FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

FS101E Researching and Writing Theology

Lecture 3-1: Claim, Reason, Evidence and Objection

Contents 31
FS101E Researching and Writing Theology
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Honest Reading, Honest Writing
  1. Introduction: Honest Reading, Honest Writing
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Starting with a Question
  1. Lecture 1-1: Topic, Question and Thesis
  2. Lecture 1-2: Scope and the Thesis Test
  3. Lecture 1-3: Kinds of Theological Writing
  4. Lecture 1-4: Where Questions Come From
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: From Topic to Question
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Reading Well
  1. Lecture 2-1: Reading Scripture Before Reading About It
  2. Lecture 2-2: Kinds of Sources and How to Weigh Them
  3. Lecture 2-3: Reading in a Second Language and in Translation
  4. Lecture 2-4: Keeping a Record of Your Reading
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Build a Source List
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Building an Argument
  1. Lecture 3-1: Claim, Reason, Evidence and Objection
  2. Lecture 3-2: Using Scripture as Evidence
  3. Lecture 3-3: Treating Other Positions Fairly
  4. Lecture 3-4: Where Readers Disagree: Authority and Method
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Map an Argument
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Writing It Down
  1. Lecture 4-1: Outlines and Structure
  2. Lecture 4-2: Paragraphs and Plain Style
  3. Lecture 4-3: Quoting, Summarising and Paraphrasing
  4. Lecture 4-4: Writing in a Second Language
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A First Draft Paragraph
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Honest Sources
  1. Lecture 5-1: Footnotes and Bibliographies
  2. Lecture 5-2: Citing Scripture and Ancient Sources
  3. Lecture 5-3: Plagiarism and Academic Honesty
  4. Lecture 5-4: Copyright, Permission and the Public Domain
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Check Your Sources
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Revising and Finishing
  1. Lecture 6-1: Revising in Layers
  2. Lecture 6-2: Giving and Receiving Feedback
  3. Lecture 6-3: Case Studies, Confidentiality and Care
  4. Lecture 6-4: Claims the Right Size
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: Final Check and Research Plan

Jump to the key points ↓

16 min

In the first two weeks you chose a question and learned to read honestly. Now you have to answer the question in a way that another person can follow and check.

That is what an argument is for. In this course, an argument is not a quarrel. It is a set of reasons offered to a reader who is free to weigh them. The writer says: "Here is what I think, here is why, and here is what I looked at. You may see where I could be wrong."

This lecture names the four parts of a simple argument: the claim, the reasons, the evidence and the objection. It takes one invented argument apart to show how they fit. It then gives four tools: the test for a restated claim, the deletion test, the argument map and the habit of scaling a claim to its evidence.

This belongs to the central claim of the course. Saying only as much as you can support is not possible until you can see what your support is. An argument laid out in parts lets you, and your reader, see it.

What these 16 minutes give you

  • Name the four parts of an argument and say what each one does.
  • Tell a reason from a claim that has only been repeated in other words.
  • Use the deletion test to find sentences that add nothing.
  • Draw a simple map of an argument and point to a gap between a reason and its evidence.
  • Scale a claim so that it is no larger than its evidence.

But sanctify the Lord God in your hearts; and always be ready to give an answer to everyone who asks you a reason concerning the hope that is in you, with humility and fear:" — 1 Peter 3:15

World English Bible

Come now, and let us reason together,” says Yahweh: “Though your sins be as scarlet, they shall be as white as snow. Though they be red like crimson, they shall be as wool." — Isaiah 1:18

WEB

Peter does not tell believers to win. He tells them to be ready to give "a reason", and to do it "with humility and fear". The word is reason, not pressure. In Isaiah the invitation is "let us reason together". A reason is something both sides can look at. These two verses do not tell us how to write an essay. They give us the spirit of it: when we make a case, we put our reasons where others can see them, and we do it gently.

1. What an argument is, and what it is not

Many students hear the word "argument" and think of a loud disagreement. Others think it means collecting quotations that agree with what they already believe. Neither is what we mean.

For this course, an argument has one job. It gives a reader a claim and the reasons for it, so that the reader can decide whether the reasons are good enough. A reader who disagrees can still see exactly where the disagreement lies. That is already a gain. A paper that only says "this is true" gives the reader nothing to do but accept or refuse.

Giving reasons is a way of answering gently. Peter's phrase is "an answer to everyone who asks you a reason". A person who asks is owed a reason. A paper is an answer to a question put by your reader, even when the reader is a person you will never meet.

2. The four parts

A simple argument has four parts.

The claim. This is what you want the reader to accept. In week 1 you called it your thesis. It is a statement that someone could doubt.

The reasons. These are the statements that make the claim believable. A claim usually needs two or three. Each one should be a separate step, not a copy of the claim.

The evidence. This is what you point to for each reason: a passage of Scripture, a line in a creed, a fact in a source. Evidence is something a reader can look up. Your opinion about the evidence is not evidence.

The objection. This is the strongest reason someone could give for doubting the claim. It comes from outside your own line of thought. A good argument names it and answers it. Lecture 3-3 shows how to state an objection fairly. Here we only need to know that it is one of the four parts.

A short way to remember them is four questions a reader silently asks. What do you want me to believe? Why should I? What shows that? What could be said against it?

3. A worked example, taken apart

Here is a short argument. It is invented, and it is not from any real student or school. (an invented example)

A congregation should leave time in its meetings for members to check what is taught against the text. The Bereans examined the Scriptures daily to see whether Paul's message was so. They are called "more noble" for doing it. Checking teaching against Scripture is a good habit. Some will say that Paul was an apostle and should not have been tested. But the text itself praises the testing.

The paragraph depends on one verse, which reads: "Now these were more noble than those in Thessalonica, in that they received the word with all readiness of the mind, examining the Scriptures daily to see whether these things were so." (Acts 17:11, WEB)

Now take the paragraph apart.

Part What the paragraph gives
Claim A congregation should leave time in its meetings for members to check teaching against the text.
Reason 1 The Bereans checked what Paul taught against the Scriptures, and the narrator praises them.
Reason 2 "Checking teaching against Scripture is a good habit."
Evidence Acts 17:11.
Objection Paul was an apostle, so the Bereans' case is special.
Response "The text itself praises the testing."

Look at what the table shows.

First, Reason 2 is not a second reason. It is the first half of the claim again. "Checking is a good habit" and "a congregation should leave time to check" say nearly the same thing. The paragraph looks as if it has two reasons, but it has one.

Second, there is a gap between the evidence and the claim. The verse says the Bereans examined the Scriptures daily. It does not say they did it in a meeting, and it does not say that a congregation should arrange time for it. The writer has moved from what the Bereans did to what a congregation should do, and has not shown the step.

Third, the response does not answer the objection. The objection says the Bereans are a special case, because Paul was an apostle. The response says the text praises testing. That is true, but it was never in doubt. The objection was about whether the example applies to ordinary teaching today.

None of this means the argument is hopeless. It means the writer now knows what to work on. That is the purpose of taking an argument apart.

4. Restating a claim is not giving a reason

The most common fault in student writing is a sentence that looks like a reason and is only the claim said again.

Here is a weak and a revised version. Both are invented. (an invented example)

Weak: Christians should read the Psalms often because the Psalms are important to read regularly.

The "because" part says "important to read regularly", which is "should read often" in other clothes.

Revised: Christians should read the Psalms often because the Psalms give words for situations in which people find it hard to pray, such as grief and fear.

The revised version gives a reason that can be examined. A reader can ask: do the Psalms really do this? Which ones? That is a question the writer can answer with evidence.

A quick test is to ask, "Could someone who rejects my claim also reject this reason?" If the answer is "only because they reject the claim", the reason is probably the claim restated.

5. The deletion test

The deletion test is simple. Take a sentence out of your paragraph. Read the paragraph again. If the reader has lost no information, the sentence was repetition.

Use it on the invented paragraph above. Delete "Checking teaching against Scripture is a good habit." The paragraph loses nothing. The sentence was repetition. Delete "They are called 'more noble' for doing it." Now the reader loses the way the narrator judges the Bereans, which is part of the evidence. That sentence stays.

The test does not tell you what to write. It tells you which sentences are not working. Short papers have little room, and a sentence that adds nothing takes the place of one that could.

6. Mapping an argument

A map is a way to see an argument at a glance. Write the claim at the top. Under it, write each reason on its own line. Under each reason, write the evidence. Then add the objection beside the claim and write the response beside it.

The diagram below shows the map for the invented paragraph, with the gaps marked. A gap is a place where the writer moves from one step to the next without showing why the step is allowed. Maps are useful because gaps are hard to see in smooth prose and easy to see on a page of boxes.

7. Scaling the claim to the evidence

When you find a gap, you have two choices. You can add the missing step, with more evidence. Or you can make the claim smaller.

Here the writer has one verse. One verse about a group of people in one town can support a modest claim. It cannot easily support a large one. A revised claim might read: (an invented example)

Acts 17:11 commends the habit of checking teaching against the Scriptures. I argue that a congregation does well to make room for this habit, for example by giving members the passage ahead of time and an opportunity to ask questions.

This is smaller than the first claim. It says "does well", not "should". It names a way to do it. It does not say the text commands a meeting format. A reader may ask for more, but the writer has not claimed more than the evidence carries.

Scaling down is not weakness. A claim of the right size is firm where the evidence is firm. Week 6 returns to this under the title "Claims the Right Size".


Diagram 1. The four parts, and the gaps in the invented example

An argument map: the invented Bereans paragraph Claim at the top, reasons below, evidence below them, objection beside CLAIM A congregation should make time for members to check teaching. REASON 1 The Bereans checked Paul and were praised for it. REASON 2 (not a reason) Checking is a good habit. This repeats the claim. EVIDENCE Acts 17:11: they examined the Scriptures daily. GAP Daily personal study is not a time set aside in meetings. OBJECTION Paul was an apostle, so the Bereans are a special case. The reply ("the text praises testing") misses this point. TWO WAYS TO FIX A GAP Add the missing step with more evidence, or make the claim smaller.

In short

  • An argument gives a reader a claim and the reasons for it, so that the reader can weigh them. It is not a quarrel.
  • The four parts are the claim, the reasons, the evidence and the objection.
  • A sentence that only repeats the claim in other words is not a reason.
  • If deleting a sentence loses no information, the sentence is repetition.
  • An argument map shows gaps between a reason and its evidence; fix a gap with more evidence or a smaller claim.
Front Back
The four parts Claim, reasons, evidence, objection.
A restated claim A "reason" that a person who rejects the claim must also reject, only because they reject the claim.
The deletion test Remove a sentence. If the reader has lost nothing, it was repetition.
Two ways to fix a gap Add the missing step with evidence, or make the claim smaller.

One sentence to remember An argument is a set of reasons placed where a reader can check them, offered to answer, not to win.

This week's action Take one paragraph of your own and mark the claim, the reasons and the evidence. Then apply the deletion test.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Take one paragraph you have written. What is the claim? Write it in a single sentence that someone could doubt.
  • Find a sentence that begins "because". Is it a reason, or the claim said again? How do you know?
  • Apply the deletion test to one paragraph of your own. Which sentences could go without loss?
  • Where is a gap in the invented Bereans paragraph that this lecture did not mention? How would you close it?
  • Peter says to give a reason "with humility and fear". How does that change the way you would answer an objection to your own claim?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.