Lecture 6-4: Putting the Maps Together
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: A Map Is Not the Ground
- Lecture 1-2: Scripture and Psychology: The Positions
- Lecture 1-3: Questions to Ask of Any Theory
- Lecture 1-4: Why This Matters for Those Who Care
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Own Map
- Lecture 2-1: The Psychodynamic Tradition
- Lecture 2-2: Attachment
- Lecture 2-3: Images of God and Early Relationships
- Lecture 2-4: Hidden Motives and the Heart
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Reading One Scene Two Ways
- Lecture 3-1: Behaviour and Learning
- Lecture 3-2: Cognitive Theories
- Lecture 3-3: Renewing the Mind: Cognitive Approaches and Scripture
- Lecture 3-4: What Habit and Thought Cannot Reach
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Same Event, Two Readings
- Lecture 4-1: The Person-Centred Approach
- Lecture 4-2: Meaning and Existence
- Lecture 4-3: Story and Solutions
- Lecture 4-4: Three Gifts, Three Cautions
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: How Do I Listen?
- Lecture 5-1: Family Systems
- Lecture 5-2: Culture, Society and Context
- Lecture 5-3: The Church as a System
- Lecture 5-4: Seeing Wider
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Drawing a Web
For five weeks you have been given maps. One looked at hidden motives and early bonds, one at learning and thinking, one at acceptance, meaning and story, one at families, culture and the church as a body, and this week at the seasons of a life. Each was set beside what Scripture and the Christian traditions say of the human person. Each was shown with what it explains and what it misses.
This lecture does one thing: it lays several maps over one scene and asks what each one sees and what each one hides. The point is not to find the single right map. It is to feel, in practice, what the central claim of the course means: a theory is a map of the person, not the person. A map shows where people tend to lose their way, but it cannot replace the ground.
The lecture also faces two honest questions that every carer meets. What is mine to do? And when is something beyond me, so that I connect the person with someone qualified? These are answered briefly here. The full teaching on ethics, boundaries, confidentiality and referral belongs to a later course in this group, Counselling Ethics, Boundaries and Referral.
What these 21 minutes give you
- Read one scene with at least three different maps and say what each helps you see.
- Say what each of those maps hides, and what no map shows.
- Explain why using several maps is safer than trusting one.
- State the difference between care given in a church and professional treatment, and say when to connect a person with a professional.
- Explain why safety comes before theory.
Where there is no wise guidance, the nation falls, but in the multitude of counselors there is victory." — Proverbs 11:14
World English Bible
Two are better than one, because they have a good reward for their labor. For if they fall, the one will lift up his fellow; but woe to him who is alone when he falls, and doesn’t have another to lift him up." — Ecclesiastes 4:9-10
WEB
These two passages are about not standing alone. They apply to the person you care for, who should not be alone with a burden. They also apply to you. A carer who trusts a single map, or who carries a heavy matter without anyone to consult, is in danger. Many counsellors and a friend who lifts: that is the shape of this lecture.
1. One scene, read slowly
The scene below is invented. No such person exists. It is written so that several of the maps in this course can be laid over it. Read it twice.
(an invented example) Daniel is fifty-seven. He is a in a mid-sized parish and has been a steady, reliable presence there for many years. In the past year several things have changed at once. His father died eight months ago. His mother, who is now frail, has moved into the home he shares with his wife. The company where he works has been restructured, and his role is smaller than it was. His adult daughter, who lives a few hours away, calls less often than she used to. At the men's group he has been short-tempered twice and has missed the last two meetings. When the group leader asks, he says, "I'm fine. Just tired." Then, on his way out, he adds, almost to himself, "My father never once said he was proud of me. Strange that I only notice it now."
There is no diagnosis here and none should be made. We do not know what Daniel feels, what he needs or what is wrong. The scene is a place to practise looking, not a case to solve.
2. What six maps see, and what each hides
The map of early bonds (lecture 2-2). It sees that a father has died, that a mother is now dependent, that a daughter is at a distance. The bonds on which Daniel built his life are all changing. It asks what it means for a person to lose a figure who was also a source of approval. It hides Daniel's present strengths and choices. It can also lead a carer to read present grief as though it were only a story from the past, and it must never be used to label him with a "style".
The map of hidden motives (lecture 2-1). It sees that irritation may sometimes cover a sorrow, or a longing for approval, that has not yet been put into words. His remark about his father is exactly the kind of thing this map notices. It hides that this is only a guess. A carer who says "you are really angry at your father" has gone beyond what she knows, and may be wrong. The map suggests where to listen; it does not tell you what you will hear.
The map of thinking (lecture 3-2). It sees that Daniel is probably telling himself stories: "I should have done more for my father", "I am no use at work now", "my daughter has moved on". Such interpretations shape feeling. It hides that some of what weighs on him is real: a death, a smaller job, a distance from his child. These are not cured by thinking differently. A carer who says "just look at it another way" has failed to hear him.
The map of acceptance (lecture 4-1). It sees that Daniel may need, first of all, an unhurried place to say what he has not been able to say elsewhere, with someone who does not judge or hurry to fix. It hides what it does not itself speak of: duty, sin and the practical help he may need. Acceptance is not agreement, and listening is not all that care requires.
The map of the family system (lecture 5-1). It sees a web: his mother has moved in, his wife stands between mother and husband, his daughter pulls away, and Daniel stands at the centre, perhaps holding the system together without saying so. Daniel's irritation might be a signal of the pressure on the whole household and not only his own. It hides Daniel's own voice and choices, and it must never be used to blur anyone's responsibility. If there were harm or abuse in such a web, the answer would be protection, not "working it out together".
The map of seasons (lecture 6-1 and 6-3). It sees a season in which work, a parent and a child's leaving are all changing together. Erikson's questions of generativity and integrity may be close at hand: what am I giving to those who come after, and what was my life for? It hides the man himself: his faith, his humour, his own account.
Also available, but not applied here, are the map of meaning (4-2), the map of story (4-3), the map of culture (5-2), and the map of faith (6-2). Each would show something more. In many cultures, for example, a son has particular duties to a parent, and a man may have few acceptable ways of saying that he is grieving. A carer who knows this will listen differently.
3. What no map shows
Lay all the maps over Daniel, and several things remain that none of them shows.
Daniel as a particular person. Not a case, but this man, with this voice and this face, whom God knows by name.
Daniel's own account. The maps are our words. Daniel has his own, and he may not use any of ours. Often the most useful thing a carer can do is to ask a plain question and listen to the answer.
Daniel's agency. He is not an object acted upon by his bonds, his thoughts and his family. He makes choices and can grow. A map that makes him only a product of causes has stopped being useful.
The work of God. The Christian picture says that a person is made in the , is marked by sin and loss, and is being renewed. What happens in a conversation is not only a matter of skill. The carer trusts that God is already present with Daniel, and that she is not the one who must repair him.
4. Why use several maps?
If one map had shown all this, we would not need the others. But each shows some of the ground and hides some. Two things follow.
First, hold every map loosely. A carer who has used one theory for years can come to see everything through it. A person who loves one map may hear the same story in every conversation. Naming the assumptions of each map, as you learned to do in the first week, keeps you honest.
Second, let the maps correct one another. The map of thinking reminds the map of hidden motives that some pain is real and external. The map of acceptance reminds the map of the system that Daniel is a person and not a part. The map of seasons reminds all of them that he has a past and a future. Used together, they are less likely to make a mistake of one kind.
Even so, a collection of maps is still not the ground. It is a better set of questions, and the answers are in the conversation.
5. What is mine to do?
A carer in a church is not a therapist, a doctor or a rescuer. What is mine to do? Here are the things that belong to anyone who cares:
- Notice. Notice that Daniel has changed, and that he has missed meetings.
- Stay. Be present, patient and kind, and let a conversation take its time. Lecture 4-4 and LM205E (Listening Well: Foundations of Lay ) say more about how to listen.
- Ask, and listen. Ask what he would like, not what you think he should do.
- Offer what a church can offer. Prayer, if he welcomes it. A meal. Company. A seat at the table. A friend to sit with his mother one evening. The ordinary practices of a community, as in the previous week, are already a form of care.
- Keep confidence, with care. What Daniel says in trust is not repeated lightly. The later ethics course will teach the detail; the short rule is that you do not pass on what you were told unless the person agrees, or unless someone is in danger.
- Seek counsel yourself. Proverbs 11:14 and Ecclesiastes 4:9-10 apply to the carer. A carer should have a pastor, a priest, a mentor or a trusted colleague with whom she can talk about how she is carrying the work, without giving away what was told to her in confidence in ways that would harm.
6. When is something beyond me?
Care given in a church and professional treatment are different things. A professional has training, supervision, legal duties and tools that a volunteer does not have, and a person who needs treatment should receive it from someone qualified. Knowing a theory does not make you a therapist.
So connect the person to a qualified professional when something is beyond you. You do not need to be certain. If you are unsure whether it is beyond you, that is itself a reason to seek advice. A carer might say, kindly, "I care about you and I want you to have more help than I can give. Would it be all right if we found someone to talk with together?" Offer to help the person make the first call or to go with them to the first appointment, if they wish. A good referral is not a way of getting rid of someone. It is a way of staying with them while the right help is found.
7. Safety before theory
The most important rule of this lecture is also the simplest. If a person may harm themselves or someone else, or is in danger, the answer is not a theory. Stay with the person. Call your local emergency number. Connect the person to a qualified professional. In the United States the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline is available; other countries have their own crisis lines. Find out the number for your area before you need it, and write it where you can find it.
Do not leave the person alone if you fear for their safety. Do not promise to keep a secret that puts anyone at risk. Do not try to analyse, to persuade or to argue them out of it. Follow your community's written policy, and the law of your country, and ask for help.
With Daniel, nothing in the scene suggests danger. But if, in a later conversation, he said that he could not go on, the maps would be put down at once.
8. A last look at the claim
You began this course with a simple sentence: a theory is a map of the person, not the person. By now you have a dozen maps, each with its strengths and its blind spots. The person in front of you is more than all of them. A careful carer learns the maps, asks what each assumes, sets each beside what Scripture and the Christian traditions say about the human person, and neither makes one theory into the gospel nor throws them all away.
This is a point where readers will not agree about how far a church should lean on the findings of psychology and counselling at all, as lecture 1-2 explained. Some will read this lecture and think it uses too much psychology; others will think it uses too little. The requirement of this course stays the same: any map is read with its assumptions named and tested against Scripture, and no tradition is called the only faithful one.
Diagram 1. One scene, six maps
Diagram 2. Mine to do, and to pass on
| Mine to do | To pass on to someone qualified |
|---|---|
| Notice a change; stay; ask and listen | Anything that may put the person or another in danger |
| Offer prayer, company, meals, practical help | Anything that seems to need medical or mental-health care |
| Keep confidence, except where someone is at risk | Anything beyond your training, or that you are unsure about |
| Seek counsel for yourself | Abuse or harm: follow the written policy and local law |
In short
- Several maps laid over one scene each show something and hide something. Used together they correct one another, but they never equal the person.
- No map shows the person as a particular individual, his own account, his choices, or the work of God.
- A carer notices, stays, asks and listens, offers what a church offers, keeps confidence and seeks counsel herself.
- Care given in a church is not professional treatment. When something is beyond you, connect the person to a qualified professional.
- Safety comes before theory: stay, call the local emergency number, and connect the person with a qualified professional.
- A carer is not alone: many counsellors, and a friend who lifts.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Why use several maps | Each shows some ground and hides some; together they correct one another, though none equals the person. |
| What no map shows | The particular person, their own account, their choices, and the work of God. |
| When something is beyond me | Connect the person to a qualified professional, kindly, and stay with them while help is found. |
| Safety before theory | If someone may be harmed: stay, call your local emergency number, connect to a professional. |
One sentence to remember Learn the maps, name what each assumes, and still ask the person for their own account.
This week's action Write down your local emergency number and a crisis line for your area, and place them where you can find them.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Which of the six maps would you reach for first with Daniel? What does that tell you about your own habits of listening?
- Which map would you be least likely to use? What might you miss as a result?
- Why is it dangerous to say aloud "you are really angry at your father"?
- What are three things a church can offer Daniel that a map cannot supply?
- What is the difference between care given in a church and professional treatment? Why does the difference matter?
- What would you do, step by step, if a person told you they could not go on? Where is your local crisis number written?
- Who is your Ecclesiastes 4:10 friend, the one who lifts you when you fall?