FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

PT719E Maps of the Person: Counselling Theories and Human Development

Lecture 4-3: Story and Solutions

Contents 31
PT719E Maps of the Person: Counselling Theories and Human Development
Chapter 0 · Introduction: A Map Is Not the Person
  1. Introduction: A Map Is Not the Person
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Reading the Theories
  1. Lecture 1-1: A Map Is Not the Ground
  2. Lecture 1-2: Scripture and Psychology: The Positions
  3. Lecture 1-3: Questions to Ask of Any Theory
  4. Lecture 1-4: Why This Matters for Those Who Care
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Own Map
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Depths and Roots
  1. Lecture 2-1: The Psychodynamic Tradition
  2. Lecture 2-2: Attachment
  3. Lecture 2-3: Images of God and Early Relationships
  4. Lecture 2-4: Hidden Motives and the Heart
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Reading One Scene Two Ways
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Thinking, Behaving, Learning
  1. Lecture 3-1: Behaviour and Learning
  2. Lecture 3-2: Cognitive Theories
  3. Lecture 3-3: Renewing the Mind: Cognitive Approaches and Scripture
  4. Lecture 3-4: What Habit and Thought Cannot Reach
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Same Event, Two Readings
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Acceptance and Meaning
  1. Lecture 4-1: The Person-Centred Approach
  2. Lecture 4-2: Meaning and Existence
  3. Lecture 4-3: Story and Solutions
  4. Lecture 4-4: Three Gifts, Three Cautions
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: How Do I Listen?
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Families, Systems and Context
  1. Lecture 5-1: Family Systems
  2. Lecture 5-2: Culture, Society and Context
  3. Lecture 5-3: The Church as a System
  4. Lecture 5-4: Seeing Wider
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Drawing a Web
Chapter 6 · Week 6: A Life, Walked
  1. Lecture 6-1: Erikson and the Eight Stages
  2. Lecture 6-2: Stages of Faith
  3. Lecture 6-3: The Adult Years and Old Age
  4. Lecture 6-4: Putting the Maps Together
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab, Three Maps, One Scene

Jump to the key points ↓

24 min

Ask a person how they are, and most do not answer with a list. They answer with a story. "It started when my father died." "Ever since the move, nothing has been the same." "I have always been the one who gets it wrong." Stories are how people hold their lives together, and they are also how people sometimes become trapped.

This lecture looks at two approaches that grew up in the later twentieth century. The narrative approach takes seriously that people live by stories, and asks what happens when one story crowds out all the others. The solution-focused approach turns attention from what has gone wrong to what is already going right, and to small steps that can be taken. They are different in many ways. They share one habit: they listen for strengths in the way a person speaks about life.

The lecture follows the three steps used in this part of the course: what the theory says, what it explains and misses, and how it meets the Christian picture of the person. Keep the central claim in view: a theory is a map of the person, not the person. Do not use a theory to diagnose yourself or anyone else. Care given in a church is not professional treatment, and this lecture does not teach technique. If a person may harm themselves or someone else, or is in danger, the answer is not a theory: stay with the person, call your local emergency number, and connect them to a qualified professional or a crisis line.

What these 24 minutes give you

  • Explain in plain words the idea that people live by stories and that one story can crowd out others.
  • Describe what "the person is not the problem" means in the narrative approach.
  • Describe the solution-focused habit of noticing exceptions and small steps.
  • Say what these approaches give and what critics say they miss, including the question of truth.
  • Set the two approaches beside Scripture as story, lament and the larger story of God's people.

Will the Lord reject us forever? Will he be favorable no more?" — Psalms 77:7

World English Bible

Has his loving kindness vanished forever? Does his promise fail for generations?" — Psalms 77:8

WEB

Has God forgotten to be gracious? Has he, in anger, withheld his compassion?” *Selah.*" — Psalms 77:9

WEB

I will remember Yah’s deeds; for I will remember your wonders of old." — Psalms 77:11

WEB

You number my wanderings. You put my tears into your bottle. Aren’t they in your book?" — Psalms 56:8

WEB

Psalm 77 is a person telling a story of distress and then changing the story by remembering. Psalm 56:8 imagines a God who keeps a record of tears. Both treat a life as something that is told, and heard.

1. What the narrative approach says

The narrative approach is associated above all with Michael White and David Epston. Its first idea is simple: people make sense of their lives by telling stories. We do not just have experiences; we arrange them. We pick out some events, leave others in the dark, and join them into a plot. "I am a failure" is a plot. So is "I am the one who holds everything together." A story of this kind decides what we notice, what we expect and what we think is possible.

The second idea is that some stories grow too large. A single account — often one told about a person by others, or by a culture — can come to describe the whole of a life, and everything that does not fit it is forgotten. Supporters of the approach call this the dominant story. A person who lives under a story of failure may truly have failed at some things, and yet the story hides the many times when the person did well, kept faith or helped someone.

The third idea has become one of the best-known sayings of the approach: "the person is not the problem; the problem is the problem." The practice behind it is to speak of a trouble as something outside the person, with a name, which can be looked at. Instead of "I am an anxious person," one might say "anxiety has been visiting me and telling me that I will fail." This is a way of speaking, not a diagnosis. Its purpose is to give a person room to stand beside the difficulty and not inside it. The person is then free to notice moments when the problem did not win, and to build a fuller story from them.

Putting the four questions that every theory answers:

  • The person: a maker and a teller of meaning, who lives within the stories told by self, family and culture.
  • Why trouble comes: a problem-filled story takes over and shuts out other accounts of the person's life.
  • What changes people: finding and telling the neglected parts of the story, so that a richer one can take shape.
  • The role of the carer: a respectful listener who is curious about the person's own words and who does not impose a reading.

2. What the solution-focused approach says

The solution-focused approach is associated with Steve de Shazer and Insoo Kim Berg. Where many approaches ask why a problem exists, this one asks mainly: what do you want instead, and when is it already happening, even a little?

Two ideas are central at concept level.

First, exceptions. A problem is rarely present every moment. There are times when it is less strong or when the person copes in some way. The approach says these times are worth noticing, because they show what the person already knows how to do.

Second, small steps. Instead of trying to understand the whole history of a difficulty, the person is invited to imagine a better day and to ask what the first small sign of it would be. The next step is not large. It is the next thing within reach.

The approach does not deny that people suffer. It makes a choice about where to look. Its supporters say that many people are helped more by a clear small step than by a long review of what went wrong.

We will not teach any technique here. For this course it is enough to know that the approach exists, what it asks of the listener — attention to strengths and to what is already working — and what the Christian tradition may say about it.

3. An everyday scene

(an invented example) Samuel is thirty and attends a house church. He tells the group's leader, Ruth, "I am a person who always ruins things. I ruined my marriage, I ruined my job, and now I will ruin this." Ruth does not argue with him, and she does not tell him he is wonderful. She asks, "Is there a time in the last month when you did not ruin something?" He thinks. Then he says, "I helped set up chairs last Sunday and nobody got hurt." They both smile a little. Ruth says, "What did you do that day?" Samuel talks for several minutes about arriving early and checking each row. The story "I always ruin things" has not been refuted, but a different thread has been found. Ruth has not claimed that Samuel's marriage was not damaged or that his losses are small. She has only noticed that the story he told about himself is not the whole story.

4. What these approaches explain

They explain why some people cannot see a way forward even when others see many. A person may be living inside one story and cannot hear the others. They explain why a label can be heavy: once a person has been described as "the difficult one," others and he or she start to act as if it were true. And they explain why even a small change in the way a life is told can open a door.

They also share a respect for the person's own language. Both approaches ask the listener to be curious and not to pronounce. For people who have been spoken about by doctors, officials, family members or church leaders, being asked "How would you say it?" is a recovery of dignity.

Finally, the solution-focused habit is practical. A carer who is overwhelmed by a long list of troubles may be helped by asking what is already working and what is one small thing to do next.

5. What they miss

Critics have several concerns, and they deserve a fair hearing.

The first is the question of truth. If every account of a life is only one story among many, is any account wrong? Suppose someone says "I was hurt by a person who had power over me," and someone else tells another version. In some forms of the narrative idea, all versions are treated as equally constructed, and this seems to leave no place for saying that something really happened or that a wrong was truly done. Many people who work in this tradition insist that they do not mean this. They hold that stories are shaped by the teller and also answerable to what happened. But the language of "constructed" stories can be heard the other way, and a careful carer will keep the distinction in mind: a story may be re-told, but a wrong done to a person is still a wrong.

The second concern is that a focus on strengths can pass over real loss. A person who has been bereaved, abused or betrayed does not need to be shown an exception to sadness. Sometimes the right response is not a new story or a small step but a long silence and a plain acknowledgement. An approach that moves too fast to what is working can leave the person feeling unheard.

The third is that both approaches say little about sin and guilt. People do sometimes do harm. A story in which the problem is always outside the person can be helpful for someone crushed by shame; it can also, if misused, allow a person to avoid the question of responsibility. Reading the approach with care, a carer will ask where it fits and where it does not.

The fourth is the usual one for a map drawn in one place: both grew mainly in Western countries and in conversations between individuals. Other cultures tell and listen to stories in other ways, and may place more weight on the family or community's account of a person's life.

6. Where they meet the Christian picture of the person

Scripture is, to a very large extent, a story. It tells of creation, of a people, of a Messiah, of a church, and of a hope still to be completed. The Christian faith is not mainly a set of statements about the human condition; it is also an account of what God has done. Believers recite this story in their creeds, in the readings of the and in the retelling of testimonies. Catholic, Orthodox, Protestant and Pentecostal traditions each tell it in their own way, and each treats the telling as an act of worship, not only a means of information.

In that light, the narrative idea that a life is set inside a story has a natural home. A Christian is invited to read his or her own life within the larger story: a creature loved by God, bound up in the failures of the human family, redeemed, and called. A person under a story of "I am a failure" may need to hear another story, told by someone else, that includes them.

Scripture also contains lament, the honest telling of pain to God. Psalm 77 is a good example. The psalmist cries out; at first he cannot be comforted (Psalms 77:2). He asks questions that few of us say aloud in church: "Will the Lord reject us forever? Will he be favorable no more?" (Psalms 77:7), "Has his loving kindness vanished forever? Does his promise fail for generations?" (Psalms 77:8), "Has God forgotten to be gracious? Has he, in anger, withheld his compassion?" (Psalms 77:9). Then, halfway through, the psalm changes direction: "I will remember Yah’s deeds; for I will remember your wonders of old" (Psalms 77:11). The change is not an argument that defeats the pain. It is a movement of memory: the speaker takes the dark story and sets it inside the longer story of what God has done.

Psalm 56:8 adds another thought: "You number my wanderings. You put my tears into your bottle. Aren’t they in your book?" The picture is of a God who keeps account of a person's tears. A suffering person's story is not lost; it is held. For a carer, this means that listening to a story is not a waste of time and not only a technique: it echoes a God who listens.

The solution-focused habit of noticing what is already going well also has echoes in Scripture. The practice of giving thanks, of remembering the deeds of God, of counting blessings, can be seen as a way of attending to what is good in a life without denying the rest. A careful reader will note that Scripture does this beside lament and not in place of it.

This is a point where readers will not agree. Some Christians welcome the stress on story, because the Bible itself is largely narrative and because naming the larger story gives a person a place to stand. They find in the approach a respectful way to help people hear their lives differently, and they see its attention to dignity as close to the way Jesus spoke with people. Others warn that a view in which "truth is constructed" or "each person writes their own story" conflicts with the Christian conviction that there is a truth given by God and an order that does not depend on what people say. In their view, an approach that treats every account as equal may weaken the difference between what is real and what is told, and may place the individual's story above the story of God. Both groups can agree that people live by stories, and that the one that tells the truth about God and about the person is the one that matters most. What this course requires is that you can state both positions fairly, that you do not treat any story as a way to deny a real wrong, and that you do not use these approaches to dismiss someone's pain with "just tell it differently."

7. Care in a church, and a limit

Listening for a person's story is something a lay carer can do without becoming a therapist. But there are limits. If a story includes harm, abuse or danger, a carer follows the community's written policy and local law, calls the local emergency number if someone is in danger, and helps connect the person to a qualified professional. If a person speaks of ending their life, the answer is not a better story: stay with the person, call for help, and find a crisis line. In the United States the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline is available; other countries have their own lines, and you should find yours before you need it. Detailed teaching on boundaries and referral belongs to a later course in this group.

8. A map, not the person

The narrative and solution-focused maps are bright where they show how much of a life is told, and how much of the telling can change. They are dim where a wrong has been done, where a loss has no repair, or where a person needs the truth said plainly. A theory is a map of the person, not the person. Use these maps to listen better, and ask of every story: is it true, and is it the whole of the truth?


Diagram 1. A life in a larger story

Story and Solutions Two ways of listening, and one larger story Narrative approach People live by stories. One story can crowd out the rest. The person is not the problem; the problem is the problem. asks: what story is being lived? Solution-focused approach Problems are not always present. Notice the exceptions. Take the next small step. asks: what is already working? In Scripture: a life told inside a larger story Lament says the pain aloud (Psalms 77:7-9). Memory sets it inside what God has done (77:11). God keeps the tears (Psalms 56:8). The story is held, not lost. Caution: a story may be retold, but a wrong done to a person is still a wrong. Strengths-talk must not hurry past real loss. A theory is a map of the person, not the person.

Diagram 2. Three questions about any story a person tells

Question Why it matters
Is there part of the story that is not being told? A single story may be hiding others.
Is it true, and is it the whole truth? A story answers to what happened; a wrong done is still a wrong.
Where is God in this story, and where is the church? Scripture sets a life inside a larger story and keeps room for lament.

In short

  • The narrative approach says people live by stories, and that one story can crowd out the others.
  • Its saying: the person is not the problem; the problem is the problem.
  • The solution-focused approach notices exceptions and small steps, and asks what is already working.
  • Critics ask about truth, about loss that is hurried past, and about sin and responsibility.
  • Scripture is a story that includes lament; Psalm 77 moves from pain to remembering, and Psalm 56:8 shows a God who keeps tears.
  • A story may be retold, but a wrong done to a person is still a wrong.
Front Back
Dominant story One account that comes to describe a whole life and hides other parts of it.
Solution-focused habit Notice exceptions and take small steps, rather than examine the whole history of a problem.
Main criticism The language of "constructed" stories can blur truth; strengths-talk can hurry past real loss.
Psalm 77 Lament said aloud, then the speaker remembers what God has done.

One sentence to remember A life is told, and heard, inside a larger story, and a story can be retold without denying what really happened.

This week's action When someone tells you a hard story this week, listen for one thing they have not said yet, and ask a gentle question about it. Do not argue with what they have said.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Think of a story people tell about a well-known figure from history or from fiction. How does that one story hide other parts of the figure's life?
  • What does it mean to say "the person is not the problem; the problem is the problem"? When could this help, and when could it be misused?
  • Why might the solution-focused habit of noticing exceptions be a bad fit when someone has just suffered a loss?
  • In Psalm 77, what changes between verses 9 and 11? What does the psalmist do with the dark story?
  • State the two Christian responses to the claim that truth is constructed, each as its holder would.

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.