Lecture 5-3: The Church as a System
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: A Map Is Not the Ground
- Lecture 1-2: Scripture and Psychology: The Positions
- Lecture 1-3: Questions to Ask of Any Theory
- Lecture 1-4: Why This Matters for Those Who Care
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Own Map
- Lecture 2-1: The Psychodynamic Tradition
- Lecture 2-2: Attachment
- Lecture 2-3: Images of God and Early Relationships
- Lecture 2-4: Hidden Motives and the Heart
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Reading One Scene Two Ways
- Lecture 3-1: Behaviour and Learning
- Lecture 3-2: Cognitive Theories
- Lecture 3-3: Renewing the Mind: Cognitive Approaches and Scripture
- Lecture 3-4: What Habit and Thought Cannot Reach
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Same Event, Two Readings
- Lecture 4-1: The Person-Centred Approach
- Lecture 4-2: Meaning and Existence
- Lecture 4-3: Story and Solutions
- Lecture 4-4: Three Gifts, Three Cautions
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: How Do I Listen?
- Lecture 5-1: Family Systems
- Lecture 5-2: Culture, Society and Context
- Lecture 5-3: The Church as a System
- Lecture 5-4: Seeing Wider
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Drawing a Web
Every group that stays together for years develops habits. Who sits where. Who speaks first. Who is asked to do the difficult task. Which subjects everyone avoids. What happens when a visitor says something unexpected. No one decided these things in a meeting. They grew up, as paths grow across a field where people walk.
A congregation is such a group. So is a parish council, a small group that meets in a home, a prayer team, a choir, a chaplaincy volunteer team. In the last two lectures we saw that a person lives in a family and in a culture. A church member lives in one more web, and a carer who works in a church is inside it.
This lecture applies the idea of a system, which we met in lecture 5-1, to the life of a church. It asks what happens to worry and conflict when they travel through a congregation, what roles people slip into, and what a carer should know about their own place in the web. It also draws a firm line. A church that thinks of itself as a family or a body must be a safe one, and where there is danger or abuse, the answer is protection, not "working it out together".
What these 25 minutes give you
- Describe how worry and conflict can spread through a congregation or small group, using the ideas of anxiety and triangles.
- Explain what is meant by roles in a group (for example the fixer or the scapegoat) and why they are patterns to notice, not labels for people.
- Describe how a carer is also part of the system, with a history of their own.
- State why, where there is danger or abuse, the answer is protection and not mutual adjustment, and state the disagreement about systems language in the church.
For as the body is one, and has many members, and all the members of the body, being many, are one body; so also is Christ." — 1 Corinthians 12:12
World English Bible
that there should be no division in the body, but that the members should have the same care for one another." — 1 Corinthians 12:25
WEB
but speaking truth in love, we may grow up in all things into him, who is the head, Christ;" — Ephesians 4:15
WEB
from whom all the body, being fitted and knit together through that which every joint supplies, according to the working in measure of each individual part, makes the body increase to the building up of itself in love." — Ephesians 4:16
WEB
Paul chose the image of a body to speak of the church. A body is the clearest picture of a system we have: if the foot is hurt, the whole body limps. The same apostle says what the body needs in order to grow — truth, told in love, and every joint supplying what it has.
1. A congregation is also a web
Think about the last time something upset a group you belong to. Perhaps a leader left suddenly. Perhaps there was a quarrel over money, over a building, over the music, over a decision that was announced instead of discussed. How did the news travel? Who heard it first? Who told whom? Who stopped speaking to whom? Who seemed to carry the worry for everyone else?
You were seeing a system at work. In lecture 5-1 we met two ideas that apply here. The first is anxiety passing from person to person — a tension that is not only felt inside one head but spreads through a group like a mood. The second is the triangle — the habit of two people in tension drawing in a third person, so that they do not have to speak directly to each other.
(an invented example) In a small assembly that meets in a rented hall, a member named Reuben is unhappy with a decision by the leader, Mrs Adebayo. He does not speak to her. Instead, he tells a friend in the congregation, who tells her husband, who mentions it to another member. Within a few weeks, half the assembly "knows" that there is a problem, but each person has heard a different version, and none of them has heard it from Reuben himself. Mrs Adebayo senses a coolness and does not know why. She begins to avoid Reuben, and in her turn confides in a trusted . The triangle is now a web of triangles. Everyone is anxious, and the only two people who could clear it up have not spoken.
Nobody in that story is wicked. Each person did what was easiest for them. This is exactly how a system works: it moves by many small, understandable steps.
2. Roles that groups hand out
Groups also tend to hand out roles. A person does not always choose a role. Often the group quietly offers it, and the person, for reasons of temperament or history, takes it up. The following are descriptions of patterns, not of kinds of people, and they are (invented examples).
The fixer. Whenever there is tension, this person steps in with a solution, a plan or a casserole. The group is grateful. But the fixer may be tired, and the group may never learn to solve its own troubles.
The peacemaker who swallows. This person's way of keeping peace is to say nothing, take the loss and move on. Peace is kept, but only by one person absorbing the cost.
The one who is blamed. When a group is anxious, it sometimes settles its worry on one person or one small family — the "difficult one" whom everyone explains the trouble by. Sometimes such a person really is behaving badly. Sometimes the group has simply found a place to put what it cannot face. The group feels better for a while, and the person bears the weight. People sometimes use the word scapegoat for this, after the ancient practice described in Leviticus 16 of sending a goat into the wilderness carrying the people's guilt away. The word is a warning. A group that needs a scapegoat has a problem that is larger than the scapegoat.
The one who always says yes. This person cannot refuse any request, and carries more than anyone should.
The silent one. This person has a view but never states it in the open, so the group never has the benefit of it.
The hero. This person is always capable and never needs help, and so is not helped when they need it.
Notice what these descriptions are for. They are not for sorting your fellow members into types, or for announcing to anyone that they are "a scapegoat". They are for noticing what the group is doing, and for asking gently whether it could do something else. A role is something a person does in a web. It is never the whole person.
3. Healthy and unhealthy patterns
Systems thinkers sometimes distinguish groups that cope with tension in a flexible way from groups that cope in a stuck way. Here is a simple, non-technical way to describe the difference, which you can recognise without any special training.
In a group that copes well:
- People are able to say hard things to the person concerned, kindly and directly, rather than speaking about them to others.
- A mistake can be admitted without a crisis.
- Different views can be spoken, and the group can stay together.
- Roles and responsibilities are known, and leaders can be questioned in the proper way.
- People can say "no" without being punished.
- Worry is shared and prayed over rather than passed on.
In a group that is stuck:
- Everything important is said in corridors and car parks.
- Some subjects cannot be touched.
- The same two or three people carry all the work, and the same one or two are blamed when anything goes wrong.
- A person who asks a question is treated as a threat.
- Leaders are either never questioned or constantly attacked.
Most groups are a mixture, and the mixture changes over time. A church is a gathering of imperfect people. The point is not to produce a flawless community but to notice when a pattern has become a trap.
The apostle's picture in Ephesians 4 is a good test. He says that the body grows when its members speak truth in love, and when every joint supplies what it has. A congregation where truth is told only behind backs, or where one joint is expected to supply everything, is not yet the body he describes.
4. A carer is part of the web
Here is a point that is easy to overlook. A carer is never outside the system. If you care for people in a church, you belong to its web. You were also born into a family, and that family taught you, without your noticing, how to behave when people are upset.
Perhaps you grew up in a home where conflict meant shouting, and now your stomach tightens whenever a voice is raised. Perhaps you grew up in a home where nobody ever said anything directly, and now you find it very hard to tell a friend that you are hurt. Perhaps you were the child who held the family together, and now you cannot stop yourself from fixing everyone's trouble. These are not faults. They are habits that once helped you, and they come with you into the church.
Why does it matter? Because a carer's own habits shape what they hear and what they do. A carer who fears conflict may steer every conversation away from it. A carer who needs to be needed may take on more than they can carry and may quietly discourage a person from standing on their own. A carer who was once badly hurt in a group may see danger where there is none, or fail to see it where there is.
You do not need to dig into your own past. This is not a request for confessions. It is a request for a little honesty: "What do I usually do when a group is tense? When do I speak, and when do I go quiet? Who do I find it hard to see clearly?" If something painful rises as you ask these questions, you may stop; and you should talk with a person you trust, or a qualified professional, rather than carry it alone. The point is only that a carer who knows their own tendencies is safer for others than one who does not.
5. Where it meets the Christian picture
The Christian traditions have always spoken of the church as more than a club. The New Testament calls it a body, a household, a family, a flock, a temple built of living stones. Each of these images says that the members belong to one another and affect one another. When one suffers, all suffer. When one rejoices, all rejoice. Paul's picture of a body with a weak member who is honoured, an eye that cannot say to the hand "I have no need of you", and a care that is the same for each, is a picture of a healthy system.
The Christian traditions also name what spoils the body: division, pride, contempt for the weaker member, the hiding of sin, the abuse of authority. Catholic and Orthodox traditions have ordered ways to settle disputes, through the bishop, the pastor, the council, the confessor. Protestant traditions have congregational meetings, elders, deacons and . Pentecostal and charismatic communities rely on prophetic and pastoral leaders and on the mutual care of the gathered assembly. All of them, in their different languages, are concerned with how the web of the church should hold together.
What the systems map adds is a way of seeing patterns that traditions already have names for. It may help a leader notice that the same family is blamed every time, or that a message always travels around a person instead of to them. What the map cannot supply is a judgement about right and wrong. For that, a church looks to Scripture, to its tradition, and to the gift of discernment that its members are given.
6. A point on which readers will not agree
This is a point where readers will not agree. Some Christians welcome systems thinking in the life of the church. They say that it gives words for what pastors already see: that worry can be passed on, that the one who is named as the problem may be carrying what others cannot, that a leader who stays calm can help a whole group. They point to the body language of Paul as an early form of the same insight. For them, a pastor who understands triangles will do better than one who does not.
Other Christians are wary. They say that a congregation is not a family system but a body called together by Christ, ruled by his word, and led by those he has appointed. They fear that the language of "anxiety", "triangles" and "differentiation" turns matters of sin, forgiveness and authority into matters of technique. A leader who says "the system is anxious" may be avoiding saying "someone did wrong". A congregation that has been told it is a "system" may forget that it is a church.
This course requires that you can state both. It requires that a carer who uses systems language never lets it blur who is responsible for what; the one who has done harm remains responsible. And it requires that you test any such idea against Scripture and the teaching of your own tradition, not take it as a replacement for them.
7. Where there is danger or abuse
Everything in this lecture so far assumes that the troubles of the group are the ordinary troubles of imperfect people: disagreements, hurt feelings, personality clashes, worries. In such cases, patience, honest speech and shared prayer may help.
Danger and abuse are a different matter, and the answer is different. If a person in your church is being harmed, threatened, controlled or abused — by a family member, a leader, a volunteer or anyone else — the answer is not to "work it out together", to "find a middle way", to ask the injured person to forgive quickly, or to ask the two sides to sit down and talk. Those responses place the one who was hurt back in the web with the one who hurt them. They treat harm as a difference of opinion.
In such a case:
- The first concern is the safety of the person at risk. If someone is in danger now, call your local emergency number.
- Follow your church's or organisation's written policy for protecting people from harm, and follow the law of the place where you are. If your community has no written policy, it needs one, and you should ask your leaders to make one.
- Report to the person responsible in your community for such matters. Do not try to investigate on your own, and do not promise secrecy that you cannot keep.
- Connect the person who has been hurt to qualified professionals who have the training to help.
Care given in a church is not treatment, and it is not a court. A later course in this group will teach the ethics, boundaries and referral that belong here. For now it is enough to hold the line: a systems view must never dilute the responsibility of someone who has done harm, and a church that honours the body must protect its weakest members first.
8. One more map
The church as a system is one more map. It helps a carer see the web that holds a person and the web that holds the carer. It does not tell you what is right. It does not replace prayer, the Scriptures, the sacraments or ordinances, or the guidance of those you answer to. And it does not make you a therapist for your congregation. A theory is a map, not the person — and a congregation is not a diagram, but a gathering of persons whom Christ knows by name.
Diagram 1. A message that goes around, and a message that goes direct
Diagram 2. Roles are patterns, not people
| Pattern | What the group gains | What it can cost |
|---|---|---|
| The fixer | Quick help | The group never learns to solve its own trouble |
| The peacemaker who swallows | Quiet | One person pays for everyone's peace |
| The one who is blamed | Relief from facing a hard thing | One person or family carries the group's worry |
| The one who always says yes | Work gets done | One person is worn out |
| The silent one | No open conflict | Views the group needs are never heard |
In short
- A congregation is a web: worry spreads through it, and a triangle forms whenever two people in tension draw in a third rather than speak directly.
- Groups hand out roles such as fixer, peacemaker who swallows, blamed one; these are patterns to notice, never labels for people.
- A group that copes well can say hard things directly and kindly; a stuck group says them in corridors and blames the same people.
- A carer is part of the system and brings habits learned in their own family; knowing them makes a carer safer.
- Readers disagree about systems language in the church; any such idea must be tested against Scripture and tradition and must not blur who is responsible.
- Where there is danger or abuse, the answer is protection, written policy, the law and a qualified professional, not working it out together.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Anxiety in a group | A tension that spreads from person to person, like a mood in a room. |
| Roles in a group | Patterns such as fixer or blamed one; notice them, never pin them on a person. |
| A carer in the web | A carer has their own family habits and belongs to the system they care for. |
| Danger or abuse | Protect first, follow the written policy and the law, call the emergency number, refer to a professional. |
One sentence to remember A congregation is a web in which worry travels and roles are handed out, and a church that is a body must protect its weakest members first.
This week's action Think of a group you belong to and write down one thing it does with tension; do not name any person.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- In the invented story of Reuben and Mrs Adebayo, where could the web have been broken? Who would have needed courage to do it?
- Why does the lecture say that roles such as "the fixer" are patterns to notice, not labels for people?
- What are two signs that a group is coping with tension in a flexible way, and two that it is stuck?
- The lecture says that a carer is part of the system too. Why can a carer's own habits in tense groups matter to the people they care for?
- State fairly both the welcome and the caution about systems language in the church. Which concerns seem strongest, and why?