Lecture 6-2: Stages of Faith
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: A Map Is Not the Ground
- Lecture 1-2: Scripture and Psychology: The Positions
- Lecture 1-3: Questions to Ask of Any Theory
- Lecture 1-4: Why This Matters for Those Who Care
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Own Map
- Lecture 2-1: The Psychodynamic Tradition
- Lecture 2-2: Attachment
- Lecture 2-3: Images of God and Early Relationships
- Lecture 2-4: Hidden Motives and the Heart
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Reading One Scene Two Ways
- Lecture 3-1: Behaviour and Learning
- Lecture 3-2: Cognitive Theories
- Lecture 3-3: Renewing the Mind: Cognitive Approaches and Scripture
- Lecture 3-4: What Habit and Thought Cannot Reach
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Same Event, Two Readings
- Lecture 4-1: The Person-Centred Approach
- Lecture 4-2: Meaning and Existence
- Lecture 4-3: Story and Solutions
- Lecture 4-4: Three Gifts, Three Cautions
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: How Do I Listen?
- Lecture 5-1: Family Systems
- Lecture 5-2: Culture, Society and Context
- Lecture 5-3: The Church as a System
- Lecture 5-4: Seeing Wider
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Drawing a Web
Lecture 6-1 asked how a whole life changes. This lecture asks a narrower question that every pastor and small-group leader meets: how does a person's way of believing change over a life?
Notice the word way. Two believers can hold the same creed word for word and still believe very differently. One holds her faith as something received from her family and her parish, and she would never think to question it. Another has questioned everything and now holds a faith he has tested himself. A third holds a faith that is quiet, wide and at peace with things it cannot explain. The creed is the same. The way of believing is not.
James Fowler, an American theologian and researcher, built a well-known theory around this difference. He described stages of faith. This lecture sets them out briefly, asks what they explain and what they miss, and sets them beside what Scripture and the Christian traditions say about growth. Of all the maps in this course, this one is the easiest to misuse, because it looks like a ladder and people enjoy telling others where they stand on it. The lecture is written to prevent that.
What these 23 minutes give you
- Explain the difference between *how* a person believes and *what* a person believes.
- Name Fowler's stages and describe each in one sentence.
- Explain three reasons why the stages must not be read as a ladder.
- Describe, in general terms, how the Catholic, Orthodox, Protestant and Pentecostal traditions speak about growth in faith.
- State fairly the different views Christians take of stage theories of faith.
When I was a child, I spoke as a child, I felt as a child, I thought as a child. Now that I have become a man, I have put away childish things." — 1 Corinthians 13:11
World English Bible
For now we see in a mirror, dimly, but then face to face. Now I know in part, but then I will know fully, even as I was also fully known." — 1 Corinthians 13:12
WEB
For although by this time you should be teachers, you again need to have someone teach you the rudiments of the first principles of the oracles of God. You have come to need milk, and not solid food. For everyone who lives on milk is not experienced in the word of righteousness, for he is a baby. But solid food is for those who are full grown, who by reason of use have their senses exercised to discern good and evil." — Hebrews 5:12-14
WEB
But when Jesus saw it, he was moved with indignation, and said to them, “Allow the little children to come to me! Don’t forbid them, for the Kingdom of God belongs to such as these. Most certainly I tell you, whoever will not receive the Kingdom of God like a little child, he will in no way enter into it.”" — Mark 10:14-15
WEB
Two of these passages speak of growing up. One says that even the grown person sees "dimly". One says that the Kingdom belongs to the child. Hold all four together; the lecture will return to them.
1. How a person believes, and what a person believes
Most teaching in a church is about what to believe: the creed, the Scriptures, the doctrines. This is right and necessary. But a carer who listens to people soon notices a second layer. The same words are held in different ways. For one person, "God is my Father" is a plain fact learned at her mother's knee. For another, it is a hard-won statement after years of doubt. For a third, it is a mystery that grows deeper the more it is spoken.
Fowler's work asks about this second layer. He was interested in the form of faith: how a person holds beliefs, from where they draw authority, how they deal with doubt, and who they include in their circle of care. He gathered his material by conducting a large number of long interviews and then describing patterns he saw in the answers.
One feature of his approach is important to understand. Fowler used the word faith in a wide sense. For him, faith meant the way a person gives trust and loyalty to what matters most to them, which might or might not be a religion. A Christian reader should notice the difference. In the Christian understanding, faith is a response to God, who speaks first. Fowler's wide meaning is a description of how people make meaning; it does not claim to say what faith is before God. That is one reason his theory is a map, and not the ground itself.
2. The stages, in brief
Fowler described seven positions, counting a beginning stage before words. Here they are as he is usually summarised. In each case the description is of a way of believing, and the ages given are only the usual places where the way first appears.
Primal faith (the beginning). Before language, a baby learns whether the world can be relied on. This is close to what Erikson called trust and to what attachment research studies (lecture 2-2).
Intuitive-projective faith. A young child takes in images, stories and moods from the family. Imagination is strong. God may be pictured much like a parent or a great person. The child believes what the household lives.
Mythic-literal faith. A school-age child takes stories and rules in a direct way. Fairness matters a great deal. Good is rewarded and bad is punished. Many adults also hold their faith like this, and for them it can be solid and generous.
Synthetic-conventional faith. The person holds faith together with a group. Belonging gives identity. Authority is the community, the priest, the pastor, the tradition. Questions are not forbidden, but they are rarely sharpened into a challenge. Fowler found this way common in adolescence and also among many adults.
Individuative-reflective faith. The person begins to ask, "What do I believe, and why?" She takes responsibility for her beliefs, tests the group's answers, and sometimes feels she is leaving the community in order to find herself. This can be a time of upheaval.
Conjunctive faith. The person is able to hold opposites together. He sees that truth has more sides than he thought, returns to old symbols and stories with new respect, and listens to other traditions without fear. Fowler thought this way came, if at all, in mid-life or later.
Universalizing faith. Fowler described this as rare. It is a faith that gives itself fully for the good of others, often at great cost, with little fear of loss.
3. What the theory explains
It explains why believers who agree on doctrine can feel far apart. A group may be united in creed and still divided in the way its members believe. A mother of three who values the parish as her spiritual home and a graduate student who is examining everything can sit in the same pew. The difference between them may not be a difference of orthodoxy. It may be a difference in how each holds the faith.
It helps a carer to hear a questioner kindly. (an invented example) Tomasz, twenty-three, tells his small-group leader that he no longer knows whether he believes what he was taught as a child. An anxious leader might hear this as the beginning of the end. A leader who knows this map may hear it as a person taking his faith in his own hands, a common experience in this season of life. She does not need to call it a stage. She only needs to be patient and to stay near.
It reminds us that people are different from one another. A way of believing that is natural and good for one person may be the wrong shape for another. It guards against a church in which every person is expected to believe in exactly the same manner.
It shows that a faith can mature without its content changing. Someone can keep the same creed for fifty years and still grow in how deeply it is held.
4. What the theory misses
It is easily read as a ladder. This is the first and greatest danger. The numbering suggests going up, and the later stages sound more admirable. A reader may conclude that the third stage is "behind" the fifth, and that a believer with a simple, trusting faith needs to be moved on. Fowler did describe the stages as ways of holding faith and not as measures of a person's worth, yet many readers, including some ministers, have heard a ranking. That is a reason for care, not a reason to rank.
The later stages may reflect a particular culture. The stage of questioning one's own faith, and of making it truly "mine", puts great weight on the individual who stands apart from the group and decides alone. That is a strong value in some societies. In many others the faith of the community, the family and the ancestors is not a stage to be passed through; it is where a mature person stands. A theory that treats such faith as early may be placing one culture's idea of adulthood above another's. The people interviewed were largely from the United States and largely from Christian or Jewish backgrounds, which is a further limit on how far the stages can be applied.
It tells us little about the content of faith. The stages describe a form. They do not say anything about whether a person's beliefs are true, about the work of the Holy Spirit, or about grace. A person may be at an "advanced" stage and hold a faith that is cold, and another may be at an "early" stage and love God with all his heart.
It is not an exact description of real lives. People do not march through stages. A person may take up questions at fifteen, put them aside at thirty, and take them up again at fifty. A grief or an illness can send a mature believer back to the simplest prayers. That is not failure.
5. How the theory meets the Christian picture of the person
Where they overlap. Scripture also speaks of growth. Paul writes that he put away childish things, and then, in the same breath, says that even the grown person sees "dimly" and knows "in part" (1 Corinthians 13:11-12). This is a useful check on any theory of mature faith: the Bible does not claim that the mature person has arrived. The writer of Hebrews rebukes a community that should have grown in understanding and had not, and describes maturity as senses "exercised to discern good and evil" through use (Hebrews 5:12-14). So the New Testament knows that people can be at different places in understanding and that growth is expected.
Where Scripture complicates the ladder. In the Gospel of Mark, Jesus says of children that the Kingdom of God belongs to such as these, and that whoever does not receive it like a little child will not enter (Mark 10:14-15). If a child's way of receiving were simply an early and lower stage, this saying would make no sense. The saying suggests that trust, openness and dependence are not left behind as we grow; they are the way in. Notice also that Hebrews 5 is addressed to a particular community that had grown dull of hearing; it is a pastoral rebuke to a group, not a sorting of individuals into grades.
How different traditions speak of growth. Each tradition has its own words for growing in faith, and none of them matches Fowler's scheme neatly.
- The Catholic tradition has long spoken of formation, of the sacraments as the through life, and of a journey of the soul sometimes described by the purgative, illuminative and unitive ways.
- The Orthodox tradition speaks of a life-long path of growth in the likeness of God, through prayer, fasting, the services of the church and the guidance of an .
- Protestant traditions speak of and of growth in holiness, with attention to knowing Scripture and to the freedom of conscience.
- Pentecostal traditions speak of growth in the Spirit, of gifts and of fruit, and of a deepening life of prayer and witness.
Notice that these are not stages in Fowler's sense. They are descriptions of a way of life with God that is shared by a whole community. A parish member in the Orthodox tradition who follows the rhythm of the services with trust, and does not ask questions of the individual-reflective kind, is not "earlier" than a Protestant student of theology. They are walking different roads.
This is a point where readers will not agree. Some Christians find stage theories of faith helpful for pastoral wisdom: they help a minister understand why a young person's doubts are not a rebellion, and why an older person's plain trust is not simple-mindedness, and they teach patience. Others fear that any stage scheme becomes a ladder that ranks believers, with some "advanced" and others "behind". They also doubt that the stages hold in every culture and tradition, and some think that a scheme that describes faith without naming the Spirit's work is incomplete. Both views have strong reasons. This course requires only this much: that the stages be used, if at all, as descriptions of ways of believing and not as a ranking; that no one be called "behind"; and that no carer tell a person which stage they are in.
6. A word of care
A theory of faith must not be used to diagnose a person or to answer a person's doubt. If someone says, "I am not sure I believe anymore," the answer is not "you are in the questioning stage." It is to stay, to listen, and to take the person seriously. If a person's doubt is mixed with deep hopelessness, or with thoughts of harming themselves, the matter is not one of faith theory. Stay with the person, call your local emergency number if there is danger, and connect the person to a qualified professional. Care given in a church is not treatment.
And remember the main claim of this course. A theory is a map of the person, not the person. Fowler drew a map of ways of believing. The woman in the third pew and the young man at the back of the hall are not points on it. Each is a person whom God knows fully, even as they see dimly.
Diagram 1. Fowler's stages: ways of believing, not ranks
Diagram 2. A ladder reading and a fair reading
| Question | A ladder reading (to avoid) | A fair reading |
|---|---|---|
| What do the numbers mean? | Higher is better | They only mark different ways of holding faith |
| Where is a questioner? | At risk of losing faith | Taking faith into their own hands, and needing company |
| Where is a trusting parishioner? | Not yet grown up | Possibly standing exactly where the tradition places a mature believer |
| What does a carer do? | Moves people on | Listens, stays near, and trusts God with the growth |
In short
- Fowler's theory describes how a person believes, not what a person believes. The same creed can be held in very different ways.
- He described seven positions, from a baby's trust to a rare faith that gives itself for others.
- The stages must never be read as a ladder. They carry cultural limits, say little about grace, and people move among them.
- Scripture itself says that even the mature see "dimly", and that the Kingdom belongs to the child.
- Catholic, Orthodox, Protestant and Pentecostal traditions each speak of growth in their own words; none matches the scheme exactly.
- No one is "behind", and a carer never tells a person which stage they are in.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The question Fowler asks | Not what a person believes, but how a person holds belief. |
| Why the ladder reading fails | The stages are ways of believing, not ranks. They reflect cultural limits and people move in and out of them. |
| What the Bible adds | The mature still see dimly; the Kingdom belongs to the child. Growth is expected, but not as a ranking. |
| What this course requires | Stages as descriptions only; no one is behind; no carer names a stage for another person. |
One sentence to remember Stages describe ways of believing; they do not rank believers, and no one is behind.
This week's action Think of one believer whose faith looks different from yours. Write down one thing their way of believing shows you that yours does not.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- What is the difference between *how* a person believes and *what* a person believes? Why does a carer need to notice both?
- Why might a parish member who never asks questions about the faith be a mature believer? What would you say to someone who thinks this person is "behind"?
- In your tradition, what words are used for growth in faith? How are they like or unlike Fowler's stages?
- Jesus says the Kingdom belongs to children. How does this saying challenge a reading of the stages as a ladder?
- Why is it a mistake to tell a doubter which stage they are in?
- What is the main reason Christians disagree about stage theories of faith, and what does this course require of you?