Lecture 4-4: After the Story: Questions and Sharing
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Story, Not Explanation
- Lecture 1-2: Scene, Character, Plot
- Lecture 1-3: Repetition, Tension and Key Words
- Lecture 1-4: What the Narrator Does Not Say
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Reading One Scene
- Lecture 2-1: Choosing and Bounding a Story
- Lecture 2-2: Adding Nothing, Taking Nothing Away
- Lecture 2-3: Hard Texts I: Violence
- Lecture 2-4: Hard Texts II: Sexual Content and Age
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Skeleton and a Faithfulness Check
- Lecture 3-1: Voice and Breath
- Lecture 3-2: Silence and Pause
- Lecture 3-3: Body, Eyes and Space
- Lecture 3-4: Memory and Your Own Words
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Tell a Story and Give Feedback
- Lecture 4-1: Children
- Lecture 4-2: Teenagers
- Lecture 4-3: Adults, Newcomers and Mixed Cultures
- Lecture 4-4: After the Story: Questions and Sharing
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: One Story, Two Listeners
- Lecture 5-1: Oral Cultures and How Stories Travel
- Lecture 5-2: Chronological Bible Storying
- Lecture 5-3: Telling Where Few Read
- Lecture 5-4: How the Churches Have Told the Story
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Three Stories and a Retelling
The story ends. The teller stops. What now?
Many tellers feel a sudden need to fill the silence. They explain, summarise, apply, and draw the lesson, and so take back from the listeners the very thing the story has just given them: a moment to think. This lecture is about that moment. It asks what a teller does in the first minutes after a story, how to ask questions that open a conversation and not close it, how to bear a silence, and how to protect a listener from being pushed into saying more than they want to say.
The principle of the week holds here too: adjust the telling, not the text, and respect every listener. Respect after a story means leaving the listener room, asking honestly, and never forcing a confession.
What these 21 minutes give you
- Explain why leaping straight to the lesson takes something from the listeners.
- Ask three open questions after a story and say why each leaves room.
- Tell a leading question from an open one and rewrite one into the other.
- Describe what to do with a silence, and with an answer you did not expect.
- Name the practices that force a listener to confess, and say what to do instead.
- Say what to do if a listener shares something painful or something that suggests harm.
Behold, two of them were going that very day to a village named Emmaus, which was sixty stadia from Jerusalem." — Luke 24:13
World English Bible
While they talked and questioned together, Jesus himself came near, and went with them." — Luke 24:15
WEB
But their eyes were kept from recognizing him." — Luke 24:16
WEB
He said to them, “What are you talking about as you walk, and are sad?”" — Luke 24:17
WEB
He said to them, “What things?” They said to him, “The things concerning Jesus, the Nazarene, who was a prophet mighty in deed and word before God and all the people;" — Luke 24:19
WEB
They said one to another, “Weren’t our hearts burning within us, while he spoke to us along the way, and while he opened the Scriptures to us?”" — Luke 24:32
WEB
The passage is the walk to Emmaus (Luke 24:13-35). We quote the verses that matter for this lecture. Notice the order of the scene. The stranger who joins the two travellers does not begin by explaining. He begins by asking.
1. The leap to the lesson
Take a story of ten minutes and a talk of five that follows. In many churches, classes and homes the talk goes: "So what do we learn from this? We learn that..." It is a habit with a long history, and it is not wicked. It comes from a real wish to be useful. But it has a cost.
The cost is that the listeners are given a conclusion before they have had time to reach one. A person who hears the parable of the two sons, and who in the quiet after it is quietly thinking of their own brother, has no room to think when the teller says "We learn that God forgives." The thought is cut off. The listener may agree, but agreement with an answer is not the same as having heard the story.
There is a second cost. When the teller always supplies the lesson, listeners learn that a story is a container and that the lesson is what matters. They learn to wait for it, and to stop attending to the story. Week 6 takes this up in full. For now: the lesson is not forbidden, but it should not be the first thing said, and it should not be the only thing.
The scene on the road to Emmaus is an example in the text. The stranger comes alongside the two travellers who are sad, and he asks, "What are you talking about as you walk, and are sad?" (verse 17). When one of them answers, he asks again, "What things?" (verse 19). Only after they have spoken does he explain the Scriptures. We should not press the comparison too far; he is the risen Lord and his teaching is of a kind no teller can claim. But the order of the scene is plain: he asks, he listens, and then he speaks.
2. Three open questions
A simple frame of three questions has served many tellers and leaders. It does not belong to any one church. The questions are:
- What did you notice? This asks for something in the story: a word, an action, a person. It is the easiest to answer, because nobody can be wrong about what they noticed.
- What do you wonder? This asks for a question the listener carries. It admits that the story has gaps (lecture 1-4), and it welcomes not knowing.
- What stays with you? This asks for the thing that will go home with the listener. It does not ask for a lesson or for a decision. It may be a single word.
Each of these has the same virtue: it can be answered by anyone, at any level, from any background, and there is no wrong answer. A child, a newcomer and a long-time reader can all say what they noticed.
Use them in this order, and wait after each. Do not add a fourth ("and how will you apply this?") until you have been asked.
| Question | What it opens | What it does not do |
|---|---|---|
| What did you notice? | Attention to the text itself | Ask for an opinion |
| What do you wonder? | The gaps and the not-knowing | Ask for an answer |
| What stays with you? | The listener's own response | Ask for a lesson or a decision |
3. Open and leading questions
A leading question has an answer built into it. "Don't you think the brother was being selfish?" has one right answer. "Wasn't it wonderful how the father forgave?" has one. So has "Who here would like to be forgiven like that?" The listener can say yes, or can say nothing, and the nothing is read as no.
An open question has no answer built in. "What do you notice about the elder brother?" "What do you make of how the father went out to him?" Anyone can answer it, and the answer will be theirs.
It is not wrong to ask a plain question with a plain answer. "Who went out to meet the younger son?" is a good question for a child or for a group that needs to be sure of the story. It is a question about the text. The mistake is to dress a conclusion up as a question.
| Leading | Open |
|---|---|
| "Wasn't the father generous?" | "What do you notice about the father?" |
| "Don't you agree the disciples were wrong to stop the children?" | "How do you read what the disciples did?" |
| "Surely we all see ourselves in the elder brother?" | "Which person in the story do you find hardest to understand?" |
| "Would you not say the lesson is forgiveness?" | "What stays with you from the story?" |
A quick test: if you would be surprised or disappointed by some answers, the question is probably leading.
4. Silence
The hardest part of asking is waiting. You ask a question. Nobody speaks. A few seconds feel very long.
Do not rush. A silence after a good question is people thinking. If you fill it, you tell them you did not mean it. A practical help: count slowly to ten in your head before you speak again. Most groups will speak before you reach the end.
If nothing comes, say the question again in different words, or say, "Take a moment. You may like to tell the person next to you." Turning to a neighbour lowers the cost of speaking, especially for those who are shy or speak a second language.
Some groups are quiet by habit. In some communities, a young person does not speak before an elder, or a woman before a man, or a guest before the host. A teller who pushes for an answer there may cause real discomfort. Ask the group how they like to share, and let them show you.
5. Answers you did not expect
An open question brings answers you did not plan for. Some are wrong about the text. Some are sharp. Some are beautiful. A few will be sad.
- An answer that is wrong about the text. Go back to the text, kindly. "Let us look at that verse again. What does it say?" Do not say "No, that is not right." The text can correct the answer.
- An answer that disagrees with another listener. Let both stand. "So we see this differently. That is worth noticing." Disagreement among listeners about what a story means is normal, and it is not a failure.
- An answer you cannot answer. Say so. "I do not know. Let me find out." Then do.
- An answer from the child, the newcomer or the quiet person. Thank them. Do not praise so much that the others feel they are being compared.
- An answer that shows pain. This needs its own section.
6. Not forcing a confession
There are customs in some places that move quickly from a story to the listeners' own failings. "Think of a time you were like the elder brother." "Raise your hand if you have ever refused to forgive." "Share one sin you are struggling with." Some of these have good motives. They also have a cost, and the cost is higher than it looks.
- They put the listener on display. A person who must say, in front of others, what they have done is not free to say nothing.
- They are hard to refuse. A refusal looks like pride, and so the listener complies.
- They give the group something to use. What is said in a circle can be repeated, even by those who mean no harm.
- They can draw out what the teller is not able to hold. A person who says something heavy in a group needs someone able to listen, and a teller is not necessarily that.
So we do not ask a listener to confess in front of others. We do not use the story to bring out a testimony that has not been offered. We do not make a rule that everyone must speak. Instead:
- Make speaking a free choice. "You may speak or pass, and either is welcome."
- Ask about the story, not about the person. "What do you notice about the elder brother?" rather than "Where are you like the elder brother?" A person who wants to say something about themselves will find the way.
- Let a person speak of themselves if they choose. If they do, listen. Do not push on, and do not draw others in.
7. If a listener shares something painful
A good story can open a door that the listener had kept shut. Someone may say something about grief, or a broken family, or a fear, or a harm done to them or by them. When that happens:
- Listen. Do not hurry to fix. "Thank you for telling us" is a good reply. Do not say "I know exactly how you feel" or "God has a plan".
- Do not ask for more in front of the group. Offer a private word afterwards: "I would be glad to listen at the end, if you would like."
- Protect the group. Say, gently, that what is said in the room stays in the room. Do not promise more than that, for there are limits (below).
- Do not make yourself a counsellor. A teller is not a trained counsellor. Know who is, and how to reach them: a pastor, a priest, a counsellor, a doctor.
- Know the limits of confidence. If a listener, child or adult, tells you of harm to themselves or someone else, do not promise secrecy. Tell the safeguarding lead the same day. Where the law requires a report, follow it. If someone is in danger now, call the local emergency number. If a listener speaks of wishing to end their life, stay with them, take it seriously, and get help at once.
These are the same duties that apply to a story told to a child (lecture 4-1), and they apply to every listener.
8. Sharing that is a gift
Not all sharing is a risk. Often, after a story, someone says what they noticed, and another adds, and a third says, "I never saw that before." It is one of the best things a teller can hear. The teller's work is to make room for it: to ask well, to wait, to receive what comes, and to resist the tidy lesson. The story, as we have said all course, does its own work.
9. An invented example
(An invented example.) After telling the walk to Emmaus to an evening group, a teller says: "So what is the lesson here? The lesson is that Jesus is always with us, even when we do not see him. Let us go round the circle, and each say one time when you did not see him but he was there."
The first speaker says a few words. The second shakes her head and says, "I would rather not." The teller says, "Come on, it is only a few words."
The weakness is plain once seen: the lesson leaps in, a closed prompt follows, and the pressure to speak is applied to a person who has passed. What question would you have asked, in place of "so what is the lesson"?
Diagram 1. From the story to the conversation
Diagram 2. Leading or open?
| Say it as a test | Leading if... | Open if... |
|---|---|---|
| Could someone answer "no" and be welcome? | They could not | They could |
| Do I already know the answer I want? | Yes | No |
| Does it begin "Don't you think", "Surely", "Wouldn't you say"? | Yes | No |
| Is it about the text, or about the person's failings? | The person's failings | The text |
In short
- Leaping to the lesson takes from listeners the time to think; ask, listen, and speak afterwards.
- Three open questions: what did you notice, what do you wonder, what stays with you.
- A leading question has its answer built in; an open one can be answered by anyone.
- Bear silence: count to ten, rephrase, or invite listeners to turn to a neighbour.
- Do not force confession; make speaking free, ask about the story, and let people choose to speak of themselves.
- If pain or harm is shared, listen, offer a private word, promise no secrecy and tell the safeguarding lead.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Three open questions | What did you notice? What do you wonder? What stays with you? |
| Leading question | A question with the answer built in, usually beginning "Don't you think" or "Surely". |
| In a silence | Count slowly to ten, rephrase, or invite listeners to speak to a neighbour. |
| If someone shares pain or harm | Listen, offer a private word, promise no secrecy, tell the safeguarding lead, and call emergency services if there is danger now. |
One sentence to remember After a story, ask before you explain, and never make anyone confess.
This week's action After your next telling, ask the three questions in order, wait for each, and note which one gave the most.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- What do you usually do in the first minute after a story ends? What would you change?
- Why does the lecture say the lesson is "not forbidden" but should not be first?
- Choose a story. Write the three open questions for it, in your own words.
- Take one of your own leading questions and rewrite it as an open one.
- Why can a custom of "share a time when you..." be a harm even when it is meant well?
- A listener says something painful after a story. What are the first two things you do, and what do you not do?