Lecture 1-4: Authority and Accountability in Different Traditions
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What Authority Is For
- Lecture 1-2: How Authority Is Misused
- Lecture 1-3: Unequal Power and Why Consent Is Not Enough
- Lecture 1-4: Authority and Accountability in Different Traditions
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, My Map of Power
- Lecture 2-1: Scripture and the Minister's Money
- Lecture 2-2: Pay, Gifts and Conflicts of Interest
- Lecture 2-3: Openness and Shared Control
- Lecture 2-4: Honest Reports and Honest Appeals
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Checklist for My Money
- Lecture 3-1: Dual Relationships
- Lecture 3-2: Sexual and Romantic Boundaries
- Lecture 3-3: Meeting, Messaging and Online
- Lecture 3-4: Family, Favourites and Friends in Ministry
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: My Boundary Statement
- Lecture 4-1: What Is Told to You, and Where Silence Ends
- Lecture 4-2: Records, Data and Gossip
- Lecture 4-3: Honesty About Yourself and Your Work
- Lecture 4-4: When Silence Becomes Concealment
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab, An Honesty Check
- Lecture 5-1: Not Standing Alone
- Lecture 5-2: Shared Oversight
- Lecture 5-3: Codes of Conduct and Personal Covenants
- Lecture 5-4: Tired, Lonely and Hurt: When Ethics Gives Way
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: My Web of Accountability
Lecture 1-1 said that every tradition places the check on a minister somewhere. Lecture 1-2 showed how authority drifts, and lecture 1-3 showed why the minister, and not the other person, carries the responsibility for limits. This lecture asks the practical question that follows: when something goes wrong, or is about to, who can hold a minister to account, and how?
The answer differs from one community to another. Some ministers have a bishop, some an eldership, some a congregation that can dismiss them, some a founder's circle, some almost nobody. This lecture describes how each kind of community tends to carry accountability, what it does well, and where it tends to fail. It ranks none of them. Every arrangement in this lecture has been the home of faithful ministers and also of failures.
It then turns to a question that matters to many readers: what can a minister who has no overseer build for himself or herself? And it asks what any structure must do to be real, rather than a name on a page.
What these 28 minutes give you
- Describe, for episcopal, presbyterian, congregational, charismatic and independent, and Catholic and Orthodox settings, how a minister tends to be held to account, with a strength and a risk of each.
- Use five plain questions to test whether any structure of accountability is real.
- Explain how Acts 15 and Exodus 18 are read by different traditions, and what both show about authority that is shared.
- Describe what a minister with no overseer can build, without presenting it as a substitute for a real body.
- Explain why a structure that exists only on paper is not accountability.
Some men came down from Judea and taught the brothers, “Unless you are circumcised after the custom of Moses, you can’t be saved.” Therefore when Paul and Barnabas had no small discord and discussion with them, they appointed Paul and Barnabas, and some others of them, to go up to Jerusalem to the apostles and elders about this question." — Acts 15:1-2
World English Bible
Then it seemed good to the apostles and the elders, with the whole assembly, to choose men out of their company, and send them to Antioch with Paul and Barnabas: Judas called Barsabbas, and Silas, chief men among the brothers." — Acts 15:22
WEB
For it seemed good to the Holy Spirit, and to us, to lay no greater burden on you than these necessary things:" — Acts 15:28
WEB
On the next day, Moses sat to judge the people, and the people stood around Moses from the morning to the evening. When Moses’ father-in-law saw all that he did to the people, he said, “What is this thing that you do for the people? Why do you sit alone, and all the people stand around you from morning to evening?”" — Exodus 18:13-14
WEB
Moses’ father-in-law said to him, “The thing that you do is not good. You will surely wear away, both you, and this people that is with you; for the thing is too heavy for you. You are not able to perform it yourself alone." — Exodus 18:17-18
WEB
Moreover you shall provide out of all the people able men, such as fear God: men of truth, hating unjust gain; and place such over them, to be rulers of thousands, rulers of hundreds, rulers of fifties, and rulers of tens. Let them judge the people at all times. It shall be that every great matter they shall bring to you, but every small matter they shall judge themselves. So shall it be easier for you, and they shall share the load with you." — Exodus 18:21-22
WEB
In Acts 15 a dispute is taken beyond the local church to a larger gathering, and the decision is shared. In Exodus 18 a leader who was carrying everything alone is advised, from outside, to share the load with trustworthy people. Both are about authority that does not stand alone.
1. Five plain questions
Before looking at traditions, here are five questions that can be asked of any structure of accountability, in any community. They are the measure used in the rest of the lecture.
- Who can hear a concern about the minister? Is there a person or group to whom a member, a colleague or a young person can go, and do they know about it?
- Who can act? A body that can listen but cannot restrain or remove has a voice and no hands.
- Who sees what the minister does with money, time and closeness? Accountability needs sight. If nobody outside the minister sees the accounts, the diary or the way he or she relates to young people, nobody can notice a problem early.
- Is the body independent enough to say something unwelcome? If every member of the body was chosen by the minister, depends on the minister, or is a close friend, the structure may be real in form and weak in practice.
- What happens to a person who raises a concern? If raising a worry carries a cost, no one will do it, and the structure will hear only what is comfortable.
A structure that can answer all five is doing its work. One that cannot is a name, not a check.
2. Episcopal settings: held by a bishop
In churches led by bishops, a priest or pastor usually serves under the bishop of a region and has been ordained, or appointed, within a wider body. The bishop typically has the right to hear complaints, to move, restrain or suspend a minister, and, in serious cases, to begin a formal process. Bishops themselves are usually answerable to other bishops: to a council of bishops (a synod), a senior bishop or, in some Orthodox churches, a patriarch (a senior bishop over a large church), according to the tradition.
Strengths. There is a person with a clear office to whom a concern can be taken, and a larger church that the minister belongs to. Written rules of discipline often exist. Ministers move between places, which can prevent a long and private hold on one community. In many of these traditions the priest or pastor also has a confessor or a spiritual director to whom he or she is accountable in a different way.
Risks. A bishop may be far away, may govern a large area, and may know the local minister mainly through reports the minister writes. A bishop may also be reluctant to act against a colleague, or may think first of the church's name. A person with a concern may not know where to go, or may fear that the office will side with its own. The structure then exists on paper, while the local minister, in practice, acts alone.
3. Presbyterian settings: held by elders and councils
In communities governed by elders, a minister is usually one member of a body of elders, and the local body is answerable to a regional body, which in turn may answer to a larger assembly. Decisions are made together, and a complaint can be taken to the local council or to the next body.
Strengths. No single person decides everything. A complaint can be taken to people who share the minister's work and know the community. There is usually a written order for how a case is heard.
Risks. A council may be small, or chosen by the minister, or made up of people who owe him or her a great deal. It may defer to a strong personality, or avoid a hard conversation for the sake of peace. A regional body may meet rarely, and hear a case only after it has been in trouble for a long time. Plural leadership is a good protection, and it is only as good as the independence of those who share it.
4. Congregational settings: held by the members
In communities where the local assembly governs itself, the congregation calls the minister, and may end the call. Complaints are often heard by a committee of members or by the whole body. Some belong to an association or a convention of churches that offers counsel, but does not command.
Strengths. The minister serves under the people, and the people have the final word. This fits the biblical picture of a gathered community that bears responsibility for its own life.
Risks. Members often depend on the minister for care, friendship and teaching, so it is costly for them to bring a complaint. In a small church, where almost everyone is related, the risk is greater. The members may also be misled by a persuasive minister, or may dismiss a faithful minister unfairly because a group has turned against him or her. Where there is no body outside the congregation to turn to, a wrong done by a minister, or to a minister, may have no place to be heard.
5. Charismatic and independent settings: held by a circle
In communities founded on a leader's call or gift, accountability rests, if it exists, on a circle of other leaders, on a network of related churches, on a board, or on an outside adviser. In many such communities a founder or senior leader holds great practical authority and is, in effect, the final voice.
Strengths. These communities can respond quickly and can reach people whom older structures have not reached. A leader with a clear can carry a work that would otherwise not exist. Many have built excellent structures of their own, such as boards with outside members and written covenants.
Risks. Where authority rests on a single person's call, nobody is placed to say that the call has been misused. A board may consist of the leader's friends or relatives. A network may share the leader's view and hold back from saying anything unwelcome. For this reason, in such communities, voluntary structures of accountability matter more, not less. A leader who has chosen them freely, and who can be outvoted by them, is safer than one who has not.
6. Catholic and Orthodox settings, including religious orders
In Catholic and Orthodox communities, a priest or serves under a bishop, and a member of a religious order may also be under a superior of the community. Catholic priests are usually celibate, Orthodox parish priests may be married, and those who belong to an order have promised obedience, poverty and chastity or similar vows, according to the rule of their order. These traditions have long-established written rules of discipline, with processes for hearing a complaint and for acting on it. Many priests make their own confession to another priest.
Strengths. The role is larger than the person, with centuries of experience in discipline and care. A member of an order lives under a rule and a superior, and may be moved or called back. There are recognised ways to address a case, and a wider church that has thought about them for a long time.
Risks. Because the office is held to be given by God, people may find it very hard to question someone who holds it, and may find it hard to believe that such a person has done wrong. The sacred standing of the office can protect the person in it more than the people who were harmed. Local leaders may be tempted to handle a matter within the community to protect its name. In some places, the structure is strong in form and hard for an ordinary person to reach.
7. A minister with no overseer
Many readers serve in places with no bishop nearby, no council above them, and no association that would notice if something went wrong. A small church in a remote region, a missionary on a new field, a minister of a house church, a chaplain working alone, a founder of a small ministry: each may be the only trained person for a long way. This is not a failure of the minister. It is a fact of the place. But it means that the minister has to build, with deliberate effort, what other communities are given.
Here is what is possible, even in a very small place. The list builds a structure; it is not a way of avoiding one.
- Choose an outside adviser. One or two people with experience, who are not members of the congregation, who do not depend on the minister for anything, and who are free to say what the minister does not want to hear. They need not live nearby: regular conversation by telephone or message can serve. Choose someone who will be honest, not someone who will be comfortable.
- Give them the right to ask. Tell the adviser, and the people of the community, that the adviser may ask about money, about closeness and about how decisions are made, and that the minister will answer.
- Form a small body inside the community. Two or three trusted adults, ideally not related to the minister, who meet regularly, can see the accounts, and can hear a concern. They do not need to be experts.
- Write a short promise. A page that states how the minister will handle money, how and where he or she will meet with people, and whom anyone may go to with a concern. Give it to the people. Week 5 returns to this.
- Make it known how to complain. A member should be able to learn, without asking the minister, whom to speak to if they are worried. Write the name where people can read it.
- Say what happens to those who raise a concern. State that no one will be punished for raising one in good faith.
- Know your local law and the rules of any association you belong to. They differ by country and region, and some duties, especially those for children and vulnerable adults, are fixed by law and not by the church. A course on church safety covers this in more detail.
None of this replaces a real overseer. It is a way of making sure that the minister is not alone with his or her own power.
8. A small case: a body that is only on paper
(An invented example.) A pastor in a large town leads a growing independent church. He has a board of five, and the church's papers describe it as the body that oversees him. In practice, he chose each member when the church began. Three are his relatives. The board meets once a year to approve the budget he has prepared. When a member of the church, who works in the office, asks him why a repair contract was given to a company owned by a cousin of the pastor's wife, he says, "The board has approved it." The member does not ask again, because the board is mostly the pastor's family and friends. Measured by the five questions: the board can hear a concern, in form, but it is not independent. It cannot act against him, because he can replace it. It sees the accounts once a year, after the decisions were made. A person who raised a concern would be raising it with the same people. The structure exists and does not check anything. A better path: the pastor, seeing this, invites two outside people who do not depend on him, such as an experienced minister from another church and an accountant from outside the congregation, to join the board, with the right to see the accounts at any time. He writes that anyone may bring a concern to them. He also asks that the contract in question be reviewed by someone without a connection to it. This costs him some freedom, and it protects him, and the church, from a danger he could not see from the inside.
9. Acts 15 and Exodus 18: how traditions read them
The two main passages of this lecture are read differently by different traditions, and that fact is useful.
In Acts 15, a dispute arises in Antioch about what is required of non-Jewish believers. The local church does not settle it alone. Paul and Barnabas are appointed to go up to Jerusalem "to the apostles and elders" (15:2). The apostles and elders gather, and the passage says that the decision seemed good to them "with the whole assembly" (15:22), and that it "seemed good to the Holy Spirit, and to us" (15:28). Traditions with bishops often see in this the apostles acting as a governing body. Traditions with elders see a council of elders reaching a decision together. Congregational traditions note the phrase "the whole assembly." Different communities read the same chapter differently, and each reading has some support in the text. What the chapter shows, and what all can accept, is a community in which an authority question is taken beyond one person, heard in the open, and decided together, with people who disagreed given a hearing.
In Exodus 18, Moses is sitting from morning to evening to judge the people. His father-in-law, Jethro (named in Exodus 18:1), who is not an Israelite official, sees it and says, "The thing that you do is not good" (18:17). He advises Moses to appoint able men who fear God, men of truth who hate "unjust gain," to share the work, and to keep for himself only the great matters. The passage shows that it was an outsider, who was not under Moses' authority, who saw what Moses could not, and that Moses listened. It also shows that sharing the load is not a loss of authority, because Moses remained the leader. It makes the leader safer, and the people better served. And notice what kind of people Jethro asks for: not people who agree, but people who are able, who fear God and who hate unjust gain.
What a real structure does
Whatever tradition a minister belongs to, a real structure of accountability can hear a concern, can act on it, can see what the minister does, is free to say what is unwelcome, and does not punish those who bring a concern. A structure that cannot do these things is a name, and it gives the minister a false sense of safety.
10. No tradition is the villain
Notice what this lecture has not said. It has not said that bishops are safer than elders, or that congregations are safer than founders, or that big churches are worse than small ones. Failures happen in every arrangement, and so do faithful, careful ministries. What matters is not the label on the structure but whether it passes the five questions. A bishop who listens and acts is a real check; a bishop who does not is a name. A congregation that can hear a concern and does not punish the one who brings it is a real check; one that cannot is not. A minister who sits alone in a small place and has chosen two honest advisers may be better held than one who sits under a large body that has never been asked a hard question.
Diagram 1. Where the check is, and five questions to test it
In short
- Every setting places the check somewhere: a bishop, elders and councils, the members, a circle or board, a superior. Each has real strengths and real risks. None is ranked.
- Five questions test any structure: who hears, who can act, who sees, who is free to say the unwelcome, and what happens to the one who speaks.
- A body chosen by the minister, meeting rarely and unable to act, is accountability in name only.
- A minister with no overseer can build one: an outside adviser, a small trusted body, a written promise and a known way to complain.
- Acts 15 and Exodus 18 show authority that is shared, heard in the open and checked from outside, and each tradition reads them in its own way.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Five questions for a structure | Who hears a concern; who can act; who sees money, time and closeness; who is free to say the unwelcome; what happens to a person who speaks. |
| A structure on paper | A body that exists in form but is chosen by the minister, rarely meets, or cannot act. |
| Exodus 18 | An outsider tells Moses that carrying everything alone is not good; sharing the load makes him safer and the people better served. |
| No overseer: what to build | An outside adviser, a small trusted body, a written promise, and a known way to complain. |
One sentence to remember What matters is not the label on a structure but whether it can hear, see, act and speak without fear.
This week's action Answer the five questions about the structure you are under, or build, in one line each, and mark the weakest answer.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- In the tradition you know best, how would a concern about a minister travel? Who would hear it, who could act, and would an ordinary member know?
- Choose one setting described in the lecture that is not your own. State its strength as someone who belongs to it would state it, and its risk fairly.
- Apply the five questions to the structure you know best. Where does it answer well, and where is it a name only?
- The lecture says that, for charismatic and independent communities, voluntary structures matter more, not less. Why?
- If you served alone in a remote place, whom would you ask to be your outside adviser, and what would you give them the right to ask?