FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

CH404E History of Christian Spirituality: Classics and Traditions

Lecture 6-4: Many Roads, One Question

Contents 31
CH404E History of Christian Spirituality: Classics and Traditions
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Reading the Classics of the Way
  1. Introduction: Reading the Classics of the Way
Chapter 1 · Week 1: The Beginning of the Way - Desert and Monastery
  1. Lecture 1-1: What "Spirituality" Means and How to Read a Classic
  2. Lecture 1-2: The Desert Fathers and Mothers
  3. Lecture 1-3: Benedict's Rule and the Western Monastery
  4. Lecture 1-4: Women and Households of the Early Church
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Reading One Page of a Classic
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Confessions and the Eastern Way
  1. Lecture 2-1: The Confessions: Writing the Inner Life
  2. Lecture 2-2: God in the Dark: Eastern Mystical Theology
  3. Lecture 2-3: Hesychasm and the Philokalia
  4. Lecture 2-4: The Spiritual Father and the Elder
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Classic, Two Pairs of Eyes
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Western Ways of the Middle Ages
  1. Lecture 3-1: The Way of Love: the Cistercians and Bernard
  2. Lecture 3-2: Poverty and Brotherhood: Francis and Clare
  3. Lecture 3-3: Women and Laity: Julian, Catherine and the Cloud of Unknowing
  4. Lecture 3-4: The Imitation of Christ and the Modern Devotion
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Gift and Shadow
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Spirituality in the Age of Reform
  1. Lecture 4-1: Ignatius and Carmel: Spirituality in Catholic Reform
  2. Lecture 4-2: The Calling of Ordinary Life: Luther, Calvin and Protestant Spirituality
  3. Lecture 4-3: Puritans, Pietists, Moravians and Wesley
  4. Lecture 4-4: Devotional Classics for Ordinary Readers: Bunyan and Law
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Shape of a Day
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Songs and Revivals, Ways around the World
  1. Lecture 5-1: Songs under Slavery: the Spirituality of the Black Church
  2. Lecture 5-2: Holiness and Pentecost: Experience at the Centre
  3. Lecture 5-3: Ways Around the World
  4. Lecture 5-4: Hymns as Spiritual Classics
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Reading a Song
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Classics of the Modern Age and Discernment
  1. Lecture 6-1: Classics of the Twentieth Century
  2. Lecture 6-2: When Spirituality Harms
  3. Lecture 6-3: Discernment: Joining the Classics and Today
  4. Lecture 6-4: Many Roads, One Question
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: My Reading Map

Jump to the key points ↓

22 min

By now you have met a great many people, books, rules and songs. A fair question to ask is: what do I do with all of this? One answer would be to choose the best way and discard the rest. This course does not give that answer, because the central claim of the course is that the history of Christian spirituality is not one correct course to God. It is a record of the same Gospel lived by people of different ages and situations in different ways.

A second answer would be to collect the classics, as one collects stamps, and to feel more spiritual for having read them. That answer is a trap too, and lecture 6-2 gave it a name.

This lecture offers a third answer, and a modest one. It gives you six questions that you can put to any spiritual classic, from any tradition and any age, and that you can go on using long after this course has ended. It then looks back at the ways you have met, in a fair summary that does not rank them, and it names the points where readers still do not agree.

What these 22 minutes give you

  • State the six questions to put to any spiritual classic, and give a reason for each.
  • Use the six questions on a short description of an unfamiliar book.
  • Describe each of the ways met in this course by one gift and one shadow, without ranking them.
  • Name the main points on which readers of different traditions still do not agree.
  • Explain why a reading list is not a score of faith.

He has shown you, O man, what is good. What does Yahweh require of you, but to act justly, to love mercy, and to walk humbly with your God?" — Micah 6:8

World English Bible

but speaking truth in love, we may grow up in all things into him, who is the head, Christ; from whom all the body, being fitted and knit together through that which every joint supplies, according to the working in measure of each individual part, makes the body increase to the building up of itself in love." — Ephesians 4:15-16

WEB

The first passage is a prophet's short reminder that the life with God and the life with neighbours were never meant to be separated. The second speaks of a body whose parts are fitted together, and of speaking the truth in love. We use them as the spirit in which the six questions are asked, and we do not claim that either one settles the questions on which Christians differ.

1. Why questions and not a verdict

A verdict says: this way is right and that one is wrong. This course has declined to give verdicts on ways of life. That was not because everything is the same. It was because the claim "this is the best way" is one that a historian cannot test and a neighbour of another tradition cannot hear without offence. It is also because the ways were lived by real people in real places, and each of them could say what it had given them.

A question works differently. It does not end the conversation. It opens a door into the book, and the reader walks through it. The six questions below are ones that have come up in nearly every lecture of this course. We now write them out plainly.

2. Six questions for any spiritual classic

1. Who is the author? Who was this person, in what place and time, with what position in the church and the world? A bishop, a monk, a married merchant, a former slave and a journalist will each write from somewhere. Add what we know and what we do not. Several classics in this course are anonymous, and some have authors whose names are disputed. In such a case, the honest answer is a line of the form, "the author is not known". We saw in lecture 1-1 that this is the first of four questions.

2. Who is the reader? For whom was it written, and who has read it since? A rule was written for a community; a devotional book for a layperson at home; a song for a people gathered. A book may travel far beyond its first readers and be read in ways the author never imagined. A reader should ask whether the book was meant for them, and in what sense.

3. What is the gift? What did it give to those who lived it? This question comes before the next one, and not by accident. A reader who begins with the shadow often cannot hear anything else, and a reader who begins with the gift can hear the question later. Ask what the person who loved this way would say that it gave them.

4. What is the shadow? What cost, limit or harm did it leave, or leave open? A shadow is not an accusation. It is what an honest reader says after thanking the author. It may be a harm done in the way's name (see lecture 6-2), or it may simply be a limit: something the way could not see because of where it stood.

5. Who is left out? Whose voice is missing from the book, or reaches us only through someone else's pen? Women's voices in the early church come to us largely through men's writing (lecture 1-4). Much spirituality was carried by song and by community, and not by books, so that the books we have are not the whole story (week 5). The people who could not read, who did not hold office, who were enslaved, poor or far from a centre of the church, often left no book. This question asks a reader to keep a place open for them.

6. What does it ask of my neighbour? Not only what it asks of me. A way of life that asks everything of the person who follows it and nothing of how they treat the people near them has missed something that Micah 6:8 and Matthew 25 (lecture 6-1) both assume. And a way that makes neighbours into means for my own growth has misread the same passages from the other side. This question brings a classic back from the page to the street.

3. One question under the six

The six are, in the end, one question put in different ways: what does this way ask, of me and of my neighbour, and who is not in the room? We do not claim that this one sentence is the whole of the faith. It is simply the question that a careful reader keeps asking, and that every tradition in this course would recognise as a fair one, even if each would add its own.

It matters how the question is asked. Micah 6:8 puts "act justly" and "love mercy" next to "walk humbly". The questions are not for catching an author out, and they are not for putting oneself above the authors. They are for walking humbly with a book.

4. A worked example: the questions on a book that does not exist

To practise, we use an invented book, so that no real author or tradition is judged.

(An invented example.) The Weaver's Hours is a small devotional book from a river town, written in the eighteenth century by Odo Brin, a weaver. It was copied by hand for other weavers and later printed. It divides the working day into short pauses at the loom, and for each pause it offers a short reading and a thought. It says that careful work is a form of thanks, and that a weaver who is out of work has a claim on his neighbours' bread.

Let us ask the questions.

  1. Author. A working weaver, a layman, in a town. We know little else.
  2. Reader. Other weavers who could read. Possibly their families. Not meant for monks or scholars.
  3. Gift. It gives dignity to ordinary work, and it shows that prayer need not be taken from the working day. Readers could find in it a way to hear God in the middle of an ordinary shift.
  4. Shadow. The day it describes is set by the loom and by the master. It assumes that a reader can pause when they wish, and some could not. It may also teach a person to see every hour as something to be filled and measured, and a hard employer could use it to demand more.
  5. Left out. The women who spun the thread, the children who worked beside the weavers, the weavers who could not read, and the poor who had no loom at all. Their voices are not in the book.
  6. Neighbour. It asks the weaver to share bread with a neighbour out of work, and to treat apprentices fairly. It does not ask what should be done about a system that left the neighbour without work.

Notice what the exercise did and did not do. It did not decide whether The Weaver's Hours is a good book. It found the places where a reader could talk with it. The same six questions fit the Rule of Benedict, the Confessions, the Imitation of Christ, The Pilgrim's Progress, a hymn or a modern book.

How to use the six questions

Take any book, song or rule you are about to read. Before you begin, write the six headings. After you have read a part of it, fill in what you can. Leave blank what you cannot. A blank is itself an answer; it tells you what you must find out.

5. A fair look back: the ways of this course

The table below does not rank. It gives each way one gift and one shadow, in the plainest terms, and one question about whose voice may be missing. A reader from each tradition would add much more, and might change the wording. That is a fair outcome. The table is a starting point for talk.

The way A gift A shadow Who may be left out
Desert and monastery (week 1) Listening, humility, and a rule that gave a community balance Severe asceticism that harmed; a rule that could confine Women, whose words reach us through men's writing
Confessions and the Eastern way (week 2) An honest inner story; a God more than words can hold; the wisdom of a guide Self-absorption; a guide with no one to answer to Those with no access to a guide or a community
The medieval West (week 3) Love, poverty, and the voices of women and laity The ideal that hardens into an institution; inwardness far from the world Those who did not read, or who stood outside the cloister
The age of reform (week 4) Ordinary life seen as a ; Scripture and books for ordinary readers; guidance for the inner life A spirituality of effort; each reform let something go Those on the other side of the division
Songs, revivals and the world (week 5) Comfort and protest sung together; experience at the centre; many regions A song can carry a distorted theology; culture can cover as well as clothe Those whose songs were never written down
Modern classics and discernment (week 6) Prayer joined to action; the old tests of discernment The cost to helpers; the patterns of harm in lecture 6-2 Those who were never asked to write

6. Where readers still do not agree

Several lectures of this course carried a paragraph that began, "This is a point where readers will not agree." The five are set out in one place here so that you can see how they relate. None of them has been settled by this course.

The question Where it was met In short
What the word "spirituality" should mean Lecture 1-1 The whole life under the Holy Spirit; a vague or borrowed word; "piety" or "" instead
Mystical experience and the Word Lectures 2-2 and 4-1 Union with God beyond words; or a fear that experience can float free of Scripture and church
Saints and icons Lectures 2-3 and 4-2 Honoured by Catholic and Orthodox communities; objected to by Lutheran and Reformed voices on grounds of Scripture
Holiness, perfection and the Spirit Lectures 4-3 and 5-2 Wesleyan holiness, Pentecostal and cessationist readings of gifts and perfection
Spirituality and theology Lecture 6-3 One thing; or feeling overriding truth; or doctrine without life

Each of these has strong people on more than one side. The course asked, each time, that you could state each position fairly and say what its holders fear. It did not ask you to give up your own view. It asked you not to hold it in a way that cannot hear the others.

7. Unity without sameness

Ephesians 4:15-16 speaks of a body fitted and knit together, with every joint supplying something, and of growing in love by speaking the truth. Christians read this differently: some hold that the church is one visible body, and some that it is one in Christ across all its divisions. The course does not choose.

What this verse does not say is that every part is the same. A body with only hands is not a body. When we read the many ways side by side, as in this course, we need not pretend that every difference is small, and we need not pretend that the differences cancel out. "Speaking the truth in love" asks for both: the honesty to name a shadow, and the love that does it with a gift in hand.

8. A last caution: the reading list as a score

It would be a poor result of this course if a reader finished it with a list of classics to read and a vague feeling of being behind. The six questions give no list and set no pace. A person with one book that they return to for years may be reading better than a person with a hundred titles. Lecture 6-2's first pattern applies to reading as well: the shape of pride that treats spirituality as a project of the self can hide inside a very serious bookshelf.


Diagram 1. Six questions for any spiritual classic

Six Questions for Any Classic An old neighbour to talk with, not a model to copy 1. Who is the author? Who was this person, and in what place and time? Say "not known" when it is not. 2. Who is the reader? Who was it written for, and who has read it since? Was it meant for me? 3. What is the gift? What did it give to those who lived it? Ask this one first. 4. What is the shadow? What cost, limit or harm did it leave, or leave open? Not an accusation. 5. Who is left out? Whose voice is missing, or comes through another's pen? Keep a place open for them. 6. What of my neighbour? What does it ask of the people near me, and of me? Back from the page to the street. One question under the six What does this way ask, of me and of my neighbour, and who is not in the room? Not a score. Not a ranking. Best asked with others, and humbly.

Diagram 2. The six questions on an invented book

Question The Weaver's Hours (an invented example)
Author A working weaver in a river town
Reader Other weavers who could read
Gift Dignity for ordinary work; prayer inside the working day
Shadow A day set by the loom and the master; a hard employer could use it
Left out Spinners, children, weavers who could not read, those without a loom
Neighbour Share bread with a neighbour out of work; treat apprentices fairly

In short

  • The course gives no verdict on ways of life; it offers six questions for any spiritual classic.
  • The six are: who is the author, who is the reader, what is the gift, what is the shadow, who is left out, what does it ask of my neighbour.
  • Ask the gift before the shadow; a shadow is what an honest reader says after thanking the author.
  • Each way met in this course had a gift and a shadow, and none is ranked above another.
  • Readers still disagree on the word "spirituality", experience and the Word, saints and icons, holiness and the Spirit, and spirituality and theology.
  • A reading list is not a score of faith.
Front Back
Six questions Author; reader; gift; shadow; who is left out; what it asks of my neighbour.
Why gift first A reader who begins with the shadow often cannot hear anything else; a shadow is said after thanking the author.
Who is left out? Whose voice is missing or comes only through another's pen, such as women, the unlettered, the enslaved and the poor.
A reading list It is not a score of faith; one book returned to for years may be read better than a hundred.

One sentence to remember A classic is an old neighbour to talk with, and the six questions are a way to talk with it honestly.

This week's action Pick one book, hymn or rule you know and write its answers to the six questions in six short lines.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Which of the six questions is the easiest for you to ask? Which one do you tend to skip?
  • Why does the lecture put "gift" before "shadow"? What might go wrong if the order were reversed?
  • In *The Weaver's Hours*, who is left out? What could you do to keep a place open for them when you read?
  • Take a book, a hymn or a rule that you know well. Ask it the sixth question. What does it ask of your neighbour?
  • Look at the table of ways. Is there a gift or a shadow in the table that you would word differently? What would you say?
  • How is a reading list like a score? What would it mean to read well, as distinct from reading much?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.