Lecture 2-3: Conscience, Resistance and the Limits of Obedience
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: Is Faith Private?
- Lecture 1-2: What Public Theology Is, and Who Has Done It
- Lecture 1-3: Church and State: Patterns
- Lecture 1-4: Speaking in a Plural Square: Public Reason and the Language of Faith
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Place I See Public Life From
- Lecture 2-1: What Scripture Says About Authority
- Lecture 2-2: Justice, the Common Good and Freedom
- Lecture 2-3: Conscience, Resistance and the Limits of Obedience
- Lecture 2-4: Crime, Punishment and Restorative Justice
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: My Relation to Authority
- Lecture 3-1: Wealth, Work, Sabbath and Jubilee in Scripture
- Lecture 3-2: Markets, Property and the Poor: Voices of the Traditions
- Lecture 3-3: Work, Vocation and Stewardship
- Lecture 3-4: Poverty, Charity and Justice: Giving and Changing Structures
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: My Work and My Money
- Lecture 4-1: Human Dignity and Human Rights
- Lecture 4-2: The Neighbour and the Stranger: Hospitality
- Lecture 4-3: War and Peace
- Lecture 4-4: Racism, Prejudice and One Humanity
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Neighbour Beside Me
- Lecture 5-1: Caring for Creation
- Lecture 5-2: Culture, Media and the Arts
- Lecture 5-3: Witness in a Plural Society and the Freedom of Religion
- Lecture 5-4: Civil Society and Education: The Church Among Associations
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: The Community I Belong To
Lecture 2-1 found that Scripture asks for honour toward authority and also shows refusals. This lecture asks the question that follows: how far does obedience go, and when, if ever, may a Christian refuse, resist or break a law? The church has argued about this for almost two thousand years. The argument is not finished, and the course does not finish it.
We look first at how four older teachers (Augustine, Aquinas, Luther and Calvin) answered, each from his own tradition. We then separate four kinds of response, from conscientious objection to armed resistance. We look at the pacifist traditions, and at three historical cases that Christians still study: the Barmen Declaration, Dietrich Bonhoeffer and Martin Luther King Jr. They are cases from the past. We pull none of them into a verdict about any government today.
이 28분으로 얻는 것
- Describe, in general outline, how Augustine, Aquinas, Luther and Calvin each spoke of unjust rulers and the limits of obedience.
- Explain the difference between conscientious objection, civil disobedience, nonviolent resistance and armed resistance.
- Describe the pacifist traditions' reasons, and the questions put to them.
- Describe three historical cases briefly, using only what is certain, and say why none of them is a rule.
- State fairly three positions on how far resistance may go, each with its strength and its weak point.
The king of Egypt spoke to the Hebrew midwives, of whom the name of the one was Shiphrah, and the name of the other Puah, and he said, “When you perform the duty of a midwife to the Hebrew women, and see them on the birth stool; if it is a son, then you shall kill him; but if it is a daughter, then she shall live.” But the midwives feared God, and didn’t do what the king of Egypt commanded them, but saved the baby boys alive. The king of Egypt called for the midwives, and said to them, “Why have you done this thing, and have saved the boys alive?” The midwives said to Pharaoh, “Because the Hebrew women aren’t like the Egyptian women; for they are vigorous, and give birth before the midwife comes to them.” God dealt well with the midwives, and the people multiplied, and grew very mighty. Because the midwives feared God, he gave them families." — Exodus 1:15-21
World English Bible
Shadrach, Meshach, and Abednego answered the king, Nebuchadnezzar, we have no need to answer you in this matter. If it happens, our God whom we serve is able to deliver us from the burning fiery furnace; and he will deliver us out of your hand, O king. But if not, let it be known to you, O king, that we will not serve your gods, nor worship the golden image which you have set up." — Daniel 3:16-18
WEB
You have heard that it was said, ‘An eye for an eye, and a tooth for a tooth.’ But I tell you, don’t resist him who is evil; but whoever strikes you on your right cheek, turn to him the other also. If anyone sues you to take away your coat, let him have your cloak also. Whoever compels you to go one mile, go with him two. Give to him who asks you, and don’t turn away him who desires to borrow from you. “You have heard that it was said, ‘You shall love your neighbor, and hate your enemy.’ But I tell you, love your enemies, bless those who curse you, do good to those who hate you, and pray for those who mistreat you and persecute you, that you may be children of your Father who is in heaven. For he makes his sun to rise on the evil and the good, and sends rain on the just and the unjust. For if you love those who love you, what reward do you have? Don’t even the tax collectors do the same? If you only greet your friends, what more do you do than others? Don’t even the tax collectors do the same? Therefore you shall be perfect, just as your Father in heaven is perfect." — Matthew 5:38-48
WEB
What the text says. In Exodus 1, two midwives disobey the king's command to kill the Hebrew baby boys, because they feared God, and God deals well with them. In Daniel 3, three men refuse to serve the king's gods or to worship his image, and say that God is able to deliver them, and that even if he does not, they will not worship. In Matthew 5, Jesus quotes the old rule of an eye for an eye, tells his hearers not to resist the one who is evil, and gives examples: a cheek, a coat, a mile. He then tells them to love their enemies, bless those who curse them and pray for those who mistreat them, so that they may be children of their Father.
A tradition's reading. Many Christians have read the first two as examples of conscientious refusal, narrow, public and accepted at cost. The third has been read in several ways: as a rule for every situation, so that Christians never use force; as a rule for the believer's own personal wrongs and not for the duty of an officer who protects others; as a description of active, nonviolent ways of answering injustice with dignity; and as a call to love the enemy even while restraining the wrong he does.
Our judgement. Both the refusals and the sermon end up asking for something hard, which is neither obedience at any price nor a plan to win by force. The question of how these texts guide a situation of grave injustice is one on which Christians have disagreed, and we shall state the disagreement fairly.
1. Teachers of obedience who also taught limits
It is sometimes said that the older Christian tradition simply told people to obey. That is not accurate. The teachers who most strongly valued order also set limits to it.
Augustine wrote in the fourth and fifth centuries, when the Roman empire had become friendly to the church. He taught that Christians should use and seek the earthly peace, and that obedience to rulers is part of this. He also held that a law contrary to justice is hardly a law at all, and that there is a point at which a believer cannot do what is commanded. He was cautious about armed rebellion, and he never held that any government was the kingdom of God.
Thomas Aquinas, in the thirteenth century, taught that a human law gets its force from reason and the common good. A law may be unjust in three ways: if it aims at the ruler's advantage and not the common good, if the ruler goes beyond his authority, or if it spreads burdens unfairly. Such a law does not bind in conscience, unless obeying it is needed to avoid a greater disorder or scandal. A law that commands what is contrary to God's law may never be obeyed. About the tyrant, Aquinas was cautious: he preferred remedies by public authority and not by private persons, and he warned that the cure by rebellion can be worse than the disease.
Martin Luther, in the sixteenth century, spoke of two kinds of rule, which later writers called the two kingdoms or two governments. In his view God rules the world through temporal authority, which keeps order by the sword, and also rules through the word and the gospel, which touch the conscience. The ruler has real authority in the first, and none over what people are to believe. Where a ruler commands what is against God, Luther said, one must refuse, and suffer the penalty, but not take up arms against him. He wrote sharply against armed revolt in the 1520s. Later Lutheran writers in the mid-sixteenth century argued, in a different situation, that lower magistrates have a duty to resist a ruler who attacks the true faith, which shows that the tradition did not stay in one place.
John Calvin, also in the sixteenth century, held that rulers are set in place by God and that private persons are not to resist, even a bad ruler, since God judges him and may raise up others to remove him. But he added two limits. First, obedience to a ruler must never be at the price of obedience to God; where the two clash, Calvin said, the ruler gives way. Second, he held that where a people have magistrates appointed to restrain the king's power (he named old examples from Sparta, Rome and Athens, and spoke of the assemblies of his own day), those magistrates would betray their duty if they stood by while the powerful trampled the people. Later Reformed writers built on this to argue for resistance led by lower officers.
Taken together, these four did not give one answer. They agreed that obedience has limits, and that the limit is at least a command to sin. They differed over what may be done beyond refusal, who may do it, and with what means.
2. Four kinds of response
Four terms help, and they are often confused.
Conscientious objection is refusing to do a particular act, for example to bear arms, to swear an oath, or to take part in a ceremony, because it would be a sin. The person accepts that there may be a penalty, or asks for a lawful exemption where one exists.
Civil disobedience is the open, deliberate breaking of a law, usually by nonviolent means, to bear witness against an injustice or to call a community to change. Those who practise it usually accept the penalty openly, in order to show that they respect the legal order as a whole while refusing one wrong.
Nonviolent resistance is a wider term. It includes protest, boycott, strikes, public speech and refusals to cooperate, all without harming people.
Armed resistance is the use of violence against an unjust power. It is the most contested, and the traditions that allow it do so only under strict conditions.
There is also something the early church called martyrdom. The word martyr means a witness. Christians who suffered and died rather than deny Christ, or do what was forbidden, were counted as witnesses. This is not a method of resistance, but it shows an old Christian pattern: to refuse, and to endure, without striking back.
3. The pacifist traditions
Some Christian traditions hold that Christians must not take part in violence at all. The best known are the Mennonites, who come from the Anabaptist movement, the Quakers, who arose in the seventeenth century, and the Church of the Brethren. Their reasons are drawn above all from the Sermon on the Mount and the example of Jesus on the cross, and from the early church's refusal of the sword.
Historians disagree about how widely the earliest Christians refused military service; some writers from the early centuries opposed it, and other evidence shows Christians within the army. Nobody can say with certainty that the whole early church was pacifist, or that it was not.
The pacifist traditions are not a retreat from public life. Many have worked for relief and for reconciliation and have accepted costs in refusing to bear arms, such as imprisonment. Where the law allows alternative service, many have chosen it. The questions put to them, by Christians from other traditions, are serious. What of the neighbour who is being attacked and could be saved by force? Is refusing violence a refusal of responsibility? Their replies are also serious. Jesus gave us the way of love of enemies and of suffering, and we do not have to calculate results; and there are active, nonviolent ways of protecting a neighbour that are too seldom tried. The traditions that allow force (the just war tradition, taken up in a later week) take another view of the neighbour's protection. We do not rank them.
4. Three historical cases
These three cases are widely studied. They are given only briefly, and only with what is certain. We use them to think with, and they are not rules.
The Barmen Declaration. In 1934, in Germany, delegates from several Protestant churches (Lutheran, Reformed and united) met at Barmen and issued a statement, drafted in large part by the Swiss-born theologian Karl Barth. It said that Jesus Christ, as witnessed in Scripture, is the one Word of God that the church must hear and obey, and it rejected the idea that the church could take its message or its order from any other lord or from the political movement of the time. The statement is not a call to revolt. It is a confession about who has the final claim on the church. It was an act of refusal by speech. The wider history of the churches in that period, including what many did not do, has been studied with great seriousness by Christians since.
Dietrich Bonhoeffer. Bonhoeffer was a Lutheran pastor and theologian in Germany. He was part of the Confessing Church, which stood behind statements like Barmen. He taught and led a training seminary for pastors in a time when this was against the authorities' wishes. In later years he became involved with people who were working to end the regime by other means. He was arrested in 1943 and executed in 1945. Christians have read his path in different ways. Some see in it a rare and costly example of responsible action. Others say it was an exceptional case that does not guide ordinary decisions. Bonhoeffer himself, in his writings, seemed to accept that one who acts in responsibility may take guilt upon himself and must rely on God's grace. It is a mistake to turn his story into a rule that anyone may apply.
Martin Luther King Jr. King was a Baptist minister who became a leading figure in the civil rights movement in the United States in the 1950s and 1960s. He led nonviolent campaigns and drew on the teaching of Jesus and on the example of Gandhi's nonviolence. In 1963 he wrote the Letter from Birmingham Jail, answering clergy who had urged him to wait. In it he argued that a law out of line with God's justice is not a just law, citing Augustine and Aquinas, and that one who breaks such a law openly and accepts the penalty shows the highest respect for law. He was killed in 1968. Even in his own time, Christians disagreed about his methods and his timing, and honest study includes those disagreements.
A fourth example from another setting. In the early twentieth century, when the Korean peninsula was under Japanese colonial rule, Christians took part in the independence movement of 1919. In the 1930s the authorities required participation in shrine ceremonies, which many Christians understood to be worship of something other than God. Historians record that some churches and believers refused and suffered for it, and that others complied, for reasons that included fear, pressure and an argument that the ceremonies were only civic. Korean churches have continued to study and to debate this memory. We mention it as an example of a church facing a requirement that touched worship, not as a model of how to judge any person.
Notice what these cases do and do not show. They show that the question of limits has been real, costly and argued in several traditions. They do not show that any one method is right, and they do not tell us what to do in a different place and time.
5. A conscience that can err
A refusal made from conscience is serious, but conscience is not infallible. Aquinas held that a person must follow conscience even when it is mistaken, and that one has a duty to form it well. The Reformed and Lutheran traditions also hold that conscience is bound by the word of God, not by one's own feeling. So the questions below are useful, whatever one's tradition.
(An invented example.) A village teacher is told to begin each day by reading aloud a statement that she believes to be false. If she refuses she may lose her post, which supports her family. She asks herself:
- Is the command plainly against what God commands, or is it something I only dislike? A false statement read as one's own is not the same as a rule one finds foolish.
- Have I asked for counsel? From Scripture, from a pastor, priest or , from someone who disagrees with me.
- Have I tried lesser steps? An explanation, a petition, a request to say it differently.
- Can I act openly and accept the cost, and who else will bear it? Her family, her pupils.
- What is my spirit? Is it love of neighbour, including the one who gave the order, or is it anger?
The questions do not decide for her. They protect her from acting in haste or in pride, and from failing to act out of fear.
6. Where readers will not agree
This is a point where readers will not agree: how far a Christian may go in resisting an authority that commands or does grave wrong. We give three positions. None is the whole of any tradition.
The first holds that the Christian may refuse what is sinful, say so plainly, and bear the penalty, but may not go further. Its strength is that it follows the pattern of the midwives, Daniel's friends and the apostles, and keeps the church from being drawn into violence and the pride of judging when a ruler has failed. Its weak point is that it can seem to leave the weak to suffer when stronger means might have saved them, and the church has at times used it to excuse silence.
The second holds that Christians may also use active, nonviolent resistance, including open civil disobedience, to call a society to justice. Its strength is that it joins love of enemies with a refusal to cooperate with evil, and it has a long witness behind it. Its weak point is that, in the eyes of critics, breaking a law can weaken respect for law in general, and the judgement that a law is unjust can be made carelessly.
The third holds that armed resistance may be justified as a last resort, under strict conditions, when a power is gravely and persistently unjust and every other means has failed. Its strength is that it takes seriously the protection of the innocent, and has roots in Aquinas and in Calvin's lower magistrates. Its weak point is that the conditions are very hard to meet, violence is hard to control, and the pacifist traditions say that Jesus's way excludes it.
What this course requires is that you can state each position as its holders would, name what it protects and what it risks, and explain why the cases in this lecture do not settle the matter. It does not ask you to choose, and it does not apply any of them to a government today.
Diagram 1. A ladder of responses
핵심 요약
- Augustine, Aquinas, Luther and Calvin taught obedience and also set limits; they agreed that a command to sin may not be obeyed.
- They differed over what may be done beyond refusal, who may do it, and with what means.
- Four responses are distinguished: conscientious objection, civil disobedience, nonviolent resistance and armed resistance.
- The Mennonite, Quaker and Brethren traditions refuse violence on the ground of the Sermon on the Mount and the cross.
- Barmen, Bonhoeffer and King are historical cases to think with; none is a rule, and Christians have read each differently.
- Conscience can err and must be formed by Scripture, tradition and counsel; the course asks for a fair statement of positions, not a choice.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Conscientious objection | Refusing one act that would be sin, and accepting the penalty or a lawful exemption. |
| Civil disobedience | Open, deliberate, usually nonviolent breaking of a law as witness, accepting the penalty. |
| Common ground of the four teachers | A command to sin may not be obeyed; they differed on how far resistance may go. |
| Why the cases are not rules | They were different times and places, they are read differently, and each is an argument, not a formula. |
One sentence to remember Christians agree that obedience has limits, and disagree about how far refusal may go, so state each position fairly before you judge.
This week's action Read Acts 5:17-42 slowly, and list what the apostles refused, what they accepted, and how they spoke.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Name one limit that Augustine, Aquinas, Luther or Calvin set on obedience. How does it differ from a limit set by another of them?
- What is the difference between conscientious objection and civil disobedience? Give an invented example of each that does not name any real country.
- What are the pacifist traditions' reasons, and what questions are put to them? What do they reply?
- Why does the lecture say that Barmen, Bonhoeffer and King are cases to think with and not rules to follow?
- Choose two of the three positions in the contested paragraph and state each as its holders would, with its strength and its weak point.