Lecture 3-4: What Habit and Thought Cannot Reach
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: A Map Is Not the Ground
- Lecture 1-2: Scripture and Psychology: The Positions
- Lecture 1-3: Questions to Ask of Any Theory
- Lecture 1-4: Why This Matters for Those Who Care
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Own Map
- Lecture 2-1: The Psychodynamic Tradition
- Lecture 2-2: Attachment
- Lecture 2-3: Images of God and Early Relationships
- Lecture 2-4: Hidden Motives and the Heart
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Reading One Scene Two Ways
- Lecture 3-1: Behaviour and Learning
- Lecture 3-2: Cognitive Theories
- Lecture 3-3: Renewing the Mind: Cognitive Approaches and Scripture
- Lecture 3-4: What Habit and Thought Cannot Reach
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Same Event, Two Readings
- Lecture 4-1: The Person-Centred Approach
- Lecture 4-2: Meaning and Existence
- Lecture 4-3: Story and Solutions
- Lecture 4-4: Three Gifts, Three Cautions
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: How Do I Listen?
- Lecture 5-1: Family Systems
- Lecture 5-2: Culture, Society and Context
- Lecture 5-3: The Church as a System
- Lecture 5-4: Seeing Wider
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Drawing a Web
Every map ends somewhere. A good map-reader learns where it ends, because the most dangerous place to travel is the edge of a map that you believe has no edge.
In this week we have met two maps. The learning map shows how habits, feelings and confidence are formed. The cognitive map shows how the reading of an event shapes what a person feels and does. Both are useful. Both have been studied carefully. And both run out.
This lecture names five places where they run out: grief, trauma, injustice, mystery, and sin and grace. It then asks why the church, across its many traditions, practises so much more than skills: worship, sacraments or ordinances, confession, fasting and fellowship. The answer is not that the church is behind the times. It is that a person is more than a response to what happens to them.
This lecture does not teach how to deal with grief or trauma, and it does not attempt to define them. Those subjects need their own courses and their own trained helpers. The aim here is only to mark the edge of the two maps clearly, so that you do not try to travel beyond it by the wrong means.
What these 19 minutes give you
- Name five places where behaviour and cognitive maps run out, and say why each is not simply a habit or a thought.
- Explain what Romans 7:24-25 and Psalms 88 show that a skills-only account cannot.
- Describe how worship, the sacraments or ordinances, confession, fasting and fellowship differ from techniques.
- State why a carer who meets something beyond their place connects the person to a qualified professional.
What a wretched man I am! Who will deliver me out of the body of this death?" — Romans 7:24
World English Bible
I thank God through Jesus Christ, our Lord! So then with the mind, I myself serve God’s law, but with the flesh, the sin’s law." — Romans 7:25
WEB
For my soul is full of troubles. My life draws near to Sheol." — Psalms 88:3
WEB
You have put lover and friend far from me, and my friends into darkness." — Psalms 88:18
WEB
Yahweh is near to those who have a broken heart, and saves those who have a crushed spirit." — Psalms 34:18
WEB
Romans 7 is the cry of a person who finds that knowing and wanting are not enough. Psalms 88 is the prayer of a person for whom the night has not lifted by the end. Both are in Scripture, and both are given to the church to read.
1. Where the two maps run out
Let us first recall what each map is good at.
The learning map is good at patterns: how a reaction became attached to a signal, how an action was kept alive by its results, how confidence was built in small steps. The cognitive map is good at readings: how the same event can be read in different ways, and how a reading can be noticed and questioned.
Both of them have the same quiet strength. They say that something in the person can change. And both have the same quiet limit. They are best when the trouble is a pattern or a reading. They are weaker when the trouble is not a pattern or a reading at all. Five such places are named below.
2. Grief
A person who has lost someone they loved is not showing a badly learned habit. They are not misreading the event, either. They have lost someone, and the sorrow is fitting. The best response to such a loss is not a new skill but company, time, and the rituals by which a community says goodbye: the funeral or memorial, the meal, the visit, the prayers for the dead in those traditions that offer them, the quiet presence of people who do not hurry the mourner.
Learning and thinking do play a part in grief, as they do in everything human. But a carer who reaches first for a skill or a better thought has misunderstood what is happening. Grief is taught in detail in a later course in this group. For now, remember only that sorrow over a real loss is not a problem to be corrected.
3. Trauma
Some events are so frightening or so harmful that they leave deep marks on a person: on memory, on the body, on the sense of being safe in the world. This is called trauma, and the word is used here only in its everyday sense, as a deep mark left by something terrible.
The point for this lecture is small and firm. A deep mark of this kind is not a mere habit, and it is not a mere thinking error, and a person should not be told to "just think differently" or "just practise something new." People who help others with such marks need proper training, and the person needs safety first. A carer in a church does not try to treat it, does not ask a person to describe what happened in order to "work through it", and does not need to understand it fully. A carer stays kind, stays steady, and helps the person connect to a qualified professional.
4. Injustice
When a person has been wronged — cheated, threatened, ignored, mistreated, or abused — the trouble is not first of all in their thoughts. It lies in what was done to them. The answer is justice: the wrong must be named as wrong, the person must be protected, and the one who did the harm must answer for it.
A cognitive map that tells a person who has been wronged to "reframe it" risks teaching them that the problem is their own mind. Scripture does not talk like that. It is full of the cry for justice, and of a God who sees the wronged. If there is any present danger or any abuse, the response is protection, following your community’s written policy and local law, and your local emergency number if someone is in danger.
5. Mystery
Why does a good person suffer? Why does a child fall ill? Why does a prayer seem not to be answered? No map of learning or thinking answers these questions, and a carer who offers a quick answer usually does harm.
Scripture knows this. It contains Job, which refuses easy explanation, and the psalms of lament. Psalms 88 is among the plainest. The psalmist cries "day and night" (verse 1), says his soul is "full of troubles" (verse 3), and ends with friends gone "into darkness" (verse 18). The psalm does not turn toward hope at the end. It simply stops. And the church has kept it in the book of psalms that it prays. That is a quiet but strong statement: a prayer without a resolution is still a prayer, and a person in that place has not failed.
A carer need not explain. A carer can stay, and let the silence be a silence.
6. Sin and grace
The last edge is the one that Christians have always insisted on. Paul writes, in Romans 7, of a struggle in which what he wants to do and what he does are at odds, and he ends with a cry: "What a wretched man I am! Who will deliver me out of the body of this death?" (verse 24).
Notice what kind of cry this is. If the trouble were only a habit, a person might practise something new. If it were only a reading, a person might look again at the evidence. Paul does neither. He cries out for deliverance, and the answer he gives is "I thank God through Jesus Christ, our Lord!" (verse 25). The answer is a person, not a skill.
Readers of Romans differ about whether Paul is speaking here of his life before faith or of the struggle of a believer, and this lecture does not try to settle that. Either way, the passage shows that there is a kind of human trouble in which wanting and knowing are not enough, and which Scripture answers with grace, not with a method. A skills map can describe the pattern and cannot say who forgives.
7. Why the church practises more than skills
If these five places are real, we should not be surprised that the church has never been content with skills alone. Look at what it actually does.
Worship. In worship a person addresses God. It is not first of all a way of improving the self; it is a turning of the face. The person is met by someone who is not themselves.
Sacraments or ordinances. Christians understand baptism and the Lord’s Supper (called by various names, among them the Eucharist or Holy Communion) in different ways, and this course does not decide between those ways. But in every tradition they are things received: the person does not achieve them as a skill. They are signs that something is given.
Confession. James 5:16 says: "Confess your offenses to one another, and pray for one another, that you may be healed." Some traditions practise it privately before a priest, others before the congregation or a trusted friend, and others mainly before God. In every case it deals with what no change of thinking can reach, which is real guilt.
Fasting. The body is included. Hunger, restraint and prayer together train a person’s desires, and they point beyond oneself. It belongs to the practices discussed in lecture 3-1, but its purpose is to turn the person toward God, not to produce a result.
Fellowship. The letter to the Hebrews says: "not forsaking our own assembling together, as the custom of some is, but exhorting one another; and so much the more, as you see the Day approaching" (Hebrews 10:25). A person is not meant to be alone with a thought, or with a sorrow. The community prays, listens, eats and waits together.
These practices are not techniques for solving problems, and they should not be turned into techniques. They do shape the person by repetition, as lecture 3-1 said. But they are first of all ways in which a person is met by God and by other people. That is why they can hold what skills cannot: grief, the dead of night, the guilty conscience, the question with no answer. Psalms 34:18 says that Yahweh is near to those who have a broken heart. Nearness is not a method.
8. More than stimulus and response
The learning map pictures a person as one who responds to what happens. The cognitive map pictures a person as one who interprets what happens. Both are true in part. But Christians say more. A person is made in the , is accountable, can love and be loved, can be forgiven, and has a name known to God. That is why a person cannot be fully described by what has been learned or by how they read their days.
9. Knowing the edge
A carer who knows where the two maps end is safer to others. You will not try to use a skill where a presence is needed. You will not give an explanation where silence is better. You will not try to treat what only a trained professional can help with. And when something is beyond you, you do not need to feel that you have failed. Connecting a person to a qualified professional is a part of caring for them, not a refusal to care. If you are worried about someone’s safety, stay with them, call your local emergency number, and do not leave them alone. In the United States, the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline is available, and other countries have their own crisis lines.
10. A map, not the person
The learning map and the cognitive map are good maps. They have a place in understanding how people change. But they are maps of the parts of the ground that can be reached by practice and by thought. The rest of the ground — grief, deep wounds, wrong done, mystery, sin and grace — needs other things: company, protection, truth, prayer and forgiveness, and in some cases trained professional help.
Diagram 1. Where habit and thought run out
Diagram 2. What the church practises, and what each is for
| Practice | What it is first of all | What it is not |
|---|---|---|
| Worship | Turning the face toward God | A method of self-improvement |
| Sacraments or ordinances | Signs of something given and received | Skills achieved by effort |
| Confession | Bringing real guilt into the open to be forgiven | A reframing of the facts |
| Fasting | Including the body in prayer | A technique for producing results |
| Fellowship | Not being alone with a sorrow or a thought | Group therapy |
In short
- The learning map and the cognitive map are useful, and both run out where the trouble is not a pattern or a reading.
- Grief, trauma, injustice, mystery, and sin and grace each call for more than skills or better thoughts.
- Psalms 88 ends in darkness and is still prayed by the church, and Romans 7 ends its cry with a person, not a method.
- Worship, sacraments or ordinances, confession, fasting and fellowship are first of all ways of being met, not techniques.
- A carer who knows where the maps end connects the person to a qualified professional when something is beyond them.
- A person is more than stimulus and response: made in God’s image, accountable, and able to be forgiven.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Five places the maps run out | Grief, trauma, injustice, mystery, and sin and grace. |
| Psalms 88 | A prayer that ends in darkness, kept by the church: a prayer without a resolution is still a prayer. |
| Romans 7:24-25 | A cry for deliverance answered by a person, not a skill. |
| Church practices | Worship, sacraments or ordinances, confession, fasting, fellowship: ways of being met, not techniques. |
One sentence to remember A person is more than stimulus and response, and some of what people carry needs company, truth and forgiveness more than skill.
This week's action Read Psalms 88 slowly, and note that it gives you permission to pray without finishing on a happy note.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Why is it a mistake to treat sorrow over a real loss as a problem to be corrected? What does a grieving person more often need?
- Psalms 88 ends in darkness and is still in the church’s book of prayer. What does that tell you about how the church sees honest sorrow?
- In Romans 7:24-25, Paul cries for deliverance and the answer is a person. How is that different from a skills answer?
- Which of the five practices (worship, sacraments or ordinances, confession, fasting, fellowship) is most familiar in your tradition? How do you see it as something received, not just practised?
- Why is connecting a person to a qualified professional a part of care, not a refusal to care?