Lecture 4-2: Meaning and Existence
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: A Map Is Not the Ground
- Lecture 1-2: Scripture and Psychology: The Positions
- Lecture 1-3: Questions to Ask of Any Theory
- Lecture 1-4: Why This Matters for Those Who Care
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Own Map
- Lecture 2-1: The Psychodynamic Tradition
- Lecture 2-2: Attachment
- Lecture 2-3: Images of God and Early Relationships
- Lecture 2-4: Hidden Motives and the Heart
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Reading One Scene Two Ways
- Lecture 3-1: Behaviour and Learning
- Lecture 3-2: Cognitive Theories
- Lecture 3-3: Renewing the Mind: Cognitive Approaches and Scripture
- Lecture 3-4: What Habit and Thought Cannot Reach
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Same Event, Two Readings
- Lecture 4-1: The Person-Centred Approach
- Lecture 4-2: Meaning and Existence
- Lecture 4-3: Story and Solutions
- Lecture 4-4: Three Gifts, Three Cautions
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: How Do I Listen?
- Lecture 5-1: Family Systems
- Lecture 5-2: Culture, Society and Context
- Lecture 5-3: The Church as a System
- Lecture 5-4: Seeing Wider
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Drawing a Web
Some questions do not go away. Why am I here? What is my life for? What will be left when I die? Does any of this matter? People ask them at funerals and at weddings, after a diagnosis or a job loss, and sometimes late at night for no reason they can name.
A group of thinkers in the twentieth century made these questions the centre of their work on the person. They are often called existential approaches — "existential" here means concerned with the basic facts of being a human being alive: that we choose, that we die, that we are alone in some ways and together in others, and that we look for sense in our lives. This lecture looks at two voices in this group: Viktor Frankl, who wrote about the search for meaning, and Irvin Yalom, who described four deep concerns that every life meets.
The lecture follows the three steps used in this part of the course: what the theory says, what it explains and misses, and how it meets the Christian picture of the person. Keep the central claim in view: a theory is a map of the person, not the person. Do not use these ideas to diagnose yourself or anyone else. Care given in a church is not professional treatment. If a person speaks of ending their own life, this is not a moment for a theory about meaning: stay with the person, call your local emergency number, and connect the person to a qualified professional or a crisis line. In the United States the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline is available; other countries have their own lines, and you should find yours before you need it.
What these 22 minutes give you
- Explain in your own words Frankl's idea that people search for meaning, and the three ways he named of finding it.
- Name Yalom's four concerns — death, freedom, isolation and meaninglessness — and describe each at concept level.
- Describe what these approaches explain well and what critics say they miss.
- Set the existential questions beside Ecclesiastes, Job and the Psalms.
- State fairly the disagreement over whether meaning is made by the person or given.
Vanity of vanities,” says the Preacher; “Vanity of vanities, all is vanity.”" — Ecclesiastes 1:2
World English Bible
So teach us to number our days, that we may gain a heart of wisdom." — Psalms 90:12
WEB
So they sat down with him on the ground seven days and seven nights, and no one spoke a word to him, for they saw that his grief was very great." — Job 2:13
WEB
Three voices from Scripture ask the existential questions without hurrying to answer them. One says that everything is empty. One asks to learn how to count days. One sits in silence beside a man in grief. Read them as companions to the theories, not as proof texts for them.
1. What the theory says: Frankl
Viktor Frankl was an Austrian doctor who worked with people in distress. During the Second World War he was held in Nazi camps. After the war he wrote a short book, Man's Search for Meaning, which has been read all over the world. From his work and his experience he built a way of thinking called logotherapy — the word comes from logos, a Greek word that here means "meaning." You do not need to learn the treatment. What matters for this course is the picture of the person behind it.
Frankl's central claim was that the deepest drive in human beings is not pleasure and not power but a will to meaning: a need to find that one's life is for something. When a person cannot find any reason to go on, he said, other troubles grow worse. When a person has a "why," he or she can bear a great deal.
He named three broad places where meaning can be found.
- In what we do — in work, in creating something, in a task that matters to someone else.
- In what we receive or love — in an experience of beauty, truth or another person.
- In the stance we take toward suffering that cannot be avoided — in the way a person meets pain when nothing can change it.
Notice a careful point. Frankl did not say that suffering is good, or that people should look for it. His claim was narrower: if suffering truly cannot be avoided, a person still has some freedom in how he or she stands before it. A reader who turns this into "suffering is a gift" has changed what Frankl said and, more importantly, has said something that can wound a person in pain.
2. What the theory says: Yalom
Irvin Yalom, an American psychiatrist and writer, gathered a number of existential ideas into one plain list. He suggested that every human life meets four deep facts, which he called ultimate concerns. They are not illnesses. Everyone faces them, in different ways and at different times.
Death. We know that we will die, and that those we love will die. This knowledge can make us anxious. It can also make life seem more precious.
Freedom. We have to choose, and we are responsible for our choices. No one can live our life in our place. This can feel like a gift and like a weight.
Isolation. However close we are to others, there is a gap that nobody can fully cross: each person is, in some sense, alone inside his or her own mind. Yalom also described another kind, the sense of being cut off from other people.
Meaninglessness. If we are going to die and our choices are our own, what makes any of it matter? How can a being who needs sense live in a world that does not hand over its sense?
You can see how this list connects with Frankl. For Yalom, much human struggle can be understood as the different ways people turn away from these four facts or try to face them. This is a way of reading, not a test; nobody should treat the list as a tool for sorting people.
3. An everyday scene
(an invented example) Elena is fifty-eight. She has worked for thirty years in a clothing factory, and the factory is closing. Her children are grown. At the evening prayer group she says quietly, "I do not know what I am for now." The woman beside her begins, "God has a plan for you," but Elena looks away. A who has been listening says nothing at first. Then he says, "That sounds like a very big question to carry." Elena says, "It is." Later she talks about what she cared about in her work: the younger women she trained, the small pride in good stitching. Neither she nor the deacon is sure yet where this leads. But she has begun to speak about meaning in her own words, and not in someone else's slogan.
An existential reading would hear in that evening some of Frankl's three places (a task, a care for others) and one of Yalom's concerns (meaninglessness). A reader should hear it with care: Elena is a person, not an example of a theory.
4. What it explains
These approaches explain why some losses hurt in a particular way. The loss of a job, a spouse or a role is not only the loss of money or company; it can be the loss of the answer to "what am I for?" A carer who sees this will not hurry to fix a practical problem and miss the larger one.
They also explain why simple cheerfulness often fails. A person who is asking about meaning is not helped by being told not to worry. The existential tradition insists that the question is real and that a person has a right to ask it.
And they give a language for the whole of life. Many theories look at childhood or at illness. These look at the ordinary adult who is wondering whether life adds up. Some people find that language the first that fits.
5. What it misses
Critics raise several concerns, and they should be heard fairly.
First, the idea of meaning can be too individual. If meaning is something each person creates for himself or herself, then it is not clear what makes one meaning better than another. A life built around a cruel purpose is still a life with a purpose. The theory's supporters answer that Frankl himself held that meaning is found in the world and not simply invented, and that some meanings are better than others. Even so, later popular use of the idea often loses this point.
Second, the approach can sound as if people who cannot find meaning are failing at something. A person who is overwhelmed by pain may not be able to search for anything. The question "what is the meaning of this?" is sometimes cruel when it is put to someone who has just been bereaved or hurt.
Third, the ideas were drawn from a certain place and time: mainly European and North American writers, working with individuals, in a time of great upheaval. Cultures that think first of the family or the community will place the questions differently. Do not assume that all people everywhere state these four concerns as Yalom does.
Fourth, the existential map describes the questions better than it answers them. It says that people look for meaning; it is less able to say where meaning comes from. That is not a fault in a map of the person. But it means the map points beyond itself.
6. Where it meets the Christian picture of the person
Scripture asks the existential questions long before the twentieth century, and it is worth listening to how.
The book of Ecclesiastes opens with a voice that says all is "vanity" — a word that means breath, mist, something that cannot be held (Ecclesiastes 1:2). The Preacher asks what a person gains from his labour (Ecclesiastes 1:3). The book looks hard at death and at work that seems to come to nothing. Yet it also says that God has made everything beautiful in its time and has set eternity in human hearts (Ecclesiastes 3:11). The longing for meaning, in this reading, is not a sickness. It is part of what it is to be human.
The Psalms put death and time in front of God. "So teach us to number our days, that we may gain a heart of wisdom" (Psalms 90:12). The psalm begins with God as "our dwelling place for all generations" (Psalms 90:1) and goes on to say that our years pass quickly (Psalms 90:10). Here the facing of death is done in prayer, with someone to pray to.
The book of Job is a long study in the meaning of suffering, and its first lesson for a carer is a quiet one. When Job's three friends hear what has happened to him, they come, they weep, and they sit with him on the ground for seven days and seven nights without speaking, "for they saw that his grief was very great" (Job 2:13). That silence is the best thing they do. Later they begin to speak, to explain his suffering and to defend God, and the book does not treat their explanations as right. At the end God says to one of them, "you have not spoken of me the thing that is right, as my servant Job has" (Job 42:7). A careful reader takes this as a warning: it is easy to explain someone's pain; it is harder and more faithful to stay with it.
For this reason, do not use one verse to explain a person's suffering. A sentence like "all things happen for a reason" or "God needed another angel" placed on top of a grief may be spoken in love and still wound. Scripture itself holds protest, lament, silence and hope side by side, and no single verse is meant to close the question.
This is a point where readers will not agree. Some Christians welcome the existential stress on meaning, because it takes seriously a question that Scripture also takes seriously, and because it keeps a carer from offering answers too quickly. They see in Frankl's idea that meaning can be found even in unavoidable suffering an echo of what many believers have said of their own trials. Others are cautious. They warn that the claim "each person makes his or her own meaning" can conflict with the Christian view that human life has a meaning given by God, a meaning that is received before it is chosen. In their view a theory that puts the whole weight on the individual's choice can leave out the Creator who is the source of purpose, and can leave a suffering person to carry alone a task that only God can complete. Both views take the question seriously. This course requires only that you state each fairly, that you notice where a particular author means "found" and where he or she means "made," and that you do not use any verse as an explanation of someone's suffering in a sentence.
7. Care in a church, and a limit
A person who is asking about meaning may be having an ordinary, deep and healthy struggle. A person who says life is not worth living, or speaks of ending their life, is in a different situation, and a conversation about meaning is not enough. If you hear this: stay with the person, do not leave them alone, call your local emergency number if they may act now, and help them reach a qualified professional or a crisis line. In the United States the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline is available; elsewhere, find the local line in advance. Do not argue a person out of despair with a theory, and do not decide by yourself what lies behind it. Knowing these ideas does not make you a therapist; it helps you listen better and recognise when to bring in someone with training.
8. A map, not the person
The existential map is dark and honest. It draws the edge of the territory — death, loneliness, choice, emptiness — and does not pretend those edges are not there. That is a real service. But it is a map. It tells you where people stand when they ask what life is for; it does not tell you who the person in front of you is, or what God has said to that person. A theory is a map of the person, not the person.
Diagram 1. Frankl's three places and Yalom's four concerns
Diagram 2. What each voice does with the question
| Voice | Takes the question seriously by... | What a careful reader asks |
|---|---|---|
| Frankl | Naming a will to meaning and three places to find it | Is meaning found, or made? |
| Yalom | Listing four concerns every life meets | Who is the person who meets them? |
| Ecclesiastes | Saying "vanity" out loud, and also "eternity in their hearts" | Where does the book let the question rest? |
| Job's friends (2:13) | Sitting in silence for seven days | What changed when they began to explain? |
In short
- Frankl held that people have a will to meaning, and named three places to find it: what we do, what we love, and our stance toward unavoidable suffering.
- Yalom named four concerns every life meets: death, freedom, isolation and meaninglessness.
- These approaches explain why some losses hurt, and why cheerful answers fail.
- Critics warn that meaning can become something each person simply makes, and that "find your meaning" can wound the suffering.
- Ecclesiastes, Psalms and Job ask the same questions; no single verse should be used to explain a person's suffering.
- If a person speaks of ending their life, stay, call the emergency number, and connect to a crisis line or professional.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Frankl's central claim | People have a will to meaning; meaning can be found in doing, in loving, and in the stance taken toward unavoidable suffering. |
| Yalom's four concerns | Death, freedom, isolation, meaninglessness. |
| Main criticism | Meaning may be treated as personal creation; the search can sound like a duty laid on the suffering. |
| Job 2:13 | Presence and silence came first; explanation came later and was judged wrong. |
One sentence to remember The question of meaning is real and deserves company before it deserves an answer.
This week's action Next time someone tells you about a loss, resist the urge to explain it. Stay with what they say and ask one question that invites them to say more.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Frankl named three places where meaning can be found. In which of the three do people around you most often look?
- Why is it a mistake to say "suffering is a gift"? What did Frankl actually claim?
- Yalom lists death, freedom, isolation and meaninglessness. Which of these do you think is hardest to talk about in your church, and why?
- What do Job's friends do well in Job 2:13, and what changes later? What does it teach a carer?
- State the two views on whether meaning is made or given, each as its holder would, in two or three sentences.