FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

FS101E Researching and Writing Theology

Lecture 6-4: Claims the Right Size

Contents 31
FS101E Researching and Writing Theology
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Honest Reading, Honest Writing
  1. Introduction: Honest Reading, Honest Writing
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Starting with a Question
  1. Lecture 1-1: Topic, Question and Thesis
  2. Lecture 1-2: Scope and the Thesis Test
  3. Lecture 1-3: Kinds of Theological Writing
  4. Lecture 1-4: Where Questions Come From
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: From Topic to Question
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Reading Well
  1. Lecture 2-1: Reading Scripture Before Reading About It
  2. Lecture 2-2: Kinds of Sources and How to Weigh Them
  3. Lecture 2-3: Reading in a Second Language and in Translation
  4. Lecture 2-4: Keeping a Record of Your Reading
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Build a Source List
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Building an Argument
  1. Lecture 3-1: Claim, Reason, Evidence and Objection
  2. Lecture 3-2: Using Scripture as Evidence
  3. Lecture 3-3: Treating Other Positions Fairly
  4. Lecture 3-4: Where Readers Disagree: Authority and Method
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Map an Argument
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Writing It Down
  1. Lecture 4-1: Outlines and Structure
  2. Lecture 4-2: Paragraphs and Plain Style
  3. Lecture 4-3: Quoting, Summarising and Paraphrasing
  4. Lecture 4-4: Writing in a Second Language
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A First Draft Paragraph
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Honest Sources
  1. Lecture 5-1: Footnotes and Bibliographies
  2. Lecture 5-2: Citing Scripture and Ancient Sources
  3. Lecture 5-3: Plagiarism and Academic Honesty
  4. Lecture 5-4: Copyright, Permission and the Public Domain
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Check Your Sources
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Revising and Finishing
  1. Lecture 6-1: Revising in Layers
  2. Lecture 6-2: Giving and Receiving Feedback
  3. Lecture 6-3: Case Studies, Confidentiality and Care
  4. Lecture 6-4: Claims the Right Size
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: Final Check and Research Plan

Jump to the key points ↓

20 min

Every paper makes claims. Some are small ("In verse 3 Paul uses the word 'gift'"). Some are large ("The early church was united on this question"). A claim has a size, and it has a matching size of evidence. When the claim is larger than the evidence, the paper says more than it knows. When the claim is smaller than the evidence, the paper hides what it has found.

This is the last of the lectures on argument, and it comes at the end because it is a final check. After you have a thesis, reasons, sources and a draft, you go through the paper and ask of each claim: is this the right size?

The lecture teaches four things. First, how to spot the words that make claims too large. Second, how to hedge in a way that is accurate and not evasive: firm where the evidence is strong, careful where it is not. Third, how to say what you did not check and what your paper does not cover. Fourth, how to avoid taking your own setting for the whole world. A closing section places all this under humility about interpretation.

It is the central claim of the course in its plainest form: say only as much as I can support.

What these 20 minutes give you

  • Recognise words that often signal an overgeneralisation and test each claim against the evidence.
  • Explain the difference between hedging that is accurate and hedging that is evasive.
  • Rewrite an oversized claim so that it matches what the evidence shows.
  • Write a short statement of the limits of a paper: what was not checked and not covered.
  • Explain why a claim about "the church" or "people" needs a place and a time.

Do you see a man wise in his own eyes? There is more hope for a fool than for him." — Proverbs 26:12

World English Bible

For we know in part, and we prophesy in part;" — 1 Corinthians 13:9

WEB

For now we see in a mirror, dimly, but then face to face. Now I know in part, but then I will know fully, even as I was also fully known." — 1 Corinthians 13:12

WEB

For you ought to say, “If the Lord wills, we will both live, and do this or that.”" — James 4:15

WEB

Proverbs 26:12 names a danger for every writer: being wise in your own eyes. Paul, in 1 Corinthians 13, says that we know in part and that for now we see dimly, though we will know fully when we meet face to face. James, in the verse that follows a warning about planning a year of trade as if the future were ours, says to speak with the thought, "If the Lord wills." None of these verses tells a writer how long a sentence should be. They give a stance: we know some things, we do not know everything, and an honest voice says which is which. That stance does not make a writer weak. A person who is clear about what is known is more trusted when saying what is not.

1. Claims have a size

Take two sentences about the same passage. (an invented example)

A. "In Mark 9:24, the father's words show that all true faith contains doubt."

B. "In Mark 9:24, the father says he believes and asks for help with his unbelief; in this story, faith and doubt are present in one person at the same time."

Sentence A claims something about all true faith, in every person and every time. A single verse cannot show that. Sentence B claims something about this story, and the verse shows it. B is smaller. B is also stronger, because a reader can check it and find it true.

The rule is simple to state and hard to keep: the claim should be no bigger than the evidence, and no smaller. Big claims are tempting because they sound important. Small claims sound safe. Neither is the aim. The aim is the claim that your evidence can carry.

2. Signals of oversize

Some words invite attention because they often carry a claim larger than the evidence. They are not forbidden. A sentence with "always" can be true. But each one should make you stop and ask: have I shown this?

Signal Questions to ask A smaller form
all, every, everyone Have I looked at all of them? "the three letters I read", "most of the sources I found"
always, never At every time and place? "in these passages", "in the period I studied"
no one, nobody Can I be sure that none exists? "I found no writer who..."
clearly, obviously, of course If it is clear, why is it not shown? Give the reason, and drop the word
the church, the Bible, Christians, scholars Which church, which book, which people, which scholars? Name them
proves, shows (about a large matter) Does it prove, or does it fit? "is consistent with", "supports"
today, in our time Where, and for whom? Name the place and the group

Here is an example of the whole row at work. (an invented example)

Before: "Scholars have always agreed that this letter was written to the whole church, and nobody today doubts it."

After: "The three commentaries I consulted treat the letter as written to the whole church. I did not look at how the question has been argued in other periods."

The second version is shorter in what it claims and longer in what it says. It tells the reader what was read.

3. Hedging is accuracy, not evasion

A hedge is a word or phrase that limits a claim: "probably", "in this passage", "most likely", "I suggest". Some writers think hedging is weak. Others hedge everything so that no claim can be wrong. Both have misunderstood.

Accurate hedging matches the strength of the evidence. Where the evidence is strong, be firm: "Paul writes to the Galatians that..." is a fact about the text. Where the evidence is partial, step back: "This reading is likely, because...". Where it is doubtful, say that it is: "The text does not tell us whether..."

Evasive hedging hides the claim. "It could perhaps be said that, to some extent, there may be a sense in which..." says nothing. The reader cannot disagree, because there is nothing to disagree with, and cannot learn, because nothing is claimed.

A test: could a careful reader say what you are claiming, and what evidence would show you wrong? If yes, your hedging is accurate. If no, you have hidden the claim.

A short pair of examples. (an invented example)

Evasive: "It might be suggested that perhaps the author may have intended something like a warning."

Accurate: "The author most likely intends a warning, because the sentence ends with a threat and the next verse gives a consequence."

The accurate version commits to a view, says how strong it is ("most likely"), and gives the reason. And do not hedge a thing you know. "Perhaps Jesus spoke in parables" is false modesty; the Gospels say he did.

Also take care with the opposite danger: a confident tone that has no support. Strong words are not strong evidence. A paper that says "undoubtedly" and then gives no reason is asking the reader to trust the tone.

4. Saying what you did not check

An honest paper says where its reading stopped. This is not an apology. It tells the reader how far to trust the result, and it makes it possible for another reader to continue.

You can do this in a sentence or a short paragraph, usually near the end, or at the point where the limit matters:

  • "I read this letter in an English translation and did not check the Greek."
  • "I limited the sources to those available to me in English and did not consult the work written in other languages."
  • "I looked at the first three centuries only."
  • "I did not interview anyone outside the congregation I describe."
  • "I could not find a source that discusses this point, and did not see a way to check it."

A short example of a limits paragraph. (an invented example)

"This paper argues from the text of Philippians 2 and from three secondary sources. It does not discuss the history of the interpretation of the passage, and it does not examine the Greek word beyond what the sources say about it. The conclusion therefore applies to the reading of the passage in English, in the sources I used."

This is a strong paragraph. It does not weaken the paper. The reader knows what to rely on. A reader who finds a limit hidden will wonder what else was hidden.

Do not use the limits statement to excuse laziness ("I did not have time to read the main work on this topic"). If the paper needs it, read it, or narrow the question (lecture 1-2) so that you do not need it.

5. Do not take your setting for the world

A writer sees the world from somewhere. It is easy to write as if everyone were there too. A pastor of a large city church may write "people today are busy and distracted". A student from a rural village may write "families live together and take care of the old". Each may be true of the writer's setting. Neither is true of everyone.

Watch for these phrases: "people today", "in our culture", "the modern world", "families", "young people", "the church in the West", "in Africa", "in Asia". Each is a claim about a vast number of people. Ask: whom have I actually seen or read? Can I name the place and the group?

The remedy is not to avoid your setting. It is a great gift to write from one. A paper that says, "In the two congregations I know, both in a large city in one country, young adults leave after they finish school" is useful and honest. The same sentence with "young adults leave the church" is a different and much larger claim.

Be careful also with generalisations about other people's cultures or religions. Describe a tradition in its own terms and check its own sources (lecture 3-3). A claim about "Muslims" or "Catholics" or "Pentecostals" or "Africans" is almost never one claim; it covers many communities, countries and centuries. Name the community, the document or the person, and say what you read.

And do not assume that your tradition's convention is the one the reader holds. A reader may use a different Bible translation, a different calendar, a different way of counting books, a different set of authorities. Lecture 3-4 says to state the authority you assume. This is the same point at the size of a word.

6. Humility about interpretation

Everything above is about evidence. There is a further point about interpretation itself. When you read a text and tell the reader what it means, you give your best reading. Others have read it differently. Some of them knew more than you; some knew less. Honest writers know this and say it when it matters.

Paul's words are the model: "Now I know in part." He says this near the end of a chapter on love, in the middle of a letter that argues strongly about many things. Humility did not stop him from writing firmly. It meant that he knew the limit of his own sight.

A few habits grow from this:

  • Say "I read the passage as..." and not "The passage means..." when others read it differently.
  • Present the other readings and say why you chose yours (lecture 3-3).
  • Leave room for being shown wrong. A paper that ends with "this is the only possible reading" is more likely to be wrong than a paper that ends with "this is the reading the evidence best supports, and here is what would change my mind".
  • Do not use humility as an excuse for having no view. The reader asked a question and is owed an answer: your best answer, in its right size.

7. Matching the size: a method

Here is a short method to use in the last reading of a paper.

  1. Underline every sentence that makes a claim, not only the thesis.
  2. For each, write in the margin the evidence for it. If you cannot, mark it.
  3. For each marked claim, choose: support it (add the evidence), shrink it (change the words so that they match), or cut it.
  4. Look for the signal words in the table. Ask the question beside each.
  5. Write the limits statement. What did you not check? What does the paper not cover?
  6. Read the introduction and conclusion again. Do they claim the same amount as the body shows?

The last step catches a common fault: the introduction promises more than the body delivers, and the conclusion promises more again. The conclusion should say what the paper has shown and where it stops (lecture 4-1).

8. The reader's time

Behind this lecture stands a person: the reader. The reader has given you time. A reader who finds a claim too big spends that time checking it and finds it wanting, and then starts to doubt the rest. A reader who finds that each claim matches its evidence can relax and follow the argument.

That is a form of respect, as lecture 4-2 says of plain style. It treats the reader as a person who will judge, and it does not try to push the reader into agreeing. It also makes the writer easy to trust. A writer who says "I do not know this" is believed when saying "I do know this".


Diagram 1. Fitting the claim to the evidence

Claims the Right Size No bigger than the evidence, and no smaller TOO BIG "All true faith contains doubt." Evidence: one verse about one father. The claim outruns the text. THE RIGHT SIZE "In this story, faith and doubt are in one person." Evidence: the same verse. The reader can check it. Firm, and no larger. TOO SMALL "The verse contains the word believe." True, and it tells the reader nothing. The finding is hidden. Last reading: six steps Underline each claim. Write its evidence in the margin. Support, shrink or cut it. Check signal words: all, always, never, clearly, the church, scholars, people today. Write what you did not check and what the paper does not cover. Be firm where the evidence is strong; step back only where it is not.

In short

  • Every claim has a size, and the evidence must match it: no bigger, and no smaller.
  • Words such as all, always, never, clearly, the church and scholars should make you ask whether you have shown the claim.
  • Accurate hedging is firm where the evidence is strong and careful where it is not. Evasive hedging hides the claim.
  • Say what you did not check and what the paper does not cover. Do not take your own setting for the whole world.
  • Humility about interpretation means giving your best reading, saying that others read differently, and leaving room to be shown wrong.
Front Back
The right size No bigger than the evidence, and no smaller.
Accurate hedging Firm where the evidence is strong, careful where it is not.
A limits statement A short note saying what you did not check and what the paper does not cover.
"People today" A claim about vast numbers; name the place and the group you actually know.

One sentence to remember Claim what your evidence can carry, and tell the reader where it stops.

This week's action Underline every claim in a draft, write its evidence in the margin, and shrink, support or cut each one that has none.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Find a sentence in your own writing with "all", "always", "never", "clearly" or "everyone". What evidence do you have for it? How would you change it?
  • Write one example of evasive hedging and one of accurate hedging on the same topic. What is the difference?
  • Write a limits statement of two or three sentences for a paper you have written or plan to write.
  • Which phrase about "people today" or "our culture" have you used? What setting did you actually have in mind?
  • How do you tell the difference between humility and having no view?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.