Lecture 6-1: Classics of the Twentieth Century
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What "Spirituality" Means and How to Read a Classic
- Lecture 1-2: The Desert Fathers and Mothers
- Lecture 1-3: Benedict's Rule and the Western Monastery
- Lecture 1-4: Women and Households of the Early Church
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Reading One Page of a Classic
- Lecture 2-1: The Confessions: Writing the Inner Life
- Lecture 2-2: God in the Dark: Eastern Mystical Theology
- Lecture 2-3: Hesychasm and the Philokalia
- Lecture 2-4: The Spiritual Father and the Elder
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Classic, Two Pairs of Eyes
- Lecture 3-1: The Way of Love: the Cistercians and Bernard
- Lecture 3-2: Poverty and Brotherhood: Francis and Clare
- Lecture 3-3: Women and Laity: Julian, Catherine and the Cloud of Unknowing
- Lecture 3-4: The Imitation of Christ and the Modern Devotion
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Gift and Shadow
- Lecture 4-1: Ignatius and Carmel: Spirituality in Catholic Reform
- Lecture 4-2: The Calling of Ordinary Life: Luther, Calvin and Protestant Spirituality
- Lecture 4-3: Puritans, Pietists, Moravians and Wesley
- Lecture 4-4: Devotional Classics for Ordinary Readers: Bunyan and Law
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Shape of a Day
- Lecture 5-1: Songs under Slavery: the Spirituality of the Black Church
- Lecture 5-2: Holiness and Pentecost: Experience at the Centre
- Lecture 5-3: Ways Around the World
- Lecture 5-4: Hymns as Spiritual Classics
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Reading a Song
Most of the books in this course are old. Some are very old, and their authors lived in worlds that no longer exist. This lecture turns to the century just ended, the twentieth. It was a century of two world wars, of cheap printing and of great movements of people, and it left a number of spiritual books that are still read in many languages.
We will meet three people, all now dead: a German pastor, an American monk and an American journalist. Each wrote a book that readers still pick up. Each lived through a time when the world pressed hard on the church, and each answered in a different way. They are not a list of heroes, and they are not the "best" of the century. They are three neighbours to talk with. For each we ask the two questions of this whole course: what gift did this way give, and what question did it leave?
A word on what this lecture does not do. It does not teach the thought of these people; the theology of Bonhoeffer belongs to the course on particular persons and movements (CH403E). It does not judge any of them. And it does not offer their lives as patterns to copy.
What these 24 minutes give you
- Describe, for Bonhoeffer, Merton and Day, one book or work, one scene and the setting in which it was received.
- State one gift and one open question for each of the three, without ranking them.
- Explain why the pairs "action and silence" and "community and the world" are a teaching device and not a sorting of the three people.
- Read a modern classic with the four questions of lecture 1-1: who wrote, to whom, in what form, in what age.
for I was hungry, and you gave me food to eat. I was thirsty, and you gave me drink. I was a stranger, and you took me in. I was naked, and you clothed me. I was sick, and you visited me. I was in prison, and you came to me.’ “Then the righteous will answer him, saying, ‘Lord, when did we see you hungry, and feed you; or thirsty, and give you a drink? When did we see you as a stranger, and take you in; or naked, and clothe you? When did we see you sick, or in prison, and come to you?’ “The King will answer them, ‘Most certainly I tell you, because you did it to one of the least of these my brothers, you did it to me.’" — Matthew 25:35-40
World English Bible
He said to all, “If anyone desires to come after me, let him deny himself, take up his cross, and follow me." — Luke 9:23
WEB
The first passage is the one that many Christians of every tradition have heard read when the church speaks of the hungry and the stranger. The second is the saying about the cross, which some of the people in this lecture read as a call to share the cost of a neighbour's life. We use them here as the background of the three stories, not as a verdict on any of them.
1. A recent classic is still an old neighbour
Lecture 1-1 offered four questions for any classic: who wrote it, to whom, in what form, and in what age. They work as well on a book from 1939 as on one from the fourth century.
A recent classic has one special difficulty. We are too close. Some readers have parents who remember these people, and photographs and recordings exist. That closeness makes it easy to turn a person into a banner, for or against some present cause. The old rule of this course still holds: a classic is not a model to copy. It is a neighbour to talk with, and every neighbour has both gifts and shadows.
2. Dietrich Bonhoeffer and Life Together
Where. Germany in the 1930s. A state was pressing the churches to bend to its wishes, and a part of the Lutheran church refused. Bonhoeffer, a Lutheran pastor and teacher, helped to train ministers for that part of the church in a small residential seminary. The students and teachers lived together, ate together and began and ended the day together. The authorities closed the seminary in 1937.
What the book is. Life Together appeared in 1939. It is a short book about the common life of Christians. It was written out of that seminary's days, and it is not a study in theology. Its aim is practical and pastoral. It describes a day shaped by shared worship, with Scripture read, psalms sung and prayer said in company; it speaks of meals and of work; it has a chapter on time alone, since a person who cannot be alone is not helped by the group, and it speaks of one believer confessing to another. At its heart is a claim about community: it is not something we build to our own plan and then enjoy. It is a gift, received from Christ, and the first mistake is to love a dream of community more than the actual people who are there.
One scene. A morning in that house. The students gather before breakfast and read from the Psalms together, then sing a hymn, and one of them leads a prayer. Nobody has to say anything clever. The day has begun with the Word before the news, and it has begun together.
How it was received. It has been widely read, and by readers in churches quite different from the author's. Its picture of a shared, ordered day has something in common with the rule of a monastery (lecture 1-3), and some readers in religious communities have noticed it.
The gift. The book takes the weight of community off the individual's shoulders. It says, in effect, that you are carried by the faith of others on days when your own is thin, and that others are carried by yours. It also treats the ordinary details of daily life, such as meals, work and singing, as places where the Gospel is lived.
The question it leaves. It was written for a small group living together, in a time of crisis, with a teacher and a shared timetable. Most Christians do not live like that. A parish or a congregation meets for a few hours a week, and its members have jobs, children and long journeys. Readers differ on how much of the book travels. Some find that its core, the Word and prayer and honest speech between believers, reaches any gathering. Others find the picture too close to a chosen community, and feel that the book does not know the ordinary, mixed parish that must hold together people who did not choose each other.
There is a second question, and it is about the author's own life. Bonhoeffer later joined the resistance against the regime. He was arrested and was executed in April 1945, shortly before the war ended. Some readers see his life as the sequel to his book, a shared life of prayer leading outward into costly action. Others warn against reading a life as a neat story. He left no recipe for resistance, and the choices of a person under such a state are not a pattern for anyone else.
3. Thomas Merton: a monk whose silence was read by the world
Where. A Trappist monastery in Kentucky, which he entered at the end of 1941. The Trappists are a Catholic order in the line of the Cistercians you met in lecture 3-1: a strict life of prayer, work and, for most of the day, silence.
What the work is. His first great success was an autobiography published in 1948. It tells of a restless young man who found his way, by a winding road, into the cloister. The abbey had not expected it to travel far. It sold widely, and readers of all kinds wrote to him. Many of them would never enter a monastery. Over the next two decades he wrote many more books, on silence and prayer and on the older writers of the desert and of the monasteries. Then, increasingly, he wrote on matters outside the walls: war, the way people of different races are treated, and the faiths of Asia. He died in 1968 while travelling in Asia to take part in a meeting of monks.
One scene. A monk in a quiet house, at a desk, writing a letter to someone far away who has read his book and does not know what to do with a restless heart. The monastery is a place of silence, and yet it sends a great many letters. The tension between the two is part of the story.
How it was received. Many readers took him as a guide to the inner life. Others were troubled by a monk who wrote so much and so publicly. Within his own church, some of his later writings on war and on other religions were welcomed, and some were questioned. This course takes no side. We note only that the same man was loved and questioned for the same books.
The gift. He gave a language for silence and for restlessness to readers who had no cloister. A reader who had never heard of the desert tradition could find, through him, a way to speak about wanting to be still.
The question it leaves. The first book speaks of the world as something a person leaves behind. Later he himself came to see the world differently, and his own writing records that change. This leaves a real question for his readers: how far does a monk's voice belong to the world he first spoke of leaving? A second question is quieter. Silence is the subject of the work and yet the work made a very large public. Readers ask whether a way of silence can be shared widely without being altered by the sharing.
4. Dorothy Day: bread, a bed and a newspaper
Where. New York in the 1930s, during years of hardship in which many people had no work and no home. Day was a journalist who had lived in radical circles. She became a Catholic in 1927, and that decision cost her some friendships. In the early 1930s she began a penny newspaper and, with the help of a co-worker, opened houses of welcome where the hungry could eat and the homeless could sleep.
What the work is. Her way joined three things that readers often keep apart: the worship of the Catholic church, which she valued, attended regularly and did not want to leave; a plain, daily hospitality, in which meals were cooked and beds were made by people who had little themselves; and a public voice against war and against what she saw as injustice to the poor. Her autobiography, published in 1952, tells the story and does not hide her own failures. Its title speaks of loneliness, and the book does not present her as a finished saint.
One scene. A kitchen early in the morning. Soup is being made in a large pot. A man comes in from the street, is given a bowl and a place at the table, and is not asked to prove that he deserves it. The same people who ladled the soup went to Mass.
How it was received. With admiration and with anger, often in the same room. Many people, in her church and outside it, saw in her work a living picture of Matthew 25. Others, during the wars of her time, thought her opposition to war was unwise or unpatriotic, and some in her own church were uneasy about her public protests. She was arrested more than once for taking part in them. She died in 1980. Some Catholics have asked whether she should be recognised as a saint, and the church has a process for examining such a question. This course does not judge the outcome, and it does not treat any person's holiness as ours to rule on.
The gift. Her life lets the reader see prayer and hospitality as one thing and not two. Faith that never feeds anyone is a question to ask of ourselves; so, in the other direction, is hospitality that never prays.
The question it leaves. A life of welcome with no end meets the limits of tired people. Readers ask what such a way costs the helpers who work beside the one who leads it, and whether it can be sustained over many years. Readers also differ on her views on war: some see in them a faithful reading of the Gospel, and others see a reading that the church of her day did not share. A reader may find either account worth hearing.
Gift and question
Throughout this course, a gift is what a way of living gave to those who lived it and to those who came after. A question is what the way left open: a cost, a limit, a person it did not reach, or a point on which readers still differ. A question is not an accusation. It is what an honest reader says after thanking the author.
5. Reading the three together, and not too neatly
It is tempting to arrange them in a neat table. Merton stands for silence, Day for action. Bonhoeffer stands for the community and the others for the world. The table is handy for teaching, and the diagram below uses it. It is also too neat.
Merton wrote a great deal about war and about the treatment of people, and in his last years he lived part of the time in a small hermitage on the abbey grounds. Day went to Mass often and wrote about prayer. Bonhoeffer's book has a chapter on the day spent alone, and his later life was spent far from any shared timetable. Each of them held both sides of each pair, in a different mix, and none held them in balance. When two facts connect too neatly, the neatness may come from our teaching and not from the evidence.
What can honestly be said is smaller. Each was trying, in a hard time, to join the inner life to the neighbour in front of them. Each did it in the way that their church and their century made possible. Readers who have walked through lectures 1-2 and 1-3 may hear old echoes: a withdrawal for the sake of listening, a daily order, a life with the poor. Those echoes are the reader's, not a claim that any of the three modelled themselves on an earlier way.
6. A note on what is history here
These are three lives, not three programmes. Day's poverty and Merton's solitude are described as history. Nothing here suggests that more hardship, silence or poverty makes a person more faithful, and lecture 6-2 returns to what the old traditions knew about the cost of ways with no rest.
Diagram 1. Three neighbours, a gift and a question each
Diagram 2. Reading a modern classic with the four questions of lecture 1-1
| Question | Bonhoeffer | Merton | Day |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who wrote it? | A pastor and teacher of ministers | A monk and writer | A journalist who became a Catholic |
| To whom? | Believers living or meeting together | A wide public, most of them outside the cloister | Readers of a newspaper, and later a wider public |
| In what form? | A short book on the common life | An autobiography, then many books and letters | A newspaper, houses of welcome, an autobiography |
| In what age? | A state pressing the churches | A century of war and a new public for religion | Years of hardship, then years of war |
In short
- Bonhoeffer, Merton and Day are three deceased authors of twentieth-century classics; each is read for a gift and a question, not as a model to copy.
- Life Together treats shared life as a gift received from Christ; its question is how a small chosen community's shape reaches an ordinary congregation.
- Merton gave readers outside the cloister a language of silence; readers differ on how far a monk's voice belongs to the world.
- Day joined worship, hospitality and a public voice; her life leaves a question about what such a life costs the helpers around it.
- The pairs "action and silence" and "community and the world" are a teaching device, too neat for the lives themselves.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Bonhoeffer and Life Together | A pastor's book on common worship and daily life, a gift received from Christ; it leaves the question of how a small community's shape reaches a congregation. |
| Merton | A Trappist monk whose autobiography and later writing reached many outside the cloister; readers differ on how far his voice belonged to the world. |
| Dorothy Day | A journalist and Catholic who joined worship, hospitality and a public voice; her way leaves the question of what it costs the helpers. |
| The table is too neat | Each of the three held both sides of silence and action, and of community and the world, in a different mix. |
One sentence to remember A recent classic is still an old neighbour: we thank it for its gift and ask honestly about its cost.
This week's action Choose one of the three scenes and write two sentences: one gift it gave and one question it leaves.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Which of the three scenes (the morning psalms, the monk's letter, the kitchen) is closest to a scene from your own tradition? Which is furthest? What does the distance tell you?
- Why might a book written for a small seminary community be hard to carry into an ordinary congregation? What would have to change, and what would have to stay?
- Merton's first book speaks of leaving the world, and his later work turns toward it. Why might a reader be glad of both, and why might a reader find the change unsettling?
- Day joined prayer and hospitality. What happens to each when it is kept apart from the other?
- The lecture says the table of "silence, action, community, world" is too neat. Where does the neatness break down?
- Why does the lecture refuse to say which of the three is the best neighbour? Does the refusal help you read them, or frustrate you?