FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

CH404E History of Christian Spirituality: Classics and Traditions

Lecture 2-4: The Spiritual Father and the Elder

Contents 31
CH404E History of Christian Spirituality: Classics and Traditions
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Reading the Classics of the Way
  1. Introduction: Reading the Classics of the Way
Chapter 1 · Week 1: The Beginning of the Way - Desert and Monastery
  1. Lecture 1-1: What "Spirituality" Means and How to Read a Classic
  2. Lecture 1-2: The Desert Fathers and Mothers
  3. Lecture 1-3: Benedict's Rule and the Western Monastery
  4. Lecture 1-4: Women and Households of the Early Church
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Reading One Page of a Classic
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Confessions and the Eastern Way
  1. Lecture 2-1: The Confessions: Writing the Inner Life
  2. Lecture 2-2: God in the Dark: Eastern Mystical Theology
  3. Lecture 2-3: Hesychasm and the Philokalia
  4. Lecture 2-4: The Spiritual Father and the Elder
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Classic, Two Pairs of Eyes
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Western Ways of the Middle Ages
  1. Lecture 3-1: The Way of Love: the Cistercians and Bernard
  2. Lecture 3-2: Poverty and Brotherhood: Francis and Clare
  3. Lecture 3-3: Women and Laity: Julian, Catherine and the Cloud of Unknowing
  4. Lecture 3-4: The Imitation of Christ and the Modern Devotion
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Gift and Shadow
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Spirituality in the Age of Reform
  1. Lecture 4-1: Ignatius and Carmel: Spirituality in Catholic Reform
  2. Lecture 4-2: The Calling of Ordinary Life: Luther, Calvin and Protestant Spirituality
  3. Lecture 4-3: Puritans, Pietists, Moravians and Wesley
  4. Lecture 4-4: Devotional Classics for Ordinary Readers: Bunyan and Law
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Shape of a Day
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Songs and Revivals, Ways around the World
  1. Lecture 5-1: Songs under Slavery: the Spirituality of the Black Church
  2. Lecture 5-2: Holiness and Pentecost: Experience at the Centre
  3. Lecture 5-3: Ways Around the World
  4. Lecture 5-4: Hymns as Spiritual Classics
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Reading a Song
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Classics of the Modern Age and Discernment
  1. Lecture 6-1: Classics of the Twentieth Century
  2. Lecture 6-2: When Spirituality Harms
  3. Lecture 6-3: Discernment: Joining the Classics and Today
  4. Lecture 6-4: Many Roads, One Question
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: My Reading Map

Jump to the key points ↓

23 min

Most spiritual classics were not written to be read alone. They were written for a person who also had someone to talk to. Behind the book there was a guide: an older believer who listened, asked questions, and said what he or she saw.

In the desert (lecture 1-2) such a guide was an abba, "father", or an amma, "mother", and people came to them with the simple request for a word that would help them live. The Eastern church carried this habit into the Middle Ages and into modern times. In Russia, from the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, it became a famous institution of its own: the starets, a Russian word that means "elder".

This lecture looks at that tradition, using one person, Seraphim of Sarov, as the main example. It asks what an elder was supposed to do, why so many people came, and what the tradition itself knew about the dangers of such a role. It then widens the lens a little. Catholic and Protestant churches also have guides, under other names, and every tradition has to ask the same question: how much should one person's word weigh in another person's life?

This is the part of the course where care is most needed. A guide can be a gift, and a guide with no one to answer to can do harm. Both are part of history. We describe each as a general pattern. We name no case of abuse and no present-day group, and we give no instruction for choosing or following a guide.

What these 23 minutes give you

  • Explain what the *starets* tradition is and how it grew out of the desert abbas and ammas.
  • Describe one elder, Seraphim of Sarov, with one scene, and say how his life was received.
  • Name the main things a spiritual guide was said to give, and the general pattern of danger when a guide has authority without accountability.
  • State how Catholic spiritual direction and Protestant pastoral care relate to the same question, and say why readers differ on how far a guide's word should weigh.

Where there is no wise guidance, the nation falls, but in the multitude of counselors there is victory." — Proverbs 11:14

World English Bible

Remember your leaders, men who spoke to you the word of God, and considering the results of their conduct, imitate their faith." — Hebrews 13:7

WEB

Obey your leaders and submit to them, for they watch on behalf of your souls, as those who will give account, that they may do this with joy, and not with groaning, for that would be unprofitable for you." — Hebrews 13:17

WEB

The first verse speaks of many counsellors; the third speaks of obeying leaders. Readers have found both in the Bible, and the tradition of the lives between them.

1. What an elder is

The word starets means an old man, and in Russian it came to mean a particular kind of person: a monk, usually a long-experienced one, whom others recognised as a guide. He was not always a priest. He did not hold the title through an or a rank. He became an elder because others began to come to him and found that he helped them.

What did he do? The tradition describes it simply. He listened. A person came and told him what was on their mind: a struggle, a doubt, a choice about life, a sorrow. The elder asked questions, prayed, and said what he saw. In the monastic setting the disciple might tell the elder his thoughts every day, as a way of not being alone with them. In the wider world, ordinary people came on pilgrimage with a problem and left with a word.

Note that this is not the same as the of confession, in which a priest hears sins and pronounces forgiveness. The elder's role was guidance, and in the Orthodox understanding it was not an office with a legal power. The disciple was not bound by law to follow every word. The tradition itself says that the disciple's obedience should be freely given, and that a guide who forces it has missed the point.

2. Where it came from

The roots are in the desert, as lecture 1-2 saw. The early monks went to a respected older monk and asked for a word. Later monasteries kept the habit. Then, in the eighteenth century, a monk named Paisius Velichkovsky (1722 to 1794), who lived and worked in the region of Moldavia, gathered a community of monks from several lands, and made the reading of the early spiritual writers and the guidance of an elder central to its life. He also translated writings into Slavonic, and his Slavonic version of the Philokalia (lecture 2-3) travelled to Russia. Through his disciples, the tradition of the elder grew in Russian monasteries in the following century.

One of these was the monastery of Optina, south of Moscow, which became in the nineteenth century a place where ordinary people, and also writers and thinkers, came to see the elders. Some church officials of the time were wary of the crowds and of the influence the elders had. We mention the monastery here only as a place. The best-known single elder is a different person.

3. Seraphim of Sarov

Seraphim was born in 1754 into a merchant family in the town of Kursk, and entered the monastery of Sarov as a young man. We rely, for the details of his life, on the accounts written by those who revered him, and many of the more dramatic stories belong to the tradition of his community and not to firm records. Where this lecture says "according to tradition", it means that.

According to the accounts, he spent many years in a small hut in the forest near the monastery, living in solitude and prayer. He then returned for a time to the monastery. Late in his life, from about 1825 until his death in 1833, he began to receive visitors: men and women, nobles and peasants, priests and travellers. They came because they had heard that he would listen.

One scene. A visitor comes to his cell. The accounts say that he greeted people with warmth and did not distinguish between ranks. He listened, sometimes said little, and sometimes sent the person away with a short word. According to tradition, people who came afraid left comforted. The church later gave him the title of saint, in 1903.

What can we say about how he was received? There were crowds. Some saw in him a living image of the Gospel's gentleness, and the Russian church made him one of its most loved saints. At the same time, even among those who honoured him, a reader should keep the difference between the person as the accounts show him and the person as devotion remembers him. These are not the same, and a person is often both.

It is also worth noticing what the tradition does not claim. It does not say that Seraphim never made mistakes, and it does not say that every person who came to him was helped. And it does not say that everyone ought to seek out an elder, or that a believer who never met one is poorer in the faith.

4. What a guide was said to give

The tradition names several gifts. Each is described as an ideal, and each needs a limit.

Company in the struggle. A person alone with a thought can make it larger than it is. Speaking it aloud to someone who has walked a long road can lessen it.

Discernment. Orthodox writers use a word for the ability to tell what comes from God, what from the self and what from fear or pride. A guide with long experience is said to help in this. Lecture 6-3 returns to discernment as a whole.

A word at the right time. Different people need different things. The same advice can heal one person and harm another. A guide is supposed to know the difference.

A living example. Hebrews 13:7 speaks of imitating the faith of leaders. The verse says to imitate faith, and the tradition notes that this is different from imitating every habit.

Prayer. The elder prays for those who come, and that, for many, is the main gift: someone is holding my name before God.

5. The risk: authority without accountability

If the elder's word is weighty, who watches the elder? This is the question the tradition itself asked, and it is a general question about any guide.

In history, in many churches and in many centuries, the pattern of harm has been similar enough that it can be described without naming anyone. A guide's word comes to count as the word of God. The disciple stops asking questions, because to question seems like pride or lack of faith. The guide becomes the only person whom the disciple may consult, and other advice is discouraged, from family, from a doctor, from another believer or from a pastor. Decisions about marriage, money and work are given to the guide. The guide is not himself answerable to anyone else. In such a situation the disciple's conscience is weakened, and harm, in the form of manipulation, shame, financial loss or worse, can follow. People who have been through this have sometimes lost their trust in prayer and in the church for years.

We describe this as a pattern that has occurred, and we do not say that any particular guide or community has done it. We also do not say that every strong guide does harm. Most do not. The Eastern writers themselves, as a general matter, warned about this: that a disciple should test whether a guide is humble, whether his teaching agrees with Scripture and the church, and that obedience is a path for the free and not a cage. The tradition's own teaching of prelest, the spiritual illusion we met in lecture 2-3, applies to guides too. A guide can be deceived by his own state.

If a guide has harmed someone

If a guide, in any tradition, is demanding secrecy, cutting a person off from family or other help, taking money or deciding private matters, that is not a matter of spiritual discipline. Speak to a trusted person outside the situation, such as a senior pastor, a priest, a doctor or a safeguarding officer. If anyone is in danger now, call the local emergency number. A guide's word never replaces medical care or the law.

6. Other traditions, in a sentence each

The Catholic Church has a long tradition of spiritual direction, in which a trained director accompanies a person's prayer and life, often over years; we meet it again in lecture 4-1 with Ignatius and Carmel. Protestant churches generally lay the weight on the pastor's preaching and care, on the church as a whole community, and on each believer reading Scripture; many also have mentoring, small groups and older members who counsel the younger. In Pentecostal and charismatic churches a pastor's word or a prophetic word may carry weight in a similar way. In each, the question is the same: whose word weighs how much, and who watches the one who speaks?

7. How much should a guide's word weigh?

This is a question on which readers differ, though not in the form of a quarrel between traditions. It is better described as a question that runs through each tradition.

One reading emphasises Hebrews 13:17, which says to obey leaders and speaks of leaders who "watch on behalf of your souls" and will give account. Those who hold this fear a faith in which each person follows their own mind and no one is ever corrected. They remember that a disciple who never yields has little to learn.

Another reading emphasises the many counsellors of Proverbs 11:14 and the fact that Hebrews 13:7 speaks of imitating the leaders' faith, which is not the same as obeying every word. Those who hold this fear a faith in which one person's word replaces the believer's own conscience before God and the testimony of the whole church. They remember that every guide is also a sinner.

Neither reading is foolish. In practice the best of the tradition seems to have held both: a real weight to the guide's word, and a real freedom for the disciple, in a setting where the guide himself is answerable. How that balance is struck differs from one community to another. This course does not strike it for you.

8. An invented example: two guides

(An invented example.) Ilen is a young woman who is distressed about a decision. She visits two older guides on different occasions, from two different communities, and the accounts below describe what she meets.

The first guide listens for a long time. He asks what Ilen has already prayed and what her family thinks. He says that he sees two possibilities and that he does not know which is right. He tells her to speak to her own pastor and to her doctor, since she has not slept well for weeks. He says he will pray for her, and that she may come back or not.

The second guide listens for a short time. He tells her what to do. When she says that she would like to ask her sister, he says that her sister does not understand such things and that she should say nothing to anyone. He tells her to bring a sum of money to the community. When she hesitates, he says that her hesitation shows pride.

Nothing in the lecture asks you to judge a real person by this. It is a way to see the pattern. The first guide gives company and discernment, sends her toward others and leaves her free. The second shows each sign of authority without accountability.

9. Gift and shadow

The gift. The tradition of the elder showed that no one has to carry the life of . It kept a living link between the written classics and a human voice. It brought comfort to many who were afraid. It gave the Eastern church a way to hand on what books cannot hand on: a person's long experience.

The shadow and the question. Authority without accountability can harm, and history gives enough examples that the tradition itself warned against it. A second question: if the elder is so central, what happens to a believer who has none, or who lives far from any? A third: do women, who in the desert were ammas, receive the same recognition in later centuries? The record is uneven, and the sources for the women who guided others are much thinner than for men. These questions remain open for readers to carry.


Diagram 1. What a guide can give, and what can go wrong

The Guide: A Gift and a Question From the desert abba to the Russian starets What a guide was said to give Company in the struggle Discernment: what is of God, what of self or fear A word at the right time A living example of faith Prayer for the person Obedience freely given, not forced A general pattern of harm The guide's word counts as God's word Questions are called pride Other advice is discouraged: family, doctor, pastor Money, marriage and work decided by the guide The guide answers to no one History shows it; no case is named here The question every tradition faces How much should one person's word weigh in another's life, and who watches the one who speaks? Proverbs 11:14 (many counsellors) and Hebrews 13:7, 13:17 (imitate faith; obey leaders)

Diagram 2. Guides in three traditions: one question

Tradition What a guide is called What to ask
Orthodox An elder (starets), or a spiritual father or mother Is the obedience free, and is the guide humble and answerable?
Catholic A spiritual director How does the director's accompaniment relate to the sacraments and to the church's teaching?
Protestant and Pentecostal A pastor, mentor or older believer How much does the pastor's word weigh against the believer's own reading of Scripture, and who guards the pastor?

In short

  • The starets (Russian for elder) is a guide, not always a priest, who listens and gives a word; the tradition grew from the desert abbas and ammas.
  • Seraphim of Sarov (1754 to 1833), in his last years, received visitors of every rank; the church honoured him as a saint in 1903.
  • A guide was said to give company, discernment, a timely word, an example and prayer, and obedience was meant to be freely given.
  • A general pattern of harm is authority without accountability; the tradition itself warned of it.
  • Catholic spiritual direction and Protestant pastoral care meet the same question about how much one person's word should weigh.
  • The gift is that no one carries the life of faith alone; the questions are harm, absence of a guide, and the record of women guides.
Front Back
Starets Russian for "elder": a guide, usually a long-experienced monk, to whom people came for a word.
Seraphim of Sarov A Russian monk (1754 to 1833) who in his last years received visitors; honoured as a saint in 1903.
Authority without accountability A general pattern of harm: the guide's word counts as God's, questions are called pride, and no one watches the guide.
The question How much should a guide's word weigh, and who watches the one who speaks?

One sentence to remember A guide can be a gift of company and discernment, and the tradition's own wisdom is that the guide needs someone to answer to as well.

This week's action Think of one person who has helped you with a hard choice, and write down one thing they did that left you free.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • In what way is the *starets* tradition a continuation of the desert abbas and ammas, and in what way is it new?
  • Seraphim is known to us mainly from accounts written by those who revered him. How should a reader hold the person and the memory together?
  • Which of the five gifts a guide was said to give seems most needed in your own community, and which is hardest to find?
  • Describe in your own words the general pattern of authority without accountability. What would make you ask a question about a guide?
  • Hebrews 13:7 says to imitate faith and Hebrews 13:17 says to obey. How would you explain the difference to a friend, and why might two readers weigh them differently?
  • In your own tradition, who watches over the one who guides others?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.