Lecture 3-2: Cognitive Theories
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: A Map Is Not the Ground
- Lecture 1-2: Scripture and Psychology: The Positions
- Lecture 1-3: Questions to Ask of Any Theory
- Lecture 1-4: Why This Matters for Those Who Care
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Own Map
- Lecture 2-1: The Psychodynamic Tradition
- Lecture 2-2: Attachment
- Lecture 2-3: Images of God and Early Relationships
- Lecture 2-4: Hidden Motives and the Heart
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Reading One Scene Two Ways
- Lecture 3-1: Behaviour and Learning
- Lecture 3-2: Cognitive Theories
- Lecture 3-3: Renewing the Mind: Cognitive Approaches and Scripture
- Lecture 3-4: What Habit and Thought Cannot Reach
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Same Event, Two Readings
- Lecture 4-1: The Person-Centred Approach
- Lecture 4-2: Meaning and Existence
- Lecture 4-3: Story and Solutions
- Lecture 4-4: Three Gifts, Three Cautions
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: How Do I Listen?
- Lecture 5-1: Family Systems
- Lecture 5-2: Culture, Society and Context
- Lecture 5-3: The Church as a System
- Lecture 5-4: Seeing Wider
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Drawing a Web
Lecture 3-1 looked at what people have learned. This lecture asks a different question. Two people can go through the same event and come out feeling quite differently. What stands between the event and the feeling?
The cognitive theories give one answer: the way the person reads the event. The word cognitive means "to do with thinking, knowing and interpreting." A cognitive theory says that people are interpreters. They do not simply receive events; they make sense of them, quickly and often without noticing, and the sense they make shapes what they feel and do.
This is one of the most influential ideas in modern counselling theory. It is also easy to misuse. In this lecture we look at what the idea says, at two well-known thinkers who developed it, at what it shows and what it misses, and at the first steps of a conversation with Scripture, which lecture 3-3 will continue.
Please note at the start: this lecture explains ideas. It does not teach any technique, and the everyday examples of thinking habits in it are not a list of signs. Every human being takes mental shortcuts. Do not use anything here to diagnose yourself or another person.
What these 19 minutes give you
- Explain in your own words how a cognitive theory understands the link between an event, a thought and a feeling.
- Describe Ellis’s three-part ABC picture and give an invented example of it.
- Describe what Beck meant by thinking errors, and say why they are ordinary rather than signs of a condition.
- State what the cognitive map shows, and give two things it misses, including the case where the person’s reading is correct.
Keep your heart with all diligence, for out of it is the wellspring of life." — Proverbs 4:23
World English Bible
The Bible often speaks of the heart as the centre from which a life flows. This does not mean the Bible teaches a cognitive theory. It does mean that the question "what is going on inside the person that shapes what comes out?" is an old and respectable question. Lecture 3-3 will set the cognitive map beside Scripture in more detail.
1. What the cognitive map says
Let us fill in the four parts of a theory again.
The picture of the person. A person is an interpreter. In every moment the person is reading the situation: what it means, whose fault it is, what will happen next, what it says about me. Most of this reading is quick and automatic.
Why trouble comes. Trouble comes, in part, when the reading is heavily one-sided, too rigid or too harsh, and the person does not notice that it is a reading. The feeling seems to come straight from the event. In fact there is a step in between.
What changes people. Noticing the reading, and testing it. Asking, "What evidence do I have? Is there another way to see this?" A reading that is examined may change, and the feeling and action may change with it.
The role of the carer. In this map the helper is something like a patient questioner, who helps the person see their own reading.
Two thinkers did the most to build this map, and it helps to know their names.
2. Ellis and the ABC
Albert Ellis was an American psychologist who developed an approach he called rational emotive behaviour therapy. We need only one of his ideas, which is often summed up as the ABC:
- A is the activating event: what happened.
- B is the belief: how the person reads what happened.
- C is the consequence: the feeling and the action that follow.
The usual way of speaking runs straight from A to C: "She made me angry." "That news made me anxious." Ellis’s point was that B stands between them. Two people at the same A may reach very different Cs, because their Bs differ.
Here is an everyday scene.
(an invented example) Ana sends a friend a message about a church supper. The friend does not answer for two days. In the first reading, Ana thinks, "She is busy this week; she will reply when she can." She feels a little impatient and does nothing. In the second reading, Ana thinks, "She is tired of me. I have said something wrong." She feels hurt and stops writing to her.
The event is the same. The feelings and the next steps are different, and what separates them is the reading.
Ellis also drew attention to a particular kind of reading: the rigid demand. Thoughts that run on words like must, should and never, such as "I must always be liked" or "people must treat me fairly", can turn ordinary disappointment into a heavy burden, because life does not keep such rules. This is one of the ideas of Ellis that has been widely taken up, and you will recognise it in everyday sayings about expecting too much of ourselves.
3. Beck and thinking errors
Aaron Beck was an American psychiatrist whose work gave rise to what is now widely called cognitive therapy. He noticed that people often have quick, automatic thoughts running through their minds in a situation, thoughts that appear without being chosen and that seem simply true. He also described common patterns in which such thoughts go wrong. These are often called thinking errors, or cognitive distortions.
It is important to understand what this phrase means and what it does not. The thinking errors are not rare mistakes made by unwell people. They are shortcuts that every human mind takes at times, especially when tired, anxious or hurt. To make this plain, here are four ordinary ones, each in everyday words.
- All or nothing. "I forgot one name at the welcome table. I am a complete failure at hospitality."
- Jumping to a conclusion. "He did not greet me this morning, so he is angry with me." (Perhaps he did not see you.)
- Making it worse than it is. "If the sound system fails today, the whole service is ruined."
- Taking it personally. "The meeting ended early. It must be because of what I said."
Every reader has probably done each of these this month. That is the point. They are a part of being human, not a sign of anything in particular. A student must never read this list as a checklist for judging another person’s mind. If you catch yourself thinking, "that is what she does, so she must be…", stop. That is the exact move this course warns against.
4. What the cognitive map explains well
- It explains why the same event feels different to different people. This matches ordinary experience. Two members of one congregation listen to one sermon; one feels warmed and one feels accused.
- It takes the person’s own mind seriously. The person is not a puppet of habit or of the past. They have a reading, and the reading can be examined.
- It offers hope. If a reading is part of the problem, then the situation is not simply fixed. The reading may be looked at again.
- It is gentle in its method. The usual style is a question, not a lecture: "What makes you think so? What else might it be?"
- It has been studied a great deal. There is a large body of research on cognitive approaches. This course does not quote figures, but you may fairly say that this is one of the most widely studied families of ideas in counselling.
5. What the cognitive map misses
An honest account must be just as clear about the limits.
Some readings are correct. Ana’s second reading may be true. The friend may really be pulling away. A person who believes "my employer is cheating us" may be right. If the reading is accurate and the pain is fitting, telling the person to think differently is not help. It is a way of asking them to deny what is so.
Real loss is not a thinking mistake. A person whose child has died is not mistaken in feeling grief. The grief is not caused by a wrong belief and will not be cured by a better one. To suggest otherwise is cruel.
Wrong done to a person is not cured by new thoughts. If someone has been mistreated, cheated or abused, the matter is one of justice, safety and protection. A person in that position needs the wrong to be named as wrong and, where there is danger, needs protection. They do not need to be told that their pain is a matter of how they see it.
It can quietly add blame. If a carer or a church treats every sorrow as a thinking problem, the sufferer hears: "You are sad because you are thinking badly." Now the person carries two burdens: the sorrow, and the guilt of having a wrong thought about it.
It can look only at the individual mind. A person’s reading is also shaped by family, community, money, work and culture. A map that looks only inside the head will miss what lies around it. (Week 5 returns to this.)
It leaves out the body and the relationship. Sleep, illness, hunger and pain colour how things look. A person who feels weighed down for a long time may need a doctor, not an argument. If you think that may be so, your task is to encourage them toward a qualified professional, not to name what is wrong.
Finally, notice a feature of this lecture itself. We have not taught how to challenge a thought. That is a skill, practised by trained people, and a short lecture cannot give it to you. Knowing the idea helps you to understand and to listen; it does not equip you to treat anyone.
6. The first steps toward Scripture
How does this map meet the Christian picture of the person? Lecture 3-3 gives it the space it needs, but here are three first observations.
First, the Bible has no difficulty with the idea that people interpret events and that interpretations matter. Scripture is full of people reading the same event differently: those who saw a sign and those who saw only a wonder, those who heard good news and those who heard a threat. Proverbs 4:23 asks the reader to guard the heart because a life flows out from it.
Second, the Bible’s word heart is larger than the cognitive map’s word belief. In Scripture the heart includes desire, will, loyalty and love, not only opinions about events. A person may hold a correct belief and still be pulled in the wrong direction. A map that speaks only of beliefs will capture part of the heart, not all of it.
Third, the Bible does not treat every painful feeling as a mistake in thinking. Many psalms are cries of grief and anger addressed to God, and they are given to the church as prayers. A theory that sorted such cries into "wrong thinking" would meet a very old objection from Scripture itself. We will see more of this in lectures 3-3 and 3-4.
7. A map, not the person
The cognitive map teaches that between the event and the feeling there is a reading. That is a real and valuable insight, and it can make a listener more patient: when someone reacts strongly, there may be a reading behind it that you cannot yet see.
But it is a map. It does not show the loss that is genuinely a loss, the wrong that is genuinely a wrong, the body that is tired, or the God who is near to the brokenhearted. Do not use it to diagnose, and do not use it to hurry a person out of their pain. If a person says they want to harm themselves or someone else, a theory is not the answer. Stay with them, call your local emergency number, and connect them with a qualified professional.
Diagram 1. The ABC: same event, two readings
Diagram 2. Strengths and limits of the cognitive map
| What it shows well | What it misses |
|---|---|
| The same event can be read in different ways | A reading that is accurate, with pain that fits |
| The reading can be noticed and questioned | Grief, injustice and abuse, which are not thinking mistakes |
| Everyone takes mental shortcuts, so no one is singled out | The body, the family, the money and the culture around the person |
| A listener can be patient with strong reactions | The heart in Scripture, which is more than belief |
In short
- The cognitive map says that between an event and a feeling stands the person’s reading of the event.
- Ellis’s ABC: the event (A), the belief or reading (B), and the consequence in feeling and action (C).
- Beck’s thinking errors are ordinary mental shortcuts that every person takes at times; they are not a checklist for judging anyone.
- The map explains why the same event feels different to different people, and it treats the person’s own mind seriously.
- It misses the reading that is accurate, real loss, wrong done to a person, the body, and the world around the person.
- This lecture teaches an idea, not a technique, and it cannot be used to diagnose.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Ellis’s ABC | A is the event, B is the person’s reading of it, C is the feeling and action that follow. |
| Thinking errors (Beck) | Ordinary mental shortcuts, such as all-or-nothing thinking; not signs of a condition. |
| What the map shows | The same event can be read in different ways, and a reading can be noticed and questioned. |
| What it misses | Accurate readings, real loss, wrong done to a person, the body and the surrounding world. |
One sentence to remember Between the event and the feeling stands a reading, but some pain is not a mistake in thinking at all.
This week's action Notice one small moment when you reacted before you had checked your reading of what happened, and write down one other possible reading.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- In the invented scene of Ana, what other readings could there be besides the two given? What would the other person actually need to say to settle the matter?
- Why is it important that the "thinking errors" are described as ordinary shortcuts, and not as signs of a condition?
- Think of a case where the reading of an event is correct and the pain is fitting. What would it mean to answer that person with "think differently"?
- How might a church unintentionally add blame to a person who is already suffering, by treating sorrow as a mistake in thinking?
- In what ways is the Bible’s word *heart* larger than the word *belief*?