Lecture 2-1: The Confessions: Writing the Inner Life
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What "Spirituality" Means and How to Read a Classic
- Lecture 1-2: The Desert Fathers and Mothers
- Lecture 1-3: Benedict's Rule and the Western Monastery
- Lecture 1-4: Women and Households of the Early Church
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Reading One Page of a Classic
- Lecture 2-1: The Confessions: Writing the Inner Life
- Lecture 2-2: God in the Dark: Eastern Mystical Theology
- Lecture 2-3: Hesychasm and the Philokalia
- Lecture 2-4: The Spiritual Father and the Elder
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Classic, Two Pairs of Eyes
- Lecture 3-1: The Way of Love: the Cistercians and Bernard
- Lecture 3-2: Poverty and Brotherhood: Francis and Clare
- Lecture 3-3: Women and Laity: Julian, Catherine and the Cloud of Unknowing
- Lecture 3-4: The Imitation of Christ and the Modern Devotion
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Gift and Shadow
- Lecture 4-1: Ignatius and Carmel: Spirituality in Catholic Reform
- Lecture 4-2: The Calling of Ordinary Life: Luther, Calvin and Protestant Spirituality
- Lecture 4-3: Puritans, Pietists, Moravians and Wesley
- Lecture 4-4: Devotional Classics for Ordinary Readers: Bunyan and Law
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Shape of a Day
- Lecture 5-1: Songs under Slavery: the Spirituality of the Black Church
- Lecture 5-2: Holiness and Pentecost: Experience at the Centre
- Lecture 5-3: Ways Around the World
- Lecture 5-4: Hymns as Spiritual Classics
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Reading a Song
Most of the books that Christians read in the first four centuries were letters, sermons, lives of saints, explanations of Scripture and defences of the faith. Very few were a person telling the story of his own heart. Then, about the year 400, a bishop in North Africa wrote one. He did not write it to be read first by people. He wrote it as a prayer, spoken to God, and the readers listen in.
That book is the Confessions of Augustine of Hippo. It is one of the most widely read books in the history of the Western church. It is also a book that readers have understood in different ways, and it has been admired, copied, argued over and worried about for sixteen hundred years.
This week we look at two books and two traditions that speak, in very different voices, of a God who is more than words can hold. This first lecture takes the Western one. It asks what kind of book the Confessions is, what its theme is, who stands in the story besides its author, and why it became a classic. It also asks the question that every classic of the inner life must face: when a person writes honestly about the self, is that a way toward God, or a way of looking in a mirror?
Remember the boundary of this course. We are not reading Augustine's arguments about grace, sin or the Trinity; those belong to the courses on the early fathers and on particular persons (CH402E and CH403E). Here he appears as the author of one spiritual classic, and we read the book as a book.
What these 24 minutes give you
- Describe the *Confessions* as a prayer-like narrative addressed to God, and explain the two meanings of the word "confession".
- Name the book's main theme, the restless heart and its rest, and say where in the book it begins and where it is taken up again.
- Say what the book shows of Monica and of Augustine's friends, and why that part of the story comes to us through one man's eyes.
- State one reason the book became a classic, and one honest worry about the writing of the inner life.
As the deer pants for the water brooks, so my soul pants after you, God." — Psalm 42:1
World English Bible
My soul thirsts for God, for the living God. When shall I come and appear before God?" — Psalm 42:2
WEB
God, you are my God. I will earnestly seek you. My soul thirsts for you. My flesh longs for you, in a dry and weary land, where there is no water." — Psalm 63:1
WEB
The Psalms were the prayer book of the early church, and Augustine's book is full of them. These two psalms speak of thirst. Thirst is a good picture for what he calls the restless heart: a need that is not an illness, and that only one thing satisfies.
1. What kind of book it is
The Confessions is not an autobiography in the modern sense. It does not tell a life evenly from the first day to the last. It tells the parts of a life that Augustine thought mattered for one question: how did God bring a wandering person home?
Augustine was born in 354 in Thagaste, a town in North Africa, in the Roman Empire. He became a teacher of rhetoric, which means the art of public speaking. He taught in Carthage, then in Rome, then in Milan. In Milan, in 386, something changed in him, and in 387 he was baptised. Later he returned to Africa, became a priest and then bishop of Hippo, and died there in 430. The book was written about ten years after his change, around the year 400.
The book has thirteen parts, which the ancient world called books. Readers usually divide it into three. The first nine tell his story: childhood, schooling, years of ambition, a long search, his change in Milan, and the death of his mother. The tenth turns to the act of remembering, and asks how a person can hold the past inside the mind. The last three turn to time, to the beginning of the world, and to the first chapters of Genesis. The book moves from "what happened to me" to "what is time" to "how did anything begin". The author is following one thought outwards, from one person to the whole creation.
2. Two meanings of "confession"
The title is a clue. The Latin word that Augustine uses can mean two things, and the book does both.
Confession
In the Latin of Augustine's time, the word confessio meant to admit a fault. It also meant to praise, to acknowledge openly who God is. Augustine's book confesses sin and confesses praise. Often it does both in the same sentence.
This matters for how we read it. Someone who expects only a long list of sins will be surprised. Someone who expects only a hymn of praise will be surprised in the other direction. The book speaks to God, not to the reader, and it assumes that to tell the truth about oneself is already a kind of praise of the God who knows it.
Notice also what the form does to the reader. We are placed in the position of someone who overhears. We are not told, "this is what you should do". We are shown one person's prayer and invited to see whether our own matches or not.
3. The restless heart
The theme that everyone remembers comes in the first pages. Augustine says, in a sentence people have quoted for centuries, that God made us for himself and that our heart is restless until it finds rest in God. We will not quote it here as if it were a verse; it is a summary of what the book says at its opening, and it is better to take the idea than to fix the words.
The idea is simple, and the whole book is a test of it. Augustine tells how he looked for rest in many places. He looked for it in praise and success as a young teacher. He looked for it in friendship, in love, in the pleasure of a good argument. He looked for it in a religious movement of the time, Manichaeism, which promised a clear explanation of good and evil, and which he followed for several years. He looked for it in philosophy. In each place he found something real, and in each place the thirst came back.
Two scenes in the book are often retold because they are so plain.
The first is the pears. At sixteen, he tells us, he and some friends stole fruit from a neighbour's tree at night. They did not need it. They threw most of it to pigs. Augustine spends pages asking why he did it, and his answer is that he did it for the sake of doing it, and because he was not alone. He does not blame the pears or the neighbour. The scene is a small one, and it is chosen because it is small. A reader might expect a large crime. He gives us a small one and looks at it for a long time.
The second is the death of a friend. When a close friend in Thagaste died, Augustine wrote that the whole city became a place of grief for him, and that he carried a wounded soul that could not rest anywhere. Readers have found this part among the most honest in the book, because it does not try to turn grief into a lesson too quickly.
4. The garden in Milan
The turning point comes in book 8, and it is a scene the church has told for sixteen centuries. Augustine, in Milan, in a state of deep unrest, goes out into a garden with a friend. He weeps. He hears, he records, a voice like a child's from a nearby house, repeating words that he took to mean "take up and read". He went back, picked up the book of Paul's letters that lay there, and read the first passage his eyes fell on. It was a passage about leaving behind the life of the flesh and putting on the Lord Jesus Christ (the passage is Romans 13:13-14).
We describe this; we do not judge it. The church of his time read it as the turning of a life. Some modern readers have wondered how much of the scene is an exact record and how much is shaped by the author's later understanding of it. The church has not needed to settle that. What is plain is that Augustine himself placed the turning inside Scripture and inside a friendship, with other people nearby and a book in his hand. It was not a private flash in an empty room.
5. Monica and the friends
Three people at most are in the centre of this book, and one of them is not Augustine.
Monica was his mother. According to the book, she prayed for him through years of his wandering, followed him to Milan, and stayed close through his struggle. She was a North African Christian woman of the fourth century, with a strong will, and the book does not hide that. It also shows her as someone who listened to the preaching of Bishop Ambrose, and who worshipped with the rest of the church in Milan. The scene that is most remembered is at Ostia, the port of Rome, shortly before her death in 387. The two of them, the book tells us, stood at a window looking out on a garden and talked quietly about what the life of heaven would be. Augustine records that in the talk they seemed for a moment to touch something beyond all speech, and then came back to the sound of ordinary talk. Monica died a few days after. In her last days, he tells us, she told her sons that the place of her burial did not matter.
Here is a question the course will meet again. Monica comes to us only through her son's words. We do not have a single page in her hand. Her prayers, her patience and her faith reach us through a man who loved her and who was also, at that time, writing to explain himself. That is not a reason to doubt her. It is a reason to remember that the voices of women in this history are often carried by men's pens (lecture 1-4).
Augustine's friends are the other presence in the book. He writes of one who died young, and of others with whom he planned a shared life of study. The Confessions is a book about a person, and the person is never alone in it. The unnamed woman with whom he lived for many years and who is the mother of his son, is mentioned only briefly, and she never gets a name. The silence about her is also a part of what the book is.
6. Why it became a classic
A classic is a book that people go on reading in situations that its writer never imagined. Several things helped this one.
It is honest about its author. The book does not give a picture of a saint. It gives a person who was proud, ambitious, confused and afraid, and who found, as the book tells it, that this person was known and loved.
It speaks to God. Because the whole book is a prayer, a reader who is not sure of their faith can still use it. They may not be sure what to say to God, but here is someone who says it, in good prose, and in a tone they can recognise.
It joins the story and the thought. A reader begins with a boy stealing fruit and ends, a few hundred pages later, thinking about time. Few books move so naturally from a personal scene to the largest questions.
It crossed the divisions of the Western church. Catholic, Protestant and many other readers in the West have read it and used it. Augustine's name is claimed by many later movements, and they disagree about what he meant. But the book, as a book of the heart, has been read across those lines. The Eastern churches wrote in Greek, and Augustine wrote in Latin, so the book belongs mainly to the story of the West.
7. Gift and shadow
The course asks two questions of every classic: what gift did it give, and what shadow or question did it leave?
The gift. The Confessions showed that the inner life can be told, and that telling it truthfully can be a form of prayer. It gave later believers a way to speak of their own wandering. It joined the longing of the Psalms to the story of one person. It says that the restless heart is not a defect to be removed, but a sign of what we are made for.
The shadow and the question. Readers have asked several honest questions, and the course does not answer them for you.
First: does writing about the inner life lead a person toward God or toward the self? Augustine's own form guards against it, since the book is addressed to God, and it does not stay long on the self without turning outward. But a form can be borrowed without its direction. Later readers, including some who loved the book, have worried that attention to one's own inner states can slowly become the main subject.
Second: does the stress on guilt and sin, which is large in the book, shape later readers to see themselves mainly as failures? Some writers have argued that the Western church became more anxious about the individual conscience than the Bible requires. Others have replied that the book speaks so much of mercy that the guilt is always met with it. Both readings can be defended from the text.
Third: whose story is left out? The book tells one man's story. His mother, his friend, the woman with whom he lived, are seen from outside. That is the shadow of every confession written by one person, and it is not a fault peculiar to Augustine.
None of this reduces the book. A classic is a neighbour to talk with, not a model to copy. We can learn from its honesty, and also notice what it leaves unsaid.
8. A word about this course's boundaries
Augustine later wrote long works on grace, sin and the nature of the church, and these are among the most debated writings in Western Christianity. They are not part of this lecture. If you want to know what he argued, the course on the early fathers (CH402E) and the course on particular persons and movements (CH403E) take it up. If you want to know how to pray, the course on the history and practice of prayer (LM106E) is the place. Here we have asked only what kind of book this is and why people still open it.
Diagram 1. The shape of the Confessions
Diagram 2. Reading a confession: questions to ask
| Question | What to look for in the Confessions |
|---|---|
| Who is speaking, and to whom? | One person, speaking to God, with the reader overhearing |
| What form is it? | A narrative that turns into reflection, and a prayer throughout |
| What is the thread? | The restless heart and its rest |
| Who else is in the story? | Monica and friends, seen through one man's eyes |
| What is left unsaid? | The woman he lived with, the voices of others, anything he did not choose to tell |
In short
- The Confessions (about the year 400) is a narrative prayer addressed to God, and "confession" means both admitting fault and praising.
- Its theme is the restless heart and its rest; the first nine books tell his story and the last four turn to memory, time and creation.
- The pears and the death of a friend are plain scenes that show the heart looking for rest in the wrong places.
- Monica and the friends reach us through one man's writing, so their voices come to us from outside.
- It became a classic through its honesty, its prayer form and its movement from one life to large questions.
- The gift is truthful telling of the inner life as prayer; the questions are self-absorption, heavy guilt and whose story is left out.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Confessions | Augustine's book of about the year 400, a prayer in which confession means both admitting fault and praising God. |
| The restless heart | The book's thread: the heart looks for rest in many places and finds it fully only in God. |
| Monica | Augustine's mother, seen in the book only through his eyes. |
| Gift and shadow | The inner life told truthfully as prayer; the question of self-absorption, and of whose story is left unsaid. |
One sentence to remember A classic of the inner life is an old neighbour talking to God while we overhear, and we are free to ask what it says and what it leaves out.
This week's action Think of one book that has been honest with you about someone's inner life, and write down one gift it gave and one question it left.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- The word "confession" meant both admitting a fault and praising. What changes in how you read a book if it is both at once?
- Augustine chose the story of stolen pears, not a large crime, to look at sin. What does that choice say about how he understood himself?
- The book is addressed to God, not to the reader. Why might that matter to a reader who is unsure of their own faith?
- Monica and the friends reach us only through Augustine's writing. What is gained and what is lost when a story is told by one person about others?
- Some readers worry that writing about the inner life can become a study of the self. Others say that this book turns outward again and again. How would you test which is true of a book you know?
- If you were to describe one gift and one shadow of this book to a friend who has never read it, what would you say?