Lecture 3-2: Markets, Property and the Poor: Voices of the Traditions
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: Is Faith Private?
- Lecture 1-2: What Public Theology Is, and Who Has Done It
- Lecture 1-3: Church and State: Patterns
- Lecture 1-4: Speaking in a Plural Square: Public Reason and the Language of Faith
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Place I See Public Life From
- Lecture 2-1: What Scripture Says About Authority
- Lecture 2-2: Justice, the Common Good and Freedom
- Lecture 2-3: Conscience, Resistance and the Limits of Obedience
- Lecture 2-4: Crime, Punishment and Restorative Justice
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: My Relation to Authority
- Lecture 3-1: Wealth, Work, Sabbath and Jubilee in Scripture
- Lecture 3-2: Markets, Property and the Poor: Voices of the Traditions
- Lecture 3-3: Work, Vocation and Stewardship
- Lecture 3-4: Poverty, Charity and Justice: Giving and Changing Structures
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: My Work and My Money
- Lecture 4-1: Human Dignity and Human Rights
- Lecture 4-2: The Neighbour and the Stranger: Hospitality
- Lecture 4-3: War and Peace
- Lecture 4-4: Racism, Prejudice and One Humanity
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Neighbour Beside Me
- Lecture 5-1: Caring for Creation
- Lecture 5-2: Culture, Media and the Arts
- Lecture 5-3: Witness in a Plural Society and the Freedom of Religion
- Lecture 5-4: Civil Society and Education: The Church Among Associations
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: The Community I Belong To
Lecture 3-1 looked at what Scripture says. This lecture looks at how Christian traditions have spoken about property, trade and the poor since then. It does not recommend an economic policy and does not name any political party, government or economist. It describes a map of emphases, meaning the things each tradition keeps in view, and it asks what each emphasis protects and where it is weak.
The lecture covers five voices: the Catholic teaching that goods are meant for everyone while private property is still legitimate; the Reformed and Lutheran stress on work as vocation (taken up fully in lecture 3-3); voices that defend markets, voices that criticise markets, and voices that mix the two; the phrase "preferential option for the poor" in liberation theology (one sentence only, since the course World Christian Theology covers it at length); and the diversity of evangelical and Pentecostal views, including the debate over the prosperity message. It then takes up a question on which readers will not agree: how far can theology judge an economic system at all?
이 24분으로 얻는 것
- Explain the Catholic idea that goods are meant for all people, and how it sits beside private property.
- Describe, fairly, a view that defends markets, a view that criticises them and a view that mixes them, each with a strength and a weak point.
- Explain the prosperity message and the main criticism and reply, without naming any person or church.
- State two or three positions on whether theology can judge economic systems, each in its strongest form and with its weak point.
- Say why the claim of "the biblical economic system" needs a named weak point.
The rich and the poor have this in common: Yahweh is the maker of them all." — Proverbs 22:2
World English Bible
But godliness with contentment is great gain. For we brought nothing into the world, and we certainly can’t carry anything out. But having food and clothing, we will be content with that. But those who are determined to be rich fall into a temptation and a snare and many foolish and harmful lusts, such as drown men in ruin and destruction. For the love of money is a root of all kinds of evil. Some have been led astray from the faith in their greed, and have pierced themselves through with many sorrows." — 1 Timothy 6:6-10
WEB
Come now, you rich, weep and howl for your miseries that are coming on you. Your riches are corrupted and your garments are moth-eaten. Your gold and your silver are corroded, and their corrosion will be for a testimony against you, and will eat your flesh like fire. You have laid up your treasure in the last days. Behold, the wages of the laborers who mowed your fields, which you have kept back by fraud, cry out, and the cries of those who reaped have entered into the ears of the Lord of Armies. You have lived delicately on the earth, and taken your pleasure. You have nourished your hearts as in a day of slaughter. You have condemned, you have murdered the righteous one. He doesn’t resist you." — James 5:1-6
WEB
What the text says. Proverbs 22:2 says that the rich and the poor have this in common: the Lord is the maker of them all. First Timothy 6:6-10 says that godliness with contentment is great gain, that we brought nothing into the world, that those determined to be rich fall into temptation, and that the love of money is a root of all kinds of evil. James 5:1-6 tells the rich to weep over coming miseries, says their gold and silver have corroded, and says that the wages kept back by fraud from the labourers who mowed their fields cry out.
A tradition's reading. Catholic and Orthodox writers have read passages like these as a warning that wealth held with no regard for the poor is a moral danger. Many Protestants have read them in the same way, and have also pointed out that the love of money, not money itself, is named as the root. Some read James 5 as a judgement on particular employers who cheated, and not on every owner; others read it as a standing warning to anyone who holds wealth.
Our judgement. These three passages warn about the heart, about fairness in wages and about forgetting that rich and poor share one Maker. They do not tell us whether a market, a tax or a welfare programme is a good thing. That question needs other kinds of knowledge as well as Scripture.
1. Two different questions
When Christians talk about economic life they often mix two questions. The first is: What does God care about in economic life? Scripture and the tradition speak to this clearly: honest dealing, fair wages, care for the poor, a heart not ruled by money, work with dignity, rest. The second is: Which arrangement of markets, property, taxes and help does best what God cares about? Scripture does not answer this directly, and honest Christians have given different answers. This lecture keeps the two questions apart. The traditions are quite close on the first, though they put the weight in different places. They are more divided on the second.
2. Property and the goods of the earth: the Catholic outline
Catholic social teaching is the body of teaching in which popes and bishops have, since the late nineteenth century, applied Christian principles to social and economic life. The first great letter in this line, written by a pope in 1891, defends the right to own private property and also the dignity of the worker and the idea that a wage must be just. Later documents of the twentieth century, including those of the Second Vatican Council, say more.
A key idea is called the universal destination of goods. It means that God made the earth and its goods for the use of all people. Private property is still a real and good right, since people care for what is their own, and it protects families. But the right is not unlimited. It serves a purpose that reaches beyond the owner, and those in need have a claim on what is held beyond need. This idea draws on older teaching. Thomas Aquinas in the thirteenth century held that private ownership is lawful and useful for the good ordering of things, but that in extreme need what is needed may be used for relief. Some early Christian preachers, such as Basil of Caesarea and John Chrysostom in the fourth century, spoke very sharply to the rich about what they held back from the poor.
What this protects: it keeps together two things that are easily set against each other, the right of a family to own and the claim of the poor. Where it is weak: it does not by itself say how much is "beyond need", or whether a state, a charity or each person should decide, and different Catholics, like other Christians, apply it differently.
3. Vocation and work
Luther and Calvin, in the sixteenth century, taught that ordinary work is a from God. Lecture 3-3 gives the detail. Here it is enough to note one effect on the economic debate. If ordinary labour is service to God and neighbour, then honest trade and craft have dignity, and a Christian view of the economy cannot only be about giving money away. It must also ask whether work is honest, fair and useful.
4. Voices that defend markets
A market is a place or system where people buy and sell by agreement. Some Christian thinkers defend markets in whole or in part. The strongest form of the argument goes like this. Exchange by agreement honours human freedom and responsibility. Property and reward for work give people reason to labour and to care for what they have. Enterprise has created goods that many people need. A system with many independent decisions can respect human dignity better than a system run from the centre. Some who make this argument add that charity and a moral culture need to be strong beside the market.
Its weak point, as others state it: a market serves those who can take part, and does not by itself care for those who cannot. Exchange can treat people only as buyers, sellers or labour. Wealth can turn into power over others. Some of the claims made for markets are claims about what happens in the world, and these can be tested and do not rest on theology.
5. Voices that criticise markets
Others criticise markets, in part or in whole. The strongest form goes like this. A system built on competition and profit can teach people to see neighbours as rivals or as resources. It can make labour a commodity, and it can leave families without security. It tends to shape what people want, and it may put some goods, such as time, care or the earth, to the price test and nothing else. Scripture's concern for the poor, the stranger and the debtor suggests limits on what may be bought and sold and on how much inequality is tolerable.
Its weak point, as others state it: critics may underrate how much voluntary exchange and enterprise have helped ordinary people, and may not say clearly what they would put in its place and what that would cost. Some arrangements proposed against markets have also harmed the poor.
6. Voices that mix
Many Christians, probably most, do not take either side whole. They hold that markets are useful tools within moral limits, and that other institutions (families, churches, local associations, courts, governments) do work that markets do not do. The Catholic teaching of subsidiarity, the idea that a matter should be settled at the smallest level that can handle it well, belongs in this family, as does Kuyper's idea of separate social spheres, which Week 1 introduced. Its strength is that it avoids a single answer for every problem. Its weak point is that it can be vague: "a balance" may hide the very question in dispute, which is where the balance falls.
7. One sentence on liberation theology
uses the phrase preferential option for the poor: the idea that God has a special care for the poor, and that the church and its theology should stand beside them. The course World Christian Theology treats this tradition at length. For this course it is enough to say that the phrase has been taken up beyond that tradition, in Catholic teaching and by many others, and that Christians differ about what it asks in practice.
8. Evangelical and Pentecostal views
Evangelical and Pentecostal Christians are many and different. Some stress that the gospel is first the good news of salvation and that the church's chief work is to proclaim it. Others, in a statement made at an international gathering of evangelicals in the 1970s, said that the church's social responsibility is also part of Christian duty. Some work closely on relief and development. Some speak in favour of free enterprise and some against particular features of it. There is no one evangelical or Pentecostal economic view. A reader who meets a person from this family should ask what that person holds and not assume.
9. The prosperity message
The prosperity message, also called the prosperity gospel, is a family of teachings that hold that God wills the financial blessing and good health of faithful believers, and that faith, confession and giving are ways of receiving them. It is not one organised view, and many who use the language of blessing do not hold its strongest forms.
Those who hold it give reasons. The Bible speaks of God blessing his people with material good, and a faith that says nothing about daily needs seems thin. The poor are often told only to endure, and this message gives them hope and dignity and a reason to work and plan. It has been taken up in many parts of the world, among people who are not rich, as a way of saying that poverty is not God's last word.
Its critics, from many traditions, give reasons too. They point to 1 Timothy 6:6-10, to the cross of Christ and to the many faithful believers who are poor or sick, and say that the message turns faith into a way of getting things. They fear that it blames the poor and the ill for a lack of faith, and that it can press people to give more than they can. They also say it reflects the desires of a consumer culture more than the gospel.
What defenders reply is that critics often attack the harshest forms and ignore the ordinary ones, that the poor are not helped by a theology that praises poverty, and that care for the whole person, body as well as soul, is biblical.
Where does this course stand? It does not rule on any church or person. It asks that the strongest form of the message be stated fairly, and that the questions raised by its critics be answered by the same standard, the whole of Scripture, including its words on money and on suffering.
(An invented example.) A church in a city that has grown richer within one generation has older members who remember hunger and younger members who do not. The older members say that when they hear a sermon about God's provision, it is a living hope, because they know what it is to lack. The younger members say that the same words sound to them like a promise that faith produces a good job and a house. They ask whether the church is being faithful to the verses about contentment. Both groups are listening carefully to the same text from different places, and a good conversation would let each say what the words have meant to them.
This is a point where readers will not agree: whether and how far theology can judge economic systems. One view holds that theology can judge systems by what they do to persons: whether they protect dignity, care for the poor, honour work and keep power accountable. Its strongest argument is that if God cares about wages, land and debts, as the prophets show, then the church cannot say nothing about the structures that shape them. Its weak point is that these judgements depend on facts about how economies behave, and theologians may not know those facts, so the judgement can pass for theology when it is really a guess about economics. A second view holds that theology gives principles, such as dignity, honest dealing and the care of the poor, but not verdicts on whole systems, and that the verdicts belong to a careful weighing of evidence by those with the knowledge. Its strongest argument is that it respects both Scripture's limits and the technical nature of economic questions. Its weak point is that "principles only" can be used to avoid any hard judgement, and every system also shapes people's lives in ways that theology has some right to question. A third view holds that Christians should say little about systems in public and concentrate on the life of the church and on works of mercy. Its strongest argument is that the church's first task is to be a community that shows another way of living. Its weak point is that it may seem to leave the public life of the poor to others. This course requires only that you state each view fairly, say what you are claiming from Scripture and what you are claiming from experience or evidence, and do not describe any one economic arrangement as the biblical system without naming where that claim is weak. Where a believer's conclusions differ from yours, the same fairness applies.
10. Is there a biblical economic system?
Some teachers say there is, and that it can be found in the Bible. Some point to the Jubilee, some to the tithe, some to the sharing in Acts, some to the freedom to own and trade assumed in many parables. As a claim made by some, it deserves to be heard in its strongest form: Scripture does contain laws about land, debt, wages and trade, and it is odd to say that God has nothing to say about them. But the weak point is clear. Different teachers find different systems in the same texts, and the laws were made for a people in a particular society. This course reports the claim as something some Christians make and names its weak point. It does not say that Scripture is silent, and it does not say that Scripture sets one system.
Diagram 1. A map of emphases, not a ranking
핵심 요약
- Two questions must be kept apart: what God cares about in economic life, and which arrangement serves it best.
- Catholic teaching holds that private property is a real right and that the goods of the earth are meant for all.
- Some Christians defend markets, some criticise them and many mix; each view protects something and has a weak point.
- The prosperity message has defenders and critics, and each should be stated at its strongest.
- Readers disagree on how far theology can judge an economic system.
- "The biblical economic system" is a claim some make; it needs a named weak point.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Universal destination of goods | The Catholic teaching that God made the earth for all, so private property is a right that serves a wider purpose. |
| Three emphases on markets | Defend, criticise, mix; each protects something and has a weak point. |
| Two questions | What God cares about (clear), and which arrangement serves it best (honestly disputed). |
| Biblical economic system | A claim some make; different teachers find different systems in the same texts. |
One sentence to remember Scripture and the traditions are clear about what God cares about in economic life, and honestly divided about which arrangements serve it best.
This week's action Write one view about markets that you disagree with, in the words a thoughtful holder of it would use, including its strength.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- What is the difference between asking what God cares about in economic life and asking which arrangement serves it best? Why does the lecture keep them apart?
- Explain the universal destination of goods. How does it sit beside the right to own property?
- Give the strongest case for one of the three views of markets, and then the weak point that others raise.
- What does each side say about the prosperity message, and what would it mean to state the other side fairly?
- How far do you think theology can judge an economic system? Which of the three views in the contested paragraph do you find hardest to state fairly?