Lecture 1-1: A Map Is Not the Ground
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: A Map Is Not the Ground
- Lecture 1-2: Scripture and Psychology: The Positions
- Lecture 1-3: Questions to Ask of Any Theory
- Lecture 1-4: Why This Matters for Those Who Care
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Own Map
- Lecture 2-1: The Psychodynamic Tradition
- Lecture 2-2: Attachment
- Lecture 2-3: Images of God and Early Relationships
- Lecture 2-4: Hidden Motives and the Heart
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Reading One Scene Two Ways
- Lecture 3-1: Behaviour and Learning
- Lecture 3-2: Cognitive Theories
- Lecture 3-3: Renewing the Mind: Cognitive Approaches and Scripture
- Lecture 3-4: What Habit and Thought Cannot Reach
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Same Event, Two Readings
- Lecture 4-1: The Person-Centred Approach
- Lecture 4-2: Meaning and Existence
- Lecture 4-3: Story and Solutions
- Lecture 4-4: Three Gifts, Three Cautions
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: How Do I Listen?
- Lecture 5-1: Family Systems
- Lecture 5-2: Culture, Society and Context
- Lecture 5-3: The Church as a System
- Lecture 5-4: Seeing Wider
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Drawing a Web
Imagine two travellers who need to cross the same country. One has a map. The other has walked the roads for thirty years and has no map at all. Which one do you trust? On the first morning, you might choose the map. After a flood has washed out a bridge, you might choose the walker.
A map is a drawing made by someone who looked at the land and decided what to put on paper. It leaves things out on purpose. A good map is very useful, because nobody can carry the whole country in their head. But a map is not the ground. If the map says there is a bridge and the river has taken it, the river wins.
This course treats the theories of counselling and human development in the same way. A theory is a map of the person, not the person. It shows where people tend to lose their way. It cannot replace the ground, which is the actual human being in front of you, with a name, a history, a body, a family and a relationship with God that no drawing can hold.
This first lecture says what a theory is, what it can do and what it cannot do. It gives you four questions that every theory answers, so that you can read any theory later in the course. It also says, clearly, that you must not use a theory to diagnose yourself or anyone else.
What these 18 minutes give you
- Explain in your own words what a theory is and what it does for a person who cares for others.
- Name the four parts that every counselling theory contains.
- Give an example of a "home theory" that you or a person you know carries without noticing it.
- Explain why no single theory explains every person.
- Explain why a student of theory must not diagnose anyone.
Counsel in the heart of man is like deep water; but a man of understanding will draw it out." — Proverbs 20:5
World English Bible
The proverb does not say the water can be seen from the surface. The heart of a person is deep. Understanding is a patient way of drawing something up, not a way of looking down and naming what is there. Keep that picture in mind through the whole course.
1. What a theory is
In everyday speech, "theory" can mean a guess: "That is only a theory." In this course the word means something more careful. A theory is an organised set of ideas that tries to explain why people think, feel and act as they do. It is built by gathering what many observers have seen, looking for patterns, and offering an explanation that can be discussed, tested and argued about.
A theory does three useful things.
First, it gathers what is seen. A pastor, a nurse or a teacher may meet hundreds of people in a lifetime. Without some pattern, each person is a surprise. A theory says, "Many people who lose a job in this way go through something like this." It saves the next carer from starting from nothing.
Second, it gives a language. Before there was a word for "anxiety" or "attachment" or "grief," people felt these things and had trouble speaking about them. A shared word lets a person say, "This is what is happening to me," and lets a carer say, "I hear you."
Third, it suggests where to look. A theory is like a lamp turned in one direction. It lights some things and leaves others in the dark. A theory about early family life tells you to look at childhood. A theory about thinking tells you to look at what a person says to themselves. Neither lamp shows the whole room.
2. What a theory cannot do
A map has limits. So does a theory.
A theory cannot replace listening. It is made of general statements, and a person is particular. When a theory says "people often feel X in situation Y," it describes a tendency. It cannot tell you what this woman feels, or this boy, or this old man who has just buried his brother.
A theory cannot decide what is true about God or about human worth. A theory may be useful and still be wrong about the largest questions. Every theory carries beliefs about what a person is, and these beliefs often go unspoken. The next lectures will teach you to find them.
A theory cannot prove itself. Some theories rest on careful research that others have repeated. Some rest on long experience in a clinic. Some rest mostly on the brilliant ideas of one thinker. These are not the same kind of support, and lecture 1-3 will show you how to tell them apart.
3. The four parts of any theory
Every counselling theory, however different it looks, answers four questions. If you learn to ask them, you can read any theory in this course, and any theory you meet later.
1. Its picture of the person. What is a human being, at bottom? A creature driven by hidden wishes? A learner shaped by rewards? A being who grows towards health when given the right conditions? A member of a family? A seeker of meaning? Every theory has an answer, spoken or unspoken.
2. Its account of why trouble comes. Why do people suffer, struggle or lose their way? Some theories point to early relationships. Some point to learned habits, some to false beliefs, some to a lack of acceptance, some to the pressures of the family or the society around a person.
3. Its account of what changes people. What helps a person change or heal? Is it understanding the past? Practising new habits? Being listened to? Finding meaning? Changing the pattern of a family? Different theories give different answers, and these answers shape everything a carer does.
4. The role of the carer. What is the helper for? Is the helper an interpreter, a teacher, a companion, a coach, a witness? Some theories ask the helper to say a great deal. Others ask the helper to say very little.
The four parts fit together. If a theory says the person is shaped by learning, it will say trouble comes from learned habits that no longer serve, change comes through new learning, and the helper is a kind of guide or teacher. If a theory says the person grows when accepted, trouble comes from a lack of acceptance, change comes through a warm relationship, and the helper is a companion. When you meet a theory, ask the four questions in order. You will often find that it has a clear answer to each.
4. Everyone carries a home theory
You do not have to study psychology to hold a theory. Everyone has one. We may call it a home theory: a set of ideas about why people struggle and what helps, picked up from family, church, culture and experience, and never written down.
Here is an invented example.
(An invented example) Marta helps in a parish welcome group. When a newcomer seems withdrawn, she thinks, "This person is shy, and shy people need to be drawn out." She invites them to tea, asks gentle questions and introduces them to others. Her home theory has a picture of the person (some people are naturally shy), an account of trouble (isolation), an account of change (being drawn out) and a role for the carer (the one who draws out). It works for many newcomers. It does not work for a man who is not shy at all but is grieving, and who wants to sit at the back and be left alone. Marta's kindness would be hard for him.
Marta's theory is not foolish. It is a real map that has often served her. But it is only a map. When she mistakes it for the ground, she stops seeing the man in front of her.
Other home theories are common. "People struggle because they lack faith." "People struggle because someone hurt them." "People struggle because they think too much." "People struggle because they need rest." Each of these has some truth. Each of them fails for some people. Learning the major theories does not remove your home theory. It lets you see it, name it, and hold it more loosely.
5. Why no single theory explains everyone
There are many theories because there are many kinds of trouble and many kinds of people. A theory that works well for one kind of difficulty may work poorly for another. A theory built from the study of children may say little about the old. A theory drawn from one culture may misread another. Researchers and carers still disagree about how far any theory reaches.
It would be convenient if one theory covered everything. It does not, and you should be wary of anyone, however learned or kind, who says that it does. When a single theory is made to explain every person, the person is made to fit the theory. That is the reverse of care.
This does not mean that all theories are equally good, or that nothing can be known. Some are better supported than others for some purposes. It means that each theory is a partial map, and a wise carer keeps several in hand.
6. A warning: do not diagnose
This course teaches theory. It does not teach diagnosis. You must not use any theory in this course to diagnose yourself or anyone else.
A diagnosis is a professional judgement. It is made by a trained person, after careful assessment, using training and tools that this course does not give you. A theory in a lecture is much too general for that. When a student reads about a pattern and thinks, "That is my uncle," or "That is me," the student is using a map to name a country they have never visited.
This is not a small danger. A wrong label can frighten a person, can close the way to real help, and can stick to someone for years. A right label given by the wrong person can be as harmful as a wrong one, because it is given without care and without the training to follow it with help. And a label can become a way of not listening: "He is just like that" ends the conversation.
So in this course you will meet ideas, never checklists. You will be given examples and questions, not lists of signs. If you worry about your own mind or someone else's, the right step is to speak with a qualified professional, and, if anyone is in danger, to call your local emergency number.
7. Back to the map
Let us return to the two travellers. The wise traveller does not choose between the map and the walker. They take the map and ask the walker about the bridge. In the same way, the person who cares for others learns the maps and also listens to the person in front of them. The maps tell you where people often lose their way. The person tells you where this one is standing now.
Diagram 1. The four parts of any theory
In short
- A theory is an organised set of ideas that explains why people think, feel and act as they do. It is a map of the person, not the person.
- A theory gathers what is seen, gives a shared language and suggests where to look. It cannot replace listening or prove itself.
- Every theory answers four questions: its picture of the person, why trouble comes, what changes people, and the role of the carer.
- Everyone carries a home theory, picked up from family, church and culture. Naming it lets you hold it more loosely.
- No single theory explains everyone. Making one theory explain every person makes the person fit the theory.
- Do not use any theory to diagnose yourself or anyone else. Diagnosis belongs to trained professionals.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| What is a theory? | An organised set of ideas that explains why people think, feel and act as they do. A map of the person, not the person. |
| The four parts of a theory | Its picture of the person; why trouble comes; what changes people; the role of the carer. |
| A home theory | The unwritten ideas about why people struggle and what helps, picked up from family, church and culture. |
| The rule about diagnosis | Never use a theory to diagnose yourself or anyone else. That is a professional judgement. |
One sentence to remember A theory is a map of the person, not the person, and a good carer learns the maps and still listens to the one who is standing there.
This week's action Write down one saying you often use about why people struggle, and underline the part of it that is a picture of the person.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- In your own words, what is the difference between a map and the ground it shows? Where in your own life have you mistaken one for the other?
- Think of a saying about why people struggle that you heard growing up. Does it answer the four questions? What does it assume about the person?
- Marta's theory helped many newcomers and failed one. What could she have done differently, without giving up her kindness?
- Why does a label, even a correct one, sometimes stop a carer from listening?
- The proverb says that counsel in the heart is like deep water. What does it suggest about how a carer should use a theory?