Lecture 4-4: Racism, Prejudice and One Humanity
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: Is Faith Private?
- Lecture 1-2: What Public Theology Is, and Who Has Done It
- Lecture 1-3: Church and State: Patterns
- Lecture 1-4: Speaking in a Plural Square: Public Reason and the Language of Faith
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Place I See Public Life From
- Lecture 2-1: What Scripture Says About Authority
- Lecture 2-2: Justice, the Common Good and Freedom
- Lecture 2-3: Conscience, Resistance and the Limits of Obedience
- Lecture 2-4: Crime, Punishment and Restorative Justice
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: My Relation to Authority
- Lecture 3-1: Wealth, Work, Sabbath and Jubilee in Scripture
- Lecture 3-2: Markets, Property and the Poor: Voices of the Traditions
- Lecture 3-3: Work, Vocation and Stewardship
- Lecture 3-4: Poverty, Charity and Justice: Giving and Changing Structures
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: My Work and My Money
- Lecture 4-1: Human Dignity and Human Rights
- Lecture 4-2: The Neighbour and the Stranger: Hospitality
- Lecture 4-3: War and Peace
- Lecture 4-4: Racism, Prejudice and One Humanity
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Neighbour Beside Me
- Lecture 5-1: Caring for Creation
- Lecture 5-2: Culture, Media and the Arts
- Lecture 5-3: Witness in a Plural Society and the Freedom of Religion
- Lecture 5-4: Civil Society and Education: The Church Among Associations
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: The Community I Belong To
Prejudice, the habit of judging people by a group they belong to before knowing them, is as old as human communities. It takes many forms: against people of another ethnic group, another language, another caste or class, another faith, another region. In the last few centuries a particular form, usually called racism (the belief that humanity is divided into groups ranked by inborn worth, and the structures built on that belief), shaped large parts of the world. Many readers of this course have known prejudice from the receiving end, some have known it from the giving end without noticing, and many are not sure what words to use. This lecture is for all of them.
The lecture does not judge any country, group or living person, and it does not take a side on current political arguments. It does three things. It sets out Scripture's picture of one human family. It gives a short and honest historical account of how churches have both resisted and shared in prejudice. And it describes how Christian traditions speak of repentance, repair and belonging, including a point where readers will not agree: how churches should speak about group injustice and what repair means.
이 30분으로 얻는 것
- Explain what Acts 17:26, Ephesians 2:11-22 and Revelation 7:9 say about one human family.
- Describe, in general terms, how churches have both resisted and shared in prejudice, without turning the account into a verdict on any present group.
- Explain how the traditions speak of repentance, confession and repair.
- State fairly three ways of speaking about group injustice in the church, each with its strength and its weak point.
- Say what a local church can do to be a place of belonging, whatever its view on the contested point.
He made from one blood every nation of men to dwell on all the surface of the earth, having determined appointed seasons, and the boundaries of their dwellings, that they should seek the Lord, if perhaps they might reach out for him and find him, though he is not far from each one of us." — Acts 17:26-27
World English Bible
For he is our peace, who made both one, and broke down the middle wall of partition, having abolished in the flesh the hostility, the law of commandments contained in ordinances, that he might create in himself one new man of the two, making peace; and might reconcile them both in one body to God through the cross, having killed the hostility thereby." — Ephesians 2:14-16
WEB
There is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither slave nor free man, there is neither male nor female; for you are all one in Christ Jesus." — Galatians 3:28
WEB
After these things I looked, and behold, a great multitude, which no man could number, out of every nation and of all tribes, peoples, and languages, standing before the throne and before the Lamb, dressed in white robes, with palm branches in their hands." — Revelation 7:9
WEB
What the text says. In Acts 17, Paul tells the people of Athens that God made every nation of people from one, and set where they live, so that they would seek God. Ephesians 2:14-16 speaks of Christ breaking down a dividing wall and making one new humanity out of two groups, Jew and non-Jew, reconciled to God in one body. Galatians 3:28 says that those who belong to Christ are one, whatever their ethnic background, social standing or sex. Revelation 7:9 pictures a great crowd from every nation, tribe, people and language before the throne.
A tradition's reading. Christians have read these passages as the root of a conviction that the human race is one family and that the church is called to show this unity in its own life. Some readers stress the common origin in Acts 17; some stress the unity found in Christ, which they see first in the church (Ephesians 2, Galatians 3); some stress the future gathering in Revelation, which they take as a promise that makes present divisions provisional. Some readers add that the "wall" in Ephesians was a particular wall, between Jew and non-Jew in the first century, and caution against too quick a use of it for every other division; others reply that the principle (Christ makes one people of those who were enemies) reaches beyond its first case.
Our judgement. The passages say that humanity is one and that the church is a place where old hostilities are ended. They do not tell us which institutions, laws or practices of any society are unjust, nor how a church should repair a wrong of the past. Those are further questions. Scripture's picture gives the direction; it does not give the programme.
1. One human family in Scripture
The Bible's picture of humanity has a beginning and an end that matter here. At the beginning, all human beings come from one origin and bear God's image (lecture 4-1). Acts 17:26 draws the line out: the nations are many, and they have one source. Paul is speaking in a city proud of its own people, to hearers who had their own divisions of Greek and foreigner, and he tells them that they share one origin with those they considered outsiders.
At the end, Revelation 7:9 pictures a crowd that "no man could number" from every nation, tribe, people and language. Notice that the differences are not erased. The crowd comes from many nations and languages, and the passage does not say they have become the same. The picture is of unity with variety, not of a single culture. This is a gift to readers who worry that talk of one humanity must mean that everyone becomes alike.
In between, there is a story of division and its healing. In the first century, the biggest gap in the early church was between Jewish believers and non-Jewish believers. Many Jewish Christians held that the newcomers should keep the law of Moses; many non-Jewish Christians felt looked down on. Ephesians 2:11-22, which is worth reading in full, says that Christ has made the two one, ended the hostility between them, and built them together into one household of God. The letter is addressed to a church in which that unity was not easy, and it is written to say that it is already a fact in Christ and must be lived out. Galatians 2 tells of a time when even a leading apostle drew back from eating with non-Jewish believers out of fear of criticism, and Paul opposed him publicly, because the truth of the gospel was at stake. The New Testament does not hide that prejudice occurred inside the church, and that it had to be named and corrected.
2. A short and honest history
(A general account. It names no living person, group or institution, and it is not a verdict on any present society.)
The Christian churches have a double record on this question, and an honest teacher tells both parts.
On one side, Christians have resisted prejudice and oppression in the name of the gospel. Many of the early church's own writers argued that the gospel was for all peoples. In the centuries since, there have been missionaries and church leaders who protested against slavery and the mistreatment of native peoples in their time. In the late eighteenth and the nineteenth centuries, many Christians, in several countries, took a leading part in the movement to end the slave trade and slavery, and many of those who suffered slavery found in the Bible a promise of freedom and in the church a place of dignity: churches founded and led by people who had been enslaved or their descendants became centres of worship, learning and public life. In the twentieth century, Christian leaders and congregations in several countries took part in movements against segregation and unjust laws, in some cases at great cost. In many places Christians have also sheltered the persecuted and spoken for the despised.
On the other side, churches and Christians have shared in prejudice, and some have defended it. In some periods, Christian teachers argued that slavery was permitted by Scripture, and a reading of Genesis 9 was used for a long time to claim that some peoples were fated to serve; scholars of every tradition now regard that reading as a misuse of the text. In many countries, congregations were divided by ethnic group or colour, sometimes by custom and sometimes by rule, and church leaders accepted or defended the division. European colonial expansion was sometimes supported by Christians who thought it a service to the gospel, and was sometimes criticised by other Christians; churches today still discuss how to weigh the gifts and the harms of that history. For many centuries, Christian preaching about the Jewish people was hostile, and in the twentieth century that long teaching of contempt was one of the things that prepared the ground for catastrophe; after the Second World War, many churches reviewed their teaching and several, including the Catholic Church at its Second Vatican Council in the 1960s, declared that Jewish people must not be spoken of as cursed or rejected by God. Prejudice also followed lines of caste, class, language and region in many places, and churches in those places have not always been free of it.
Historians add that the modern idea of race, as a ranking of human groups by inborn worth, took shape in the early modern centuries alongside colonial expansion and the slave trade, and that many Christians absorbed it without examining it. This point is argued about in detail, but the general lesson is widely shared: Christians are not exempt from the prejudices of their time, and a church can mistake the customs of its society for the will of God. This is the same pattern we saw in lecture 1-2 when we asked what a gospel that is "at home" in a culture must still refuse.
The history is to be told neither to shame any group today nor to excuse the past. It is to be told because the truth is part of the church's witness, and because those who were harmed are owed a church that can say what happened.
3. How the traditions speak of repentance, confession and repair
Christian traditions have rich words for facing wrongdoing, and they apply them to the question of prejudice in different ways.
The Catholic tradition speaks of sin as including "structures of sin", a phrase from its teaching in the late twentieth century that means patterns in a society's life that make it easy to wrong others and hard to do right. It practises confession and penance for persons, and in recent decades its leaders have made public statements of regret for wrongs done by members of the church in the past. The Orthodox tradition emphasises repentance as the turning of the whole person, and the contains many prayers of confession that name sins in common ("we have sinned"). The Reformed and Lutheran traditions have long held that all are sinners and that a church confesses together; many congregations include a corporate prayer of confession in every service, and some have written specific confessions about particular sins of the past. The Anabaptist traditions stress the church as a community of mutual accountability. Evangelical and Pentecostal communities stress personal repentance and the new life in Christ, and many have also taken up public repentance for the sins of the church, in revival and in reconciliation work.
The Bible itself offers examples of a people confessing a wrong that is larger than one person. In the prayers recorded in the books of Daniel, Ezra and Nehemiah, the one who prays says "we have sinned", including the sins of earlier generations, and does not claim to have personally done each deed. Readers of different traditions take this as a pattern of corporate confession. Others say that the prayer is part of a relationship with a particular people and cannot be applied in the same way to every group in every nation. This is one of the places where the traditions differ in their use of the same text.
Three ideas often appear in the traditions' talk of repair. The first is truth-telling: saying what happened, in language the injured can recognise. The second is repentance, a turning away from a wrong that may include apology and a change in the church's own life. The third is restitution, the making good of what was taken or damaged, as Zacchaeus in Luke 19 promised to repay (a text we met in lecture 2-4, in a different context). How far these ideas apply to groups, and to wrongs of the distant past, is argued about, as the next section shows. What is not argued about among Christians is that the way of the gospel is not denial.
4. This is a point where readers will not agree
This is a point where readers will not agree: how a church should speak about group injustice (wrongs done to or by groups of people, across generations, through law, custom or institutions) and what repair means. We present three broad views as their holders would state them. Many people hold a mixture.
The first view says the church should name group and structural injustice, and pursue repair. Its holders say that the Bible treats peoples as well as persons as moral actors, that the prophets condemned the practices of whole societies, that the prayers of confession in Daniel, Ezra and Nehemiah include the sins of earlier generations, and that Christians who say nothing about injustices built into laws and institutions leave the injured without a witness. They add that repair is a Christian idea (Zacchaeus; the repair of damaged relationships), and that it may include apology, changes in the church's own policies, shared leadership, support for education or housing, and the return of what was taken. The strength of this view is its honesty about how wrongs outlast the people who committed them and its care for those who still bear the cost. The weak point, as critics see it, is that language about groups can slide into blaming individuals for what they did not do, or treating people as members of a category before knowing them; that it can be vague about what repair is and who owes what to whom; and that it may be used to settle political arguments that the church has no special authority to settle.
The second view says the church should speak chiefly about personal sin and the unity of all in Christ. Its holders say that Scripture holds each person responsible for his or her own deeds (a theme in Ezekiel 18), that the gospel is a message for every individual, that Galatians 3:28 teaches that in the church such categories no longer divide, and that the way to end prejudice is to refuse to see people as members of a group at all and to treat each person as an individual before God. They fear that talk of group guilt and group innocence will divide the church, harden suspicion and replace the gospel with a political programme. The strength of this view is its protection of the individual and its zeal for unity. The weak point, as critics see it, is that it can leave inherited injustice unexamined, can seem to tell those who suffer that their experience is not real, and can use unity as a way to avoid hard conversations.
A third view says that churches should act locally, concretely and in company with those affected. Its holders say that the debate about words is less important than particular steps: to listen to those who have been hurt, to examine the church's own history, to share the table and the leadership, to ask what the injured themselves say they need, and to be slow to speak for others. They hold that repair is best worked out in a place by the people who live there. The strength of this view is its practicality and its humility. The weak point, as critics see it, is that it may avoid the larger questions of law and institutions, and that "local" can become a reason to do very little.
The course does not require a student to choose among these. It requires that the student state each view in its strongest form, name its strength and its weak point, and avoid saying that one view is the only Christian one. It also requires that no one be treated as a representative of a whole group, and that no one in the room be made a target of blame because of a category they belong to. Where laws, courts, public offices or policies are concerned, readers should follow their own country's law and their community's written rules, and a church leader who is unsure should seek qualified advice.
5. Belonging in a local church
Whatever one's view on the contested point, a local church can ask honest questions about belonging.
Who is at the table? Congregations often form along lines of language, ethnic background, class or age. Some of this serves people well: a congregation in the language of a newcomers' community may be a place of home, worship and mutual help, and is a gift. Some of it can become separation, where groups that could know one another never meet. Churches differ on how far to cultivate groups that share a language or background, and how far to seek mixed congregations; both can be defended. The question for each church is whether its way of gathering is a gift to those in it and whether it leaves the door open to others.
Whose voice is heard? A church can ask who preaches, who leads the music, who sits on the committee, and whose stories are told. These questions are not an accusation; they are a way of noticing.
What do we say about people? Jokes and casual remarks about a group can wound, and they can be quietly corrected. The apostle's counsel in Ephesians 4:25 to speak truth to one another applies also to the stories we tell about others, which are often less than true.
What do we do when we are wronged, and when we have wronged? Prejudice runs in both directions in a mixed community; a person may be hurt, and a person may hurt others unknowingly. A church can make it possible to say, "That was hard to hear", and to answer, "Thank you for telling me", without reprisal. If there is cruelty, harassment or abuse, it is not to be handled as a matter of opinion; it should go to the responsible person named in the church's own written policy, and, if there is danger now, to the local emergency number.
(An invented example.) A congregation meets in two languages. For years the two groups shared a building but worshipped separately, and few people knew each other's names. A proposes a joint meal on the fourth Sunday of each month, with each group cooking one dish and the children leading a short song in both languages. Some members are pleased; some are tired of one more event; one man says he would rather keep his own service as it is. The deacon does not insist. A year later the meal is still held, a few friendships have formed, and nothing about the separate services has changed. Nothing here settles the large questions, and it is not meant to. It shows that belonging is often built in small acts that anyone can offer.
6. What does not follow
Three cautions complete the picture.
First, to say that humanity is one does not mean that differences of language, culture and story do not matter. Revelation 7:9 keeps them.
Second, to say that prejudice is sin does not mean that the person who holds a prejudice is beyond change. The New Testament speaks of conversion in this very field: Peter's vision in Acts 10 changed a settled habit of separation, and the story shows that a faithful person can need to be corrected.
Third, to condemn prejudice does not give a church the right to condemn a named person or group today. The church's task is to bear witness, to repent where it has erred, and to be a home. It is not the church's task to hand down verdicts on those outside it.
Diagram 1. One family, many wounds, and three ways of speaking of repair
핵심 요약
- Scripture pictures one human family: one origin (Acts 17), one new people in Christ (Ephesians 2, Galatians 3), and a crowd from every nation and language (Revelation 7).
- Churches have both resisted prejudice and shared in it; an honest church tells both parts of the history without verdicts on any present group.
- The traditions speak of repentance, confession and repair in different ways; truth-telling, repentance and restitution recur.
- Readers disagree on how to speak of group injustice and on what repair means; three views each have a strength and a weak point.
- Whatever the view, a local church can ask who is at the table, whose voice is heard, and how wrongs are handled, and can offer belonging.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Scripture's picture of humanity | One family with one origin, one new people in Christ, and a gathering from every nation and language, unity with variety. |
| The church's double record | It has resisted prejudice and slavery, and it has also shared in and defended prejudice; an honest church tells both. |
| Three views on group injustice | Name it and pursue repair; stress personal sin and unity in Christ; act locally and concretely with those affected; each has a strength and a weak point. |
| What a local church can ask | Who is at the table, whose voice is heard, what we say about people, and how we handle wrongs. |
One sentence to remember Humanity is one family, the church has both resisted and shared in prejudice, and Christians who differ on repair can still make their own table a place of belonging.
This week's action Notice one habit in your community of speaking about a group of people, and ask whether it is true and kind.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- What do Acts 17:26, Ephesians 2:14-16 and Revelation 7:9 each say about one human family? Why does Revelation 7:9 not describe a world in which everyone has become the same?
- How have churches both resisted and shared in prejudice? Why does an honest church tell both parts of the story?
- How do the traditions speak of repentance and confession? Why do some readers apply the prayers in Daniel, Ezra and Nehemiah to the present and others hesitate?
- State the three views about group injustice in the church, each with its strength and its weak point. Which strongest form of a view you do not hold is hardest to state?
- In your own church or community, which of the questions about belonging (who is at the table, whose voice is heard, what we say about people, what we do when wronged) could be asked gently, and by whom?