FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

CH404E History of Christian Spirituality: Classics and Traditions

Lecture 5-2: Holiness and Pentecost: Experience at the Centre

Contents 31
CH404E History of Christian Spirituality: Classics and Traditions
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Reading the Classics of the Way
  1. Introduction: Reading the Classics of the Way
Chapter 1 · Week 1: The Beginning of the Way - Desert and Monastery
  1. Lecture 1-1: What "Spirituality" Means and How to Read a Classic
  2. Lecture 1-2: The Desert Fathers and Mothers
  3. Lecture 1-3: Benedict's Rule and the Western Monastery
  4. Lecture 1-4: Women and Households of the Early Church
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Reading One Page of a Classic
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Confessions and the Eastern Way
  1. Lecture 2-1: The Confessions: Writing the Inner Life
  2. Lecture 2-2: God in the Dark: Eastern Mystical Theology
  3. Lecture 2-3: Hesychasm and the Philokalia
  4. Lecture 2-4: The Spiritual Father and the Elder
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Classic, Two Pairs of Eyes
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Western Ways of the Middle Ages
  1. Lecture 3-1: The Way of Love: the Cistercians and Bernard
  2. Lecture 3-2: Poverty and Brotherhood: Francis and Clare
  3. Lecture 3-3: Women and Laity: Julian, Catherine and the Cloud of Unknowing
  4. Lecture 3-4: The Imitation of Christ and the Modern Devotion
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Gift and Shadow
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Spirituality in the Age of Reform
  1. Lecture 4-1: Ignatius and Carmel: Spirituality in Catholic Reform
  2. Lecture 4-2: The Calling of Ordinary Life: Luther, Calvin and Protestant Spirituality
  3. Lecture 4-3: Puritans, Pietists, Moravians and Wesley
  4. Lecture 4-4: Devotional Classics for Ordinary Readers: Bunyan and Law
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Shape of a Day
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Songs and Revivals, Ways around the World
  1. Lecture 5-1: Songs under Slavery: the Spirituality of the Black Church
  2. Lecture 5-2: Holiness and Pentecost: Experience at the Centre
  3. Lecture 5-3: Ways Around the World
  4. Lecture 5-4: Hymns as Spiritual Classics
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Reading a Song
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Classics of the Modern Age and Discernment
  1. Lecture 6-1: Classics of the Twentieth Century
  2. Lecture 6-2: When Spirituality Harms
  3. Lecture 6-3: Discernment: Joining the Classics and Today
  4. Lecture 6-4: Many Roads, One Question
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: My Reading Map

Jump to the key points ↓

23 min

Last lecture we met a spirituality carried by song and gathered people. This lecture meets another, which put one thing at the centre: the experience of the Holy Spirit. For the people of the holiness movements, and then of Pentecostal churches, faith was not first a set of ideas or a rule of life. It was something that happened, in the body, in a meeting, to ordinary people, and that changed how they lived and prayed.

This is a way that other traditions have sometimes found hard to understand. Catholic and Orthodox readers may ask where the church and the sacraments stand. Reformed and Baptist readers may ask where Scripture stands. A student who has never been in such a meeting may find it noisy or alarming. A student who has may find that a lecture cannot catch what it was. So this lecture will do two things: describe what happened and what the people themselves said about it, and set out fairly why other Christians have asked questions.

We keep to the course's usual rule. We describe experience as "recorded" and do not judge whether any experience was genuine. We say how people tested it, and what it gave and left behind.

What these 23 minutes give you

  • Explain what the holiness movements of the nineteenth century taught and why they put experience at the centre.
  • Describe the beginning of the Pentecostal movement in Los Angeles in 1906, using the scene of William Seymour, and say why historians speak of more than one beginning.
  • State fairly what Pentecostals, charismatics and those who hold that the gifts ceased each believe about the Spirit's gifts, and what each fears.
  • Name one gift and one shadow of this way, including a health caution.

Now when the day of Pentecost had come, they were all with one accord in one place." — Acts 2:1

World English Bible

Suddenly there came from the sky a sound like the rushing of a mighty wind, and it filled all the house where they were sitting." — Acts 2:2

WEB

Tongues like fire appeared and were distributed to them, and one sat on each of them." — Acts 2:3

WEB

They were all filled with the Holy Spirit, and began to speak with other languages, as the Spirit gave them the ability to speak." — Acts 2:4

WEB

Now there are various kinds of gifts, but the same Spirit." — 1 Corinthians 12:4

WEB

There are various kinds of service, and the same Lord." — 1 Corinthians 12:5

WEB

There are various kinds of workings, but the same God, who works all things in all." — 1 Corinthians 12:6

WEB

But to each one is given the manifestation of the Spirit for the profit of all." — 1 Corinthians 12:7

WEB

For to one is given through the Spirit the word of wisdom, and to another the word of knowledge, according to the same Spirit;" — 1 Corinthians 12:8

WEB

to another faith, by the same Spirit; and to another gifts of healings, by the same Spirit;" — 1 Corinthians 12:9

WEB

and to another workings of miracles; and to another prophecy; and to another discerning of spirits; to another different kinds of languages; and to another the interpretation of languages." — 1 Corinthians 12:10

WEB

But the one and the same Spirit works all of these, distributing to each one separately as he desires." — 1 Corinthians 12:11

WEB

All the parties in this lecture read these texts. They differ on what they say about our own time. Notice that Paul's list ends on the Spirit's choice, "as he desires", and begins with the profit of all, not of the one who receives.

1. Holiness: the longing for a whole heart

The holiness movements of the nineteenth century grew in the English-speaking world, especially in the United States and Britain, partly out of the Methodist tradition. Their roots are in the teaching of John Wesley, who spoke of Christian perfection (see lecture 4-3), by which he meant a life made perfect in love, not a life that never errs. Later teachers developed this into a more fixed pattern. Many of them taught that after conversion a believer could look for a second, deeper work of God, often called entire , a word that means being made wholly holy, set apart for God with the whole heart.

The great camp meetings and revivals of the early nineteenth century formed the setting (the general history is in CH202E). People were used to meetings in which many were moved to weep, to cry out and to change their lives. The holiness movements asked what came next. A person had been converted; what then? Could the believer simply stay where he or she began, or was there more?

Our first person in depth is Phoebe Palmer, a Methodist laywoman of the nineteenth century in New York, who died in 1874. From the 1830s she led a weekly gathering in her home that became known as a Tuesday meeting for the promotion of holiness. Women and men came to it, and ministers too, according to the accounts. She taught, to people who sat in an ordinary room and listened and prayed, that a believer could give himself or herself wholly to God and trust that God accepted the gift. She wrote and taught widely, and she was one of the voices that carried holiness teaching across churches. Her scene shows something that will return in this lecture: a form of spirituality that began in a room of ordinary people, led by a woman who held no church office.

The gift of the holiness movements was a seriousness about the whole life, and a hope that the Christian life need not stay small. The shadow was a danger that came with the hope. If one could be "entirely sanctified", then someone who was not could be thought to be lacking. Pressure to claim an experience, and a quiet competition about who had it, are recurring marks of such movements. We will return to this.

2. Pentecost in Los Angeles

The Pentecostal movement drew on the holiness movements and added one thing: the teaching that the baptism in the Holy Spirit is an experience that a believer can receive, often after conversion, and that it is commonly shown by speaking in other languages, often called tongues, as in Acts 2. Early teachers also spoke of healing, prophecy and the other gifts of Paul's list.

How to read the Spirit's gifts today is a question on which readers differ, and the positions are set out fairly after the story.

Our second person in depth is William Seymour. He was the son of formerly enslaved parents in Louisiana and was born around 1870. He became a holiness preacher, and he studied for a time under a teacher in Houston who taught that tongues were the sign of the baptism in the Spirit. In 1906 he went to Los Angeles to serve a small congregation. Meetings began in a private home, and then moved to a plain building on Azusa Street, a former church that had been used for other purposes.

What happened there is known from the writings of people who were present, from newspaper reports and from later memories, and these do not all agree. According to those who were there, meetings ran for long hours, with singing, prayer, testimonies, spoken witness and speaking in tongues, and with less fixed order than most churches of that time. Participants recorded that people of different races and backgrounds sat together and prayed at a time and in a country where most churches were divided by race. Seymour's leadership was marked, according to those accounts, by his gentleness; he did not insist on being at the centre. Newspapers of the city wrote about the meetings with ridicule. Some Christian leaders called them fanaticism. Others travelled to see for themselves, and some came away convinced. Visitors who went home carried the teaching with them.

Two points should be added so that the picture is not too neat. First, historians stress that Pentecostalism had many beginnings, not only one. Similar revivals arose around the same years in several places in the world, with their own leaders, and some were not influenced by Los Angeles at all. Los Angeles is one of the most visited beginnings, not the only one. Second, the picture of an interracial meeting did not last. As the movement grew and formed churches, divisions followed, including along lines of race, as historians record. The scene at Azusa Street shows a gift and a shadow in the same story: a community of unusual openness, and a later history in which that openness was not kept.

3. How the movement spread, and what grew from it

We describe the flow only. From early beginnings, Pentecostal churches grew in many countries and took many local forms. In the middle of the twentieth century the same kind of experience began to appear among members of older churches. This is often called the charismatic renewal, from the Greek word charisma, meaning a gift of grace. It touched Catholic, Anglican, Lutheran and other communities, from around the 1960s. Many of these Christians stayed in their own churches and kept their own worship, while also praying for the Spirit's gifts. Later chapters of Christian history have seen further movements that share some of these features, and we need not trace them here.

4. Three readings of the Spirit's gifts

This is a point where readers will not agree. Here are three readings, set out as their holders would set them out.

Classical Pentecostals teach that the gifts of Acts and of 1 Corinthians 12 were not only for the first century. They believe the same Spirit gives them now, and that a believer should seek the baptism in the Holy Spirit as a real experience after conversion. Many hold that speaking in tongues is the first sign of it. Not all Pentecostals state it so; there are differences within the movement. Their fear is a church with correct teaching and no living power: a church that knows the right words about the Spirit and has no room for the Spirit to act. They fear that a church may "quench" the Spirit, a word taken from Paul.

Charismatics also hold that the gifts continue, but they differ among themselves, and from Pentecostals, about what is and whether tongues must follow it. Many see the Spirit already given at baptism or conversion, and see later experiences as a release or a renewal of what is already present. Their fear is partly the same as the Pentecostals', and partly that an experience may be turned into a test that divides the church into those who have it and those who do not.

Those who hold that the extraordinary gifts ceased are found among some Reformed, Baptist and other Protestant teachers. They teach that gifts such as prophecy, tongues and miracles served the early church's founding, and that with the completion of the apostles' witness and the writing of Scripture they ceased. Their reason is that Scripture is sufficient, and that claims of new revelation, however sincere, can compete with it. Their fear is a church led by feelings and personalities, open to confusion and to the abuse of leaders who say "God told me". They also point to cases where people were harmed by false claims of healing. Not all who hold this view are against the experience of joy and prayer. They hold that the Spirit works in ordinary ways, through the Word, preaching and the common life of the church.

A fourth voice should be mentioned. Many Catholic and Orthodox Christians teach that the Spirit is given in baptism and the sacraments, and that the life of the church is the place where the Spirit's gifts are to be known. They are not against experience, as the charismatic renewal in the Catholic Church shows. But they ask that experience be tested by the whole life and teaching of the church.

What does this course require? Less than any one position requires. It asks you to state each reading in a way that its holders would recognise. It asks you not to treat a believer's experience as either proof or fraud. And it asks you to notice what each position fears, since the fear shows what each is trying to protect: the living work of the Spirit; the authority of Scripture; the unity of the church.

5. Gift and shadow

The gift. Pentecostal and charismatic Christianity put the whole person at worship: voice, body, tears, joy. It gave a place to ordinary people, to women, to the poor and to those with no formal schooling, who could be called to pray, to speak and to lead. It gave hope to people who lived in hard places that God was close and active in their lives. It spread widely among people who had been outside the reach of other churches. It also called the church back to a living expectation of the Spirit's help.

The shadow. Three shadows are named by critics and by many people inside the movement.

The first is that experience can become a score. When a particular experience is treated as the mark of the "Spirit-filled", those who have not had it may feel second-rate, and those who have it may feel above others. Paul's own list, as we saw, ends on the Spirit's choice and not on the believer's achievement, and the same chapter asks for gifts to be used for the profit of all.

The second is pressure and authority. Where much depends on an experience in the meeting, a leader may gain great influence. History shows a pattern, in many traditions and not only this one, in which the authority of a leader over the experience of others is not checked by anyone. We name this only as a general pattern. It is a reason that every tradition has asked how experience should be tested.

The third is health. Many Pentecostal and charismatic Christians pray for the sick, and many have found comfort and healing in doing so. A caution must nonetheless be given in plain words. Faith does not replace medicine. No illness, depression, addiction or other condition should be treated as a failure of faith, and no one should be told to stop seeking medical help because they have prayed. Many Pentecostal communities have built hospitals and clinics, and many ask their members to see a doctor and pray as well. This course gives no instruction to seek or avoid any practice. It records the history, and it records that some people were harmed when prayer was set against care.


Diagram 1. From holiness to Pentecost, and three readings of the gifts

Experience at the Centre A flow, not a ladder: the way, and the questions it raised Holiness movements Nineteenth century A whole heart; a second work of God (Phoebe Palmer) Pentecostal beginnings Los Angeles, 1906, and other places (William Seymour): many beginnings Spread and renewal Many countries; from the 1960s the charismatic renewal in older churches Three readings of the Spirit's gifts: what each holds, and what each fears Pentecostal Holds: the gifts continue; seek Spirit baptism Fears: right words with no living power; quenching the Spirit Charismatic Holds: the gifts continue; views differ on tongues Fears: a church without power; experience made a test that divides Gifts have ceased Holds: the sign gifts served the founding; Scripture suffices Fears: new claims that rival Scripture; leaders saying "God told me" Gift and shadow Gift: ordinary people, women and the poor given a voice; joy; the whole body at worship. Shadow: experience as a score; unchecked authority; prayer set against medicine.

Diagram 2. Three questions to put to any claim of experience

Question Why it helps
Does it agree with the Scripture the church reads? Guards against experience floating free of the Word
Is it confirmed by others, over time? Guards against private claims no one can question
What does it bear in love of neighbour? Looks to fruit, not to feeling

In short

  • Holiness movements of the nineteenth century taught that a believer could look for a whole heart; Phoebe Palmer led a home meeting that carried the teaching across churches.
  • Pentecostalism added the baptism in the Spirit, often shown by tongues; it began in many places, and Los Angeles in 1906, with William Seymour, is one of them.
  • Readers differ: Pentecostals, charismatics and those who hold the gifts ceased each fear something different, and each protects something real.
  • The gifts of this way include a voice for ordinary people and joy; the shadows include experience as a score and unchecked authority.
  • Prayer for healing is part of this way, but faith does not replace medicine, and illness is never a failure of faith.
  • Early Los Angeles was unusually open across races, and later divisions followed.
Front Back
Entire sanctification The holiness teaching that a believer may look for a second work of God, a whole heart set apart for him.
Baptism in the Holy Spirit The experience that Pentecostals teach a believer can receive, often shown by speaking in tongues.
Three readings of the gifts Pentecostal: they continue and are to be sought; charismatic: they continue, with differences; others: the sign gifts ceased as Scripture was completed.
Gift and shadow A voice for ordinary people and joy; experience made a score, unchecked authority, prayer set against care.

One sentence to remember Each reading of the Spirit's gifts protects something real, and a fair reader can say what each fears.

This week's action Write out the position of one view that you do not hold, in words its holders would accept, and one thing it protects.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • What did the holiness movements hope for, and why could that hope turn into pressure?
  • The scene at Azusa Street shows a gift and a shadow. What were they?
  • State the position of those who hold that the gifts ceased in a way that they would recognise. Then state what they fear.
  • State what Pentecostals fear in a church with sound teaching and no living power. Why is it a real concern?
  • Where in your own tradition, or in the traditions you know, do people ask how experience should be tested? What answers are given?
  • Why does the lecture say that faith does not replace medicine, and how is that a different matter from whether the Spirit heals?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.