Lecture 6-1: Erikson and the Eight Stages
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: A Map Is Not the Ground
- Lecture 1-2: Scripture and Psychology: The Positions
- Lecture 1-3: Questions to Ask of Any Theory
- Lecture 1-4: Why This Matters for Those Who Care
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Own Map
- Lecture 2-1: The Psychodynamic Tradition
- Lecture 2-2: Attachment
- Lecture 2-3: Images of God and Early Relationships
- Lecture 2-4: Hidden Motives and the Heart
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Reading One Scene Two Ways
- Lecture 3-1: Behaviour and Learning
- Lecture 3-2: Cognitive Theories
- Lecture 3-3: Renewing the Mind: Cognitive Approaches and Scripture
- Lecture 3-4: What Habit and Thought Cannot Reach
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Same Event, Two Readings
- Lecture 4-1: The Person-Centred Approach
- Lecture 4-2: Meaning and Existence
- Lecture 4-3: Story and Solutions
- Lecture 4-4: Three Gifts, Three Cautions
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: How Do I Listen?
- Lecture 5-1: Family Systems
- Lecture 5-2: Culture, Society and Context
- Lecture 5-3: The Church as a System
- Lecture 5-4: Seeing Wider
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Drawing a Web
Every theory in this course so far has looked at a slice of the person. One theory looked at hidden motives, another at early bonds, another at learning and thinking, another at acceptance and meaning, another at families and culture. This week the view widens in time. We ask: what does a whole life look like, from the first year to the last?
The best-known answer from psychology comes from Erik Erikson, a psychoanalyst who worked with children and then studied how people change across the whole span of life. He described eight stages. Each stage has a central tension, and each tension is a question that a person meets in a certain season. This lecture sets out the eight stages, with more weight on the three adult ones, because the childhood stages are taught in detail in PT706E (development from birth to eighteen). It asks what the scheme explains, what it misses, and how it stands beside what Scripture says about the seasons of a life.
Remember the central claim of the course. A theory is a map of the person, not the person. A map of a whole life is the hardest kind to hold lightly, because it is easy to hear it as a road everyone must walk in the same order. It is not.
What these 24 minutes give you
- Name Erikson's eight stages in order and say what "a tension between two pulls" means in his scheme.
- Explain in your own words the three adult tensions: intimacy, generativity and integrity.
- State two things the scheme explains and two things it leaves out, including its cultural limits.
- Explain why the stages describe seasons of a life and do not rank anyone.
- State fairly the different views Christians take of stage theories.
For everything there is a season, and a time for every purpose under heaven: a time to be born, and a time to die; a time to plant, and a time to pluck up that which is planted;" — Ecclesiastes 3:1-2
World English Bible
God, you have taught me from my youth. Until now, I have declared your wondrous works. Yes, even when I am old and gray-haired, God, don’t forsake me, until I have declared your strength to the next generation, your might to everyone who is to come." — Psalms 71:17-18
WEB
But say the things which fit sound doctrine, that older men should be temperate, sensible, sober minded, sound in faith, in love, and in patience:" — Titus 2:1-2
WEB
The first passage says that a life has seasons. The second is a prayer from a person who has lived long and still has a task for the next generation. The third describes the character expected of older believers, in a passage about how the generations relate. The rest of Titus 2 gives instructions for households that readers understand in different ways; this lecture does not take them up.
1. Why look at a whole life?
Most of what we call counselling theory was built to explain a problem at a moment: a fear, a conflict, a loss. A person in a church, however, is not a moment. The same woman is a daughter, a worker, a mother, a neighbour and a member of the choir, and she is not the same woman she was twenty years ago. A carer who sees only the present scene misses where the person has come from and where the person is going.
A theory of the whole life gives a carer three things. It gives a long view: this hard season sits inside a larger story. It gives a shared language: words for changes that people feel but cannot name. And it gives patience: some questions cannot be settled in a month because they belong to a whole season of life.
2. What Erikson said
Erikson's central idea is simple. At each period of life, a person meets a particular tension, which means two pulls in opposite directions. A young child is pulled between trusting the world and mistrusting it. An older person is pulled between accepting the life that has been lived and sinking into regret. Erikson used the word crisis for each tension, but he did not mean a disaster. He meant a turning point, a time when a person is especially open to growth and especially open to harm.
Three features of the scheme are easy to forget.
First, both pulls are normal. Nobody reaches a stage with only trust and no mistrust. Erikson's hope was for a healthy balance, in which the positive pull is stronger but the negative one still teaches. A person with no capacity for mistrust at all would be foolish, not mature.
Second, earlier tensions come back. A person who lost a spouse at sixty may feel again the old question of whether the world can be trusted. The stages are not rooms we leave and lock. They are themes that return in new forms.
Third, the stages are about relationship. The tension is not settled inside a person alone. It is settled between a person and the people and the community around them.
3. The five childhood and youth stages, briefly
Erikson's first five stages cover the years before adulthood. They are taught in PT706E, so here they are only named, each in one paragraph.
Trust versus mistrust belongs to infancy. A baby learns, through being fed, held and answered, whether the world is a place where needs are met. (Lecture 2-2 on attachment looked at a related idea from another school.)
Autonomy versus shame and doubt belongs to the toddler years. A small child wants to do things alone, to say no, to try. Too much scolding and control can leave a child ashamed of wanting to try.
Initiative versus guilt belongs to the early school years. A child makes plans, plays at being a grown person and asks endless questions. The tension is between enjoying one's own energy and feeling guilty for it.
Industry versus inferiority belongs to the school years. A child learns to make things and to do them well, and begins to compare herself with others. The tension is between pride in work and a feeling of being less than the others.
Identity versus role confusion belongs to adolescence. A young person asks who he is, what he believes and where he belongs. The tension is between a growing sense of self and a scattering of roles that do not fit together. Because this stage falls before the age of eighteen, PT706E is the place to read about it.
4. Intimacy versus isolation
The first adult stage, in Erikson's scheme, belongs to young adulthood. The question is: can I give myself to a close bond without losing myself? The bond may be a marriage. It may also be a deep friendship, a vow to a religious community, or a commitment to a shared work. The pull towards intimacy is the wish to be truly known and to know someone truly. The pull towards isolation is the wish to stay safe by staying apart.
Erikson's point is that closeness needs a self that is secure enough to be shared. A person who is still unsure who he is may fear that a close bond will swallow him, or may cling to a bond to avoid facing himself. This is why, in his order, identity comes first.
5. Generativity versus stagnation
The second adult stage belongs to the middle years. Generativity is Erikson's word for care for what will outlast me. The word is awkward, but the idea is plain. A person in this season begins to ask: what am I giving to the next generation, and what will remain after I am gone?
Generativity is not only about having children. It includes teaching, mentoring, building something useful, caring for a community and passing on skills and stories. (an invented example) Lucía is fifty-six and has no children. For years she thought of this as a gap in her life. Then the parish asked her to train teenagers who help in the church kitchen. She found, to her surprise, that teaching a fifteen-year-old to keep a clean workplace and to speak kindly to the elderly guests answered the very question she had thought she could not answer. This is what Erikson meant, and it shows that the stage is wider than parenthood.
The opposite pull he called stagnation. It is the feeling that nothing grows, that one's energy goes only to oneself, one's comfort, one's own concerns. Note that this is a pull that nearly everyone feels sometimes, not a label for a kind of person. A reader must not use the word to describe anyone, including herself, as though it were a verdict.
6. Integrity versus despair
The last stage belongs to late adulthood. The question is: can I look at the one life I have lived, with its mistakes and its good, and accept that it was mine? Erikson called the positive pull integrity, which here means a sense of wholeness, the ability to see one's life as one story. The negative pull he called despair, a bitter sense that time is too short to start again and that the life has been wasted.
Erikson also linked each stage with a strength that can grow from it. In his later writing, hope belongs to the first stage and wisdom to the last. The idea is that the end of a life, rightly met, bears the fruit of wisdom, and that the beginning of a life, rightly met, bears the fruit of hope.
7. What the scheme explains well
The scheme has lasted because it explains several real things.
It covers the whole life. Many theories stop at childhood or at a clinical problem. Erikson insisted that adult life has its own tasks and its own growth. For a church, this is important, because most of its members are adults and many are old.
It joins the person to the community. Each tension is settled with other people. This agrees with what a pastor sees: the lonely widower and the burdened mother of young children are not facing problems in the same way, because they are in different places in the web of relationships (lecture 5-1).
It names real turning points. Many people say that a change of life — leaving home, marrying, the children leaving, retirement — brought them to questions they had not asked before. The scheme gives a language for that.
It is hopeful. Every stage has a possible gain. Even the last stage, which meets illness and the nearness of death, is not described as only loss.
8. What the scheme misses
An honest map shows where it stops. Here are the main limits.
The sample and the culture. Erikson drew on clinical work, on observation, and on biographical studies. These came largely from Western settings. The emphasis on identity, on separate selves who must become independent, and on the individual's own life story reflects a particular culture. In many cultures the self is understood more as a member of a family or a people, and adulthood is marked by different events (lecture 5-2). Readers in such cultures may find that the order of the stages does not match their experience.
The order may be too fixed. The scheme suggests that the stages follow one another. Real lives do not always do this. A refugee who must be responsible for others at fourteen, a person who marries late, a person who changes at fifty, or one who loses a child, may meet these questions in a different order or all at once.
The scheme says little about suffering that comes from outside. Poverty, war, illness, a death or an injustice done by another person shape a life, and the scheme describes them only as hindrances or helps to the stage tasks. It does not give them their own weight.
It is a description, not a proof. The scheme gathers many wise observations, but its stages are hard to test one by one. This does not make it useless; it makes it a map to be held loosely.
9. How the scheme meets the Christian picture of the person
Where they overlap. Scripture also knows that a life has seasons (Ecclesiastes 3:1-2). It knows that the old have a task for the young. The psalmist asks God to keep him until he has declared God's strength to the next generation (Psalms 71:17-18), which is very close to Erikson's idea of generativity. Titus 2:1-2 names the settled character expected of older believers, and the chapter as a whole places old and young in relationship. In many traditions, this appears as the spiritual mother or father, the , the sponsor or the mentor. Catholic and Orthodox parishes have long honoured the elder who prays and counsels; Pentecostal and Protestant congregations speak of mentoring and discipling. Erikson's word is new; the concern is old.
Where they differ. For Erikson, integrity is a kind of acceptance of one's own life. The Christian understanding adds something that a psychological scheme cannot supply by itself. A life looked at honestly contains wrongs done and wrongs suffered, and a person cannot simply accept them. In the Christian picture, what makes a whole life possible is not only self-acceptance but also forgiveness, being forgiven, and trust that God can receive a life and make something of it. Likewise, the answer to despair in the Christian picture is not only a good view of the past but hope in God. What you learned about the human person in your course on theology (ST3E) stands behind this: a person is made in the , damaged by sin, and being renewed.
This is a point where readers will not agree. Some Christians find stage theories of life and faith useful for pastoral wisdom: they help a minister to see that a person of twenty-five and a person of seventy are asking different questions, and to be patient. Others fear that stages become a ladder, so that believers are sorted into the advanced and the behind, and they doubt that the stages hold true for every person and every culture. Both concerns have good reasons behind them. The useful side is the long view and the patience it brings; the cautious side is the danger of ranking and of imposing one culture's order on all. This course requires only this much: that the stages be read as descriptions of seasons and of common questions, never as a ranking of believers, and that no one be called "behind". A person at any age may be at any point of faith or of growth.
10. A word of care
Erikson's scheme must never be used to diagnose or to place a person. Do not tell anyone, "You are in the stage of stagnation." The scheme describes pulls that everyone feels. It does not sort people. Care given in a church is not treatment, and a carer who hears a person describe deep distress, hopelessness or thoughts of self-harm does not reach for a stage. If someone may harm themselves or others, the answer is not a theory: stay with the person, call your local emergency number, and connect the person to a qualified professional.
And no one is trapped. A person who struggled with trust in infancy may grow in trust at forty, through a faithful friend, a patient community, or the long experience of being met by God. A person who has felt stagnant for years may be given a new work. The stages are not a sentence.
This is the first map of the week, and the same rule holds as in lecture 1-1: a theory is a map of the person, not the person. Erikson drew a map of seasons. The person you meet is a particular man or woman, in a particular place, in the hands of God.
Diagram 1. Eight stages of a life, in Erikson's scheme
In short
- Erikson described eight stages of life, each a turning point between two pulls, such as trust and mistrust. A healthy life holds a balance.
- The five childhood and youth stages are taught in PT706E. The adult stages are intimacy, generativity and integrity.
- Generativity means caring for what will outlast me. It is wider than parenthood and includes teaching, mentoring and service.
- The scheme drew largely on Western material, suggests a fixed order, and says little about suffering from outside.
- Christians differ on stage theories. This course requires only that stages are never read as a ranking of believers.
- A theory is a map of the person, not the person. No one may be placed in a stage as a diagnosis.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| A stage in Erikson's scheme | A turning point between two pulls, such as trust and mistrust, in which both are normal and balance is the goal. |
| The three adult tensions | Intimacy versus isolation; generativity versus stagnation; integrity versus despair. |
| Generativity | Care for what will outlast me: children, pupils, work, community. It is not only parenthood. |
| The main limits of the scheme | Largely Western material; a fixed order; little weight given to suffering that comes from outside. |
One sentence to remember A stage theory describes the seasons of a life; it never ranks the believer.
This week's action Write down one way a person older than you has cared for you, and one way you might care for someone younger. Keep the page private.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Erikson says both pulls in each stage are normal, and that health is a balance. What is the difference between "a balance" and "a victory"? Why does it matter for a carer?
- Think of the adults you know in your congregation. Without naming anyone, what different questions do you think a person of thirty and a person of seventy-five might be asking?
- The lecture says generativity is wider than parenthood. What are some ways, in your own church, that people care for what will outlast them?
- What parts of the scheme fit the culture you know, and what parts do not?
- Some believers fear that a stage theory becomes a ladder. What would you say to prevent that in your own thinking?
- In what ways does the Christian picture of a finished life add something to "integrity"?