the body which seem to be weaker are necessary. — 1 Corinthians 12:22
World English Bible
whereas our presentable parts have no such need. But God composed the body together, giving more abundant honor to the inferior part, — 1 Corinthians 12:24
WEB
that there should be no division in the body, but that the members should have the same care for one another. — 1 Corinthians 12:25
WEB
When one member suffers, all the members suffer with it. Or when one member is honored, all the members rejoice with it. — 1 Corinthians 12:26
WEB
He has said to me, “My grace is sufficient for you, for my power is made perfect in weakness.” Most gladly therefore I will rather glory in my weaknesses, that the power of Christ may rest on me. — 2 Corinthians 12:9
WEB
As he passed by, he saw a man blind from birth. — John 9:1
WEB
His disciples asked him, “Rabbi, who sinned, this man or his parents, that he was born blind?” — John 9:2
WEB
Jesus answered, “Neither did this man sin, nor his parents; but, that the works of God might be revealed in him. — John 9:3
WEB
In 1 Corinthians 12 Paul describes the church as a body with many members and says that those which seem weaker are necessary. The passage is about the community of believers, using the body as a picture. In 2 Corinthians 12 Paul speaks of a weakness he carried and of the answer he received; the text does not say what the weakness was. In John 9 the disciples ask whether a man's blindness is someone's fault, and Jesus rejects that frame. Each of these passages has been read in ways that comfort and in ways that wound. We read them slowly, and we say at each step what the text says, what readers have made of it, and what we judge.
1. Ways of understanding disability
The word "disability" covers a very wide range: bodies and minds that differ in how they move, see, hear, learn, feel and communicate; conditions a person is born with and conditions that come later; conditions that are stable and conditions that change. It would be wrong to speak of all of these as one thing. People with a disability differ in how they understand themselves, and nothing in this lecture should be read as speaking for all of them.
Scholars and disabled people themselves have described a few general ways of understanding disability. Three are useful here. They are not rivals in the sense that only one can be true. Each notices something, and each has a weak point.
The medical way sees disability as a condition of the individual body or mind, something to be diagnosed and, where possible, treated or repaired. Its strength is that it takes seriously real pain, real limits and the real good that treatment has done. Its weak point is that it can lead us to see the person as a problem to be solved, and to overlook that much of a person's difficulty may come from how the world around them has been built.
The social way says that much of what disables a person is not the body but the barriers that others have set up: a stair where a ramp might be, a form that cannot be read, a belief that a person cannot learn or work. On this view, a society that is built for one kind of body will disable others. Its strength is that it shifts attention from the person to the surroundings, and it has helped to bring about real changes in buildings, schools and law in many places. Its weak point, according to some critics, including some disabled people, is that it can seem to deny that a body may also bring pain, fatigue or limit that no building will remove.
A relational way looks at the person in the web of relationships that shape a life: family, friends, community, work, faith. It asks whether the person is known, welcomed and given a place to give as well as to receive. Its strength is that it begins with belonging. Its weak point is that it does not by itself tell us what a society or a clinic should do.
For the church, the point is not to pick one but to notice which one we are using without noticing. A congregation that sees a disabled member only through the medical way will talk about cure. A congregation that has understood the social way will ask what in its own building and habits keeps people out.
2. What disabled people have said about screening, cure and enhancement
In earlier weeks we met prenatal testing and gene editing (lectures 2-2 and 2-3). Here we listen to what many disabled people and their families have said about them. These critiques are not the opinion of everyone with a disability, and we state them as claims some make.
One concern is about screening and selection. If a test is used to identify a condition before birth, and if some conditions then lead more often to an ending of the pregnancy, some disabled people hear a message: that lives like theirs are less worth having. They ask what such a message does to people who are already here. Many say they are not asking that a parent be blamed for a hard choice. They are asking that the society make room for such lives and not treat them as a cost to be avoided.
A second concern is about cure. Medical ways of speaking can make cure the only goal, and a person who is not cured can come to feel that they have failed. Some disabled people say they would welcome a treatment, and some say they would not want to be changed, since the way they live is the only life they know and has brought real joy. Others live with pain and long for relief and do not wish it described as a gift. All of these voices are real and they do not agree with each other.
A third concern is about enhancement. If medicine is aimed at "improving" the body beyond ordinary health, it matters whose body becomes the standard. A standard of strength, speed or intelligence can quietly turn every body that does not meet it into a lesser body. People who are already at the edge may be the first to feel it.
This is a point where readers will not agree. Some hold that the critiques of screening and cure are among the most important things a disabled person can say to the church. On this view, a medicine that does not listen to disabled people will, over time, shape a culture in which fewer such lives are welcomed, and Christians, who believe that every human life is a gift, should be the first to resist. Its strongest argument is that it takes seriously the experience of people most affected and the Bible's concern for the weak. Its weak point is that it can seem to leave little room for a parent who, with love and fear, hopes that a child will not suffer, or for a disabled person who longs for a treatment. The other view holds that the relief of suffering is a real good, that a treatment which helps a person walk, see, hear or live without pain is something to welcome, and that those who raise cautions should not stand in the way of people who want help. Its strongest argument is that it takes seriously the suffering that real conditions bring and the freedom of persons to seek healing. Its weak point is that it can pass over the way in which a hope for "cure" can slide into a judgement that a life is less. This course does not require you to choose. It requires that you can state both fairly, and that you have heard what disabled people say before you speak about them.
3. Weakness and the body of Christ
Paul's picture in 1 Corinthians 12:22-26 is among the most important texts for this lecture. He speaks of the church as a body. The parts that seem weaker are necessary, and God has given more honour to the part that lacks it, so that there is no division and the members care for each other. When one suffers, all suffer; when one is honoured, all rejoice.
Notice what the text does and does not do. It says that the apparently weak members are necessary to the body, not merely tolerated. It says that the community shares both suffering and joy. It does not say that weak members exist so that the strong may have someone to help. Read in that way, the text would turn a person into an occasion for another's virtue, and many disabled people have said they have been treated like that: admired, pitied or prayed over, but not asked what they have to give.
A reading that does justice to the text asks what a congregation loses when disabled members are missing from its leadership, its teaching, its music, its decisions. If the weaker members are necessary, then their absence is a loss of something the body needs. This is a question to put to ourselves, and our judgement, not something Paul says in so many words.
4. Two passages that have been misused
2 Corinthians 12:9. Paul says that he asked for a weakness to be taken away, and he was told that grace is enough and that power is made perfect in weakness. The text does not say what the weakness was, and readers have proposed illness, opposition or something else. It was Paul's own weakness, reported in his own voice. Many have found in it real comfort: a person in pain or limit may hear that they are not abandoned. The same words have been used to tell others that their pain is a blessing, or that they should not seek relief. The text does not say this. It reports what Paul was told, and it does not forbid anyone to seek treatment or to hope for healing. Nor does it say that a disability is a weakness in Paul's sense. A reading that tells a disabled person that their condition is "their thorn" is a judgement, and not what the text says.
John 9:1-3. The disciples ask who sinned, this man or his parents, that he was born blind. Jesus answers that neither did, and that something else is at issue. Here too readings differ. Many readers hear in the first part of the answer a clear rejection of the idea that a disability is a punishment for anyone's sin, and they find in this a word the church needs. The second part of the answer, "that the works of God might be revealed in him", has been read in several ways. Some say it means that God sent the blindness so that a healing could happen, and some find that painful. Others say that the sentence points not to why the man was born blind but to what is now going to happen, and that it is about the work of God now beginning. Others take it to mean that God's work is shown in the whole life of the man, and not only in the healing. The Greek can be punctuated in more than one way, and scholars differ. This course does not require you to settle that question. It does require that you never use the passage to explain why a particular person is disabled, and that you hear the first answer, that nobody sinned, as the clear part.
5. The dream of enhancement, in one sentence
Some people imagine that technology could one day raise human strength, health, intelligence or the length of life beyond what has been normal. We do not treat this large question here; the course AI and the Human Person (STEL6E) takes up the dream of enhancement and of ending death. What matters for this lecture is that any such dream has to be asked what it says about the people who are not enhanced, and about the people who already live with bodies that differ from the standard.
6. What a congregation can do
A congregation can ask disabled people what they would like to see, and listen to the answer. It can look at its building, its habits and its language and ask what keeps people out. It can notice who leads, and who is only helped. It can avoid saying "I will pray that you are healed" as a first word and ask instead what the person would like. It can pray for healing, if the person wishes it, and also pray for the justice and belonging a community owes. It need not choose between prayer and welcome.
When this lecture is studied in a group, some members may live with disability, or have family who do. They may speak if they wish, and they are never asked to be the group's example. Nobody should name a real person in the discussion.
Diagram 1. Three ways of seeing disability, and what each notices
핵심 요약
- Disability covers a wide range, and no one speaks for all disabled people.
- The medical, social and relational ways of understanding disability each notice something and each has a weak point.
- Disabled people have critiqued screening, cure and enhancement; others hope for treatment; both are heard fairly.
- In 1 Corinthians 12:22-26 the weaker members are necessary; the church loses when they are absent.
- 2 Corinthians 12:9 and John 9:1-3 are read in several ways and are never used to explain a person's disability.
- The wider dream of enhancement is taken up in STEL6E; here we ask what it says about those who are not enhanced.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Three ways of seeing disability | Medical (a condition to treat), social (barriers in the world), relational (belonging and giving); each has a weak point. |
| A critique of screening | Some disabled people hear in it a message that lives like theirs are less worth having; others hope for treatment. Both are heard fairly. |
| 1 Corinthians 12:22-26 | The weaker members are necessary; the body shares suffering and joy; the church loses when they are absent. |
| John 9:1-3 and 2 Corinthians 12:9 | Read in several ways; never used to explain why a person is disabled; the clear part of John 9 is that nobody sinned. |
One sentence to remember The members that seem weaker are necessary, so the church listens to disabled people before it speaks about them.
This week's action Ask yourself one question about who is missing from the life of your congregation, and note one way you could learn from someone who lives with disability.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- What does each of the three ways of understanding disability notice, and what does each overlook?
- State the critique of prenatal screening that some disabled people make. State the reply of those who hope for treatment. What is the weak point of each?
- How does 1 Corinthians 12:22-26 speak of weakness? In what way could it be misused so that disabled people become only the objects of care?
- Why should 2 Corinthians 12:9 and John 9:1-3 never be used to explain why a particular person is disabled?
- What in your own congregation or community might keep disabled people out or leave them without a voice, and who could you ask?