Lecture 1-1: What Authority Is For
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What Authority Is For
- Lecture 1-2: How Authority Is Misused
- Lecture 1-3: Unequal Power and Why Consent Is Not Enough
- Lecture 1-4: Authority and Accountability in Different Traditions
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, My Map of Power
- Lecture 2-1: Scripture and the Minister's Money
- Lecture 2-2: Pay, Gifts and Conflicts of Interest
- Lecture 2-3: Openness and Shared Control
- Lecture 2-4: Honest Reports and Honest Appeals
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Checklist for My Money
- Lecture 3-1: Dual Relationships
- Lecture 3-2: Sexual and Romantic Boundaries
- Lecture 3-3: Meeting, Messaging and Online
- Lecture 3-4: Family, Favourites and Friends in Ministry
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: My Boundary Statement
- Lecture 4-1: What Is Told to You, and Where Silence Ends
- Lecture 4-2: Records, Data and Gossip
- Lecture 4-3: Honesty About Yourself and Your Work
- Lecture 4-4: When Silence Becomes Concealment
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab, An Honesty Check
- Lecture 5-1: Not Standing Alone
- Lecture 5-2: Shared Oversight
- Lecture 5-3: Codes of Conduct and Personal Covenants
- Lecture 5-4: Tired, Lonely and Hurt: When Ethics Gives Way
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: My Web of Accountability
Anyone who serves as a pastor, priest, deacon, chaplain, missionary, youth worker or group leader has been given something by other people. It may be an office, a title, a robe, a pulpit, a key to the building, a place at the front. It may be only a habit: when this person speaks, others stop and listen. Whatever its form, it is a kind of power, and this whole course is about how a minister holds it.
This course treats the minister's own conduct. It does not give legal advice, it does not rank traditions, and it does not judge any named person or community. Its claim, which every week returns to, is this: ministry ethics is not the guarding of your own reputation. It is the limiting of your own power for the sake of the people who trusted you, and standing inside structures that can hold you to account.
Before a minister can limit power, the minister must be able to say what the power is for. That is the question of this first lecture. We will look at what authority is, what shape Jesus gave it, how different traditions understand it, and what minimum they share. We will also meet a point where readers do not agree, and say what the course requires.
What these 28 minutes give you
- Distinguish authority, power and influence, and say where a minister's power comes from.
- Describe the shape of authority that Jesus sets against the way rulers use it, without turning it into a denial of all authority.
- Describe in a sentence how episcopal, presbyterian, congregational, charismatic and independent, and Catholic and Orthodox settings each tend to understand authority.
- State the minimum this course asks of every minister: authority is given to build up those who are entrusted to it.
- State fairly two views on how much deference an office deserves.
Jesus summoned them, and said to them, “You know that they who are recognized as rulers over the nations lord it over them, and their great ones exercise authority over them. But it shall not be so among you, but whoever wants to become great among you shall be your servant. Whoever of you wants to become first among you, shall be bondservant of all. For the Son of Man also came not to be served, but to serve, and to give his life as a ransom for many.”" — Mark 10:42-45
World English Bible
I exhort the elders among you, as a fellow elder, and a witness of the sufferings of Christ, and who will also share in the glory that will be revealed. Shepherd the flock of God which is among you, exercising the oversight, not under compulsion, but voluntarily, not for dishonest gain, but willingly; neither as lording it over those entrusted to you, but making yourselves examples to the flock." — 1 Peter 5:1-3
WEB
So when he had washed their feet, put his outer garment back on, and sat down again, he said to them, “Do you know what I have done to you? You call me, ‘Teacher’ and ‘Lord.’ You say so correctly, for so I am. If I then, the Lord and the Teacher, have washed your feet, you also ought to wash one another’s feet. For I have given you an example, that you also should do as I have done to you." — John 13:12-15
WEB
Notice what these passages do not say. They do not say that nobody leads. Peter writes to elders and tells them how to hold an office. Jesus says "for so I am" about his own title. The question the passages answer is not whether there is authority, but what it is for and how it is held.
1. Three words: power, authority, influence
Three words are easily mixed, and the difference matters for the rest of this course.
Power is the ability to affect what other people can do, know, have or hope for. A person has power when others must reckon with what that person decides, says or withholds.
Authority is power that other people have agreed to recognise. A bishop, a pastor, a parish priest, an or a group leader has authority when a community, directly or through its structures, has given that person a place from which to speak and act for it.
Influence is the effect a person has without any formal place at all: because they are admired, trusted, older, better informed, or simply kind.
A minister usually has all three together. That is why the minister's power is larger than it looks from the inside. A pastor who thinks, "I am only giving my opinion," may be giving an opinion that a member of the congregation hears as the voice of God. The minister may not intend that. The effect is real anyway, and the responsibility for the effect belongs to the one who holds the place.
2. Where a minister's power comes from
It helps to name the sources, because each one has its own risks.
- The office or role. A community has set this person apart, by ordination, appointment, , or the trust of a founder's call.
- Knowledge. The minister has read, studied or been trained in what the others have not. Many hearers cannot check what they are told about Scripture, doctrine or the church's rules.
- Spiritual standing. Hearers may believe that the minister is closer to God, speaks for God, or can bring blessing or loss. This source is the hardest to see and the easiest to misuse, because it cannot be measured by anyone.
- Access. The minister knows who is ill, who is in debt, whose marriage is troubled, who is new in the country. In a small community the minister may know more about its people than anyone else.
- Control of resources. The minister may decide who is helped, who is hired, who speaks, who holds a key, who is invited to the meal, who is listed on the roster.
- Dependence. Some people depend on the minister for friendship, for housing, for work, for a letter to a government office, or for the only help available in their language.
Nothing on this list is wrong in itself. All of it is part of what makes pastoral work possible. But every item on it can be used to build people up or to press them down. The next lectures return to each.
3. The shape Jesus gave to authority
In the passage from Mark, two disciples have just asked for places of honour, and the others are angry about it. Jesus does not say that rulers do not exist. He points at the way rulers of the nations hold power: they "lord it over" people and "exercise authority over them." Then he says the pattern is not to be copied among his followers. Greatness is measured in service. The one who wants to be first is to be "bondservant of all." He ends by pointing to himself: the Son of Man came to serve and to give his life.
A very similar scene appears in the Gospel of Luke, in the account of the last meal. In John, Jesus does what he has just described. He washes the disciples' feet. Then he says something which people sometimes forget: "You call me 'Teacher' and 'Lord.' You say so correctly, for so I am." He does not give up the titles. He shows what they are for. The one who truly holds the higher place is the one who takes the lower task.
1 Peter 5 carries the same shape into the life of a congregation. The elders are told to "shepherd the flock," to exercise oversight "not under compulsion, but voluntarily," "not for dishonest gain," and "neither as lording it over those entrusted to you." Notice the word entrusted. The flock is not the elder's property. It is given into his or her keeping. Notice too that Peter writes as "a fellow elder." He does not stand above the people he is advising. The elder is also under the Chief Shepherd. The authority is real, and it is held on behalf of someone else.
Three features of this shape matter for ministry ethics.
First, authority is given for the sake of others. It is not a reward for the minister, and it is not a private possession. People gave it, or God gave it through them, so that they might be served.
Second, service does not remove the office. Jesus washes feet and remains Lord. A minister who gives up all firmness, all decision and all leadership, in the name of humility, may be leaving the flock without a shepherd. Humility in this sense is not weakness. It is a way of holding strength.
Third, the example is visible. "I have given you an example." Authority that is truly for service can be watched, and it can stand being watched. This will matter in lecture 1-4, where we look at how a minister can be held to account.
The minimum this course asks
Whatever a tradition teaches about the source of ministerial authority, this course asks one thing of every minister: authority is given to build up the people entrusted to it, and it is to be held in ways that serve them. Every other rule in the course is a way of checking that this is what the authority is doing.
4. How traditions understand authority
Christian communities have organised authority in different ways. Each way carries real strengths and real risks. None of them is the villain of this course, and none of them is the answer to every problem. The summaries below are short on purpose. They describe tendencies, and any one community may differ.
Episcopal settings (communities led by bishops, such as many Catholic, Orthodox, Anglican and some Lutheran and Methodist churches). Authority tends to come through ordination (the church's act of setting a person apart for ministry) and through a bishop who oversees a region. A priest or pastor acts within the bishop's oversight. Strength: there is a person and an office above the local minister, to whom a complaint can be taken, and a wider church to which the minister belongs. Risk: the overseer may be far away, or may be reluctant to act against a colleague, so that the structure exists on paper while the local minister is effectively alone.
Presbyterian settings (communities governed by elders or a council of elders, local and regional). Authority tends to be shared: the minister is one among elders, and larger bodies oversee smaller ones. Strength: it is hard for one person to decide everything. Risk: a council may be chosen by the minister, or may defer to a strong personality, so that plural leadership becomes agreement by habit.
Congregational settings (communities in which the local assembly decides, often by vote, including many Baptist and some other free churches). Authority tends to rest with the whole body of members, which calls and may dismiss its minister. Strength: the minister serves under the people. Risk: members may be unwilling to challenge a minister they depend on, or the minister may be dismissed unfairly by a group that has been turned against him or her. Both risks fall on a small congregation with particular force.
Charismatic and independent settings (communities in which authority rests on a founder's call, a gift recognised by the people, or a network of relationships rather than a formal office). Authority tends to be personal and may be strong. Strength: it can move quickly, and a gifted leader can serve people the official structures have not reached. Risk: when authority rests on one person's call, and there is no body that can question it, nobody is placed to check it. This is why, in such communities, voluntary structures of accountability matter more, not less. Lecture 1-4 returns to this.
Catholic and Orthodox settings, including religious orders. Here authority is bound up with the sacraments (rites such as baptism and communion): the priest acts in a role that the church holds to be given by Christ through ordination. Catholic priests are usually celibate, Orthodox parish priests may be married, and some priests serve within an order whose rule asks obedience to a superior. Confession is an office of trust in which a person speaks to a priest as to Christ's minister. Strength: the role is larger than the person, with a long tradition of discipline and of care for the one confessing. Risk: because the office is held to be given by God, a person may find it hard to question the one who holds it, and a community may find it hard to believe that one who wears the office has done wrong.
Communities with no external office. Many small churches, mission posts, house churches and ministries in remote places have no bishop, no council and no denominational office within reach. The minister may be the only trained person for many days' travel. These communities face the same questions as every other, with fewer structures to answer them. The minister of such a place can build accountability, for example with a trusted outside adviser or a small written . Week 5 of this course is about exactly that.
Each of these settings can hold a faithful ministry, and each can hide a failed one. What differs is where the check is placed. The point of this lecture is not to find the best arrangement. It is to notice that, in every arrangement, the question "who can question me?" has an answer, and that the minister should know the answer.
5. Where readers will not agree: how much deference does an office deserve?
This is a point where readers will not agree. Some Christians hold that the office itself deserves a high degree of deference, quite apart from the person who holds it. They point to texts such as Hebrews 13:17, which asks believers to obey and submit to their leaders, and to a long tradition in which a bishop, a priest or an elder speaks with an authority that is not his own. For them, a community that weighs every pastoral word on the scales of personal approval has no shepherd; and a minister who must prove himself or herself afresh to everyone each week cannot serve. Respect for the office, they say, also protects the ordinary believer from being left to the opinion of the loudest voice.
Other Christians hold that deference should follow the faithful use of authority, not come before it. They point to the Bereans, who examined the Scriptures to see whether what Paul said was so (Acts 17), and to prophets and apostles who corrected leaders openly. For them, a community that gives an office high deference with no habit of testing is exposed: the more a person is trusted, the more it matters that the trust be checked, and an office that cannot be questioned will sooner or later be used by someone who should not hold it.
Both positions have serious defenders in every tradition, and each is held out of love for the flock. What this course requires is less than either side would ask on its own. It does not require a congregation to approve of every decision, nor to trust every minister without question. It requires two things of the minister: that deference be received as something given for the people's sake and never demanded for the minister's sake, and that there be some structure, in the community or beyond it, through which the minister can be questioned. How much deference the office should receive in ordinary matters is left to each tradition to settle.
6. A small case: the same decision, held in two ways
(An invented example.) A parish has a long-running Thursday evening group for young adults. The priest, who has led it for six years, decides on his own to end it, because he is tired and the numbers have dropped. He announces the decision after the Sunday service. A few members are upset. One of them, a woman who has attended since she arrived in the country, says, "Father, may we talk about it?"
One way to hold the decision. He replies, "The matter is decided. A pastor must make hard choices, and the parish must trust that I have prayed about this." The decision may well be a reasonable one. But the way he holds it tells the woman, and everyone who hears of it, that no question is welcome and that his authority can be used to close a conversation.
A better way. He says, "Yes, of course. I made this decision because I am worn out and because attendance has been small. I may have been wrong not to ask you first. Could you and two others meet with me and the parish council next week? I will explain what I know, and I am prepared to hear another view. If the council thinks the group should go on, we will look for how." He keeps the office and the final responsibility. He also lets his reasons be seen and questioned, and he points to a body that shares the decision.
Nothing in the better answer gives up his authority. It shows what the authority is for: the care of a group of people, which he does not own.
7. What good use looks like
It is easy for a course on ethics to be read as a list of things not to do. So it is worth saying plainly what authority looks like when it is doing what it is given for.
- It makes people more able, not more dependent. A good minister trains others to read, to pray, to lead, and does not keep all of that in one pair of hands.
- It gives reasons. A decision that touches people is explained, so that they can understand, ask and, if necessary, disagree.
- It can be questioned without penalty. A person who asks "why?" is not marked as disloyal.
- It accepts limits. A good minister knows what is not his or hers to decide, and refers it to the council, the bishop, the congregation, a specialist, or the people concerned.
- It stays open to correction. The minister can say, "I was wrong," and can say it without fear.
None of these is a technique. Each is a way of holding power as something lent.
Diagram 1. Where power comes from, and what it is for
Diagram 2. Five settings, one question
| Setting | Tends to hold authority in | Where the check is placed | A risk to watch |
|---|---|---|---|
| Episcopal | The bishop and the line of ordination | The bishop and the wider church | An overseer too far away or too slow to act |
| Presbyterian | Elders, and councils above them | The council and larger bodies | A council that only agrees with a strong minister |
| Congregational | The assembly of members | The members, who call and may dismiss | Members who depend on the minister and cannot question |
| Charismatic and independent | A founder's call or recognised gift | Voluntary advisers, covenants, peers | No body able to question one strong leader |
| Catholic and Orthodox, including orders | Ordination, the sacraments, a superior | A bishop, a superior, church-law discipline | An office too sacred to be questioned |
In short
- Power is the ability to affect others; authority is power a community has recognised; a minister usually holds both, and influence besides.
- A minister's power comes from role, knowledge, spiritual standing, access, resources and others' dependence. Each can serve or press down.
- Jesus changes the shape of authority from lordship to service, yet keeps the titles: "for so I am." Peter says the flock is entrusted, not owned.
- Every tradition places the check somewhere: a bishop, a council, the members, voluntary advisers, a superior. A minister should know where.
- The minimum for every minister: authority is given to build up those entrusted to it.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Authority | Power that a community has recognised and given to a person for a place from which to speak and act. |
| The shape of authority (Mark 10) | Not lording it over others; greatness measured in service, as the Son of Man came to serve. |
| 1 Peter 5:3 | Elders are not to lord it over those "entrusted" to them; the flock is given into their keeping. |
| The minimum this course asks | Authority is given to build up those entrusted to it, and is held so that it can be questioned. |
One sentence to remember Authority is lent to a minister by other people, so that those people may be built up.
This week's action Write down, in one line each, where your own authority comes from and who in your community or beyond it could question you.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- In your own words, what is the difference between power, authority and influence? Which of the three is hardest for a minister to notice?
- In Mark 10, Jesus sets his followers against the way "rulers of the nations" hold power. Does he remove authority altogether, or change its shape? What in the passage supports your answer?
- Of the six sources of a minister's power, which is most present in the community you know best? Which is hardest to see?
- In the tradition you know best, where is the check on a minister placed? If someone were worried about a minister, to whom could they go?
- Which of the two views on deference, in the paragraph beginning *This is a point where readers will not agree*, seems stronger to you? Say it as the other side would most want it said.