Lecture 1-4: Women and Households of the Early Church
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What "Spirituality" Means and How to Read a Classic
- Lecture 1-2: The Desert Fathers and Mothers
- Lecture 1-3: Benedict's Rule and the Western Monastery
- Lecture 1-4: Women and Households of the Early Church
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Reading One Page of a Classic
- Lecture 2-1: The Confessions: Writing the Inner Life
- Lecture 2-2: God in the Dark: Eastern Mystical Theology
- Lecture 2-3: Hesychasm and the Philokalia
- Lecture 2-4: The Spiritual Father and the Elder
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Classic, Two Pairs of Eyes
- Lecture 3-1: The Way of Love: the Cistercians and Bernard
- Lecture 3-2: Poverty and Brotherhood: Francis and Clare
- Lecture 3-3: Women and Laity: Julian, Catherine and the Cloud of Unknowing
- Lecture 3-4: The Imitation of Christ and the Modern Devotion
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Gift and Shadow
- Lecture 4-1: Ignatius and Carmel: Spirituality in Catholic Reform
- Lecture 4-2: The Calling of Ordinary Life: Luther, Calvin and Protestant Spirituality
- Lecture 4-3: Puritans, Pietists, Moravians and Wesley
- Lecture 4-4: Devotional Classics for Ordinary Readers: Bunyan and Law
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Shape of a Day
- Lecture 5-1: Songs under Slavery: the Spirituality of the Black Church
- Lecture 5-2: Holiness and Pentecost: Experience at the Centre
- Lecture 5-3: Ways Around the World
- Lecture 5-4: Hymns as Spiritual Classics
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Reading a Song
The last two lectures were full of men: Antony, Pachomius, Evagrius, Basil, Benedict. A reader might think that the early church's spirituality was made by men alone. It was not. Women led households, founded and supported communities, taught, gave money, travelled and died for their faith. But much of what we know about them was written down by men, and some of what they said and did is lost.
This lecture looks at women and household communities in the early church, mostly in the fourth century. It also asks a question about sources that applies to the whole course: when a voice comes to us through someone else's writing, what do we hear, and what is missing?
There is a risk in a lecture like this. It would be easy to turn a few women into a new set of heroes, which would repeat the mistake of the old lists of male saints. The lecture tries to do something else. It looks at what we can say with confidence, marks what is uncertain, and describes the gifts and the shadows of the lives these women lived.
What these 20 minutes give you
- Describe how women appear in the New Testament as hosts, helpers and servants of the churches.
- Give an account of Macrina, Paula and Melania the Elder, marking which details are well established and which are uncertain.
- Explain how the desert *ammas* and household communities were part of the movement described in earlier lectures.
- State what the sources do and do not tell us, and why women's voices often come to us through men's writing.
A certain woman named Lydia, a seller of purple, of the city of Thyatira, one who worshiped God, heard us; whose heart the Lord opened to listen to the things which were spoken by Paul." — Acts 16:14
World English Bible
When she and her household were baptized, she begged us, saying, “If you have judged me to be faithful to the Lord, come into my house, and stay.” So she persuaded us." — Acts 16:15
WEB
I commend to you Phoebe, our sister, who is a servant of the assembly that is at Cenchreae," — Romans 16:1
WEB
that you receive her in the Lord, in a way worthy of the saints, and that you assist her in whatever matter she may need from you, for she herself also has been a helper of many, and of my own self." — Romans 16:2
WEB
Soon afterwards, he went about through cities and villages, preaching and bringing the good news of the Kingdom of God. With him were the twelve," — Luke 8:1
WEB
and Joanna, the wife of Chuzas, Herod’s steward; Susanna; and many others; who served them from their possessions." — Luke 8:3
WEB
These passages show women already at work in the first generation: a woman whose household was baptized and who opened her home, a woman commended as a helper of many, and women who supported Jesus' ministry from their own means. The household was where much of the early church lived.
1. The household as the first church
Before there were church buildings, there were houses. The New Testament shows believers meeting in the homes of those who could host them. In Acts 16, Lydia, a seller of purple cloth, hears Paul, is baptized with her household, and asks the missionaries to stay in her house. In Romans 16, Paul commends Phoebe, who is described as a servant of the assembly at Cenchreae and a helper of many, including Paul himself. The Greek word translated "servant" there is diakonos, which other translators render as "". Readers differ on how much of an office the word names in this verse, and the difference is not settled here. In Luke 8, women who had been healed travel with Jesus and "served them from their possessions", which means that they gave money.
None of this proves that women held every role. It does show that women were present, active and often wealthy enough to support others. A household was a unit that included family, servants, dependents and guests. When the household turned toward faith, it became a small community.
2. Households that became communities
In the fourth century, this older pattern met the new interest in a life set apart for God. Some women of means and some who had little organised their homes as communities of prayer, study, work and care. These were not always monasteries in the later sense, with walls and fixed rules. Often they were households that changed gradually into something more.
Three women are the best known, and all three are known mostly through men's writing. Remember the limit from lecture 1-1: a life written by someone else tells us what the writer wanted readers to see.
3. Macrina
Macrina lived in the fourth century, in the region of Pontus, in the north of what is now Turkey. She came from a Christian family of some standing. She was the sister of Basil, whom we met in lecture 1-2 as a writer of monastic guidance, and of Gregory of Nyssa, who appears again in lecture 2-2.
What we know of her comes mostly from the Life of Macrina, written by her brother Gregory shortly after her death. According to Gregory, after her father had died and her younger brothers had gone to study or to church work, Macrina persuaded her mother to turn the family's estate into a shared community. The women of the household, including those who had been servants, lived together as equals, in prayer and work. Gregory says that Macrina was his teacher, and he wrote another work in which she appears as the wiser speaker in a conversation with him, shortly before her death.
The scene that Gregory sets at the centre is her last illness. He tells how he visited her after a long absence, and how he found her very ill, lying on a hard bed. He describes her as calm and continuing to speak of God and of the life to come. He wrote this account as a tribute. How did the church receive it? It was read as an example of a life that combined learning and humility. That reception is partly Gregory's own doing, since he decided what to include.
Two cautions. Gregory was her brother, writing with love and with an aim. And the Life tells us little about what Macrina herself wrote or said apart from his report.
4. Paula
Paula was a Roman noblewoman, born in the middle of the fourth century. After she was widowed, she gathered around her a group of Christian women in Rome, and then went east, accompanied by her daughter Eustochium, to visit the holy places and eventually to settle in Bethlehem. There, according to the man who wrote about her, she founded communities for women and for men, and gave much of her wealth to support them.
Our source for much of this is Jerome, a scholar and writer who worked in Bethlehem near her, and who wrote a long letter about her after her death at the beginning of the fifth century. Jerome says that she studied Scripture seriously, and that she learned Hebrew. Jerome was an advisor and a friend, but also a polemical writer who did not always see his opponents fairly.
The scene is her leaving Rome. Jerome describes a hard departure in which she was torn between love for her children and her wish to go, and he presents it as an act of faith. We should see in this also a question that the tradition rarely asks: what did those she left behind think of it? Some people in Rome criticised these ascetic women and the men who advised them. The death of a young woman in this circle, after severe fasting, caused some in Rome to blame the movement. This is the history of harm that lecture 1-2 spoke of, and it shows that the criticism was heard at the time.
5. Melania the Elder
Melania the Elder was another Roman woman of wealth, of about the same generation as Paula. She is known from a collection of stories about the monks and nuns of the time, the Lausiac History by Palladius, who knew her. Palladius reports that she travelled to Egypt to see the desert monks, and later settled in Jerusalem, where she supported a community on the Mount of Olives. He praises her generosity. Details differ among our sources, and some stories about her are likely to have grown in the telling. We include her here because she shows that the movement of women was not confined to one place, and that wealth could be used to support a community as well as to own a house.
6. The ammas and the household
The desert mothers of lecture 1-2 were part of the same wide movement. Syncletica, Sarah and Theodora appear in the collections of sayings as women whose words were remembered by monks. We know very little of their lives. The sayings attributed to them are short. Each shows the pattern we saw: a concern for humility, for discernment, for the quiet of the heart. The words that have come down may or may not reflect what each woman said. They were gathered and arranged later, and the sources do not tell us by whom.
Women also lived in communities, some large and some small, in the towns as well as the desert. Some lived as unmarried ascetics in their own homes. We have far fewer names than we would like.
7. What the sources tell us, and what they do not
Here is the central difficulty of the lecture. Almost every account of these women that has survived was written by a man, often a relative or a friend, and always for a reason. He had a message to deliver: that this way of life is admirable, or that it is dangerous, or that his own teaching was right. So we need three habits.
- Ask who wrote it and why. A life written by a loving brother is a tribute. A letter written by a scholar who relied on the woman for money and company is something else.
- Notice the way men praise women. The sources sometimes praise a woman by saying that she had risen above her sex, or become like a man. This reveals something about the writer's assumptions. It does not give us the woman's own view.
- Remember who is missing. The women whose lives are told were mostly from families with money and leisure. The women who worked in the fields or in the markets, who raised children and cared for the sick without leaving any writing, are almost silent. Their faith was real, and our sources have lost it.
None of this means we should give up on the sources. It means reading them with the four questions of lecture 1-1.
8. Gift and shadow
The gifts. These households gave the early church places where women could study, teach, lead and use their wealth for the sake of others. They gave a form of life in which servants and mistresses could share a common table, at least in the accounts we have. They show that the spiritual life was lived in the household and the town, as well as in the desert. And they show learning as part of the life of prayer: Paula's study of Scripture is one example.
The shadows and questions. The ideal of a life set apart often grew alongside a low view of marriage and the body, and it could imply that the ordinary lives of married women, who raised children and ran households, were of less worth. The people left behind, children and relatives, remain mostly silent in our sources. The severe fasting that some of these women practised harmed some of them; this is history, not an example. And the women's voices come to us through men, which means that every account is partly a statement about what men wished women to be.
Traditions differ in how they honour these women
Catholic and Orthodox communities honour some of these women as saints; the church of the time and later churches judged them so. Protestant readers may know them less well, or may be uneasy about the way the tradition honours people. This lecture reports that honour as history and does not rank it.
Diagram 1. How a woman's voice reaches us
Diagram 2. Three women and their sources
| Woman | Where | Main source | What to keep in mind |
|---|---|---|---|
| Macrina | Pontus, fourth century | A life by her brother Gregory | A tribute written with love and a purpose |
| Paula | Rome, then Bethlehem | A letter by Jerome after her death | A friend and adviser who was also a combative writer |
| Melania the Elder | Rome, Egypt, Jerusalem | A collection of stories by Palladius | Some details may have grown in the telling |
In short
- The New Testament shows women as hosts, helpers and supporters of the church, and the household was where the early church often met.
- In the fourth century some households became communities; Macrina, Paula and Melania the Elder are known mostly through men's writing.
- The desert ammas were part of the same movement, but we know little of their lives.
- Our sources were written by men with reasons for writing, and they leave out the women who left no writing.
- The gifts were study, leadership and generosity. The shadows were a low view of ordinary marriage, those left behind, and the harm of severe fasting.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The household | A unit of family, servants and guests, where much of the early church met, and from which some communities grew. |
| Macrina, Paula, Melania the Elder | Three fourth-century women known through writings by Gregory of Nyssa, Jerome and Palladius. |
| The central difficulty | Women's voices mostly reach us through men's writing, shaped by their reasons for writing. |
| Gift and shadow | Gift: study, leadership, generosity. Shadow: a low view of ordinary life, those left behind, harm from severe fasting. |
One sentence to remember When a woman's voice comes through a man's pen, ask who wrote, why, and who is missing.
This week's action Think of someone in your own family or congregation whose faith left no writing, and write down one thing you know of how they lived it.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- In the New Testament passages, what do Lydia, Phoebe and the women of Luke 8 each do for the early church? What would be missing if they were left out?
- The lecture warns against turning three women into a new set of heroes. How might one tell the difference between honouring someone and making them a hero?
- Why does it matter that Gregory was Macrina's brother? What does he tell us, and what might he leave out?
- Some sources praise a woman by saying she had become like a man. What does that suggest about the writer's view of women?
- Who is missing from the sources of this lecture? What kinds of faithful lives left no writing?
- Catholic and Orthodox communities honour some of these women as saints, and some Protestant readers are uneasy about that. How might each side state its reasons fairly?