FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

BT617E Exegesis in Practice: Working Through a Biblical Text Step by Step

Lecture 5-2: The Theological Check

Contents 31
BT617E Exegesis in Practice: Working Through a Biblical Text Step by Step
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Exegesis as Listening
  1. Introduction: Exegesis as Listening
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Choosing and Reading the Text
  1. Lecture 1-1: What Exegesis Is, and in What Order We Work
  2. Lecture 1-2: Choosing the Passage and Marking Its Edges
  3. Lecture 1-3: Translations Side by Side
  4. Lecture 1-4: Reading the Footnotes: Where Manuscripts and Translators Differ
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The First Reading Note
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Context and Structure
  1. Lecture 2-1: The Literary Context and the Flow of the Book
  2. Lecture 2-2: Drawing the Structure
  3. Lecture 2-3: Genre: Questions to Ask
  4. Lecture 2-4: Signals Inside a Passage: Repetition, Contrast, Turning Points
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Drawing a Structure
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Words, Grammar and Translation
  1. Lecture 3-1: How Far to Go with a Word
  2. Lecture 3-2: Grammar and the Sentence
  3. Lecture 3-3: Where Translations Divide, Where Readings Divide
  4. Lecture 3-4: Figures of Speech and Idiom
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: One Word and One Translation Difference
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Background, Canon and Other Traditions
  1. Lecture 4-1: Using Historical, Cultural and Geographic Background
  2. Lecture 4-2: Reading Within the Canon
  3. Lecture 4-3: Other Traditions' Readings
  4. Lecture 4-4: Choosing and Comparing Commentaries
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Two Commentary Extracts
Chapter 5 · Week 5: The Main Point, the Theological Check and the Bridge
  1. Lecture 5-1: Writing the Main Point in One Sentence
  2. Lecture 5-2: The Theological Check
  3. Lecture 5-3: From Exegesis to a Bridge to Today
  4. Lecture 5-4: Writing a One-Page Exegetical Summary
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: One Page
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Difficult Texts and Lasting Habits
  1. Lecture 6-1: Difficult Passages
  2. Lecture 6-2: A Checklist of Common Errors
  3. Lecture 6-3: Habits and Tools for the Long Run
  4. Lecture 6-4: Many Methods, One Discipline
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: My Exegesis Checklist

Jump to the key points ↓

27 min

A main-point sentence says what a passage is mainly about. It has been tested against the text. Before it is carried to today, it needs one more test of a different kind: a theological check.

The word theological can frighten a student who thinks it means a debate between doctrines. In this course it means something small and plain. The theological check asks three questions of the passage, and only of the passage: What does it say about God? What does it say about people? What does it say about the good news? Then it asks a fourth, which is just as important: What does it not say?

The check has two jobs. First, it tests the main point. A sentence that looked sound in the last lecture sometimes turns out to claim more about God or about people than the passage gives. Second, it guards the bridge to today. A reader who crosses to the present carrying more than the text holds will carry something that came from elsewhere, and will not know it.

This lecture shows how to run the check on Luke 15, how to label each claim by how well the text supports it, how to notice a system being laid over a passage, and what to do when two passages seem to pull apart.

What these 27 minutes give you

  • Ask the three questions of a passage (about God, about people, about the good news) and answer from the text.
  • Label a claim as *the text says*, *the text shows* or *I am adding*.
  • Name some things Luke 15:11-32 does not say, without treating silence as either proof or gap.
  • Recognise a system being laid over a text, in a reading of your own or of another.
  • Set out a tension between two passages honestly, without hiding either.

Now all the tax collectors and sinners were coming close to him to hear him." — Luke 15:1

World English Bible

The Pharisees and the scribes murmured, saying, “This man welcomes sinners, and eats with them.”" — Luke 15:2

WEB

I tell you that even so there will be more joy in heaven over one sinner who repents, than over ninety-nine righteous people who need no repentance." — Luke 15:7

WEB

He arose, and came to his father. But while he was still far off, his father saw him, and was moved with compassion, and ran, and fell on his neck, and kissed him." — Luke 15:20

WEB

The son said to him, ‘Father, I have sinned against heaven, and in your sight. I am no longer worthy to be called your son.’" — Luke 15:21

WEB

for this, my son, was dead, and is alive again. He was lost, and is found.’ They began to celebrate." — Luke 15:24

WEB

I have not come to call the righteous, but sinners to repentance.”" — Luke 5:32

WEB

for all have sinned, and fall short of the glory of God;" — Romans 3:23

WEB

Luke 15:1-2 gives the setting, and verse 7 is the comparison at the end of the sheep story. Verses 20 to 24 show the father and the son at the return. The two verses at the end are the pair that seem to pull against verse 7, and are used in the last part of the lecture.

1. What the check is, and what it is not

The theological check comes after the main point and before the bridge. The order matters.

The theological check

The theological check asks what a passage says about God, about people and about the good news (the gospel), and what it does not say. It uses only the passage and its immediate setting. It does not ask which doctrine is correct, and it does not ask which tradition reads the passage best.

It is not a doctrinal debate. A passage is not examined to see whether it supports the system a reader already holds. It is also not a summary of everything the Bible says about God. A single passage says some things about God, and the check records those, and no more.

Nor is the check a pious ending added to give the work a religious feel. It is a test. If you run it and the result does not match your main point, either the main point or the check must change. That is a good outcome, because it is an error caught before it travels.

2. Question one: what does the passage say about God?

Luke 15:11-32 does not name God in its story. The man is a father. The student can still ask what the text shows of the father, and, with care, what the setting says about whom he stands for. Start with what is plain.

The text shows the father allowing a departure (verse 12, he divides the property), watching (verse 20, he sees the son "while he was still far off"), feeling ("moved with compassion"), running, embracing, kissing, clothing (the robe, the ring, the shoes), feasting (the calf), and going out to the son and pleading with him (verse 28). He speaks twice of life and death, "dead, and is alive again", in verses 24 and 32. And he gives the elder son a word of belonging: "Son, you are always with me, and all that is mine is yours."

Notice that every item in that list is a verb or a feeling stated by the text. This is the right kind of evidence. Now look at the setting, because the story is told in answer to the complaint of verses 1-2. The sheep story before it ends with a statement about "joy in heaven" (verse 7), and the coin story with "joy in the presence of the angels of God" (verse 10). So the text, in its setting, connects the joy of a feast with a joy in heaven. How closely the father stands for God in the story is a question of interpretation. Most readers hold that he does, because of the comparison of verse 7 and verse 10. Few readers would say the text states it in a sentence.

This is where the labels in the next section help.

3. Three labels for every claim

A student running the check will write many sentences such as "God is a Father who forgives". Each one should carry a label.

The text says. The words are in the passage. "He ran and fell on his neck and kissed him" is of this kind.

The text shows. The passage does not state it, but what happens requires it. "The father welcomed the son before the son finished his speech" is of this kind, because verse 20 puts the embrace before verse 21's words. The reader's inference is small and anyone can check it.

I am adding. The claim comes from another passage, a doctrine or a tradition, and is brought to this text. "The father stands for God, who forgave through the cross" has parts of each kind. That the father stands for God is common ground in the setting; the reference to the cross is something added. Adding is not forbidden. Adding without a label is the error.

A good theological check marks every claim in this way. After a first run, a student is often surprised at how many claims fall under the third label.

4. Question two: what does the passage say about people?

Here the text is full, and it is also easy to over-read.

The younger son wastes his property (verse 13), is in need (verse 14), takes work with pigs (verse 15), and is hungry (verse 16). Then "he came to himself" (verse 17) and decides to go home. Notice what drives the decision in his own words: "How many hired servants of my father's have bread enough to spare, and I'm dying with hunger!" He plans a speech, "Father, I have sinned against heaven, and in your sight", and a request to be a hired servant (verses 18-19). A pig, in the eyes of the Law, is an unclean animal (Leviticus 11:7), so the work is a measure of how far he has fallen. Whether his return is from sorrow or from hunger, or both, the text does not say. Some readers hear in verse 17 the voice of a man who is only hungry, and some hear a true turning. Both can point to the verse. The check records that the text gives both hunger and a confession, and leaves the mixture of motive unsettled.

The elder son is "in the field" (verse 25), angry, and outside (verse 28). By his own account he has served "these many years" and "never disobeyed a commandment". The text does not say that his account is false. The father does not dispute it, and in verse 31 he says "you are always with me". What the text does show is that the son is not sharing in the joy of the house.

What can be said, then, about people? The text shows that a person can be far from the father by leaving, and also by staying. It shows a person in need who comes home. It shows a person who has done everything required and is outside the feast. It does not say that the two are the same, and it does not say who is worse. A sentence such as "all people are lost" is true to many parts of Scripture, and it may be true to this story. But the check asks what this passage says, and it is better to write what the text shows of these two.

5. The comparison of verse 7

The sheep story ends with "ninety-nine righteous people who need no repentance." This line matters for the check, because it says something about people. Who are the ninety-nine? The text is not explicit. The place where this tension surfaces is treated below. For the check on Luke 15:11-32, what matters is that the people of the story are set in the larger setting where some are called righteous and some sinners (verses 1-2), and that the story of the two sons has a figure to match each.

6. Question three: what does the passage say about the good news?

The setting is the place to look. Verse 2 states what is being said of Jesus: "This man welcomes sinners, and eats with them." The three stories are the reply. So the good news, as Luke 15 tells it, includes a welcome that comes to the lost, a joy that is shared and a table where the returning one is seated. In the story, the welcome comes with the father running, before the son's speech is finished (verse 20, then 21). The feast is the answer to the complaint.

Two cautions belong here.

The first is about what to do with the cross. A reader who knows the whole of the gospel will have the death and rising of Jesus in mind. The story does not mention them. The calf is killed for a meal. The father does not say what has happened to the debt of the property that was wasted. The check records this as a plain observation, without a verdict.

Does this story say enough about the good news?

This is a point where readers will not agree. Some hold that the story, in its setting, shows the shape of the good news complete in itself: a lost one is welcomed by a father who needs no payment before he runs, and no more is needed for the story to do its work. Others hold that the story can only be read rightly beside the rest of the Gospel of Luke and the whole , because it leaves unsaid how the welcome is made possible, and that to stop at the story is to read half of the good news. Both can say what they honour in the text. What this course requires is only a label: say whether your sentence about the good news rests on this passage alone, or on this passage read with other texts, so that the reader can see which.

The second caution is about the order of events. A famous question runs across traditions: does the welcome come before or after repentance? In this scene the son's plan to confess comes first (verses 18-19), the father's run and embrace come next (verse 20), and the son's words come after the embrace (verse 21). In the English text we are using, the son in verse 21 says "I am no longer worthy to be called your son" and does not go on to the request to be made a hired servant that he had planned in verse 19. These are facts about a scene. They are not yet a doctrine of the order of repentance and forgiveness. A tradition that has a developed teaching about repentance will read the scene in the light of that teaching, and another tradition with another teaching will read it another way. The check takes a smaller step: it records the order of the scene, and labels anything beyond that as added.

7. Laying a system over a text

A system here means any worked-out set of doctrines, such as a teaching about how a person is saved or how a church is ordered. Every tradition has one, and every reader brings some. The error is not having a system. The error is not knowing that one is laid over the passage.

The sign of it is a sentence that sounds right and has no verse behind it. A reader asked "where does the text say this?" finds the answer is in a doctrine. For example, a reader might write, "The younger son represents unbelievers and the elder son represents believers who fall." The text does not state it, and other readers hold that the elder son stands for religious people, or for the people who first complained. Whatever the merits of a sentence, a student who writes it should mark it as added.

The remedy is the label from earlier, and a second habit: read the passage once with no system, then once with each system that has a claim on it. Write down what changed. Where the text could bear both readings, say so. This is the same thing lecture 4-3 asked about other traditions, now asked about oneself.

A caution on the people of the text belongs here, because it has caused harm. Verse 2 names "the Pharisees and the scribes" who muttered. The story's elder son is often connected with them. In the history of Christian reading, this connection has sometimes been widened to a verdict on a whole people, as if the figure of the angry brother stood for Jewish neighbours of every age. That step is not in the text. The check should record what the text says of the people who muttered, and no more, and should refuse to turn a figure in a story into a judgement on any living community.

8. When two passages seem to pull apart

Sometimes the check finds that a statement in your passage seems to conflict with a statement elsewhere. In Luke 15:7 Jesus speaks of "ninety-nine righteous people who need no repentance." In Romans 3:23 Paul writes "for all have sinned, and fall short of the glory of God". In Luke 5:32 Jesus says "I have not come to call the righteous, but sinners to repentance." A student who reads all three may ask: are there righteous people who need no repentance, or not?

Do not hurry to remove the tension. Work through it.

  1. Check each passage in its own setting. What is each saying, to whom, in what kind of writing? A saying in a story told to critics may do something a statement in a letter does not.
  2. List the readings each has had. For Luke 15:7, three are common. Some say the words are ironic, spoken in the voice of those who think themselves righteous, as the muttering group of verse 2 does. Some say that Jesus is describing a possible kind of person, who has already turned and needs no further turning. Some say that the line is a comparison that does not claim such people exist. Each has a cost. The first requires hearing a tone that the text does not mark. The second must fit Paul's "all". The third must explain why the story names them at all.
  3. Do not harmonise by weakening either. To say that "righteous" must mean "sinners" because Paul says "all" is to let one passage overwrite the other without hearing it.
  4. State the tension openly. A good sentence is: "Luke 15:7 speaks of righteous people who need no repentance; Romans 3:23 says all have sinned. I read the first as ..., because ...; I mark this as a place where I am not certain."
  5. Allow the result "the text does not settle this". It is a real result.

The check does not remove every tension. Its job is to make sure that the tension is seen, named and carried into the summary instead of being smoothed over.

9. A short worked check, marked

Here is a shape for a check on Luke 15:11-32, written for this lecture.

(An invented example.) "God. The text shows a father who sees, runs, embraces, restores and goes out to plead (verses 20-24, 28). The text says he was moved with compassion. I am adding, from the setting of verses 1-10, that the father stands for God. People. The text shows a younger son who comes home from hunger and with a confession, and an elder son who stays outside. The text does not say whether the younger son's motive was pure, or what the elder son did next. Good news. God's welcome comes before the speech is finished (verse 20), as an answer to the complaint of verse 2. Unsure: how far verse 7 describes real people."

The weak place in this check is easy to miss. In the God paragraph the writer labels "the father stands for God" as an addition, which is honest. In the good-news paragraph the same claim comes back with no label, as "God's welcome", and from there it reads as if the text had said it. A label has to follow a claim wherever the claim is used. The claim is a reasonable one, held by many readers, and that is exactly why it slips through without being noticed.


Diagram 1. The check on Luke 15:11-32: what the text says, and what it does not

The Theological Check on Luke 15:11-32 Three questions, and what the text does not say (a shape, not a solution) About God About people About the good news The text says / shows Sees, runs, kisses, clothes, feasts; goes out to plead; "all that is mine is yours" The text says / shows One son far off, in need, who confesses; one son near, angry, outside the feast The text says / shows A welcome before the speech is finished; a feast in answer to the complaint of verse 2 Not said "The father is God" is not stated in the story; it comes from the setting (label it) Not said Whether hunger or sorrow drove the return; whether the elder son went in Not said No cross, no payment for the lost property; readers differ on whether this matters Label every claim: the text says / the text shows / I am adding Where two passages pull apart, state the tension and carry it into the summary.

Diagram 2. Running the check: a short procedure

Step Ask Write
1 What does the passage say or show about God? Each claim with a verse and a label
2 What does it say or show about people? Each claim with a verse and a label
3 What does it say or show about the good news? Look first at the setting; label what you add
4 What does it not say? A plain list, without a verdict
5 Does any claim pull against another passage? The tension, the readings and the cost of each

In short

  • The theological check asks what the passage says about God, people and the good news, and what it does not say.
  • Label each claim: the text says, the text shows, or I am adding from outside.
  • Luke 15 does not state that the father is God, and does not mention the cross; readers differ on how much weight the silences carry.
  • A system laid over a text has a sentence with no verse behind it; read once without it, then with it.
  • Where two passages pull apart, state the tension, list the readings with their costs, and allow "the text does not settle this".
Front Back
The theological check Asks what the passage says about God, people and the good news, and what it does not say.
Three labels The text says; the text shows; I am adding.
Laying a system over a text Bringing a worked-out doctrine to a passage without knowing it; a sign is a sentence with no verse behind it.
Two passages that pull apart Read each in its own setting, list the readings and their costs, do not harmonise by weakening either, state the tension.

One sentence to remember Say what the text says, say what it shows, and mark everything you added.

This week's action Write three sentences about a passage you know, one with each label, and check which label you reached for first.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Why does the lecture say that the theological check is a test and not a pious ending?
  • Take the sentence "The father in the story is God." Which label belongs to it, and what would you point to in the text to support it?
  • In Luke 15:17-19, what drives the son's decision? Why does the lecture leave the question of motive unsettled?
  • Read Luke 15:7, Luke 5:32 and Romans 3:23 together. Which reading of "righteous" in verse 7 do you find most natural, and what does it cost you?
  • Why is it a problem to move from "the elder son is angry" to a judgement on a group of people today?
  • Choose a short passage and write one claim of each label: the text says, the text shows, I am adding.

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.