Lecture 6-4: A Map of Where Believers Disagree: Course Synthesis
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: Is Faith Private?
- Lecture 1-2: What Public Theology Is, and Who Has Done It
- Lecture 1-3: Church and State: Patterns
- Lecture 1-4: Speaking in a Plural Square: Public Reason and the Language of Faith
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Place I See Public Life From
- Lecture 2-1: What Scripture Says About Authority
- Lecture 2-2: Justice, the Common Good and Freedom
- Lecture 2-3: Conscience, Resistance and the Limits of Obedience
- Lecture 2-4: Crime, Punishment and Restorative Justice
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: My Relation to Authority
- Lecture 3-1: Wealth, Work, Sabbath and Jubilee in Scripture
- Lecture 3-2: Markets, Property and the Poor: Voices of the Traditions
- Lecture 3-3: Work, Vocation and Stewardship
- Lecture 3-4: Poverty, Charity and Justice: Giving and Changing Structures
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: My Work and My Money
- Lecture 4-1: Human Dignity and Human Rights
- Lecture 4-2: The Neighbour and the Stranger: Hospitality
- Lecture 4-3: War and Peace
- Lecture 4-4: Racism, Prejudice and One Humanity
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Neighbour Beside Me
- Lecture 5-1: Caring for Creation
- Lecture 5-2: Culture, Media and the Arts
- Lecture 5-3: Witness in a Plural Society and the Freedom of Religion
- Lecture 5-4: Civil Society and Education: The Church Among Associations
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: The Community I Belong To
This course has met many questions on which believers do not agree. In each lecture we stated the positions in their strongest honest form, named the weak point of each and asked the student to do the same. This lecture collects them on one map. It is a map, not a verdict: it shows where the disagreements lie, what the main positions are, what each protects and what each is asked, and it does not say which is right.
The lecture then looks at what the disagreements have in common, shows how a person can hold a view while listening to others, gives a short list of books to read next and says how to go on learning. It returns to the claim the whole course has served: the church is called out of the world and sent for the world, and a theology of public life is not baptising one political or economic line.
이 31분으로 얻는 것
- Name the main questions of the course on which believers differ, and state the main positions on at least five of them fairly.
- Say what the disagreements have in common: the reading of Scripture, facts versus principles, who judges and who bears the cost.
- Hold a view on a contested question while stating the strongest case for another, and say what you would ask yourself before changing your mind or not.
- Explain how the course's central claim fits together with the fact of honest disagreement.
- Choose one way to go on learning, such as a book, a listening conversation or a service to a neighbour.
There is one body, and one Spirit, even as you also were called in one hope of your calling; one Lord, one faith, one baptism, one God and Father of all, who is over all, and through all, and in us all." — Ephesians 4:4-6
World English Bible
After these things I looked, and behold, a great multitude, which no man could number, out of every nation and of all tribes, peoples, and languages, standing before the throne and before the Lamb, dressed in white robes, with palm branches in their hands. They cried with a loud voice, saying, “Salvation be to our God, who sits on the throne, and to the Lamb!”" — Revelation 7:9-10
WEB
Not for these only do I pray, but for those also who believe in me through their word, that they may all be one; even as you, Father, are in me, and I in you, that they also may be one in us; that the world may believe that you sent me. The glory which you have given me, I have given to them; that they may be one, even as we are one; I in them, and you in me, that they may be perfected into one; that the world may know that you sent me, and loved them, even as you loved me." — John 17:20-23
WEB
What the text says. Paul writes that there is one body and one Spirit, one hope, one Lord, one faith, one baptism and one God and Father of all. John pictures a crowd that no one could count, from every nation, tribe, people and language, standing before God and crying out in praise. Jesus prays, in the Gospel of John, for those who will believe through the word of his disciples, that they may all be one, so that the world may believe that the Father sent him. A tradition's reading. Christians have read these passages as the ground of the church's unity: a unity given by God, not made by our agreement. Some stress that the unity is already real in Christ and is to be shown. Others stress that it is a goal for which the church must work and pray. The traditions differ about what visible form it should take, and they have been divided over it. Some read the prayer in John as asking that the unity be so plain that the world will notice it. Our judgement. These passages do not say that believers will agree on every public question. They say that believers are one in Christ, and that this oneness is part of the witness. The course asks that we hold our differences inside that unity, and that we argue as people who belong to one another.
1. How to use the map
The map below is built from the lectures of this course. It lists only questions that the lectures themselves treated as matters on which honest believers differ. It does not list everything on which people disagree about public life. It also does not claim that the positions given are the only ones, or that a tradition holds exactly one of them. In almost every case, believers in the same church hold different views, and many hold views between the ones given.
Each row gives: the question; the main positions, in a few words; a strength that its holders would claim for the position; and a criticism that is raised against it. Some rows set out a strength and a criticism for each position. Read the longer treatment in the lecture named before relying on the short form. A short form always leaves something out.
2. Week 1: Faith in the Public Square
| Question (lecture) | Main positions | Strength claimed | Criticism raised |
|---|---|---|---|
| How far should a church, as a church, take part in politics? (1-1) | Keep to worship, teaching and care; speak as a church on public justice; form members and speak as a church only when the gospel is at stake | Freedom and welcome for all; faithfulness to the prophets; formation of citizens | Silence can favour the strong; hard to tell gospel from a favourite plan; "when" may be settled by the loudest |
| Should the laws of a country be shaped by the Christian faith, or should state and church be separate? (1-3) | A nation acknowledges God and draws laws openly from the tradition; strict separation; the state endorses no faith but welcomes all | Honesty that no law is neutral; protection of conscience and church; fairness and openness | Others may feel pressed; faith seems shut out of citizens' reasoning; hard to apply when groups' beliefs clash |
| Should believers put convictions into shared terms, or speak in faith's own language? (1-4) | Translate into shared terms; speak in faith's language; speak both ways by setting | Courtesy and open debate; honesty and distinctiveness | May hide real reasons and treat "shared" as neutral; may sound like a claim of authority |
3. Week 2: Politics and Authority
| Question (lecture) | Main positions | Strength claimed | Criticism raised |
|---|---|---|---|
| How does Romans 13:1-7 relate to the passages of refusal? (2-1) | Plain subjection with refusal only where obedience would sin; authority defined by its purpose; a particular kind of subjection that refuses and accepts the cost | Takes the words seriously; fits the refusals; joins Romans 12 and 13 with the cross | Used to ask for silence; who judges when a ruler has failed; enough guidance when order hurts others |
| What is the proper task of government? (2-2) | A real responsibility for the common good, acting where smaller groups cannot; a limited task of order and justice; the church's first act is a different way of life | Care for the weak; limits on power; clear witness | A wide state may grow too large; a limited state may not protect the weak; may give too little guidance |
| How far may a Christian resist an authority that does grave wrong? (2-3) | Refuse and bear the penalty; nonviolent civil disobedience; armed resistance as a last resort | Follows Scripture's refusals; joins love of enemies with refusal; protects the innocent | May leave the weak to suffer; breaking a law may weaken respect for law; conditions are very hard to meet |
| May the state take the life of a person convicted of grave crime? (2-4) | May, in grave cases; should not; just in principle but not to be used in practice | Weight of a life and of justice; and repentance; weight of crime and weakness of judgement | Genesis 9:6 may not be a command to a court; the tradition mostly accepted it; hard to say what is safe enough |
4. Week 3: Economy and Work
| Question (lecture) | Main positions | Strength claimed | Criticism raised |
|---|---|---|---|
| Are the Jubilee and the early church's sharing models for economic life today? (3-1) | God's own pattern for an economy; given to a community, not a programme for a state; principles that shape conscience without prescribing a system | Rooted in creation and exodus; Scripture does not make the move to a plan; shapes choices | Tied to a system of family land; may leave the texts with no public force; principles need judgement |
| How far can theology judge an economic system? (3-2) | Judge systems by what they do to persons; give principles but not verdicts; a mixture | If God cares about wages and land the church cannot be silent; verdicts need evidence | May pass a guess about economics as theology; may leave principles with no force |
| Are an employer's and a worker's duties matters of conscience, agreement or law? (3-3) | Go beyond the minimum; enforceable rules; form honest people and leave rules to others | God's concern for wages; the labourer's cry; formation | Those who most need protection may have none; rules may harm; may leave the rules to others |
| Should the church put relief first or work for structural change? (3-4) | Relief first; structural change; both | The hungry cannot wait; the prophets speak of yokes and bonds; both side by side in Scripture | Causes stay in place; facts about societies disputed; "both" does not say how to weigh them |
5. Week 4: People and Neighbours
| Question (lecture) | Main positions | Strength claimed | Criticism raised |
|---|---|---|---|
| What are the roots of human rights? (4-1) | Stress Christian roots; stress the Enlightenment and other streams; say the question is too large | Accounts for the growth of ideas of dignity; takes the actual history seriously | Same societies tolerated slavery and torture; may overlook Christian shaping and Christian reformers |
| How far does the duty to welcome the stranger go beside the responsibilities of a political community? (4-2) | The duty of welcome first; the responsibilities of a political community first; many hold a mixture | Seriousness about the person in front of us; realism about order and the poorest at home | A duty without a plan shifts costs; "common good" can refuse almost everyone |
| May Christians take part in war? (4-3) | Just war; pacifism; tragic necessity | Protects the endangered; loyalty to the Sermon on the Mount; honesty about moral cost | Conditions bent to the fighters' interests; protecting a neighbour who is attacked; can become an excuse |
| How should churches speak about group injustice, and what does repair mean? (4-4) | Name group and structural injustice and pursue repair; speak chiefly of personal sin and unity in Christ; act locally and concretely with those affected | Honesty about how wrongs outlast persons; protection of the individual and zeal for unity; practicality and humility | May blame people for what they did not do, and be vague about repair; may leave inherited injustice unexamined; may avoid larger questions of law |
6. Week 5: Creation, Culture and Civil Society
| Question (lecture) | Main positions | Strength claimed | Criticism raised |
|---|---|---|---|
| How should the human toward creation be read: dominion or care? (5-1) | Dominion is the main word; care is the main word; both are needed and the question is what to do when they pull apart | Takes the text's own word seriously and protects the place of the human person; joins Genesis 1 to Genesis 2 and Psalm 24; honest about a real tension | Dominion has excused harm; care may shrink the needs of the poor; may leave a reader without an answer |
| How should a church stand toward the surrounding culture? (5-2) | Stand apart; bless and find Christ in it; build on its good; live in tension; work to transform it | Keeps the gospel's sharpness; feels at home; values reason and art; honest about a good and fallen world; gives reason to engage | May overlook the community's own faults; may lose the gospel's power to judge; may settle too quickly what is good; may leave no guidance; may become a plan for control |
| How far does religious freedom reach in public life? (5-3) | Reaches far, including public expression and exceptions for conscience; full freedom of belief and worship with equal public rules; strict public neutrality | A freedom that stops at the church door is hollow; equal treatment protects minorities; neutrality stops a majority pressing its faith | May collide with the rights of others; equal rules fall unevenly on some practices; neutrality may be impossible and asks believers to be different in public |
| Who is to educate the children? (5-4) | Parents first; the state has a duty to see every child educated; the church or faith community as a teacher in its own right | Protects the family bond and minority ways of life; opportunity for every child and shared citizenship; faith is learned in community | Some parents cannot provide, and the child has claims of their own; a single standard leaves out families who differ; a community school may limit what children meet and be hard to inspect |
7. Week 6: The Church's Public Witness
| Question (lecture) | Main positions | Strength claimed | Criticism raised |
|---|---|---|---|
| Should the pulpit speak on political questions? (6-1) | Scripture and gospel only; speak to public justice; teach principles and trust members | A home for those who differ; the prophets spoke to kings; forms people | Silence can bless wrong; hard to tell gospel from a plan; "when the gospel is at stake" can be decided by the loudest |
| May a believer ever speak sharply in public? (6-3) | Always gentle; sometimes plain and hard; ask about purpose and hearer | Scripture asks for gentleness; prophets and Jesus spoke strongly; asks who is served | Gentleness can silence the wronged; everyone thinks it is such a time; hard to apply |
8. What the disagreements have in common
Reading down the map, four things come up again and again. Noticing them makes a disagreement easier to understand.
First, the reading of Scripture. Many disagreements turn on how to read the same text. Romans 13 and Acts 5, the Jubilee and the Good Samaritan, Genesis 9:6 and the Sermon on the Mount are all read by people who honour the text. The question is often not "does Scripture matter?" but "how does this verse relate to those, and how far does it reach?" The course's three layers (what the text says, what a tradition has drawn from it, what I judge) are meant to help here.
Second, facts and principles. Many questions combine a principle (every person matters; the poor have a claim) with a judgement about facts (what will help the poor; what a policy would do). Two believers may share the principle and differ on the facts. A theologian is trained in principles, and may not know the facts, and it is honest to say so.
Third, who judges. Several questions ask who is to decide: when a ruler has failed, when a law is unjust, when the gospel is at stake, when the time for sharp speech has come. Each answer has a risk that the one who judges is partial, angry or mistaken. This is why the traditions have often asked that such judgements be made in community and with counsel, not alone.
Fourth, who bears the cost. In many of these questions the cost of a view falls on different people. The cost of too much welcome may fall on the poorest at home; the cost of too little falls on the stranger. The cost of silence falls on the powerless; the cost of speech may fall on a community's peace. A fair statement of a position names the cost it asks others to bear, and who they are.
9. Holding a view while listening
The course has not asked you to have no view. It has asked you to state other views fairly. Here is a way to hold both.
Know which kind of question it is. Some questions are matters on which the church has spoken with one voice for centuries, such as the worth of every person, and some are matters on which it has not. Treating the second kind as if it were the first is one of the quickest ways to wound a fellow believer.
Say the other's case first. Before giving your own view, state the case for the view you do not hold, in a form its holders would accept. You may find that it changes how you hold your own. At the least, you will hold it more gently.
Name your weak point. Every position on the map has one. If you cannot name the weak point of your own, you have probably not understood it.
Ask what would change your mind. This is not a trick. It is a way of finding whether your view rests on evidence, and what kind. If the answer is "nothing", ask whether you hold it as a conviction or as an identity.
Keep the table open. A believer who cannot sit at one table with those who differ has lost something the prayer in John 17 asks for. This does not mean that every disagreement can be left alone. It means that the first place to argue is at a table.
10. How this fits with the central claim
The claim of the course is that the church is a community called out of the world and sent for the world, and that a theology of public life is not baptising one political or economic line. It is discerning, in the light of Scripture and tradition, what justice and peace for the neighbour require, bearing witness with humility and truthfulness, and saying honestly where believers disagree.
The map is the last part of that claim in practice. A church that can say where its members differ, and can state each view fairly, is free of the temptation to call one line the faith. It can serve all its neighbours, it can speak where the gospel is plainly at stake, and it can listen where it is not. This is not weakness. It is a form of the humility and truthfulness the course has asked for.
11. Further reading
These are books a student might read next. Each is a well-known work on a topic we have met. Editions and translations vary, so look for a good current edition. Listing a book is not an endorsement of every claim in it, and the books disagree with one another.
- Augustine, The City of God. An early and very influential account of two loyalties, written in the early fifth century. Read selections first, since it is long.
- Martin Luther, Temporal Authority: To What Extent It Should Be Obeyed (1523). A short work in which Luther sets out how he thinks of earthly authority and the Christian's relation to it.
- H. Richard Niebuhr, Christ and Culture (1951). A study of several ways in which Christians have related faith to the culture around them.
- John Howard Yoder, The Politics of Jesus (1972). A statement from an Anabaptist-descended point of view of the church as itself a public community.
- Nicholas Wolterstorff, Until Justice and Peace Embrace (1983). A Reformed philosopher's reflection on justice, peace and the church's calling in the modern world.
- Oliver O'Donovan, The Desire of the Nations (1996). A study of political theology that draws on Scripture and the tradition.
- Pontifical Council for Justice and Peace, Compendium of the Social Doctrine of the Church (2004). A summary of Catholic social teaching, a good place to start with that tradition.
- Miroslav Volf, A Public Faith (2011). An argument for how Christians may speak and act in a plural society, written for general readers.
A student should read at least one work from a tradition different from his or her own.
12. How to go on learning
Reading is one way. There are others, and the course hopes you will take at least one.
- Listen to one person who differs from you. Not to argue. To ask what matters to them and why.
- Serve beside someone of another tradition. Shared work often teaches what discussion cannot.
- Read your own church's teaching on one topic from this course. Many students find that they know less of it than they thought.
- Keep a short note of what you changed your mind about. Even a small change is a sign that you are still learning.
- Return to Scripture without a question. Read a gospel through, with no public issue in mind, and see what the Lord says to you and not to your cause.
Follow local law and your community's written rules in whatever you do. And remember that every conversation is with a person for whom Christ died.
Diagram 1. Four things that run through the disagreements
Diagram 2. Reading the map: a short guide
| Step | What to do |
|---|---|
| Find the question | Which row is closest to the matter in front of you? |
| Read the long form | Open the lecture named; do not rely on the short form. |
| Separate the layers | What does the text say? What has a tradition drawn? What do I judge? |
| Find the kind of disagreement | Reading, facts, who judges, or who bears the cost. |
| State the other side first | In a form its holders would accept. |
핵심 요약
- The map lists the questions the lectures treated as contested, with the main positions, a strength and a criticism of each.
- The disagreements share four things: the reading of Scripture, facts and principles, who judges and who bears the cost.
- Holding a view while listening means saying the other case first, naming your own weak point and asking what would change your mind.
- The central claim and honest disagreement fit together: a church that can state where members differ is free to serve all its neighbours.
- A short list of well-known books gives a way to go on, and each reader should read one from a tradition other than their own.
- Learning goes on by listening, serving beside others, reading your own tradition and returning to Scripture without an agenda.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Four things that run through the disagreements | The reading of Scripture; facts and principles; who judges; who bears the cost. |
| Holding a view while listening | Say the other case first; name your own weak point; ask what would change your mind; keep the table open. |
| What the map does not do | It does not say which position is right, and it does not claim that every tradition holds exactly one. |
| How the map fits the central claim | A church that says honestly where believers differ is not baptising one line and is free to serve all its neighbours. |
One sentence to remember Believers are one in Christ and differ on many public questions, and the church's witness is helped when it says both plainly.
This week's action Pick one question from the map where you hold a view, and write the strongest case for the other side in a form its holders would accept.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Choose three questions from the map. For each, state two positions so that a holder of each would say you were fair, and name the strength and the criticism of each.
- Which of the four things that run through the disagreements (the reading of Scripture, facts and principles, who judges, who bears the cost) do you find most often in your own thinking?
- What is the difference between a matter on which the church has spoken with one voice and one on which it has not? Why does it matter to know which kind a question is?
- How would you explain to a friend why a church can say where its members differ without being weak?
- How do Ephesians 4:4-6 and John 17:20-23 help you hold your view while keeping the table open? What do they not say?