Lecture 5-2: Culture, Media and the Arts
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: Is Faith Private?
- Lecture 1-2: What Public Theology Is, and Who Has Done It
- Lecture 1-3: Church and State: Patterns
- Lecture 1-4: Speaking in a Plural Square: Public Reason and the Language of Faith
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Place I See Public Life From
- Lecture 2-1: What Scripture Says About Authority
- Lecture 2-2: Justice, the Common Good and Freedom
- Lecture 2-3: Conscience, Resistance and the Limits of Obedience
- Lecture 2-4: Crime, Punishment and Restorative Justice
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: My Relation to Authority
- Lecture 3-1: Wealth, Work, Sabbath and Jubilee in Scripture
- Lecture 3-2: Markets, Property and the Poor: Voices of the Traditions
- Lecture 3-3: Work, Vocation and Stewardship
- Lecture 3-4: Poverty, Charity and Justice: Giving and Changing Structures
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: My Work and My Money
- Lecture 4-1: Human Dignity and Human Rights
- Lecture 4-2: The Neighbour and the Stranger: Hospitality
- Lecture 4-3: War and Peace
- Lecture 4-4: Racism, Prejudice and One Humanity
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Neighbour Beside Me
- Lecture 5-1: Caring for Creation
- Lecture 5-2: Culture, Media and the Arts
- Lecture 5-3: Witness in a Plural Society and the Freedom of Religion
- Lecture 5-4: Civil Society and Education: The Church Among Associations
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: The Community I Belong To
Culture is what a people makes and shares: its language, stories, songs, buildings, food, jokes, festivals and the ways it argues. The media are the channels through which a culture speaks to itself, from a village crier to a printed page, a radio, a screen or a phone. Christians live inside a culture and also hold that the gospel judges every culture, so they have always had to decide how to stand toward the world of art and communication around them.
This lecture does four things. It sets out a well-known map of postures toward culture and its criticisms. It looks at how the church has used and feared the arts. It asks what truthfulness requires in an age when anyone can speak to thousands. And it asks about the responsibility of a speaker, whether a pastor, a teacher or an ordinary member who shares a message with friends. The lecture teaches no technique for using media and takes no side in any dispute about what a particular work of art, show or platform is worth.
이 25분으로 얻는 것
- Describe five postures toward culture in a well-known typology, and state one strength and one weak point of the typology.
- Explain, in general terms, why the church has both used and feared the arts, giving two examples.
- Say what Ephesians 4:25, Philippians 4:8 and Proverbs 31:8-9 ask of a Christian speaker.
- Apply a short set of questions to a message before sharing it.
- Say how a church can be truthful in public without treating its neighbours' culture as an enemy.
Therefore putting away falsehood, speak truth each one with his neighbor. For we are members of one another." — Ephesians 4:25
World English Bible
Finally, brothers, whatever things are true, whatever things are honorable, whatever things are just, whatever things are pure, whatever things are lovely, whatever things are of good report; if there is any virtue, and if there is any praise, think about these things." — Philippians 4:8
WEB
Open your mouth for the mute, in the cause of all who are left desolate. Open your mouth, judge righteously, and serve justice to the poor and needy.”" — Proverbs 31:8-9
WEB
What the text says. Ephesians 4:25 tells believers to put away falsehood and to speak truth with their neighbours, because they are members of one another. Philippians 4:8 gives a list of things to think about: what is true, honourable, just, pure, lovely and of good report. Proverbs 31:8-9 tells the hearer to open the mouth for those who cannot speak, and to judge rightly and serve justice for the poor and needy.
A tradition's reading. Many Christians have read Ephesians 4:25 as a rule for all speech, including speech in public, and not only for speech between church members. Philippians 4:8 has been read in two ways: as a reason to avoid works that dwell on what is ugly or false, and as a reason to look for what is true and lovely wherever it is found, in a church or outside. Proverbs 31:8-9 has been read as a call to advocate for people with little voice, and some traditions stress the task of speaking and others the task of making sure those people can speak for themselves.
Our judgement. These verses speak to the speaker and to the thinker. They do not name any art form, any medium or any work. When someone says that a verse proves that a particular film, song or platform is forbidden or required, the verse is being asked for more than it says.
1. What we mean by culture
Culture is the shared way of life of a people: the stories it tells, the songs it sings, the way it greets, cooks, buries and celebrates, and the things it admires or fears. No culture is only good or only bad. Each is made by people who bear God's image and who also fall short. For that reason Christians have rarely been able to say simply "yes" or "no" to a whole culture. They have said yes to some parts, no to others, and have disagreed with each other about which is which.
This week's principle is that Christians share the public world with people of other faiths and none, and that the line between witness and domination must be kept. Culture is the field where that line is tested every day: in what we watch, what we write, what we sing and what we pass on.
2. A well-known map of postures
In the middle of the twentieth century a theologian, H. Richard Niebuhr, wrote a book called Christ and Culture that described five typical ways in which Christians have related the two. It is widely read, and it is easily misused, so here it is with its limits. The five are described as "types", which means patterns, and Niebuhr himself said that no real person or church fits a type exactly.
- Christ against culture. The faithful community stands apart from the surrounding culture, whose values it counts as in conflict with Christ. Strength: it keeps the church's distinct life and the sharpness of the gospel's challenge. Weak point: it can overlook the ways the community itself uses the culture's language and tools, and it can slide into contempt for neighbours.
- The Christ of culture. The best of a culture is seen as the work of Christ, and Christ as the fulfilment of its hopes. Strength: it finds God's goodness in places the church had not looked, and it makes the gospel feel at home. Weak point: it can lose the gospel's power to judge and may simply bless whatever a society already admires.
- Christ above culture. Christ meets what is good in human culture and carries it further, adding what culture could not reach by itself. Strength: it values reason, art and learning and holds them together with revelation. Weak point: critics ask whether it settles too quickly what counts as the human good and who gets to say.
- Christ and culture in paradox. Both Christ and culture have real claims; the believer lives under both and feels the tension without resolving it. Strength: it is honest about how hard it is to live faithfully in a world that is both good and fallen. Weak point: critics ask whether it leaves the believer without guidance in the public world, or excuses a split between faith and daily work.
- Christ the transformer of culture. Culture is fallen but can be redeemed; Christians take part in changing it from within. Strength: it gives a reason for active engagement in art, work and civic life. Weak point: it can underrate how stubborn evil is, and can become a plan for control, which is where it meets this week's line between witness and domination.
The has had many critics. Some say it treats "culture" as one thing, when a culture is many things, some of them in conflict. Some say its reading of particular historical figures is open to question. Some say its five patterns are really five tendencies that appear in every Christian, in different moods or on different days. Another scholar, D. A. Carson, wrote a book that revisited and criticised it, and others have defended it. A student need not decide. It is a set of questions: Am I standing apart? Am I blessing? Am I building on? Am I living in tension? Am I trying to change? And a good second question is: Which of these is my community's habit, and which do we rarely ask?
(An invented example.) Four members of a church talk about a popular film that is being discussed in their city. The first says that the film shows the world's emptiness and that the church should have nothing to do with it. The second says that it asks questions that the gospel answers and that the church should invite its neighbours to talk about it. The third says that it is a fine piece of craft and that Christians should learn from its skill and also ask what its picture of a good life leaves out. The fourth says she is not sure and that she will watch, listen and pray. These four are not enemies. Each has a posture and a reason, and a church that can hear all four is probably wiser than one that hears only one.
3. The arts and the church
The church has used the arts for as long as it has existed, and has also feared them. Both are part of the record, and an honest lecture reports both.
On the side of use: the church has built places of worship and filled them with painting, carving, glass and cloth; it has made music, from chant and hymn to the many kinds of song sung in different places today; it has written poems, plays and stories; it has used images to teach people who could not read. Orthodox churches hold that icons are a way of confessing that God became visible in Christ, and they treat the making of an icon as a work of prayer. In the Lutheran tradition congregational singing has had a very large place. In many communities, the songs people sing in church are the main way the faith is learned by heart.
On the side of fear: the church has also worried that images, music and drama might take the place of God, or might stir the feelings in a way that leads away from the word. In the eighth and ninth centuries the Christian East argued bitterly over whether images could be used in worship at all, and the argument was settled, in the main, in favour of icons. Some Reformed churches of the sixteenth century removed images from places of worship and restricted the kind of music sung there. Other Christian communities have limited drama, dance or instruments in worship, for reasons that they can explain. Each of these decisions was made by sincere believers with reasons that came from Scripture and from experience, and a student who wants to understand them should ask for the reasons before forming a view.
A few questions can be asked of any use of the arts without settling which tradition is right.
- Does this work help people see something true, or does it hide something?
- Does it serve the worship of God and the good of the neighbour, or does it mainly serve the display of the maker?
- Who is left out of it, such as the poor, people who cannot read, people with different abilities, people from another language?
- Is the maker paid and treated fairly? (Follow local law and agreements.)
Philippians 4:8 gives a different kind of guidance. It does not list forbidden art. It asks believers to think about what is true, honourable, just, pure and lovely. That can be a reason to avoid what dwells on cruelty for its own sake. It can equally be a reason to praise a song or a story from a neighbour's tradition in which these things are found. Christians have used the verse both ways, and the course does not require either reading.
4. The media and the duty to tell the truth
For most of history a person could speak to the people within reach of the voice. Writing, printing, radio, television and the internet each widened the reach, and each brought new questions. Today a person with a phone can send a message to thousands of strangers in a minute. The tools differ in each region, and so do the laws about speech, so this lecture names categories only and does not assume any country's rules. Follow local law and your community's written rules.
Ephesians 4:25 gives a plain base. The reason it gives is that believers are members of one another. Falsehood damages the body, not just the person who is lied to. In a world of shared messages, it is easy to harm many people by passing on something that is untrue, even when we did not make it up. A rumour is a message that has not yet been checked. A true statement can also deceive: a photograph without its context, a quotation cut short, a figure without what it counts. The old rule against false witness reaches these as well.
Here is a short set of questions a speaker can put to a message before sharing it. They are a check, not a law.
- Do I know this is true, or do I only want it to be?
- Do I know where it came from, and could I say so?
- Does it name a real person or group, and is what I say about them fair and fully in context?
- Would I say it to the person's face?
- Who might be hurt if it is wrong, and who might be hurt even if it is right?
- Does it need to be shared at all?
(An invented example.) A member of a church sees a message in a group chat claiming that a local business has done something shameful. It is shocking, and it comes with a photograph. She feels she should warn others. Before sending it on, she asks the questions above and finds that she does not know where the picture came from or when it was taken. She decides to hold it. Later it turns out that the picture was old and from a different place. A pastor can hold up a case like this and say, without naming anyone, that a church can be a place where members learn the habit of checking before passing on. This is what it means to speak truth with a neighbour.
The same attention applies to a church's own communication. A church that advertises, posts online or tells stories about its own work is also a speaker. It is easy to exaggerate good news, to use a picture of a person without their knowledge, or to turn a person's hardship into a story that attracts support. A church should ask the people in its stories, and where they are children or in difficulty, should protect their privacy and follow local law and its own written rules. A person helped by a church is not a prop for its message.
5. The responsibility of the speaker
Proverbs 31:8-9 speaks to a person with a voice, and asks them to use it for those without one. It is easy to hear this as a call to speak for others. It also raises a question that careful Christians ask: Am I speaking for them, or helping them to speak? There are times when a person cannot speak and someone must. There are times when a group has its own voice and what it needs is to be heard, not replaced. A church that hears this verse well will ask the people concerned, check what it says, and be ready to be corrected.
The speaker's responsibility has four parts, and you may recognise them from earlier weeks.
- Truth. Say what you know, and say how well you know it.
- Fairness. State a view that you oppose in a form its holders would accept.
- Care. Think of those who will read and hear, including those hurt by the subject.
- Humility. Be ready to say "I was wrong", and to take down what you should not have said.
Preachers and teachers carry these in a particular way, because people trust what they say from the front. Week 6 returns to the pulpit. For now it is enough to say that a message from a church leader carries weight beyond the one who sends it, and that this is a reason for more care and not less.
6. Culture as a place of witness
Where does this leave the line between witness and domination?
Witness in culture takes the form of making and sharing good work, honest speech and generous attention to what neighbours make. It means being able to say what we love in a story and why. It means taking part in the arts and the media of our place as people who have something to give and something to learn. In a place where Christians are a minority, it may mean making things that stand beside the work of others without claiming to be the only voice.
Domination in culture takes the form of contempt, boycott or ridicule as a first move; of treating a neighbour's art or story as worthless; of using the media to shame people; or of using public power to silence what a church dislikes. The postures of the map above can each slip toward it: "against" can become contempt, "transformer" can become control. The guard against both is the one that runs through the course: speak truthfully, say where we disagree and treat the neighbour as a bearer of God's image.
No one posture is required. A church may stand apart on some things and take part on others, and different churches reach different decisions about what is good for them. What the lecture asks is that the decision be made with reasons, in the open, with an ear for those who see it differently.
Diagram 1. Five postures and one check before you share
핵심 요약
- A well-known typology describes five postures toward culture: against, of, above, in paradox and transforming; it is a set of questions and has many critics.
- The church has both used and feared the arts, and each choice came with reasons that a student should hear first.
- Ephesians 4:25 gives a base for public speech: speak truth, because we are members of one another.
- A rumour is a message not yet checked; a true statement can still deceive when it is cut from its context.
- A speaker owes truth, fairness, care and humility, and should ask whether to speak for others or help them speak.
- Witness in culture makes and shares good work; domination uses contempt, shame or power to silence.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Five postures | Against culture, of culture, above culture, in paradox with culture, transforming culture; patterns, not boxes. |
| Arts: use and fear | The church has filled worship with art and music, and has also limited images, music or drama for reasons that its own members can explain. |
| Truth in public speech | Ephesians 4:25: put away falsehood and speak truth, since we are members of one another; check before you share. |
| Speaker's four duties | Truth, fairness, care and humility. |
One sentence to remember Whatever our posture toward the culture around us, we owe our neighbours the truth, and we owe them the same fairness we ask for ourselves.
This week's action Before you next share a message, ask the six questions. If you cannot answer two of them, do not send it.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Describe two of the five postures in your own words. For each, give one strength and one weak point. Which does your community reach for first?
- Why have Christians both used and feared the arts? Give one reason from each side, and explain why a student should ask for the reasons before forming a view.
- What does Ephesians 4:25 add to the old rule against false witness when it says that we are members of one another?
- Apply the six questions to a message you have recently received. What would you do differently?
- How can a church take part in the arts and media of its place without moving from witness to domination?