Lecture 6-2: When Spirituality Harms
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What "Spirituality" Means and How to Read a Classic
- Lecture 1-2: The Desert Fathers and Mothers
- Lecture 1-3: Benedict's Rule and the Western Monastery
- Lecture 1-4: Women and Households of the Early Church
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Reading One Page of a Classic
- Lecture 2-1: The Confessions: Writing the Inner Life
- Lecture 2-2: God in the Dark: Eastern Mystical Theology
- Lecture 2-3: Hesychasm and the Philokalia
- Lecture 2-4: The Spiritual Father and the Elder
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Classic, Two Pairs of Eyes
- Lecture 3-1: The Way of Love: the Cistercians and Bernard
- Lecture 3-2: Poverty and Brotherhood: Francis and Clare
- Lecture 3-3: Women and Laity: Julian, Catherine and the Cloud of Unknowing
- Lecture 3-4: The Imitation of Christ and the Modern Devotion
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Gift and Shadow
- Lecture 4-1: Ignatius and Carmel: Spirituality in Catholic Reform
- Lecture 4-2: The Calling of Ordinary Life: Luther, Calvin and Protestant Spirituality
- Lecture 4-3: Puritans, Pietists, Moravians and Wesley
- Lecture 4-4: Devotional Classics for Ordinary Readers: Bunyan and Law
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Shape of a Day
- Lecture 5-1: Songs under Slavery: the Spirituality of the Black Church
- Lecture 5-2: Holiness and Pentecost: Experience at the Centre
- Lecture 5-3: Ways Around the World
- Lecture 5-4: Hymns as Spiritual Classics
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Reading a Song
For five weeks this course has looked at gifts. A desert teacher's humility, a rule that gave a community balance, a book that opened an inner life, a song that carried a people through suffering: each was real, and each helped real people.
This lecture is about the other half. The same books, rules and ways that helped some people hurt others, and sometimes they hurt the same people at different times. Any honest history of Christian spirituality has to say so. The old writers said so themselves, often more sharply than we do.
We will look at six general patterns of harm. We name no case and no present-day group. The patterns are drawn from history and from what classic authors warned against, so that a reader can recognise a shape without having to judge anybody.
What these 25 minutes give you
- Describe six patterns in which spirituality can harm, and give a historical or classic warning for each.
- Explain why a guide's authority becomes a harm when it has no one to answer to.
- Say how the history of severe asceticism is told in this course, and why it gives no instruction to imitate.
- Explain why illness, depression and addiction are not met by faith alone, and why prayer and care belong together.
- State what the lecture does not claim: that spirituality is bad, or that every harm is the fault of a tradition.
Then Jesus spoke to the multitudes and to his disciples, saying, “The scribes and the Pharisees sat on Moses’ seat. All things therefore whatever they tell you to observe, observe and do, but don’t do their works; for they say, and don’t do. For they bind heavy burdens that are grievous to be borne, and lay them on men’s shoulders; but they themselves will not lift a finger to help them. But all their works they do to be seen by men. They make their phylacteries broad, enlarge the fringes of their garments, and love the place of honor at feasts, the best seats in the synagogues, the salutations in the marketplaces, and to be called ‘Rabbi, Rabbi’ by men. But don’t you be called ‘Rabbi,’ for one is your teacher, the Christ, and all of you are brothers. Call no man on the earth your father, for one is your Father, he who is in heaven. Neither be called masters, for one is your master, the Christ. But he who is greatest among you will be your servant. Whoever exalts himself will be humbled, and whoever humbles himself will be exalted." — Matthew 23:1-12
World English Bible
Beloved, don’t believe every spirit, but test the spirits, whether they are of God, because many false prophets have gone out into the world." — 1 John 4:1
WEB
The first passage is a warning by Jesus about religious leaders who load burdens on others and do their works to be seen. The second is a short instruction to test claims that come in the name of the Spirit. Both are older than any tradition in this course, and every tradition has read them as addressed to itself.
1. Why this lecture exists
A course that told only of gifts would be telling half of the truth, and would be a poor friend to its readers. Some readers of this course have been hurt in a church or by a spiritual teacher. Some are tired in faith, and the tiredness has a cause. Some have never been hurt but have a friend who was. It is no disloyalty to any tradition to say that its good things were sometimes turned to bad use. The prophets said it of Israel, Jesus said it of the leaders of his day, and the church's own teachers have said it of the church in every century.
A second reason is practical. A reader who has read the classics with only admiration is poorly prepared for the day when a book, a leader or a practice begins to feel wrong. The old traditions knew the signs. This lecture lays them out.
One more thing before we begin. Naming harm is not the same as saying that spirituality is a mistake. A good teacher can be abused by a poor student, a good rule can be bent by a poor leader, and a good song can be put to bad use. The shadow in each case belongs to what people did, and not necessarily to the way itself.
2. Pattern one: spirituality as self-improvement
The first pattern is quiet and common. Prayer, reading and discipline are taken up as a project for the self. The person asks, how am I doing? Am I further along than last month? Am I ahead of the others? The old writers had a name for this shape of pride: spiritual pride, or vainglory, the wish to be seen as holy. Collections of the desert sayings (lecture 1-2) contain many stories warning against it, and the Rule of Benedict (lecture 1-3) gives a whole chapter to humility, pictured as a ladder, not as a ladder to climb for the sake of status but as a way of learning to depend on others.
Jesus' words in Matthew 23 describe the same shape in his own time: works done to be seen, the place of honour at feasts, the title "Rabbi" sought from others. The Gospel does not say that the practices were wrong. It says that they had been made a performance.
In our own time the same pattern has a modern face. The word "spirituality" is used for many kinds of self-care, and some of it borrows the vocabulary of the classics without their questions. We are not saying that all such use is harmful. We are saying that a person who treats faith as a score of their own progress has misread every classic in this course. None of them offers a score.
3. Pattern two: severe asceticism
An ascetic, from a Greek word for training, is a person who practises hard self-denial for the sake of the Gospel. We have met ascetics in the desert, in the monasteries and in the medieval West. This is history, and it is not instruction. The lecture gives no encouragement to fast, to sleep little or to stay silent for long.
The history is mixed, and the church of the time knew it. Some of the stories from the desert tell of people who ate very little, slept very little and went on in this way for years. The same collections include voices that urged moderation and that praised a person who ate with a guest and kept the fast another day. Basil, in the fourth century, is remembered for urging a shared life and moderation over solitary extremes, and Benedict's Rule is notable for its balance (lecture 1-3). In the medieval West, some women fasted so severely that their confessors and their communities were alarmed. Some voices in the church insisted that the body is God's creation and not an enemy to be starved. The criticism came from inside the church.
The harm was real. People were ill, some died young, and some were praised for what was, to those who loved them, a slow harm. Modern historians and doctors read some of these stories in terms of illness. Other historians warn against reading the past only through modern medicine. This lecture does not try to diagnose people who cannot answer. It says only this: when a way of life damages a person's body or mind, the church's own best teachers have, again and again, asked that it be stopped.
Health and safety
Nothing in this course asks you to fast, to sleep less, to be silent for long periods or to endure pain. If you are ill, low in mood, anxious or struggling with food or drink or any addiction, prayer and medical or professional care belong together; is not the cure for illness. Speak to a doctor or a trained counsellor, and to a trusted pastor or priest alongside. A person who is very ill, or in danger of harming themselves, should call the local emergency number now.
4. Pattern three: a guide's authority without anyone to answer to
Lectures 2-4 and 4-1 met the spiritual father, the and the director: a more experienced person who walks beside another. The traditions value this, and many Christians have been grateful to a wise guide all their lives.
The pattern of harm is also old, and it follows a general shape. A guide's word begins to be treated as the word of God. Questions are discouraged, and doubt is called disloyalty or pride. The follower is asked to bring everything, thoughts, doubts, money, family, to one person and to no one else. The follower is gradually cut off from friends and from relatives who might raise a question. The guide answers to nobody: not to a bishop, an elder board, a congregation, or a council. When the follower is hurt, the community protects the guide, and the one who spoke up is told that they have a bad spirit. Fear and shame hold the whole thing together.
Different traditions have tried to set guides inside some accountability: in Catholic and Orthodox churches through the office of the bishop, in Reformed churches through elders and synods, in many free churches through the meeting of the congregation. None of these structures has prevented abuse in every case, and history contains cases in every tradition where a structure was used to protect a person instead of the people they harmed. We name none here. The pattern is the point.
A short story will show the drift. It is invented, and no real person or group is meant.
(An invented example.) Kira joins a small prayer group in the town of Marle. The leader, whom everyone calls the Teacher, is warm and wise, and for a year the group is good for her. Then little things change. The Teacher says that Kira should tell him about her dreams, and no one else. Later he says that her sister, who asks questions, has "a closed spirit", and that Kira should see her less. In the winter, when Kira has a long illness, he says that the medicine her doctor gave her shows a lack of trust. Kira's friend Tamsin, from a different church, asks only one question: "Who does the Teacher talk to when he is unsure?" Kira realises she does not know.
The story does not show a villain with a plan. It shows a drift, and every step in it could have been explained as care. The questions the friend asks are ordinary ones. We will come back to them.
5. Pattern four: competition about experiences
In the New Testament, Paul wrote to the church in Corinth because its members were proud of their and ranked one another by them (1 Corinthians 12-14). The pattern did not end there. Wherever a tradition prizes an experience, such as a vision, a gift of the Spirit, a deep silence, a period of tears or a night of prayer, there is a temptation to turn it into a contest. The person who has not had it feels lesser, and the person who has had it feels higher. Some people then manufacture what they have not had, so as not to be left out.
The old teachers of experience knew this and warned against it. Teachers of the Catholic mystical tradition, such as the authors met in lecture 4-1, cautioned readers against treating extraordinary experiences as the goal. The desert collections include stories that warn against trusting visions and against being proud of them. Paul himself, in 1 Corinthians 13, said that gifts without love count for nothing. In every case the point is the same: an experience is not a measure of a person's faith.
This lecture does not say that experiences are false. We describe them and do not judge them, as we have throughout. We say only that any tradition that prizes them has to guard against the ranking of persons by them.
6. Pattern five: commercialisation
When a spiritual way becomes popular, someone usually finds a way to sell it. In the medieval church there was a trade in relics, the physical remains of the saints, and in souvenirs for pilgrims. Honouring the saints was a deep part of the religion of many ordinary people; the trade grew up around it. The selling of indulgences, which was one of the things the Reformers protested against in the sixteenth century, joined holy things and money in a way that many of the church's own members found wrong. Catholic readers will recognise that the church itself later reformed its practice.
The same shape appears in every age. Books, retreats, courses and objects are offered with promises that no honest guide would make. The person who is lonely or in pain is the person most likely to pay. The old test is plain: is the way presented as a gift, or as a product that gives results? A way that offers certain results has already stepped outside what the classics claim.
We make no judgement of any present-day seller, and none is named. The warning is old, and it is for all of us who buy and who sell.
7. Pattern six: spirituality welded to a nation or a party
The last pattern is the joining of faith to political power until the two cannot be told apart. It has taken many forms. A king is said to rule by God's favour and no one may criticise him. A war is preached as holy and the enemy as the enemy of God (lecture 3-1 noted this shadow in the age of the ). A church blesses the state's actions and does not ask whether they are just. Or, from the other side, a church is made a tool of one party, and a person who votes differently is treated as less than a believer.
History shows it on every continent. In the age of slavery, some who held people in bondage taught the enslaved a version of the Gospel that stressed obedience to masters, and many readers have understood the spiritual life of the enslaved themselves (lecture 5-1) as in part a refusal of that version. In the twentieth century, the pastor met in lecture 6-1 lived in a country where many in the churches went along with the state, and he and others in the church saw that as a betrayal of the Gospel. These are patterns, not verdicts on individuals, and the lecture does not name any present-day body or movement.
The older traditions did not agree on what faithful relation to a state looks like, and this course does not settle it. The warning is narrower. When a faith can no longer say anything that the nation or the party does not want to hear, something has gone wrong.
8. What the old traditions asked in answer
The classic authors did not meet these harms with silence. They met them with a few steady questions. We list them here as history, and lecture 6-3 will bring them together.
- Does it agree with Scripture? The Spirit of Jesus does not contradict the Gospel (1 John 4:1 calls for testing).
- Is it answerable? A spiritual guide is not the only judge of their own work. The community, and often an office beyond the community, can ask questions.
- What are the fruits? Does the way bring a person more love for neighbour, more patience, more honesty, or more fear and secrecy?
- Does it leave room for humility? A way that cannot be questioned, or that makes its followers feel superior, has a fault.
None of these questions is a formula. Each can fail, and lecture 6-3 will say how. They are a beginning.
9. If you or someone you know has been harmed
This lecture is not a counselling service. It says only this: abuse, whether physical, sexual, financial or spiritual, is not a "spiritual matter". It is a harm, and in many places a crime. A person who is being harmed by a leader should speak to someone outside the relationship: a trusted friend, a doctor, a safeguarding person or a trusted minister from a different community, and, where there is danger or a crime, the police or the local emergency number. Follow your own church's written safeguarding rules and local law. Tiredness and loss of faith after a hurt are not signs of weakness. They are what a hurt does.
Diagram 1. Six patterns of harm, and the old questions
Diagram 2. Questions a friend might ask of the Teacher in Marle (an invented example)
| A friend's question | What it asks about |
|---|---|
| Who does the Teacher talk to when he is unsure? | Whether the guide answers to anyone |
| Is it all right to disagree with the Teacher? | Whether doubt is allowed |
| Can Kira still see her sister, her doctor and her old church? | Whether the follower keeps other voices and care |
| What would happen if someone left? | Whether leaving is free |
In short
- Spirituality can heal and harm. Naming harm is not disloyal; the old teachers named it first.
- Six general patterns: self-improvement, severe asceticism, a guide with no one to answer to, contests of experience, commercialisation, and faith welded to power.
- The history of severe asceticism is told as history, with the harm and the church's own criticism; it gives no instruction.
- A guide's authority turns harmful when the word is beyond question, the follower is cut off, and the guide answers to no one.
- Prayer and medical care belong together; faith alone is not the cure for illness.
- The old questions are Scripture, answerability, fruits and humility; each can fail, and none is a formula.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Six patterns of harm | Self-improvement; severe asceticism; a guide with no one to answer to; contests of experience; commercialisation; faith welded to power. |
| Asceticism in this course | History, with the harm and the church's own criticism named; no instruction to imitate. |
| A guide's authority | It becomes a harm when the word is beyond question, the follower is cut off, and the guide answers to nobody. |
| Health | Prayer and medical or professional care belong together; faith alone does not cure illness. |
One sentence to remember The shadow of a spiritual way belongs to what people did with it, and the old traditions asked the same few questions of it.
This week's action Think of a book, a teacher or a practice you value, and write down who it answers to, and who else is allowed to ask it a question.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Which of the six patterns is easiest to see in the history you know best? Which is hardest to see in your own tradition?
- Why does the lecture say that the same book, rule or teacher could help one person and hurt another?
- In the story of Marle, what were the small steps? Which one might a friend have noticed first?
- Why does the lecture treat the history of severe fasting as history and give no instruction? What might a reader be tempted to take from it?
- The lecture says "faith alone is not the cure for illness". How would you explain the point kindly to someone who believes that taking medicine shows a lack of trust?
- Why does the lecture say that naming a harm is not disloyal to a tradition? Do you agree?