FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

FS101E Researching and Writing Theology

Lecture 1-4: Where Questions Come From

Contents 31
FS101E Researching and Writing Theology
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Honest Reading, Honest Writing
  1. Introduction: Honest Reading, Honest Writing
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Starting with a Question
  1. Lecture 1-1: Topic, Question and Thesis
  2. Lecture 1-2: Scope and the Thesis Test
  3. Lecture 1-3: Kinds of Theological Writing
  4. Lecture 1-4: Where Questions Come From
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: From Topic to Question
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Reading Well
  1. Lecture 2-1: Reading Scripture Before Reading About It
  2. Lecture 2-2: Kinds of Sources and How to Weigh Them
  3. Lecture 2-3: Reading in a Second Language and in Translation
  4. Lecture 2-4: Keeping a Record of Your Reading
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Build a Source List
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Building an Argument
  1. Lecture 3-1: Claim, Reason, Evidence and Objection
  2. Lecture 3-2: Using Scripture as Evidence
  3. Lecture 3-3: Treating Other Positions Fairly
  4. Lecture 3-4: Where Readers Disagree: Authority and Method
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Map an Argument
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Writing It Down
  1. Lecture 4-1: Outlines and Structure
  2. Lecture 4-2: Paragraphs and Plain Style
  3. Lecture 4-3: Quoting, Summarising and Paraphrasing
  4. Lecture 4-4: Writing in a Second Language
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A First Draft Paragraph
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Honest Sources
  1. Lecture 5-1: Footnotes and Bibliographies
  2. Lecture 5-2: Citing Scripture and Ancient Sources
  3. Lecture 5-3: Plagiarism and Academic Honesty
  4. Lecture 5-4: Copyright, Permission and the Public Domain
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Check Your Sources
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Revising and Finishing
  1. Lecture 6-1: Revising in Layers
  2. Lecture 6-2: Giving and Receiving Feedback
  3. Lecture 6-3: Case Studies, Confidentiality and Care
  4. Lecture 6-4: Claims the Right Size
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: Final Check and Research Plan

Jump to the key points ↓

22 min

Some students say, "I do not have a question." Usually they do. They have not noticed it yet, or they have not put it into words. A question is not a clever idea that arrives from nowhere. It is more often a small discomfort that stays: a verse that does not fit, a sentence in a creed that you cannot explain, a problem in your community that no one can answer, a claim in a book that you doubt.

This lecture describes four places where questions come from. They are Scripture reading (a snag, a repeated word), tradition (a creed's wording, or a disagreement between traditions), ministry (a pastoral problem) and other writers (a claim you doubt). It shows how to turn a ministry problem into a research question without making it a complaint. It recommends keeping a question log, and ends with a step that is easy to forget: asking who has already asked your question.

This lecture also says something about honesty. A question that comes from your life or your community is a gift, but it carries a danger: you may already be sure of the answer. The task is to hold your question open long enough to read.

As in every lecture, the assignment comes first. If the assignment gives you the question or limits the choices, the ideas here still help you to understand what the question is really asking.

What these 22 minutes give you

  • Name four sources of questions and give an example of each.
  • Turn a snag in reading into a question that names a text.
  • Turn a ministry problem into a research question without making it a complaint.
  • Keep a question log and explain what it is for.
  • Explain why you should ask who has already asked your question.

Will the Lord reject us forever? Will he be favorable no more? Has his loving kindness vanished forever? Does his promise fail for generations? Has God forgotten to be gracious? Has he, in anger, withheld his compassion?” Selah." — Psalm 77:7-9

World English Bible

Immediately the father of the child cried out with tears, “I believe. Help my unbelief!”" — Mark 9:24

WEB

Some men came down from Judea and taught the brothers, “Unless you are circumcised after the custom of Moses, you can’t be saved.”" — Acts 15:1

WEB

Therefore when Paul and Barnabas had no small discord and discussion with them, they appointed Paul and Barnabas, and some others of them, to go up to Jerusalem to the apostles and elders about this question." — Acts 15:2

WEB

Scripture does not hide hard questions. The psalm asks them in the open: will the Lord reject us, has his promise failed? The father in Mark says two things that seem to belong to different sentences, "I believe" and "help my unbelief", and says them together. These are the sounds of honest people. We may take from them a modest permission: a person can hold a question and still stay in the faith.

Acts 15 shows how a community can handle a real disagreement. Some men taught one thing, Paul and Barnabas disagreed, and the church sent them "about this question". The word "question" is in the text. The disagreement was put to the apostles and elders as something to be examined, and not buried. Lecture 3-3 comes back to this passage as a model.

1. A question is often a discomfort you have named

Most people think of research as starting with curiosity, a cheerful wish to know. Sometimes it does. But in theology, questions often start with something less comfortable. You are reading a passage and it seems to say two things at once. You hear a teaching in church and you cannot see where it comes from. A friend asks you something and you have no answer. A writer says a thing so confidently that you stop reading and think, "Is that true?"

That small stop is where a question lives. The skill of this lecture is learning to notice the stop, name it and put it into words that can be answered. Four places are especially rich.

2. Scripture reading: the snag and the repeated word

When you read slowly, you find snags. A snag is a place where your reading catches.

  • A word that repeats. In a short passage, a word appears three times. Why does the writer keep returning to it?
  • A detail that seems out of place. An odd order, a sudden change of scene, a number that seems too exact.
  • Two passages that seem to disagree. Two accounts of the same event differ in a detail, or two teachings seem to pull in different directions.
  • A passage you find hard to accept. If you flinch, ask why. The flinch is information.
  • A word you do not understand. What did the first hearers hear in it?

Writing it down is the first step. Compare:

  • "This is confusing." (A feeling. Not yet a question.)
  • "Why does Mark 9:24 hold 'I believe' and 'help my unbelief' in one sentence, and what does Jesus do with it in the next verses?" (A question that names a text and a relation. Notice that the first part can be answered by reading the verse, and the second needs a short look at what follows.)

A snag is not always a problem with the text. Often it is a problem with the reader, and this is a good thing to find out. You may discover that what puzzled you was a custom, a word or a setting that the first hearers knew and you do not. A question that turns out to have a small answer is still a good start. It will teach you how to look.

(The Mark question above is offered as an example of the form of a question. It does not claim an answer.)

3. Tradition: a creed's wording and a disagreement between traditions

Christians have inherited creeds, confessions, prayers and practices. Each contains choices of words, and each choice was usually made for a reason. This is a rich source of questions.

A wording in a creed or prayer. Why does a creed say "begotten, not made"? Why does a confession place a particular article before another? A question about wording is a question about what the writers were answering. For example, (an invented example): "Why does this confession's article on Scripture appear before its article on God, and what does the order show about the writers' concerns?"

A disagreement between traditions. Christians have long disagreed about some matters, such as how many sacraments there are, how a church is led, how Scripture and tradition relate, or what happens in the Lord's Supper. A disagreement is a ready-made question: how does each tradition reach its position, and which texts and reasons does it use? This kind of question asks you to report each side fairly, and so it is a good training for the habit of lecture 3-3.

A caution: if you start from a disagreement, you can drift into taking sides before you read. Ask, "What would a thoughtful member of each tradition say is the heart of the matter?" and write that down before you write any judgement.

4. Ministry: a problem you meet in real life

Many of this school's students serve in congregations, in prayer groups, in hospitals, in schools or among neighbours. Ministry throws up questions that books do not answer directly. A pastoral problem is a valuable source, because it matters to someone.

(Three invented problems.)

  • A group of older members does not welcome the young people who have joined.
  • Members are anxious that they have prayed for a sick friend and the friend has died.
  • A new believer asks whether it is wrong to keep a family custom that includes honouring the dead.

Each is real, but none is yet a research question. A problem is something that needs a response. A research question is something that can be answered by reading and thinking. The two are not the same, and the move between them is what this section teaches.

5. Turning a ministry problem into a research question

There are four steps. (The examples are invented.)

Step 1. Say the problem plainly, without blame. "Older members and young people do not mix" is a description. "Older members are selfish" is a complaint. A complaint closes the question, because it tells you who is at fault before you have looked. Write the description.

Step 2. Ask what Scripture or a tradition says that bears on it. Do not ask "What does the Bible say about young people?" That is too wide. Ask what a particular passage or source says about the thing in the problem. For the example: "What does Acts 6:1-7 show about how a community handled a complaint between two groups within it?"

Step 3. Make it a question of understanding, not of judgement. Change "How can I make the older members change?" to "What does this passage show about how a community deals with a division between groups?" You will still be able to apply the answer afterward. But the paper's task is to understand before applying.

Step 4. Narrow it. Use the four ways from lecture 1-2: passage, period, viewpoint or audience. For example: "In Acts 6:1-7, how does the community respond to the complaint of the Hellenists, and what does the response show about the role of the Twelve?"

Compare the two forms. (Both are invented.)

A complaint: "Why are churches so bad at including young people?"

A research question: "In Acts 6:1-7, how does the early community respond when one group says another group has neglected its widows, and what steps in that response might a congregation today consider?"

The second still comes from the same problem. It has the same love for the people in it. But it can be answered from a text, and it leaves room for the writer to be surprised.

A final care for ministry questions: if the problem involves real people, do not write about them in a way that could identify them. Lecture 6-3 deals with this fully. For now, describe the pattern and leave the persons out.

6. Other writers: a claim you doubt

Reading what others have written is a rich source. When you read a claim and think, "I am not sure that is right", you have a question. Another time, you read two writers who disagree. Or you read a writer who makes a statement without support, and you wonder what the support would be.

The question can take several forms.

  • Does the evidence support the claim? "This writer says that the early church had no leaders. Which texts could support that, and which seem to tell against it?"
  • Is the claim too wide? "This writer says the Psalms always end in praise. What of the psalms that do not?"
  • Do two writers actually disagree? Sometimes they use the same word in two senses.

Be careful. The question "Is this writer wrong?" is a poor start, because it lets you stop as soon as you find a flaw. A better question is, "What would this writer need to show for the claim to hold, and does the writer show it?" That keeps you reading what the writer actually wrote, which is the habit of a fair reader.

And do not attribute to the writer a view that the writer was arguing against. It happens: a writer sets out a position in order to answer it, and a careless reader quotes the first half. Lecture 2-4 returns to this.

7. A question log

Questions are easy to lose. A thought that seemed important at midnight is gone by morning. A question log is a simple way to keep them.

It can be a small notebook, a few pages, or a file on any device you use. Each entry has four parts:

  1. The date.
  2. The snag, in a sentence, in plain words: where you were reading or what happened.
  3. The question, as well as you can put it now.
  4. A note on where it came from: Scripture, tradition, ministry or another writer.

(An invented entry:) "12 March. Reading Mark 9. Father says 'I believe, help my unbelief' in one breath. Question: How does Mark present belief and doubt together in this scene? Source: Scripture."

The log has three uses. First, it holds your questions until you have time. Second, it shows you patterns: you may find that three entries all circle one theme, and that theme may be your paper. Third, when an assignment arrives, you do not start from nothing. You can look through the log and see which question could be made to fit.

Do not edit the log to make yourself look wise. A log that contains only polished questions is a display, not a tool. The rough ones are the useful ones.

8. Ask who has already asked it

Once you have a question, ask: has anyone already asked this?

It is almost always yes. Your question may feel new because it is new to you. Someone, somewhere, has probably asked it, or something close to it, and given an answer. That is good news. It means you do not have to begin from nothing, and you can learn how careful readers have gone about it.

How to find out depends on what you have. Your teacher or the person who set the assignment can often name a standard source. A good commentary on the passage usually shows the main ways the passage has been read. A dictionary or guide to the subject will often list the standard debates. A library or a knowledgeable friend can help. Weeks 2 and 5 say more about sources and about recording what you find.

Asking this does three things. It saves you from claiming to have found something that is well known. It gives you a fair account of the other answers, which you will need when you treat other positions in lecture 3-3. And it can improve your question, because you may see that the real puzzle is a little different from what you thought.

Do not be discouraged if you find it was asked. A question that has been asked many times is usually a good one. Your task is to answer it honestly for the time and place you have, and to say how your answer relates to the ones before.

9. A short caution about wishing for an answer

Questions that come from ministry or from a doubt carry feeling. That is good. But feeling can push you to a quick answer. Before you start reading, write down what you hope to find. Then read to see whether the text and the sources say it. If they do not, the honest thing is to change what you say. That is the whole of the course's central claim, applied to a single afternoon.


Diagram 1. Four sources of questions, and the route to a question

Where Questions Come From A small discomfort, named, becomes a question that can be answered SCRIPTURE A snag. A word that repeats. Two passages that seem to differ. "Why does it say this?" TRADITION A creed's wording. A disagreement between traditions. "Why was it put so?" MINISTRY A pastoral problem described without blame. "What helps us see this?" OTHER WRITERS A claim you doubt, or two writers who disagree. "What would it take?" QUESTION LOG: date, snag, question, source Keep the rough ones. Look for patterns. Begin an assignment from the log. A COMPLAINT (invented) "Why are churches so bad at including young people?" Blames before reading. Cannot be answered from a text. Too wide. A RESEARCH QUESTION (invented) "In Acts 6:1-7, how does the community respond to a complaint between groups?" Names a text. Asks how. Open to surprise. Right size. Then: who has already asked it?

In short

  • Questions often begin as a small discomfort that is noticed, named and put into words. Four rich sources are Scripture reading, tradition, ministry and other writers.
  • A snag in reading, such as a repeated word or two passages that differ, becomes a question when it names a text and a relation.
  • Turn a ministry problem into a research question by describing it without blame, choosing a bearing text or source, asking to understand before judging, and narrowing.
  • Keep a question log with the date, the snag, the question and its source. The rough entries are the useful ones.
  • Ask who has already asked your question. That saves you from false claims of novelty and gives you a fair account of the other answers.
Front Back
Four sources of questions Scripture reading, tradition, ministry, other writers.
Problem versus research question A problem needs a response; a research question can be answered by reading and thinking.
Question log entry Date, snag, question, and where it came from.
Why ask who asked it already? To avoid false novelty, to learn the other answers, and to sharpen your question.

One sentence to remember A question is often a discomfort that has been named without blame and aimed at a text.

This week's action Start a question log and write three entries from this week's reading or ministry.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Which of the four sources do you think produces most of your questions? Which do you tend to ignore?
  • Recall a place where you have felt a snag in reading Scripture. Write it as a question that names the text.
  • Take a problem in a community you know and describe it without blame, in two sentences. Then turn it into a research question using the four steps.
  • Think of a question you care about deeply. What do you hope the answer will be? What would it take for you to change your mind?
  • The father in Mark 9:24 says "I believe" and "help my unbelief" together. How might keeping a question log help a person hold belief and doubt honestly side by side?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.