Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Map an Argument
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Topic, Question and Thesis
- Lecture 1-2: Scope and the Thesis Test
- Lecture 1-3: Kinds of Theological Writing
- Lecture 1-4: Where Questions Come From
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: From Topic to Question
- Lecture 2-1: Reading Scripture Before Reading About It
- Lecture 2-2: Kinds of Sources and How to Weigh Them
- Lecture 2-3: Reading in a Second Language and in Translation
- Lecture 2-4: Keeping a Record of Your Reading
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Build a Source List
- Lecture 3-1: Claim, Reason, Evidence and Objection
- Lecture 3-2: Using Scripture as Evidence
- Lecture 3-3: Treating Other Positions Fairly
- Lecture 3-4: Where Readers Disagree: Authority and Method
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Map an Argument
- Lecture 4-1: Outlines and Structure
- Lecture 4-2: Paragraphs and Plain Style
- Lecture 4-3: Quoting, Summarising and Paraphrasing
- Lecture 4-4: Writing in a Second Language
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A First Draft Paragraph
- Lecture 5-1: Footnotes and Bibliographies
- Lecture 5-2: Citing Scripture and Ancient Sources
- Lecture 5-3: Plagiarism and Academic Honesty
- Lecture 5-4: Copyright, Permission and the Public Domain
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Check Your Sources
This is the third Practice Lab. The first four lectures of this week gave you the parts of an argument, three ways of using Scripture as evidence, a standard for describing other positions, and a way of stating the authority you assume. This lab asks you to use all of them on one argument.
The task is single and small. Draw a map of one argument: the claim, the reasons, the evidence for each reason, the strongest objection stated fairly, a response and the authority you assume.
You do not need a long paper. You do not need to have a finished thesis. The map is a working sheet, and its purpose is to show you where the argument is firm and where it is thin. A thin place is not a failure. It is the most useful thing the map can tell you.
Lecture 3-1 gave you the four parts and the gaps. Lecture 3-2 gave you the three jobs with Scripture. Lecture 3-3 gave you the holders' test and the three moves of a reply. Lecture 3-4 asked you to state your assumed authority. Today you put them on one page.
What these 20 minutes give you
- Fill in an argument map with the claim, reasons, evidence, a fairly stated objection, a response and an assumed authority.
- Find the largest gap in an argument and decide whether to add evidence or shrink the claim.
- State an objection in words that its holders would accept.
- Explain why the map is private and not marked.
- Run the lab in a small group while keeping the four rules.
But sanctify the Lord God in your hearts; and always be ready to give an answer to everyone who asks you a reason concerning the hope that is in you, with humility and fear:" — 1 Peter 3:15
World English Bible
The verse asks for readiness to give a reason, and it asks for a manner: humility. The map prepares the reason. It also prepares the humility, because a map shows you the place where you could be wrong.
1. Why map it
Smooth prose hides gaps. A paragraph can sound complete while one of its reasons has no evidence and another is only the claim said again. On a page of boxes, an empty box is plain to see.
Most writers feel resistance to mapping at first. It seems to take time away from writing. In practice it moves the time. A writer who maps spends a short time finding the gap, and not a long time after a draft has been written around it. Week 4 will turn to drafting, and a map will be waiting there when you get stuck.
2. The three ways in
A student who is not writing anything right now must still be able to do this lab. There are three ways. Choose one, or use more.
1. On your own piece of writing. Take an assignment, a draft or your notes. Choose one claim you want to make. Fill in the form for that claim. If you do not have a claim yet, use the thesis you drafted in the lab of week 1.
2. The practice topic. Use the invented argument below. It is not from any real person or school. The topic is whether a congregation should read long passages of Scripture aloud. Map the argument as you would your own.
3. The partner's way. No writing is shown to anyone. One person explains a claim aloud, with the reasons. The other asks questions: "Why do you think so? What shows that? What would someone who disagrees say?" Then the explainer states the strongest objection aloud, and the partner says whether it sounds fair. Then swap. In the second round, the partner tries the other side: the explainer defends a claim, and the listener argues against it. Then the listener says what they would have to be shown to change their mind. Argue both sides in turn.
3. The practice argument
Here is the argument. It is invented. (an invented example)
Churches should read long passages of the Bible aloud in their meetings. The book of the law was read from early morning until midday in Nehemiah 8:3, and the people were attentive. So every church must set aside an hour each week for reading. Reading aloud is always better than a sermon, and people today need it more than ever. Some say that long readings are hard for people who have little time. But reading aloud is important.
For reference, the verse the paragraph relies on reads: "He read therein before the broad place that was before the water gate from early morning until midday, in the presence of the men and the women, and of those who could understand; and the ears of all the people were attentive to the book of the law." (Nehemiah 8:3, WEB)
Read it twice. Then fill in the form in the diagram below, using the paragraph. Do this before you read the sample map further down.
4. Four rules
Say these before anyone writes, and say them every time.
- Nobody reads your draft or notes unless you choose to share them. The sheet is yours.
- Nothing is marked or graded. There is no right answer and no score.
- You may pass on any part. If a box does not fit or you would rather not fill it, leave it empty.
- The leader fills in a sheet too. In a group, the leader maps an argument like everyone else.
Never hand in this form. It is not a piece of work for the school. It is for you.
5. How to do it
Seven steps
Step 1. Choose your way. Your own claim, the practice argument, or the partner's way.
Step 2. Prepare the form. Copy the form in the diagram below onto a sheet of paper by hand, or open a blank page and write its headings. Leave room in each box.
Step 3. Write the claim in one sentence. It must be something a person could doubt. If you cannot write it in one sentence, the claim is not yet clear. Write it as best you can and come back.
Step 4. List the reasons, and the evidence for each. One reason per line. Beside each, write the passage or source, with the book and verse or the page. Where the evidence is Scripture, mark in the margin which of the three jobs it does: says, follows or applies. If the evidence is only your opinion, write "opinion". If a line is only the claim said again, write "repeats claim".
Step 5. Find the biggest gap. Look at the step from evidence to claim. Where do you move from what a source says to what you want the reader to accept, without showing why? Write it in the gap box. Decide whether you can add evidence or must shrink the claim.
Step 6. State the strongest objection, fairly. Write it in words that people who hold it would accept. Then write your response in the three moves: what you concede, what the evidence shows again, and where the difference in assumptions lies. You may find that you want to change the claim. That is a good result.
Step 7. Write the authority you assume, and rewrite the claim. In one sentence, say what you treat as your authority and how. Then write the claim again, at the size the evidence supports.
6. What the practice map might show
After you have tried it, compare your map with this one. It is only one reading. Yours may differ in good ways. (an invented example)
- Claim. Churches should read long passages of the Bible aloud in their meetings.
- Reason 1. Nehemiah 8:3 shows a long public reading to attentive hearers. Evidence: the verse. The verse says it happened once, in one setting. That is the first job, says. The writer jumps to "every church must set aside an hour each week", which is an application with no step shown. Gap.
- Reason 2. "Reading aloud is always better than a sermon." Evidence: none. It is a universal claim ("always") and it brings in a comparison that the paragraph does not argue for.
- Reason 3. "People today need it more than ever." Evidence: none, and "more than ever" would need a source.
- Last sentence. "Reading aloud is important." This repeats the claim.
- Objection as written. "Long readings are hard for people who have little time." It is stated briefly and the reply does not answer it.
- A fairer objection. A long reading may leave out people who cannot sit for long, or who do not follow the language in which it is read. Nehemiah 8:8 says the aim was that the hearers understood: "They read in the book, in the law of God, distinctly; and they gave the sense, so that they understood the reading." (Nehemiah 8:8, WEB) So understanding, and not length, may be the point of the passage.
- A reply in three moves. Concede that a long reading can leave some people out. Return to Nehemiah 8:3 and 8:8 and say what they show: a public reading, a hearing, an explanation. Name the difference: a reader who takes the narrative as a pattern for today and a reader who takes it as a record of one occasion will draw different conclusions.
- A smaller claim. On Nehemiah 8:3 and 8:8 I judge that a congregation does well to include regular public reading of Scripture, of a length and in a language its hearers can follow, with some explanation.
- An authority sentence. "I take Scripture as the first authority for what a congregation does in worship, and I treat this narrative as an example that guides, not as a command that fixes a schedule."
Notice that the revised claim is smaller and nearer to what the text says. That is the usual result of a map.
7. What usually goes wrong
Three reactions come up often.
"My map has no gaps. Everything is supported." That may be true. It may also mean you wrote the evidence in a way that matches the claim exactly, which can hide a step. Ask for each reason: "If a reader opened this source, would they find what I say it says?" And ask whether the reader could accept every reason and still ask "so what?".
"My objection is easy to answer." Then it may be a weak version. Ask who actually holds the opposing view, and what they would say. If you can only imagine them, look for their own writing, or use the partner's way and let your partner argue it for you.
"I find I do not know what I assume." That is useful to know. You may have been writing from habit. Look at which sources you reached for first, and what you treat as the last word when two of them disagree. Write what you find in a sentence.
8. Leader's note, for running this in a group
Gaps first, people never
Say the four rules out loud before anyone writes. Nobody reads the sheet, nothing is marked, anyone may pass, and you will fill in a sheet too. Say it even if you said it last week.
Choose the way to fit the group. If most people are between assignments, use the practice argument. If someone is working on a real piece of writing, offer the first way, and make sure that nobody feels asked to show it. The partner's way suits a group in which people like to talk.
Fill in your own sheet. A leader who watches while others write turns the room into an examination. Map the practice argument, or a claim of your own, in the same time.
When people share, ask about the map, not the person. "Where is the biggest gap?" is a good question. "Whose argument is weakest?" is not. If someone shares a claim of their own, thank them and ask questions of the map only.
Protect the other side. In the partner's way, the person arguing against a claim must state the opposing view in a form its holders would accept. If it becomes a joke or an attack, stop and restate it. A real disagreement among members of the group about a doctrine is not a reason to settle it; the lab is about the shape of the argument.
Allow anyone to pass. Say the words: "If you would rather not say, just pass." Then move on, with no pause that makes passing costly.
Do not turn the map into a verdict. A gap in an argument is a place to work. If a student says "my argument is bad", say gently that the map has found a place to work, and ask what they would do first.
Keep the end small. Ask each person to choose one change to make: a reason to remove, a source to find, a claim to shrink. Nobody needs to say it aloud.
Diagram 1. The form: Map an Argument
Diagram 2. Leader's checklist for this lab
| Item | Done |
|---|---|
| Stated the four rules out loud before anyone began | [ ] |
| Chose a way (own writing, practice argument, partner) that fits the group | [ ] |
| Filled in my own sheet beside the group | [ ] |
| Asked "Where is the biggest gap?" | [ ] |
| Did not ask "Whose argument is weakest?" | [ ] |
| Required the opposing view to be stated so its holders would accept it | [ ] |
| Offered a genuine option to pass, and moved on cleanly | [ ] |
| Ended with one small change for each person, said aloud only if they chose | [ ] |
In short
- The lab asks you to map one argument on one page: claim, reasons, evidence, objection, response and assumed authority.
- There are three ways in: your own writing, the invented practice argument, and the partner's way of arguing both sides aloud.
- Four rules apply: nobody reads your notes unless you choose, nothing is marked, you may pass on any part, and the leader fills in a sheet too.
- A map shows gaps, repeated claims and universal claims with no evidence; the usual fix is more evidence or a smaller claim.
- In a group, ask "Where is the biggest gap?", never "Whose argument is weakest?"
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The task | Map one argument on one page and find its biggest gap. |
| The three ways | Your own writing; the invented practice argument; the partner's way, arguing both sides aloud. |
| The usual result | The claim becomes smaller and closer to what the evidence supports. |
| The leader's question | "Where is the biggest gap?", never "Whose argument is weakest?" |
One sentence to remember A gap you have seen can be mended; a gap you have not seen is one your reader will find first.
This week's action Do the map in one of the three ways, and choose one change to make in your claim or your evidence.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Which box of the form was hardest to fill in? What does that tell you about the argument?
- In the practice argument, which reason had no evidence? Which was only the claim again?
- How did your objection look when you restated it in words its holders would accept?
- Did your claim get smaller after the map? What did it gain?
- What did you find you were assuming about authority that you had not said?