Lecture 5-4: Writing a One-Page Exegetical Summary
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What Exegesis Is, and in What Order We Work
- Lecture 1-2: Choosing the Passage and Marking Its Edges
- Lecture 1-3: Translations Side by Side
- Lecture 1-4: Reading the Footnotes: Where Manuscripts and Translators Differ
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The First Reading Note
- Lecture 2-1: The Literary Context and the Flow of the Book
- Lecture 2-2: Drawing the Structure
- Lecture 2-3: Genre: Questions to Ask
- Lecture 2-4: Signals Inside a Passage: Repetition, Contrast, Turning Points
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Drawing a Structure
- Lecture 3-1: How Far to Go with a Word
- Lecture 3-2: Grammar and the Sentence
- Lecture 3-3: Where Translations Divide, Where Readings Divide
- Lecture 3-4: Figures of Speech and Idiom
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: One Word and One Translation Difference
- Lecture 4-1: Using Historical, Cultural and Geographic Background
- Lecture 4-2: Reading Within the Canon
- Lecture 4-3: Other Traditions' Readings
- Lecture 4-4: Choosing and Comparing Commentaries
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Two Commentary Extracts
- Lecture 5-1: Writing the Main Point in One Sentence
- Lecture 5-2: The Theological Check
- Lecture 5-3: From Exegesis to a Bridge to Today
- Lecture 5-4: Writing a One-Page Exegetical Summary
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: One Page
Four weeks of steps, a main point, a theological check and a bridge produce a great deal of paper. A student who stops there has a drawer of notes. Nobody else can read a drawer.
The last written product of this course is a one-page exegetical summary: a single page that records where the text starts and ends, how it is built, one word or translation choice that matters, what background helps, what the passage mainly says, what the theological check found, how a bridge might be built, and where the writer is not sure. It is the exegesis in a form that another person can check.
A page is short on purpose. It forces selection, and selection is a form of honesty: the writer has to decide which evidence carried the judgement. The page also ends the course's path at the right place. It is not a sermon, and it is not a commentary. It is a record, so that a preacher, a teacher or a friend can see what was done and decide how far to trust it.
This lecture sets out the eight parts of the page, shows how to state uncertainty without losing nerve, and reads a short invented summary of Luke 15:8-10 with its strong and weak points marked.
What these 22 minutes give you
- Name the eight parts of a one-page summary and say what belongs in each.
- Write each part in plain sentences, with a verse number behind each claim.
- State uncertainty in three levels without hedging every sentence.
- Say what a "where I am unsure" part should hold, and why it is not optional.
- Read a summary for strong points and weak points, including a guess presented as a fact.
He said to him, ‘Son, you are always with me, and all that is mine is yours." — Luke 15:31
World English Bible
But it was appropriate to celebrate and be glad, for this, your brother, was dead, and is alive again. He was lost, and is found.’”" — Luke 15:32
WEB
Or what woman, if she had ten drachma coins, if she lost one drachma coin, wouldn’t light a lamp, sweep the house, and seek diligently until she found it?" — Luke 15:8
WEB
When she has found it, she calls together her friends and neighbors, saying, ‘Rejoice with me, for I have found the drachma which I had lost.’" — Luke 15:9
WEB
Even so, I tell you, there is joy in the presence of the angels of God over one sinner repenting.”" — Luke 15:10
WEB
The first two verses are the last words of the father in the story of the two sons, and the end of the passage the practice summary is written on. The last three verses are the story of the coin, used in this lecture for a short invented model.
1. What the page is for
The one-page summary
A one-page exegetical summary is a short written record of an , with the evidence for each judgement and a plain statement of what is uncertain. It is written for a reader who has not seen your notes. A person who reads it should be able to check any claim against the passage.
Three uses make it worth the effort.
It is a test of the work. A step that cannot be put in a sentence has often not been done. If the writer cannot state the edges of the passage in a line, the edges were never decided.
It makes disagreement possible. Two people who write summaries of the same passage can lay the pages side by side and see where they divide. Without the pages, they have only impressions. This is the central claim of the course at work: the honesty of exegesis lies in showing the evidence and stating the disagreement openly.
It protects the next step. Whoever uses the page, whether to teach or to preach or to pray, begins from a record of what is firm and what is not. A sermon that begins from a drawer of notes has no such record.
2. The eight parts
The parts follow the order of the steps, with the main point near the middle. Each part is short, often one to three sentences.
1. The edges. Where the passage starts and ends, and the reason. One sentence of reason is enough: a repeated word, a change of speaker, a conjunction, a change of place. The common fault is to give the verses and no reason.
2. The structure line. One line saying how the passage is built: the movements, the turns, the main and supporting statements. This is not the full diagram of week 2. It is the line a reader would have if they glanced at the diagram. The common fault is a line so neat that it hides the places where the structure could be drawn another way.
3. A key word and a translation choice. One word or one choice that matters, with how sure the writer is. Only one. A page that lists six words has not chosen. The common fault is an etymology offered as a meaning. A student without the original languages may say: "this word is rendered differently in two translations, and the context favours the following sense". That is an honest sentence.
4. Background. What the text says about its own situation, and what certain history adds, each in a sentence. Mark any conjecture as conjecture. The common fault is the background that is longer than everything else on the page.
5. The main point. The one sentence of lecture 5-1, with the subject and complement, and a note on the competing sentence if there is one. This is the only part that needs to be boxed, because everything else on the page supports, tests or carries it. For the practice passage, the ending is the last test of any main point: read verses 31 and 32 again and ask whether the sentence still fits the father's last words.
6. The theological check. What the passage says or shows about God, people and the good news, with the labels of lecture 5-2, and what it does not say. Two or three sentences. The common fault is a claim that carries a label in one place and none in another.
7. The bridge. One sentence of what may carry over, how strong the footing is, and what the first situation ties down. No instruction to anyone. The common fault is to let a sermon begin here.
8. Where I am unsure. The places where the writer is not certain, and what would change the writer's mind. This is the part most often left empty, and for the reason that it is the part that costs the writer something.
3. Why the last part is not optional
A page with no entry under "where I am unsure" says one of two things. Either the writer found no uncertainty, which is rare in a text of any difficulty, or the writer found it and did not write it down. In both cases the reader cannot tell the firm claims from the soft ones. All claims look equally firm, and the reader will believe most of them.
Think of what is lost. The writer knows that the translation choice in part 3 was a close call. The reader does not. The reader will build on part 3 as if it were certain. If it later turns out to be wrong, the harm is done by the silence of the page, not by the mistake.
The entry should hold three things, each in a short line:
- What I am unsure of. A specific claim, named.
- Why. The evidence that is thin, or the two readings that are both possible.
- What would change my mind. A piece of evidence that would settle it, or that the writer has not found.
The third line is the one that shows nerve. It says that the writer is willing to be corrected, and by what.
4. Uncertainty without losing nerve
A writer who has just learned to be honest about uncertainty often goes too far. Every sentence is wrapped in "perhaps", "it may be", "some would say". The page becomes soft, and a reader cannot find a claim to test.
Three levels of language prevent this.
Level one: stated. The text says it. Write it plainly. "The father ran and kissed him" needs no softening, because the verb is in the text.
Level two: judged. The writer weighed evidence and decided. Say so once, with the reason. "I read the son's complaint as a real grievance, because the father does not dispute it." This is a claim with a reason, and a reader can disagree with it.
Level three: not sure. The evidence does not settle it. Say so in one place, the last part, and name the question. Do not scatter it.
(A bad example: too much hedging.) "Perhaps the father might be said to represent, in some sense, what some would call God, although this may not be certain." A reader can do nothing with this. There is no claim.
(A bad example: too little.) "The father is God, and the elder son is the Pharisees." Two claims at level one that belong at level two or three, with no reason.
(A better version.) "I read the father as standing for God, because the sheep and the coin stories end with joy in heaven (verses 7 and 10). I mark this as an addition to the text, and as a place where I am not certain how far the comparison reaches."
The better version states a judgement, gives a reason, labels it and says where it is soft. It uses two sentences and no empty words.
5. A model summary, with its marks
Here is a short model, written for this lecture on the story of the coin. It is an invented example, in the shape of the page. It is a shape to read, not a solution to the passage, and it is not offered as the way to read Luke 15:8-10.
(An invented example. One weakness has been placed in it for you to find.)
Passage: Luke 15:8-10.
Edges. Verse 8 opens with "Or what woman", which joins it to the sheep story before it, and verse 11 begins a new story ("He said, 'A certain man had two sons'"). Strong: the opening word and the new start mark both edges.
Structure. A question (verse 8), a finding and an invitation to share joy (verse 9), a statement about joy before the angels (verse 10). Weak: I have drawn it as a straight line; the sheep story has the same three parts, and I may be fitting one to the other.
Key word and translation choice. "Rejoice" and "joy" (verses 9 and 10). The English text keeps the coin's name, "drachma". I have not compared how other translations name it, and I have not tested whether the name matters for the point.
Background. The coin was most likely part of her savings, kept for a wedding, which is why she searches so hard.
Main point. A woman who loses one of ten coins searches until she finds it and calls her neighbours to share her joy; the story says the same joy is present before the angels of God over one repenting sinner.
Theological check. The text says there is "joy in the presence of the angels of God" (verse 10). It shows a search and a sharing. It does not say whom the woman stands for; I add, from the setting in verses 1-2, that the story answers the complaint that Jesus eats with sinners.
Bridge. The story shows a joy that is shared and is not kept to oneself. Strength: modest. It rests on one short story and its setting.
Where I am unsure. A coin does not repent. I do not know how far the comparison between the coin and a sinner reaches. What would change my mind: a reading that shows what the comparison is meant to hold.
Now read it back, in the way lecture 5-1 and the checklist at the end of this lecture teach.
What is strong. The edges give a reason. The structure line marks its own weak point. The main point stays close to the text, and the "unsure" entry names a real question with a line about what would change the writer's mind.
What is weak. The background paragraph states a guess as a fact. "Most likely part of her savings, kept for a wedding" is a reasonable-sounding picture, and the text does not say it. The text says only that she lost one of ten coins, and nothing on the page marks the sentence as conjecture, so a reader of the page alone would take it as history. This is the fault of lecture 4-1: a guess that has become part of the story. The key-word part has a smaller weakness: it admits that translations were not compared, which is honest, but leaves the part nearly empty.
Notice what a reader could do with this page. They could check each claim against the text. They could find the guess. They could disagree with the structure line. They could answer the writer's last question. That is what the page is for.
6. Reading your own page
When the page is written, read it as a stranger would. Five questions.
- Can a reader find the edges and the main point in under half a minute?
- Does each claim have a verse behind it, or a label that says it does not?
- Is any guess written as a fact?
- Does the structure line or the main point look too neat? If so, what would an awkward fit look like?
- Is the last part full, with a named question, the reason and what would change my mind?
A page that fails the fifth question is not finished, however good the first four parts are. The next lecture is a lab in which you write this page for Luke 15:11-32.
Diagram 1. The one-page summary: eight parts
Diagram 2. Reading a page back
| Question | A sign of trouble |
|---|---|
| Can the edges and the main point be found quickly? | They are buried, or the main point is spread over several sentences |
| Is there a verse behind each claim? | A claim with neither a verse nor a label |
| Is a guess written as a fact? | Words such as "most likely" with nothing behind them |
| Is the structure too neat? | Every verse fits its place exactly |
| Is the last part full? | Empty, or one vague line |
In short
- A one-page summary records an exegesis so that another person can check it; it is not a sermon or a commentary.
- Its eight parts are the edges, structure line, key word and translation choice, background, main point, theological check, bridge and where I am unsure.
- Use three levels of language: stated, judged with a reason, and not sure, named once in the last part.
- The last part holds what I am unsure of, why, and what would change my mind; an empty part makes every claim look equally firm.
- Read the page back as a stranger would, looking for a guess written as a fact and for a structure that fits too neatly.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The eight parts | Edges; structure line; key word and translation choice; background; main point; theological check; bridge; where I am unsure. |
| Three levels of language | Stated (the text says it); judged (I weighed it, here is why); not sure (named once, in the last part). |
| Where I am unsure | What I am unsure of; why; what would change my mind. |
| Reading it back | Find a guess written as a fact, a structure too neat, a claim with no verse, and an empty last part. |
One sentence to remember A page that shows where it is soft can be trusted where it is firm.
This week's action Take one old note of your own and cut it to one sentence per part, then write the last part first.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Why does the lecture say that a step which cannot be put in a sentence may not have been done?
- Why is the last part, "where I am unsure", described as the one that costs the writer something?
- Look at the three levels of language. Take a sentence you have written about a passage and say which level it belongs to.
- In the model summary of Luke 15:8-10, which weakness did you find first? Was there a second one?
- Why should a page hold only one key word and one translation choice, and what would be lost by listing six?
- A reader says, "The page is too uncertain to be useful." Another says, "The page is too sure." How would you use the three levels to answer both?