Lecture 4-1: Outlines and Structure
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Topic, Question and Thesis
- Lecture 1-2: Scope and the Thesis Test
- Lecture 1-3: Kinds of Theological Writing
- Lecture 1-4: Where Questions Come From
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: From Topic to Question
- Lecture 2-1: Reading Scripture Before Reading About It
- Lecture 2-2: Kinds of Sources and How to Weigh Them
- Lecture 2-3: Reading in a Second Language and in Translation
- Lecture 2-4: Keeping a Record of Your Reading
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Build a Source List
- Lecture 3-1: Claim, Reason, Evidence and Objection
- Lecture 3-2: Using Scripture as Evidence
- Lecture 3-3: Treating Other Positions Fairly
- Lecture 3-4: Where Readers Disagree: Authority and Method
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Map an Argument
- Lecture 4-1: Outlines and Structure
- Lecture 4-2: Paragraphs and Plain Style
- Lecture 4-3: Quoting, Summarising and Paraphrasing
- Lecture 4-4: Writing in a Second Language
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A First Draft Paragraph
- Lecture 5-1: Footnotes and Bibliographies
- Lecture 5-2: Citing Scripture and Ancient Sources
- Lecture 5-3: Plagiarism and Academic Honesty
- Lecture 5-4: Copyright, Permission and the Public Domain
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Check Your Sources
By now you have a question, a thesis in draft, a set of sources and a map of your argument. The next task is to put them in an order that a reader can follow. Many writers skip this step. They begin at the top of a blank page and hope that the order will appear as they write. Sometimes it does. More often the writer reaches page three and finds that the best idea belongs on page one, or that two parts say the same thing, or that nothing connects the middle to the end.
An outline is a plan made before the draft. It is not a promise. You may change it. But a writer who has an outline has something to return to when the draft goes wrong. It is a map. A traveller who loses the road looks at the map and finds the place again.
This lecture explains what an outline is for, what the introduction, the body and the conclusion each do, how the shape changes with the length of the piece, and how to test an outline before you spend hours on a draft. It belongs to the central claim of the course. A reader who has to guess where the argument is going has been failed. A clear structure is a way of respecting the reader, and it is also a way of checking that you really have an argument and not only a collection of notes.
Where this lecture and your assignment differ, follow the assignment. Some assignments name the parts that the paper must have, in a set order. If yours does, use that order and use this lecture to understand why each part is there.
What these 20 minutes give you
- Explain what an outline is for and why it is made before the draft.
- State what the introduction, the body and the conclusion each do.
- Choose a suitable shape for a piece of about 1,000 words, about 3,000 to 5,000 words, and about 8,000 to 10,000 words.
- Write a sentence outline in which each part states its point.
- Test an outline by removing a part, changing the order, and looking for a point you only pretend to know.
Yahweh answered me, “Write the vision, and make it plain on tablets, that he who runs may read it." — Habakkuk 2:2
World English Bible
Prepare your work outside, and get your fields ready. Afterwards, build your house." — Proverbs 24:27
WEB
In Habakkuk the prophet is told to make the message plain, so that a person who is hurrying can still read it. That is a good test for any writing. If a hurried reader cannot find the point, the writer has more work to do. The proverb speaks about order. The farmer prepares the fields first and builds the house afterwards. The writer does the same when the plan comes before the draft.
These verses do not tell us how to build an outline. They give a reason for taking care. Clear order is a kindness to the reader, and good preparation comes before good building.
1. What an outline is for
An outline does three jobs.
First, it shows you whether you have an argument. Suppose you try to write the outline and cannot say what the second part is for. Then you do not yet know what you want to say. It is better to find this out in ten minutes with a pencil than in ten hours with a draft.
Second, it gives you a place to return to. Writing is tiring. In the middle of a draft it is easy to wander. You start a side path because it is interesting. You add a long quotation because you like it. The outline reminds you of the road.
Third, it lets you change the order cheaply. Moving a line in an outline costs nothing. Moving a section of a finished draft costs an afternoon.
An outline is not a cage. As you write, you will learn things. A part may turn out to be too large, or a new part may be needed. When that happens, change the outline first, and then change the draft. If you change only the draft, the map no longer matches the land, and the next time you are lost the map will not help.
2. What the introduction does
The introduction answers four questions for the reader, in roughly this order.
- What is the question? The reader should know within the first few sentences what you are asking.
- Why does it matter? Say who needs the answer, or what is unclear without it. One or two sentences are enough.
- What is your answer? State the thesis. Do not hide it. A theological paper is not a story with a surprise at the end.
- How will you get there? Give the route in a sentence or two: which text you will read, which sources you will use, in what order.
Here is a short example of an introduction in four sentences (an invented example):
In Mark 4:35-41 the disciples are afraid twice: once in the storm and once after it ends. This paper asks why Mark records the second fear. I argue that the second fear moves the reader's question from "what happened?" to "who is this?" I first read the passage closely, then compare the two moments of fear, and last consider one alternative reading.
Each sentence has one job. The first states the puzzle. The second states the question. The third states the thesis. The fourth gives the route.
Some introductions are weak in a few common ways. Some begin with a very wide statement about all of history ("Since the beginning of time, people have asked about fear"). Such a start tells the reader nothing and delays the question. Some give a long review of other writers before the reader knows what is being asked. Some promise a plan ("This paper will discuss fear in Mark") with no thesis. Lecture 1-2 explained why a plan is not a thesis.
3. What the body does
The body is where you give your reasons and your evidence. The rule that makes the body easy to read is simple: each part carries one reason.
If your thesis rests on three reasons, the body has three main parts. Each part opens by saying what its reason is. Then it gives the evidence: the text, the sources, the examples. Then it says what follows. A reader who finishes a part should be able to say, "This part showed that…" and complete the sentence.
The body also has a place for the strongest objection. Lecture 3-3 explained why you should state another position fairly before you answer it. In an outline, give the objection its own part, or place it inside the reason that it challenges. Do not push it to the last line of the paper as an afterthought.
The order of the parts needs a reason too. Common orders are these:
- Along the text. You follow the passage from its start to its end. This works well for a close reading.
- From the clearest to the hardest. You begin with the reason that is easiest to accept, so the reader builds trust.
- From cause to result, or from the past to the present.
- From the view you will answer to the view you will defend.
Choose one order and say it in your outline. If you cannot give a reason for the order, try another.
4. What the conclusion does
The conclusion does three things.
- It gathers: it states again, briefly, what the paper has shown. It does not repeat the introduction word for word.
- It says what the result means: what changes for the reader, for the reading of the text, or for the community.
- It says where it stops: what you did not examine, what remains open, what a later study could do.
A conclusion has one rule that is easy to forget: it brings no new evidence. If a new text or a new source is needed to make your case, it belongs in the body. A conclusion that opens a fresh argument leaves the reader with a question that the paper no longer has room to answer.
Saying where the paper stops is not a weakness. It is part of saying only as much as you can support. A reader trusts a writer who marks the edge of what has been shown.
5. Three shapes for three lengths
The same question needs a different shape at a different length. Here are three outlines for one invented question: why does Mark record the disciples' second fear in Mark 4:35-41? (invented examples)
About 1,000 words. Five parts, each a short paragraph or two.
- Introduction: question, thesis, route (about 150 words).
- The first fear, in the storm (about 200 words).
- The second fear, after the storm (about 250 words).
- What the change shows about the question the disciples ask (about 250 words).
- Conclusion: what is shown and what is not (about 150 words).
There is no room for a long review of other writers or for a separate objection. At this size, the objection may be one sentence inside part 4.
About 3,000 to 5,000 words. Seven or eight parts.
- Introduction.
- The place of the passage in the Gospel (the context of the chapter).
- A close reading of the storm.
- A close reading of the stilling and the second fear.
- Reason one: the vocabulary of fear in the passage.
- Reason two: the disciples' question and what follows in the Gospel.
- The strongest alternative reading, stated fairly, and the reply.
- Conclusion.
Now there is room to show the evidence and to answer a real objection.
About 8,000 to 10,000 words. Several larger sections, each with sub-parts, and a short summary at the end of each large section. A paper of this size usually needs a section that reviews how other writers have read the passage, a section on method, and a section that places the result in the wider study of the Gospel. At this length the reader needs signposts. At the end of each large section, a sentence or two should say what has been shown and what comes next.
The longer the piece, the more the reader depends on your structure. A short piece can be held in the mind at once. A long piece cannot.
6. Sentence outlines
A topic outline lists the subject of each part: "The first fear." "The second fear." A sentence outline states the point of each part in a full sentence: "In the storm the disciples fear for their lives and ask Jesus to act."
Prefer the sentence outline. A topic outline can hide a part that has no point. You can write "The second fear" and feel that you have said something, even if you do not know what you will claim about it. A sentence forces you to claim something. If you cannot write the sentence, you have found a gap.
Here is the difference (an invented example):
| Topic outline | Sentence outline |
|---|---|
| 3. The storm | 3. The first fear is a fear of danger, and the disciples ask Jesus to act. |
| 4. The stilling | 4. After the calm, the disciples' fear changes its object: they now fear the one who has acted. |
| 5. The question | 5. Their question "who is this?" is the question Mark wants the reader to carry into the rest of the Gospel. |
The right column is also a first draft of the topic sentences of your paragraphs. Lecture 4-2 explains why this matters.
Notice that the sentence outline is not a place to hide a quotation or a long phrase from a source. Write the sentences in your own words. This will help you later, when you turn the outline into prose.
7. Testing the outline
Before you start the draft, test the outline in four ways.
1. Remove a part. Take out one part and read the rest. If the argument still works, that part may not be needed. It may be interesting but not necessary. Decide whether to cut it or to find out what it is really for.
2. Change the order. Swap two parts. If the argument reads as well in the new order, you have not yet made a reason for the old order. If it reads worse, you know why the order matters. Write that reason down.
3. Look for a point you only pretend to know. Read each sentence and ask: do I know this, or do I hope it is true? Mark each part where you are not sure. Those are the places where you need to read again before you write. If you leave the guess in the draft, the weakness will be visible, and it will be harder to repair.
4. Read only the sentence outline aloud, to yourself or to a listener. Does it sound like an argument? Does each sentence follow from the last? If the listener cannot say what the paper claims, the structure needs work.
These tests will take less than an hour. They can save days.
8. When the outline meets the assignment
Some assignments give a required structure: "Part one, summary of the text. Part two, response." Use the structure that is set. Within each required part you can still make a small outline of your own. Other assignments leave the structure to you. In that case, state in your introduction how the paper is arranged, so the reader is not left to guess.
If you are unsure whether you may choose your own structure, ask the person who set the assignment.
Diagram 1. From question to conclusion: the shape of a paper
In short
- An outline is a plan made before the draft. It shows whether you have an argument and gives you a place to return to.
- The introduction states the question, why it matters, the thesis and the route. The conclusion gathers, says what the result means and where it stops.
- In the body, each part carries one reason. The strongest objection has its own place.
- The conclusion brings no new evidence.
- A sentence outline is better than a topic outline, because a sentence cannot hide a part with no point.
- Test an outline by removing a part, changing the order, and marking every point you only pretend to know.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| What an outline is for | To show whether you have an argument, to give you a place to return to, and to let you change the order cheaply. |
| The four jobs of an introduction | The question, why it matters, the thesis, and the route. |
| The rule for the body | Each part carries one reason. |
| The rule for the conclusion | Gather, say what it means, say where it stops. Bring no new evidence. |
One sentence to remember A reader who has to guess where the argument is going has been failed, and a clear outline is the first way to prevent it.
This week's action Write a sentence outline for a piece of your own writing, or for the practice topic, and test it by removing one part.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Think of a piece of writing you found hard to follow. Where did you start to guess? What would a better outline have shown?
- Take your own question and thesis, or the practice topic of this week. Write a sentence outline of five parts. Which part is hardest to state as a sentence? What does that tell you?
- Why is it a mistake to put a new text or a new source in the conclusion?
- Remove one part from your outline. Does the argument still work? What did you learn?
- Habakkuk 2:2 speaks of a message that a person who runs can read. What does this suggest about the first page of a paper?