Lecture 5-1: Family Systems
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: A Map Is Not the Ground
- Lecture 1-2: Scripture and Psychology: The Positions
- Lecture 1-3: Questions to Ask of Any Theory
- Lecture 1-4: Why This Matters for Those Who Care
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Own Map
- Lecture 2-1: The Psychodynamic Tradition
- Lecture 2-2: Attachment
- Lecture 2-3: Images of God and Early Relationships
- Lecture 2-4: Hidden Motives and the Heart
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Reading One Scene Two Ways
- Lecture 3-1: Behaviour and Learning
- Lecture 3-2: Cognitive Theories
- Lecture 3-3: Renewing the Mind: Cognitive Approaches and Scripture
- Lecture 3-4: What Habit and Thought Cannot Reach
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Same Event, Two Readings
- Lecture 4-1: The Person-Centred Approach
- Lecture 4-2: Meaning and Existence
- Lecture 4-3: Story and Solutions
- Lecture 4-4: Three Gifts, Three Cautions
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: How Do I Listen?
- Lecture 5-1: Family Systems
- Lecture 5-2: Culture, Society and Context
- Lecture 5-3: The Church as a System
- Lecture 5-4: Seeing Wider
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Drawing a Web
Imagine a mobile hanging over a baby's bed: a thin frame, with small shapes hanging from it on threads. Touch one shape and all of them move. Pull one shape down and the others rise. If you want to understand why one shape swings so wildly, you will not learn much by holding it in your hand and looking at it. You have to look at the whole mobile.
That picture is the heart of family systems theory — the idea that a family is not a pile of separate individuals but a connected whole, in which a change in one person changes everyone. In the first four weeks we looked mostly inside the person: hidden motives, early bonds, thoughts, the need for acceptance and meaning. This week we widen the view. We ask what happens when the person is seen among other people.
This lecture teaches two well-known thinkers from this tradition, Murray Bowen and Salvador Minuchin, at the level of ideas only. It is not family therapy and it does not prepare you to do it. A later course in this group will take up marriage and family care. Here we only ask what this map shows, what it hides, and how it meets the Christian picture of the person.
What these 27 minutes give you
- Explain in plain words what it means to say that a family is a system.
- Describe Bowen's ideas of differentiation and triangles, and Minuchin's idea of boundaries, at the level of concepts.
- State one strength of the family systems map and one serious criticism of it, including the risk to the responsibility of a person who has done harm.
- State the disagreement among Christian readers about systems language and what this course requires.
Yahweh God said, “It is not good for the man to be alone. I will make him a helper comparable to him.”" — Genesis 2:18
World English Bible
You fathers, don’t provoke your children to wrath, but nurture them in the discipline and instruction of the Lord." — Ephesians 6:4
WEB
The first verse says that human beings are made for company. The second speaks to a parent about how the way he acts affects the children in his house. Neither verse is a theory of families. Both show that Scripture never thinks of a person as a lone figure standing outside every relationship.
1. From one person to a web
Most of us, when someone is in trouble, ask first: "What is wrong with this person?" or "What happened to this person?" These are good questions. But they have a quiet assumption inside them: that the answer lies inside the person, or in their past.
Family systems thinkers ask an additional question: "What is going on between these people, now?" A system, in this sense, is a group of parts that affect each other so that the group behaves as a whole. A family is the first and strongest example most of us know. The parts are people, and the threads between them are feelings, habits, rules (spoken and unspoken), loyalties and fears.
Three things follow from this view.
First, a pattern is held by several people. A family that argues every evening at the same time is not simply made of "an angry person". Each person has a part in the dance, even if the parts are very unequal.
Second, a change in one person tends to bring a change in the others — and often a pull back to the old way. The family may welcome the change, or it may quietly resist it.
Third, the same person may act differently in different webs. A man who is calm and generous at his work may be sharp and silent at home. If you only saw one of the two, you would describe him wrongly.
(an invented example) A woman telephones her parish priest. Her sixteen-year-old son has stopped coming to church. She is anxious and wants the priest to talk to him. When the priest asks a few gentle questions, a larger picture appears. Her husband says the boy should be left alone. The boy's grandmother lives with the family and tells him, in private, that his mother is "suffering because of him". The boy says little to anyone. A carer who looked only at the boy would see a young person drifting from the church. A carer who looked at the web would see that many people are pulling on the same threads. Notice also what the carer must not do: decide from one telephone call what is "really" going on. A web seen from one corner is still only a corner.
2. Bowen: differentiation and triangles
Murray Bowen was a psychiatrist who studied families and built a theory around a small number of ideas. Two are useful for us.
Differentiation of self. Differentiation means the ability to stay connected to the people you love while still keeping your own thoughts, feelings and values. Think of two opposite failures. In one, a person is so tied to the family's mood that they cannot think for themselves: when the family is anxious, they are anxious; when the family disagrees with them, they give up what they believe. In the other, a person protects themselves by cutting off, going silent, moving far away or refusing to speak, so that they are free but alone. Bowen's idea is that a more differentiated person can be close without being swallowed and can be separate without being cold. It is a matter of degree, not a label, and it moves up and down through a life.
Triangles. Bowen noticed that when two people have tension between them, they often draw in a third. The third person may be a child, a friend, a grandparent, a pastor, or even a cause or a worry. The triangle can calm the tension for a while, because the two no longer have to face each other directly. But the tension is not solved; it has only been moved. In the example above, the boy is drawn into a triangle with his father and mother, and the grandmother adds another line.
Bowen also spoke of anxiety passing from person to person in a family, like a mood in a room. A person who is more settled can help the others settle. A person who is very anxious can raise the anxiety of everyone around. He thought this was one of the main forces in a family. Notice that the word is used here in an everyday sense — a tension that people carry — not as the name of a condition.
3. Minuchin: boundaries and subsystems
Salvador Minuchin built a different but related map, sometimes called structural family theory, because it looks at the structure of a family: who belongs to which group, and what lines separate them.
A family has subsystems — smaller groups inside it. The adults who lead the household are one. The brothers and sisters are another. A parent and one child may be a third. Between these groups run boundaries, which are the invisible lines that say who may take part in which decisions and who may enter which conversation.
Minuchin described three kinds of boundary, in simple terms:
- A clear boundary lets people stay connected but keeps the roles clear. The parents decide about the family budget; the children are free to speak and are heard, but are not asked to carry the parents' worries.
- A rigid boundary is a wall. People in the family live side by side but do not really reach one another. Minuchin used the word disengaged for a family where the walls are so high that nobody notices when someone is struggling.
- A diffuse boundary is almost no line at all. Everyone is in everyone's business. Minuchin's word was enmeshed: so tangled that a child cannot be a child because they are being a friend, a judge, or a messenger for the adults.
Again, these are descriptions of patterns between people, not labels to be stuck on a family from outside. A single household can have walls in one place and no line in another, and the pattern can change from one season to the next.
4. A signal of the system
One of the most discussed ideas in this tradition is that a struggling person may be a signal of the whole system. Some family systems writers noticed that a family would often name one member as "the problem" — the rebellious teenager, the child who will not eat, the husband who drinks — while the strain was shared by many. They suggested that sometimes the trouble in one person carries a message about the group, or even keeps a tense group together because everyone's worry is aimed at the same place.
This idea has real value for a carer. It reminds you not to accept the first story you are told. If a mother says "the whole problem is my son", you may listen to her fully and still keep in mind that a family is bigger than the person named.
But the idea must be used with care. It does not say that families cause every trouble. It does not say that the person who is struggling is merely a puppet. And it does not give you the right to tell a family what its "real" problem is. A person you are caring for may be suffering from many causes at once — an illness, a loss, a hard working life, a wound that no family caused. When something is beyond you, you connect the person to a qualified professional. Systems language is not a licence to diagnose a family, and it is not a way to diagnose the person either.
5. What this map explains
Family systems theory is strong in several places.
- It explains why good advice to one person often fails. If a young man is told to be more open with his father, but the whole family is arranged so that nobody speaks directly, he may find it nearly impossible. The advice did not account for the web.
- It explains why a change in one person can upset the others, even when the change looks good. A person who stops rescuing, who sets a gentle limit or who begins to speak plainly may meet resistance from people who liked the old arrangement.
- It explains why a problem seems to "move" when only one person is addressed. The worry that was settled on the son moves to the daughter.
- It gives a carer humility. You see one corner. There are other people, with other stories, who are not in the room.
- It looks at the whole life, including the generations. Bowen was interested in how patterns, such as who speaks and who stays quiet, travel through several generations. Many people find that this widens their sympathy for their parents, and for themselves.
6. What this map misses
It is also weak in places, and the criticisms are serious.
It can blur responsibility. This is the most important criticism for a church. If every pattern is "held by the whole system", it can begin to sound as though everyone shares the blame equally for what happens. That is false in the case of harm. A person who beats, abuses, controls, or threatens another person is responsible for what he or she does, and the person who suffers it is not "part of the dance" in any sense that shares the blame. A systems view that forgets this does a second injury to the one who was hurt. A systems view must never dilute the responsibility of someone who has done harm. Where there is danger or abuse, the first answer is safety and protection, not an effort to "balance the system".
It can sound like blaming the family. Many people already carry guilt about their parents or children. A careless use of systems language ("your mother is enmeshed") can add a new weight to an old one.
It was built from particular families. The ideas grew mostly from clinical work with families in the West, where an idea of the independent adult, who becomes separate from the family, is strong. In many cultures, a person who stays closely involved with parents and relatives for life is not "failing to differentiate"; they are living a good life by their community's standards. We will come back to this in the next lecture. Treat words like "enmeshed" as questions, not verdicts.
It is hard to test. A claim like "this child's behaviour keeps the parents together" can be told as a convincing story, but it is hard to show that it is true. The researchers who work in this field do not all agree on how well the ideas stand up to evidence.
7. Where it meets the Christian picture
Here is where the map and Scripture overlap. The Bible does not describe a person as a lone unit. The verse from Genesis says that it is not good for the man to be alone. The Old Testament speaks again and again of households, clans and peoples. In the New Testament, the church is called a body, whose members suffer together and rejoice together (1 Corinthians 12:26). Ephesians 6:4 speaks of how a father's way of acting may drive a child to anger. Parents and children are bound in a pattern of conduct, and the apostle holds the father responsible for his part of it.
There is also a clear place where the Christian picture says something the systems map does not. Scripture never reduces a person to their position in a web. Each person stands before God, is asked to answer for what they have done, and is also loved and forgiven by God as a person. A child is not only "the family's symptom". An abuser is not only "a product of the family". Each person has a face, a conscience and a name. The Christian traditions have different ways of speaking of this — sin and grace, confession and absolution, repentance and amendment, the sacraments — but they agree that persons are accountable and that persons are redeemed one by one as well as together.
The picture also reaches a further point, which the family systems map cannot supply. In the Christian view, the family is not the final web. It sits inside the larger family of God, in which a believer may find new "mothers", "fathers", brothers and sisters. For someone who has been hurt in the family they were born into, this can be a source of hope. It also places a heavy duty on the church, which must then actually behave as a safe family — a subject for lecture 5-3.
8. A point on which readers will not agree
This is a point where readers will not agree. Some Christian readers welcome systems thinking. They say that Scripture is full of the idea that people belong to one another, that one member's suffering is the body's suffering, and that the sins of a father can run through a household. For them, the systems language is a modern way of seeing something the Bible already shows, and it helps carers avoid blaming one person when the strain is shared.
Other Christian readers are cautious. They say that the language of "anxiety", "triangles" and "differentiation" gives the roles of husband, wife, parent, child and church member a technical shape that Scripture does not give them, and that it can quietly replace plain biblical words such as truth-telling, forgiveness, repentance and authority. They also warn that a systems view can blur the line between the one who has authority and the one who is under it, and between the one who has done wrong and the one who has been wronged.
This course requires less than either side. It requires that you can state both positions fairly, that you use any systems idea as a question to ask rather than a conclusion to announce, and that you never let it weaken the responsibility of someone who has done harm. It does not require you to adopt the language, or to reject it.
9. One map among others
Family systems thinking is one map of the person. It is useful where relationships are the main thing. It is less useful where a person is wrestling with a loss, a belief, an illness or a that does not fit neatly into a family pattern. A carer who sees families everywhere has simply chosen a new favourite theory to explain everyone with — the mistake we met in week 1.
So take the picture of the mobile as a question, not a verdict: "Who else is hanging on these threads?" Then ask the larger question that a map cannot answer: "Who is this person, standing before God and before me?" A theory is a map, not the person.
A last reminder. You may not use family systems theory — or any theory in this course — to diagnose yourself, anyone in your family, or anyone in your church. Care given in a church is not treatment. When something is beyond you, you connect the person to a qualified professional. And if a person may harm themselves or someone else, or is in danger, the answer is not a theory: stay with the person, call your local emergency number, and connect them to a qualified professional. Where marriage and family care are concerned, a later course in this group will give you more.
Diagram 1. A triangle and three kinds of boundary
Diagram 2. Questions the systems map invites
| Question | What it is for |
|---|---|
| Who else is affected when this person struggles? | Widening the view beyond one corner |
| Who speaks to whom directly, and who carries messages? | Noticing triangles |
| Who decides what, and who carries what they should not? | Noticing boundaries |
| What has changed in this household lately? | Noticing strain that has a recent cause |
| Is anyone here afraid of someone else? | Remembering that safety comes before any map |
In short
- A family is a system: a connected whole in which a change in one person moves all the others, like the shapes of a hanging mobile.
- Bowen's differentiation means staying close to others while keeping your own thoughts and values; his triangles are the habit of drawing in a third person when two are tense.
- Minuchin's boundaries (rigid, clear, diffuse) describe who may enter which decisions and conversations in a family.
- A struggling person may be a signal of a wider strain, but this idea must not be used to blame a family or to diagnose it.
- A systems view must never dilute the responsibility of someone who has done harm; where there is danger or abuse, safety comes first.
- A theory is a map, not the person: ask "who else hangs on these threads?" and then "who stands before me?"
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Family system | A family seen as a connected whole, where a change in one person changes the others. |
| Triangle | Two people in tension draw in a third; the tension moves but is not solved. |
| Boundary | The invisible line that says who takes part in which decisions; clear, rigid or diffuse. |
| Main caution | Systems language must never weaken the responsibility of someone who has done harm. |
One sentence to remember A struggling person hangs in a web of other people, and the web must be seen without ever losing the person or excusing the harm.
This week's action Think of a public story (a novel or a film) and write down who hangs on the threads around the main character, without judging any of them.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Why is it not enough to ask only "What is wrong with this person?" Give one situation from a public story where the question "What is going on between these people?" adds something.
- In your own words, what is a triangle? Why might it calm a conflict for a while without solving it?
- Minuchin speaks of boundaries that are rigid, clear or diffuse. Why is it better to treat these as questions about a pattern than as labels for a family?
- Why does the lecture say that a systems view must never dilute the responsibility of someone who has done harm? What might go wrong if it did?
- Which of the two Christian positions on systems language seems stronger to you? What would you need to hear from the other side to take it seriously?