Lecture 6-3: Discernment: Joining the Classics and Today
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What "Spirituality" Means and How to Read a Classic
- Lecture 1-2: The Desert Fathers and Mothers
- Lecture 1-3: Benedict's Rule and the Western Monastery
- Lecture 1-4: Women and Households of the Early Church
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Reading One Page of a Classic
- Lecture 2-1: The Confessions: Writing the Inner Life
- Lecture 2-2: God in the Dark: Eastern Mystical Theology
- Lecture 2-3: Hesychasm and the Philokalia
- Lecture 2-4: The Spiritual Father and the Elder
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Classic, Two Pairs of Eyes
- Lecture 3-1: The Way of Love: the Cistercians and Bernard
- Lecture 3-2: Poverty and Brotherhood: Francis and Clare
- Lecture 3-3: Women and Laity: Julian, Catherine and the Cloud of Unknowing
- Lecture 3-4: The Imitation of Christ and the Modern Devotion
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Gift and Shadow
- Lecture 4-1: Ignatius and Carmel: Spirituality in Catholic Reform
- Lecture 4-2: The Calling of Ordinary Life: Luther, Calvin and Protestant Spirituality
- Lecture 4-3: Puritans, Pietists, Moravians and Wesley
- Lecture 4-4: Devotional Classics for Ordinary Readers: Bunyan and Law
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Shape of a Day
- Lecture 5-1: Songs under Slavery: the Spirituality of the Black Church
- Lecture 5-2: Holiness and Pentecost: Experience at the Centre
- Lecture 5-3: Ways Around the World
- Lecture 5-4: Hymns as Spiritual Classics
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Reading a Song
Lecture 6-2 ended with a list of four questions that the old traditions asked of any teaching or experience. This lecture takes those questions up and looks at them more closely. The word the traditions used for the whole practice is discernment: the patient work of telling what is of God from what is not, and what helps people from what harms them.
The central claim of this course is that the history of Christian spirituality is not one correct course to God, and that a classic is an old neighbour to talk with. Discernment is what makes that talk safe. It lets a reader take a gift from a neighbour and still ask a question. The old traditions did their discerning inside a community, and that is where this lecture ends.
We will see how several traditions tested experience and teaching, each in its own terms; four tests that many of them shared, and how each can fail; four great questions on which the traditions have not agreed; and one disagreement about the relation of spirituality to theology. The lecture ends with the smallest set of commitments that this course asks of its readers.
What these 23 minutes give you
- Explain discernment as the testing of teaching and experience, and say why the traditions did it inside a community.
- Describe how at least three traditions tested experience, in terms that a member of each would recognise.
- Name four common tests, and give one way in which each can fail.
- State fairly the disagreement about the relation of spirituality and theology, from each side.
- Say what this course asks of its readers at a minimum, and what it does not ask.
Don’t quench the Spirit. Don’t despise prophesies. Test all things, and hold firmly that which is good. Abstain from every form of evil." — 1 Thessalonians 5:19-22
World English Bible
This I pray, that your love may abound yet more and more in knowledge and all discernment; so that you may approve the things that are excellent; that you may be sincere and without offense to the day of Christ;" — Philippians 1:9-10
WEB
The first passage puts two warnings side by side: do not put out what the Spirit is doing, and do not accept everything without testing it. The second is a prayer that love should grow together with knowledge and with discernment. Each tradition in this lecture reads these verses as addressed to its own people.
1. What the word means
The English word discernment comes from a Latin verb meaning to separate or to tell apart. In the Greek of the New Testament, the matching word is diakrisis. Paul lists among the gifts of the Spirit a kind of discerning of spirits (1 Corinthians 12:10), and the verses you have just read ask for testing and for a love that grows in discernment. The idea is therefore not borrowed from outside the Bible.
Discernment
Discernment is the work, done over time and usually with others, of testing a teaching, an experience or a course of action, to tell what is good and of God from what is mistaken or harmful. It is closer to a careful listening than to a verdict. It is a practice of the community as well as of the individual.
Two things about it matter for this course. First, discernment is a practice for people who are taking something seriously. Nobody discerns what they do not care about. A reader who takes the classics seriously needs it as much as a leader does. Second, discernment is not suspicion. The two verses in 1 Thessalonians put "do not quench" next to "test". A community that tests everything and welcomes nothing has not discerned; it has simply closed.
2. How some traditions tested, in their own terms
What follows is a summary, not a survey. Each tradition has more to say, and its own members would say it better. We take care to describe each in a way a member would recognise.
The desert and the monastery. The old monastic writers prized a quality they called discretion, the ability to judge what is fitting for this person at this time. Cassian's record of desert conversations (see lecture 1-2) gives a whole conversation to it. Benedict's Rule asks the abbot to temper everything, so that the strong still have something to reach for and the weak do not run away (lecture 1-3). The test was not a rule but a trained sense, learned beside a more experienced person and inside a community.
The Catholic way. For Catholics, a claim of an experience or a revelation is examined by the church. A confessor or director listens first, and the church's authorities may examine the matter over a long time. Catholic teaching says that such private revelations are not required to be believed by the faithful. Ignatius of Loyola, whom you met in lecture 4-1, gave guidelines in the Spiritual Exercises for noticing the movements of the inner life, as times of consolation and times of desolation, and for judging where they lead. We give the gist only, and teach no method.
The Orthodox way. Orthodox writers spoke of the danger of delusion, a state in which a person takes their own imagining for grace. The remedy was not a technique. It was a life within the church: the , the Fathers of the church, a spiritual father or mother who has walked the way, and the humility to be corrected (lecture 2-4). An experience was tested by whether it agreed with the faith of the church and whether it led to humility and love.
The Lutheran and Reformed way. Here the test is Scripture, read in the church. The people of Berea, in Acts 17, are praised by Luke for examining the Scriptures daily to see whether Paul's message was so. The confessions of these churches served as a summary of what the church had understood Scripture to say, and the preaching and the shared worship of the congregation was where a teaching was weighed. A feeling was welcomed but did not rule.
The Pietist and Wesleyan way. These traditions asked about the fruit in a life. Did the person become more loving, more honest and more faithful in work? Small groups for mutual questioning, such as the bands and classes of Wesley's societies (lecture 4-3), were a place where a person's account of themselves could be gently tested by others who knew them.
The Friends (Quakers). A person who believed that they were being led to some action was traditionally asked to bring that sense to others in the community, for patient listening, before acting. The community, in its quiet, was where the leading was tested.
The Black church. In many Black churches a testimony or a sermon is answered aloud by the congregation, so that the community's response is part of how a word is received and weighed. The church was, for generations, a community where people who were told by the world that they did not count could be heard (lecture 5-1).
The Pentecostal and charismatic way. In these communities the Spirit's gifts are expected and welcomed. Paul's instruction in 1 Corinthians 14 that others should weigh what a prophet says is read as a standing rule. A word given in a meeting is expected to be tested by the meeting and by Scripture, and a gift that does not build up the body is called into question.
Several traditions, then, each with its own vocabulary. The same few questions can be heard in many of them.
3. Four tests many shared, and how each can fail
The summary that follows is ours. It is not a list that each tradition would write, and no tradition used all four in the same way. It is a way of seeing what they had in common.
1. Agreement with Scripture. Does the teaching or experience agree with the Gospel, as the church has read it? It can fail when verses are picked to suit what the speaker already wants. A person can quote Scripture to defend almost anything, and the Gospels themselves tell of a tempter who does it (Matthew 4).
2. Confirmation in the community. Is it recognised by people who know the person and can answer back? It can fail when a community confirms its own harm. A group that is afraid to disagree, or that has put its leader beyond question, will confirm anything the leader says. This is pattern three in lecture 6-2.
3. Fruit and love of neighbour. Does it make a person more loving, more honest, more patient, more concerned for the neighbour? It can fail because fruit is slow to show and hard to read. A person may be a poor witness at a hard time of life and a good one later, and communities have sometimes judged too fast. Fruit can also be faked for a season.
4. Humility. Is the person willing to be questioned and to be wrong? It can fail when humility is put on as a show. An outward lowliness can hide a settled pride. The old writers knew this, and warned about it.
Four tests, not four rules
No one of these is enough, and they can disagree. A teaching may agree with Scripture and be carried by a leader who cannot be questioned. A community may be warm and may confirm something that Scripture does not support. That is why the traditions did not rely on one test alone, and why they placed discernment inside a community and not in the hands of one person.
4. Four great questions on which the traditions differ
Beyond the tests, there are questions that the traditions have answered differently and that readers still carry. The lecture does not answer them. It sets them out, so that you can see where you stand and where your neighbour does.
Silence and action. Is the life with God mainly a life of withdrawal and listening, or of service to the neighbour? Both are in the Gospels, and Jesus is seen going away to pray and also feeding the crowd. In lecture 6-1 we saw that the same lives held both, in different mixes.
Person and community. Is faith first of all a matter between one person and God, or between God and a people? Traditions that stress the personal turning, and traditions that stress the church as a body, each have a reading of the New Testament to show. Each fears what the other can lose: a faith that is only private can drift away from the neighbour; a faith that is only communal can lose the person.
Self-denial and enjoyment. Luke 9:23 speaks of denying oneself. The Bible also says that creation is good and that it is given to be received with thanks. Some traditions emphasise the fast and some the feast, and most hold both in some measure. As lecture 6-2 said, no instruction to deny oneself is given here, and a person who is ill or low should seek care first.
Mystery and Word. Is the heart of the life with God an encounter that goes beyond words, or a response to what has been spoken and written? The Eastern teachers of God "in the dark" (lecture 2-2), and the Reformation's emphasis on Scripture (lecture 4-2), are two voices on this question. Each is afraid of something. The first fears that God will be shrunk to what we can say; the second fears that experience will float free of the text and of the church.
5. Spirituality and theology
This is a point where readers will not agree. The question is how a person's life with God and the church's teaching about God relate to each other.
Some Christians hold that the two cannot be separated. In much Orthodox thought, theology is something done in prayer, and a person who does not pray cannot speak truly of God. An old Latin saying in the Catholic tradition links the way the church prays to what it believes. For these readers, to study doctrine without the life of prayer is to study a map of a country without ever going there. They fear a theology that has become a school subject.
Other Christians, many of them in the Lutheran and Reformed traditions, are wary of letting the life of devotion judge the doctrine. They fear that feeling, once it is allowed to override the church's teaching, becomes a rule of its own; that a person can feel close to God and be wrong about him; and that the church's confession of the faith is a guard for ordinary believers against the claims of strong personalities. For them, doctrine is a gift to the believer, and the life must be tested against it.
Still others, as in Pietism, Wesleyan holiness and many Pentecostal communities, fear the opposite. They have seen churches in which the doctrine was sound and the life was cold, and they remember how Scripture speaks of a faith that does not show itself in life. For them, a teaching that does not change a person is not yet held.
Each of the three has seen a real harm. Each is right to fear what it fears. What this course requires is less than any one side asks. It requires that you can state each of the three fairly; that you notice when you are using one to dismiss another; and that you hold the question open. The course gives no verdict.
6. The course's minimum
At the close of a course that has covered nearly two thousand years and many regions of the world, it is worth saying plainly what is asked of the reader, and what is not.
- No ranking of traditions. You are not asked to think that all ways are the same. You are asked not to rank them by the standard of your own, and to remember that each has gifts and shadows.
- Honest questions about experience, without verdicts. You may ask of a vision, a gift or a way of silence whether it agrees with Scripture, is confirmed by others and bears fruit. You are not asked to rule on whether another person's experience was genuine, nor to say whether a person is a saint.
- Discernment of what harms people. You are asked to be able to recognise the patterns of lecture 6-2, and to act to protect a person from harm, with others and with proper help.
- Walking your own way inside a community. You are not asked to leave your tradition, and you are not asked to join another. You are asked to walk your own way with others who can ask you questions, and not alone.
The course does not ask you to feel more spiritual, to adopt a practice, or to measure your faith by what you have read.
Diagram 1. Four tests, how each can fail, and four questions still open
Diagram 2. How some traditions tested, in short
| Tradition | Where the testing happened | A word a member would recognise |
|---|---|---|
| Desert and monastery | With an experienced person, in a community | Discretion |
| Catholic | Confessor or director, then the church's authorities | Examination of a claim |
| Orthodox | The liturgy, the Fathers, a spiritual guide | Delusion; humility |
| Lutheran and Reformed | Scripture read and preached in the congregation | The Word; the confession |
| Pietist and Wesleyan | Small groups of mutual questioning | Fruit |
| Friends (Quakers) | The gathered community | A leading, tested |
| Black church and Pentecostal | The congregation's answer; the weighing of a word | Testimony; weighing the prophecy |
In short
- Discernment is the patient testing of teaching and experience, usually with others, to tell what is good and of God from what is mistaken or harmful.
- Traditions tested in their own terms: discretion, examination by the church, life in the liturgy, Scripture in the congregation, fruit, a gathered community.
- Four common tests are Scripture, community, fruit and humility; each can fail, so none is used alone.
- Four great questions remain open: silence and action, person and community, self-denial and enjoyment, mystery and Word.
- On spirituality and theology, some see them as one, some fear feeling will override truth, some fear doctrine without life; the course gives no verdict.
- The course asks for no ranking, honest questions without verdicts, discernment of harm, and walking one's own way inside a community.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Discernment | The patient testing, with others, of teaching and experience, to tell what is of God and helpful from what is mistaken or harmful. |
| Four common tests | Scripture, community, fruit and love of neighbour, humility. Each can fail, so none is used alone. |
| Four great questions | Silence and action; person and community; self-denial and enjoyment; mystery and Word. |
| The course's minimum | No ranking; honest questions without verdicts; discernment of harm; walking your own way inside a community. |
One sentence to remember Discernment is how a reader takes a gift from an old neighbour and still asks a question, and it is done with others.
This week's action Choose one teaching or experience you have met and name which of the four tests you would ask first, and one person you would ask.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Which of the four tests (Scripture, community, fruit, humility) does your own tradition lean on most? Which does it use least?
- The lecture says that the four tests can disagree. Can you think of a case in which a teaching passes one and fails another? What would you do?
- Why does the lecture put "do not quench" next to "test"? What happens to a community that does only one?
- Of the four great questions (silence and action, person and community, self-denial and enjoyment, mystery and Word), which one do you most want to hear another tradition's answer to?
- State, in your own words and as fairly as you can, the strongest worry of someone whose view is the opposite of yours about spirituality and theology.
- Why does the lecture say that the old traditions did their discerning inside a community and not alone? What would be lost if a person did it entirely alone?