Lecture 5-1: Writing the Main Point in One Sentence
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What Exegesis Is, and in What Order We Work
- Lecture 1-2: Choosing the Passage and Marking Its Edges
- Lecture 1-3: Translations Side by Side
- Lecture 1-4: Reading the Footnotes: Where Manuscripts and Translators Differ
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The First Reading Note
- Lecture 2-1: The Literary Context and the Flow of the Book
- Lecture 2-2: Drawing the Structure
- Lecture 2-3: Genre: Questions to Ask
- Lecture 2-4: Signals Inside a Passage: Repetition, Contrast, Turning Points
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Drawing a Structure
- Lecture 3-1: How Far to Go with a Word
- Lecture 3-2: Grammar and the Sentence
- Lecture 3-3: Where Translations Divide, Where Readings Divide
- Lecture 3-4: Figures of Speech and Idiom
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: One Word and One Translation Difference
- Lecture 4-1: Using Historical, Cultural and Geographic Background
- Lecture 4-2: Reading Within the Canon
- Lecture 4-3: Other Traditions' Readings
- Lecture 4-4: Choosing and Comparing Commentaries
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Two Commentary Extracts
- Lecture 5-1: Writing the Main Point in One Sentence
- Lecture 5-2: The Theological Check
- Lecture 5-3: From Exegesis to a Bridge to Today
- Lecture 5-4: Writing a One-Page Exegetical Summary
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: One Page
For four weeks you have been collecting. You marked the edges of a passage, read it in several translations, drew its structure, asked about its words, looked at its background, set it beside the rest of Scripture and listened to how other traditions have read it. By now a student may hold two pages of notes and no clear idea of what the passage is mainly saying.
This week asks a different kind of question. Earlier steps gathered evidence. This step, and the two after it, gather the evidence into a judgement, test the judgement, and only then carry it carefully to today. The first part of that work is small and hard: say what the passage is mainly about, in one sentence.
A single sentence cannot hold everything in a passage. It is not meant to. It is a handle, a statement the reader is willing to defend and to have tested. Writing it forces choices, and choices are exactly where the risk of error lies. The central claim of this course applies here with full force: the sentence is not "the answer". It is a stated judgement, with its evidence shown and its weak places named.
This lecture does four things. It explains the two halves of a good sentence, the subject and the complement. It gives three tests a sentence should pass. It shows what happens when two main points compete. And it takes the practice text of this week, Luke 15:11-32, where faithful readers do not agree about where the weight of the story lies, and shows what the text offers to each view.
What these 26 minutes give you
- Split a main-point sentence into its subject and its complement.
- Test a sentence by three questions: does it come from the text, does it cover the whole passage, and is it too big?
- Recognise a sentence that is too big, too small or incomplete.
- State the three main readings of the focus of Luke 15:11-32 and give the text's pointers for each.
- Write a main-point sentence for a passage and say which part of it is weakest.
Now all the tax collectors and sinners were coming close to him to hear him." — Luke 15:1
World English Bible
The Pharisees and the scribes murmured, saying, “This man welcomes sinners, and eats with them.”" — Luke 15:2
WEB
He told them this parable." — Luke 15:3
WEB
He said, “A certain man had two sons." — Luke 15:11
WEB
He arose, and came to his father. But while he was still far off, his father saw him, and was moved with compassion, and ran, and fell on his neck, and kissed him." — Luke 15:20
WEB
But when this, your son, came, who has devoured your living with prostitutes, you killed the fattened calf for him.’" — Luke 15:30
WEB
But it was appropriate to celebrate and be glad, for this, your brother, was dead, and is alive again. He was lost, and is found.’”" — Luke 15:32
WEB
Where there is no counsel, plans fail; but in a multitude of counselors they are established." — Proverbs 15:22
WEB
The first three verses give the setting in which Jesus tells the story. The next three show the opening, the father at the return and the son's complaint, and the last gives the father's last word. The Proverbs verse is a short text used only to practise on.
1. Why one sentence
A student who has finished the earlier steps often feels full and unsure at the same moment. There is a great deal of material, and nothing yet that says what it adds up to. The one-sentence main point is the step that turns the pile into a position.
Three reasons make the discipline worth the discomfort.
It forces a choice. Two readers may share the same notes and still disagree about what matters most. Writing one sentence makes the choice visible, to the writer first.
It makes the claim testable. A vague feeling that "this passage is about grace" cannot be checked. A sentence such as "the father meets a returning son before the son finishes his speech" can be checked, because anyone can open the passage and see whether it says so.
It protects against drift. Without a sentence, the later steps (the theological check, the bridge to today) are free to go wherever the writer already wanted to go. A sentence fixed in advance holds them to the passage.
One warning is needed at once. A sentence can be neat without being true to the text. If a sentence comes out too smoothly, with every part of the passage fitting into it exactly, the smoothness may come from the writer's method and not from the passage. Treat an elegant sentence with suspicion, and test it.
2. Subject and complement
A main-point sentence has two halves.
Subject and complement
The subject is what the passage is about: the person, event, idea or question the writer is talking about. The complement is what the passage says about it: the claim, the turn, the answer that completes the thought. (The word comes from grammar, where a complement "completes" a sentence.) A subject alone is a topic. A complement alone is a floating slogan. A main point needs both.
A topic such as "counsel" is only a subject. It says what a passage mentions. It does not say what the passage claims. The question that finds the complement is: what does the passage say about this subject?
Take a short practice text outside the course passages, Proverbs 15:22, quoted above.
Ask the first question: what is the writer talking about? The subject is plans, and the advice given about them. Ask the second: what does the verse say about them? Plans where there is no counsel fail; plans with many counsellors stand. A first draft sentence follows: "Plans without counsel fail, and plans with many counsellors are established." Notice that the sentence uses the text's own words and adds nothing. A draft this close to the text is a good first draft.
For a story, the same two questions work, but the subject is usually a person or a movement of events, and the complement is what happens to them or what is shown through them. "A father and two sons" is a subject-like phrase. It becomes a main point only when the writer says what the story shows about them.
3. Three tests
Once a sentence is on the page, test it three ways. Each test is a question, and each can fail.
Test 1. Does it come from the text? Underline each important word in your sentence and find the verse that stands behind it. A word with no verse behind it came from somewhere else: from a sermon heard long ago, from a doctrine held already, from a general idea about God. That does not make the word wrong. It makes it a word the passage has not yet earned.
Test 2. Does it cover the whole passage? Read the passage to its last verse and then read the sentence again. Many sentences fit the first half and quietly drop the second. A sentence that leaves out the ending of a story has probably missed what the ending was doing.
Test 3. Is it too big? Put another passage in place of this one. If the sentence still fits ("God loves people", "faith is important") it is too big, because it says nothing about this passage in particular. A good sentence fits this passage better than it fits others. Test 3 also catches a sentence that is too small: one that names a detail ("a son spent his money") and misses what the detail is for.
A fourth habit is not a test but helps: write in plain words, the way you would explain the passage to a friend who has not read it. If the sentence needs a technical word to hold together, the writer may not yet know what the passage says.
4. Three faulty sentences, marked
Here are three sentences for Proverbs 15:22, each marked with its fault. They are bad examples, written for this lecture.
(A bad example: too big.) "Wisdom is good for everyone." This fits hundreds of verses. It says nothing about plans or counsel. It fails test 3.
(A bad example: incomplete.) "Plans fail." This is half the verse. It misses the contrast that gives the verse its point, and it fails test 2.
(A bad example: leaps to today.) "Everyone should find a mentor at work." Perhaps this is wise. But it is an instruction to a reader, and it is not what the verse says. It fails test 1, because "mentor" and "work" are not in the text, and it belongs to the bridge step, not to the main point.
The third fault is the commonest. The urge to say what to do with the text arrives very early, and it quietly rewrites the sentence. This course keeps the two apart on purpose. The main point says what the passage says. The bridge, in lecture 5-3, asks what follows for today.
5. When two main points compete
Sometimes a passage will not give a single sentence. Two sentences both seem to pass the tests, and each leaves out something the other holds. This is not always a failure. It may be a feature of the passage, or a feature of how different readers weigh the same evidence.
There are three honest ways to proceed.
- Write both and say which carries more weight, and why. This is the usual choice. The reader of your summary can see that the other sentence existed.
- Write a wider sentence that holds both, if the text itself holds them together. Do this only if the passage joins them; if you join them yourself because you dislike choosing, you have built the neatness the warning above speaks of.
- Say that the passage does not settle it. This is sometimes the most accurate sentence, and it is not weakness. A passage that can be read two ways has been read two ways by serious readers for a long time.
What is not honest is to hide the second sentence so that the first looks certain.
6. The practice text: Luke 15:11-32
Now the practice text of this week. Read it whole, slowly, with the setting in view. Luke 15 begins with a crowd of tax collectors and sinners, and a complaint from the Pharisees and scribes (verses 1-2).
Two things from the first three verses will matter for the rest of the week. First, the story of the two sons is told in answer to a complaint: Jesus is criticised for welcoming sinners and eating with them. Second, verse 3 says that Jesus "told them this parable", in the singular, and then three stories follow, about a sheep, a coin and two sons. Readers differ on whether the three are one parable told in three forms or three parables with one setting. The difference affects how much the first two stories should shape the reading of the third.
Now the story itself begins at verse 11: "A certain man had two sons."
Read to the end and then ask the first question: whose story is it? Three answers are given by careful readers, and the text offers something to each.
The younger son. The story spends most of its length with him: his request, his departure, the famine, the pigs, the decision to go home, the return. Verses 11 to 24 follow his road. The scene ends with the father's command to celebrate, and the closing line of that scene, "this, my son, was dead, and is alive again", is about him. A reader who gives the weight to verses 11-24 will say the story is mainly about the lost one who is found.
The father. The story begins with "a certain man", and he is the one character who is present in both halves. Look at what he does. He divides the property (verse 12). He sees the son "while he was still far off", is "moved with compassion", runs and kisses him (verse 20). He orders the robe, the ring and the calf. Then, when the second son stands outside, he goes out and begs him (verse 28). The father's movement toward each son is the thing that does not change. A reader who gives the weight to this will say the story is mainly about the father.
The elder son. The story ends with him, and ends with the father's plea left unanswered. He is angry and stays outside, and he speaks of "this, your son" (verse 30); the father answers with "this, your brother" (verse 32). The text does not say whether the elder son went in. Readers who give the weight to the ending, and who connect the elder brother to the Pharisees and scribes who muttered in verse 2, will say the story is mainly about him, and that its last line is aimed at the people who first heard it. They point out that the story opens with a complaint about a meal and closes with a man standing outside a feast.
Notice that each of these readers has done the work of the earlier steps. They have not simply preferred a character. They have attended to length, to action, to placement and to setting.
This is a point where readers will not agree. Some readers, following the name by which the story is commonly known, hold that the weight falls on the one who was lost and is found: the story answers the complaint of verse 2 by showing what welcome looks like, and the repeated lost-and-found language of the whole chapter points at the one who comes home. Others hold that the father is the centre: his compassion, his running and his going out to both sons are the pattern that holds the story together, and the two sons are two ways of standing before him. Others hold that the elder son is the centre: the story is open-ended at its close because the hearers, the muttering critics of verse 2, are being asked to answer, and the story is incomplete until they do. All three readers can quote the text. Each can also name what the others leave unexplained: the first must account for the second half; the second must account for why the story leaves the father's last plea unanswered; the third must account for the larger share of the story given to the younger son. What this course requires is less than any of the three requires. It requires that you state which focus you give the weight to, show the verses for it, say what the other two readers would point to, and mark how far your choice reaches beyond the evidence.
7. Drafts, not answers
Here are three draft sentences, one for each focus. They are shapes to show what a sentence looks like, and not solutions to the passage. Each has a weak place, which is marked.
(A draft, younger-son focus.) "A son who has lost everything turns toward home, and his father receives him with a joy that his prepared speech did not ask for." Weak place: it says little about verses 25-32.
(A draft, father focus.) "A father goes out to meet both of his sons, the one who left and the one who stayed." Weak place: the text shows him going out to the younger son in a scene of joy and to the elder in a scene of argument, and it does not say how the elder answered; a sentence that says "meets" may claim an ending the story does not give.
(A draft, elder-son focus.) "A son who has always stayed is asked whether he will share his father's joy over a brother who returned." Weak place: it must explain why so much of the story is spent before the elder son enters, and the claim that the story is aimed at the muttering hearers is an inference from the setting, not a statement in the text.
Read the three drafts against the three tests. All three come from the text. None is too big. Each covers the whole passage only partly. That is the honest condition of this passage, and a writer who knows it can say so.
8. Writing your own
Here is a way to proceed, in order.
- Write the subject, in a few words. Then write the complement. Join them in one sentence.
- Underline the key words and put a verse number beside each.
- Read the last verse of the passage. Does the sentence still fit?
- Swap in a different passage. Does the sentence still fit?
- Write a second sentence, for the second-best reading, if there is one.
- Mark the weakest part of your sentence and write why.
Step 6 is the one most easily skipped, and it is the one this course returns to again and again. A sentence without a marked weak place is not finished.
Diagram 1. Three readings of the focus, and what each must explain
Diagram 2. A checklist for a main-point sentence
| Question | If the answer is no |
|---|---|
| Can I point to a verse behind each key word? | Remove the word, or write it down as something I brought to the text. |
| Does it still fit when I read the last verse? | The sentence covers only part of the passage. |
| Does it stop fitting when I swap in another passage? | It is too big. Say what is particular here. |
| Is it a statement about the text, not an instruction to a reader? | Move the instruction to the bridge step. |
| Did I name its weakest part? | The sentence is not finished. |
In short
- A main point has a subject, what the passage is about, and a complement, what it says about it.
- A sentence is tested three ways: from the text, whole passage, not too big.
- A sentence that tells a reader what to do belongs to the bridge, not to the main point.
- When two main points compete, write both, write a wider sentence only if the text joins them, or say the text does not settle it.
- Readers of Luke 15:11-32 weigh the story toward the younger son, the father or the elder son; each reading leaves something to explain.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Subject and complement | The subject is what the passage is about; the complement is what it says about it. Both are needed. |
| Three tests | From the text? Does it cover the whole passage? Is it too big (would it fit another passage)? |
| Two competing main points | Write both and give the weight; widen the sentence only if the text joins them; or say the text does not settle it. |
| Luke 15:11-32, three focuses | Younger son (length, lost and found); father (his actions toward both sons); elder son (placement at the end, the setting in verse 2). |
One sentence to remember A main point is a judgement stated so that it can be checked, with its weakest part marked.
This week's action Write a one-sentence main point for a short passage, put a verse number beside each key word, and note which part you trust least.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- In your own words, what is the difference between a subject and a complement? Make up a subject and two different complements for it.
- Why does the lecture say that an elegant sentence should be treated with suspicion?
- Look at "Everyone should find a mentor at work" as a sentence about Proverbs 15:22. Which test does it fail, and why does the urge to write such a sentence come so early?
- Which of the three readings of Luke 15:11-32 do you find easiest to hold? What would the other two readers say you have left out?
- In the setting of Luke 15:1-3, what difference does it make whether the three stories are one parable or three? What evidence would help you decide?
- Choose a short passage you know. Write a main-point sentence, put a verse number beside each key word and name its weakest part.