Lecture 1-1: The Faith and Its Clothing
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: The Faith and Its Clothing
- Lecture 1-2: Two Kinds of Problem: Fixing and Learning
- Lecture 1-3: Three Stories of Change in the Bible
- Lecture 1-4: Questions to Ask Before You Propose a Change
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: What We Keep, What We Might Change
- Lecture 2-1: What Change Takes Away
- Lecture 2-2: Listening to a Congregation's Story
- Lecture 2-3: Generations, Languages and Cultures
- Lecture 2-4: Who Is Not in the Room
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab, A Change Seen from One Seat
- Lecture 3-1: Who Decides? Polities and Their Roads
- Lecture 3-2: Small Steps and Reversible Changes
- Lecture 3-3: Speaking About Change
- Lecture 3-4: Buildings, Money and Endings
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Proposal
- Lecture 4-1: Conflict Is Not a Failure
- Lecture 4-2: Layers: Facts, Methods, Values, Relationships, Power
- Lecture 4-3: How Conflict Grows
- Lecture 4-4: Conflict or Harm?
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Drawing a Conflict Map
- Lecture 5-1: Where a Leader Stands
- Lecture 5-2: Running the Meeting
- Lecture 5-3: Calling in Help
- Lecture 5-4: Where Mediation Must Not Go
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: What I Will Say First
Almost every dispute about change in a church begins with two words that sound alike: "we have always." Sometimes they mean "this is what we believe." Sometimes they mean "this is what we are used to." The two are not the same, and a leader who cannot tell them apart will do harm in either direction.
Picture a meeting in a congregation. A new leader suggests moving the Sunday service one hour later. An older member stands and says, "You are changing our faith." The leader is surprised, because the leader only meant the clock. But the older member may not be speaking about the clock. He may be speaking about forty years of Sunday mornings, and about the people he prayed beside in that hour who are no longer alive (an invented example). The leader and the member are using the word "faith" for different things.
This lecture asks the question that comes before every other question in this course: what, in this community, is the faith itself, and what is the clothing it wears? The image is old and it has limits. Clothing is not worthless. A person is known by how he or she dresses, and clothes that have been worn for generations carry memory. But a person can change clothes and remain the same person. A leader needs to know which things in a community work like a body and which work like a coat, and needs to be able to say why.
The lecture does not tell you where your line falls. Christian traditions draw it in different places. It asks you to draw it honestly, from your own community's standard, and to respect those who draw it elsewhere.
What these 28 minutes give you
- Explain the difference between what a community holds as the faith and what it has chosen in a particular time and place.
- Describe from Acts 15 and 1 Corinthians 9 how the first Christians kept the message and changed some practices.
- Name the two errors: making a form into the faith, and calling the faith a form.
- State fairly how different traditions place the line between faith and form.
- Give, from a community's own standard, a reason why one thing is held as essential and another may change.
Now therefore why do you tempt God, that you should put a yoke on the neck of the disciples which neither our fathers nor we were able to bear? But we believe that we are saved through the grace of the Lord Jesus, just as they are.”" — Acts 15:10-11
World English Bible
Beloved, while I was very eager to write to you about our common salvation, I was constrained to write to you exhorting you to contend earnestly for the faith which was once for all delivered to the saints." — Jude 1:3
WEB
For you set aside the commandment of God, and hold tightly to the tradition of men—the washing of pitchers and cups, and you do many other such things.” He said to them, “Full well do you reject the commandment of God, that you may keep your tradition." — Mark 7:8-9
WEB
The first passage comes from the meeting in Jerusalem that decided what Gentile believers must carry. The second speaks of a faith "delivered," that is, handed on. The third records Jesus naming a danger on the other side. Read all three together. Each one is true, and each one stops the others from being used alone.
1. Two questions that look like one
When someone says "this must not change," there are two different claims they might be making.
The first claim is: this is the faith. It is something the community received and did not invent. To change it would be to become a different community, or to stop being a Christian one.
The second claim is: this is ours, and we love it. It is something the community made or chose, perhaps long ago. It has carried the faith well. To change it would cost real grief, even if the faith itself would remain.
Both claims deserve respect. The second is not a lesser claim in the sense that it can be ignored. A song that was sung at a hundred funerals is not a trivial thing. But the two claims call for different answers. The first claim can only be settled by going to the standard the community lives under. The second claim can be settled by listening, by honest weighing, and sometimes by a change made gently, with thanks.
The trouble is that people often argue the second claim in the words of the first. It is easier to say "this is the faith" than to say "I am afraid to lose this." A leader who takes the first sentence at face value will fight a doctrinal battle where there is only a grief. And a leader who treats every first sentence as a disguised grief will, one day, brush aside a person who was in fact defending something the community holds sacred.
2. What the Jerusalem meeting kept and what it released
Acts 15 is the best worked example in the New Testament of this question being asked in public. It began with a demand: some men taught that Gentile believers could not be saved "unless you are circumcised after the custom of Moses" (Acts 15:1). Paul and Barnabas disagreed strongly. The church in Antioch sent them to Jerusalem, to the apostles and elders, "about this question" (Acts 15:2).
Notice first that the question was brought to the community's recognised leaders and not settled by whoever spoke loudest. Notice also that the people who made the demand were not dismissed as enemies. Some of them are described as believers, from among the Pharisees (Acts 15:5). They were sincere. Their demand rested on a command that Scripture itself had given for many centuries. They held a real treasure, and they thought it was being thrown away.
Peter's answer, quoted at the head of this lecture, goes to the centre. The Gentiles had received the Holy Spirit, and God had made no distinction between them and the Jewish believers. Peter then says what he takes the faith to be: "we believe that we are saved through the grace of the Lord Jesus, just as they are." That sentence was not negotiable. What could be released, on that basis, was a yoke "which neither our fathers nor we were able to bear" (Acts 15:10). Gentile believers did not have to take on the customs of Moses to belong.
The meeting did not stop at release, however. The letter that went out asked the Gentile believers to abstain from certain things, and it describes them as "necessary things" (Acts 15:28). Readers explain these requests in different ways. Some take them as a few practical commitments that made shared meals and shared worship possible between Jews and Gentiles. Some take them as a lasting moral and ritual minimum. You do not need to settle that to see the pattern. The council did two things at once. It protected the gospel from an added condition, and it cared for the common life of the people who now sat together. It neither said "nothing is required of you" nor said "everything is required."
This passage shows how a decision about the faith and its clothing was made. It does not give a rule that any later church can apply as a formula. The apostles were in a unique position, and the question they faced, whether Gentiles must become Jews, was a once-for-all question. But the way they went about it is instructive: they heard witnesses, they went to Scripture, they named the heart of the matter, they released what was not required, and they wrote down what they decided.
3. A man who changed everything except the message
Paul gives a second view in 1 Corinthians 9.
"For though I was free from all, I brought myself under bondage to all, that I might gain the more. To the Jews I became as a Jew, that I might gain Jews; to those who are under the law, as under the law, that I might gain those who are under the law; to those who are without law, as without law (not being without law toward God, but under law toward Christ), that I might win those who are without law. To the weak I became as weak, that I might gain the weak. I have become all things to all men, that I may by all means save some. Now I do this for the sake of the Good News, that I may be a joint partaker of it." — 1 Corinthians 9:19-23 (WEB)
Paul says he became as a Jew to the Jews, and as one without the law to those without it. He is not describing hypocrisy. He is describing a person who is willing to change nearly everything about how he lives, how he eats and what he observes, for the sake of those he is trying to reach. And in the middle of that passage he draws a boundary: he was "not being without law toward God, but under law toward Christ" (9:21). He bends in the clothing. He does not bend in his loyalty.
This is the same pattern as Jerusalem, seen from one man's life. There is a centre, and there is a wide margin around it where the centre can be expressed in different ways for different people.
But 1 Corinthians 9 can be misused. Some readers hear it as permission to change anything if the result is a larger crowd. Paul does not say that. He says he did it "for the sake of the Good News." The test is not whether a change is welcomed, but whether it serves the message without altering it. A community that changes in order to be liked, and does not ask what the change does to the message, has taken Paul's words and left out his boundary.
4. The warning on the other side
Now turn to Mark 7. The Pharisees and scribes had asked Jesus why his disciples did not keep a handed-down custom about washing before meals. Jesus answered with a sharp saying, quoted at the head of this lecture: "you set aside the commandment of God, and hold tightly to the tradition of men" (Mark 7:8).
He then gives an example (Mark 7:10-13). The commandment says to honour father and mother. But a practice had grown up by which a person could declare that what he might have given his parents was "given to God," and so he was no longer expected to help them. The tradition, which had been made to honour God, had ended by cancelling a command of God. Jesus says it plainly: "making void the word of God by your tradition, which you have handed down."
Read this carefully, because it can be taken in two wrong ways. It does not say that all tradition is bad. In this passage he does not attack the Pharisees for having traditions but for using one to break a commandment. And it does not say that a leader who dislikes a tradition may call it "merely human." What the passage shows is a particular danger: a form that was made to serve God can slowly become a thing that blocks God's own word. Leaders and congregations in every century, in every communion, are open to this danger. It is not a fault only of other people.
5. What was handed on
Then there is Jude's phrase: "the faith which was once for all delivered to the saints" (Jude 1:3). The writer calls his readers to "contend earnestly" for it. This verse is often used to end an argument, as if the words "once for all" settled what the faith contains. They do not. They say that there is something given, that it is not made new by each generation, and that it is worth contending for. They do not list its contents.
How a community knows the contents is the very point at which Christians differ, and the next section says so openly. For now, notice that Jude and Mark 7 stand side by side. One says: there is something handed on that you must guard. The other says: be careful that your handing-on does not become a barrier to God. A leader who has only the first verse becomes a guard who never asks what he is guarding. A leader who has only the second becomes a reformer who never asks what is worth keeping.
6. Two errors
From these passages come two errors, and each one is common.
The first error is making a form into the faith. The hour of the service, the shape of the room, the instruments, the version of the Bible read aloud, the way the offering is taken: any of these may be treated as though changing it were an attack on God. The result is that every change becomes a crisis. Younger people and newcomers, who do not share the memories, hear a message that is not the gospel at all: "you must first accept our habits." That is very close to the yoke which Acts 15 refused to lay on the Gentiles.
The second error is the faith a form. A teaching about who Christ is, about how sins are forgiven, about what happens at baptism or the Lord's Supper, may be described as "just our tradition" or "just a style," and so be dropped when it becomes inconvenient or unpopular. The result is that the community slowly loses the thing it was gathered for, and sometimes no one can say when it happened. Paul's boundary in 1 Corinthians 9:21 is exactly what this error forgets.
Both errors share a cause. In each, someone has decided where the line falls without giving a reason, either from habit or from preference. The remedy is the same in both: give the reason, and give it from a standard that other people in the community can also read.
7. This is a point where readers will not agree
Where the line falls between the faith itself and its forms is a point on which Christian traditions differ, and they differ for serious reasons. Several positions are held, and each one is strong at its best.
Some traditions hold that Scripture alone is the standard. What Scripture teaches or commands binds the conscience; what it leaves open is a matter of wisdom and may be arranged by each church. Those who hold this position point out that it protects believers from having human customs laid on them as though God required them, which is exactly the danger of Mark 7. Some within this family go further and hold that worship should include only what Scripture authorises, so for them the margin of free choice is narrower than for others.
Other traditions hold that the standard is Scripture together with Tradition, meaning the teaching and life handed on in the church from the apostles, as received and interpreted by the councils and by those entrusted with oversight. Catholic and Orthodox communities hold this in different forms. Those who hold it point out that the New Testament itself was written, gathered and read within a community that already had a faith, a worship and a way of life, and that "once for all delivered" (Jude 1:3) describes something received through persons and not only through a book. For them, much that others call a form, such as the shape of the or the order of ministry, belongs near the centre, because it is part of how the faith is handed on.
Some hold that the liturgy as received is itself the carrier of doctrine, so that the way a community prays shows what it believes. On that view a change in wording or order is never only a change in style. It may be a change in teaching, and it needs the care that a change in teaching would need.
Some hold that the standard is found in confessional documents, such as the creeds and the statements adopted by a church family. A confession names what the community has agreed that Scripture teaches, and it allows a leader to say, "this is held; that is open."
Others, especially in independent and congregational churches, hold that each local church is free before Christ to order its own life under Scripture. They point to the gathered church in Antioch or Corinth, each of which dealt with its own questions. For them, the line is drawn by the congregation reading Scripture together, and it can honestly fall in different places in different churches.
What this course requires is less than any one of these requires. It does not ask you to change your tradition's line. It asks that you be able to say, from your community's own standard (its Scripture, its Tradition, its liturgy, its confession or its congregation's reading), why a given thing is held as essential or may be changed. And it asks that you do not treat a person who draws the line elsewhere as faithless. A believer who is more cautious than you is not necessarily afraid of the truth. A believer who is more open than you is not necessarily careless of it.
8. Why this comes first
Now you can see why the course begins here and not with methods. The central claim of the course is that change asks people to put down something they treasure, and that conflict is where those treasures collide. If you do not know what is being asked of people, you cannot tell whether you are asking them to put down a coat or a limb.
Often a leader's first discovery, when asked to say why a thing must stay, is that the reason is thin. It is a habit. It is a good habit, and it is loved, and that is a real reason to be gentle about changing it. But it is a different reason from "this is the faith," and it calls for a different kind of conversation. And sometimes the leader's first discovery runs the other way: a practice that looked like mere custom turns out to be tied to something the community has always held most dear. In both cases the leader has learned something that no amount of skill in managing meetings could have supplied.
The next lecture asks a different question of the same situation: not what is being changed, but what kind of problem it is.
Diagram 1. The faith, received forms and local choices
Diagram 2. Four passages, four jobs
| Passage | What it shows | What it does not say |
|---|---|---|
| Acts 15:1-11, 28 | A community keeps the gospel of grace, releases an added yoke, and writes down what it asks of all | That every later church should decide in the same way on the same issues |
| 1 Corinthians 9:19-23 | A leader changes a great deal for others and keeps loyalty to Christ | That anything may be changed if it brings a crowd |
| Mark 7:8-13 | A form made for God can end by cancelling God's word | That tradition itself is bad |
| Jude 1:3 | There is a faith handed on and worth guarding | A list of what it contains |
In short
- A community holds some things as the faith itself and has chosen other things in a time and place. A leader must be able to tell them apart honestly.
- Acts 15 kept the gospel of grace, released an added yoke, and still asked something of all. The council shows a way of deciding, not a formula.
- Paul changed much of his manner for others, and kept his loyalty to Christ. The test of a change is whether it serves the message without altering it.
- Jesus warned that a tradition meant for God can end by cancelling God's word. This danger belongs to every tradition.
- The two errors are making a form into the faith, and calling the faith a form.
- Traditions draw the line differently. A leader must give a reason from the community's own standard and must not call another's line faithless.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The question before every change | What is the faith here, and what is its clothing? |
| Acts 15 | The gospel of grace kept, an added yoke released, a letter written for the common life. |
| The two errors | Making a form into the faith; calling the faith a form. |
| The leader's duty | Give a reason from the community's own standard, and do not call another's line faithless. |
One sentence to remember Before you ask how to change something, be able to say, from your community's own standard, whether it is the faith or its clothing.
This week's action Choose one practice in your community that people defend strongly and write down whether it is held as the faith or chosen as a form, and by what standard you say so.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Think of a form in your community that people defend with strong words. Is it being defended as "the faith" or as "ours"? How would you tell?
- Which standard does your community use to say what is essential: Scripture, Scripture with Tradition, the liturgy, a confession, the agreement of its congregation, or more than one? Where is it written down?
- Why did the Jerusalem council both release the Gentiles from an added yoke and ask something of them? What would have been lost if it had done only one?
- Paul says he became "all things to all men." What in 1 Corinthians 9:21 keeps that from meaning "anything for a crowd"?
- Which error comes more easily to you, making a form into the faith or calling the faith a form? What in your own history leads you that way?
- How could you speak to a member who draws the line in a very different place from you, without calling that person faithless?