FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

FS102E Ministry Ethics and Boundaries: Power, Money, Relationships, Accountability

Lecture 4-2: Records, Data and Gossip

Contents 31
FS102E Ministry Ethics and Boundaries: Power, Money, Relationships, Accountability
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Power Given to Build Up
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Power Given to Build Up
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Power and Spiritual Authority
  1. Lecture 1-1: What Authority Is For
  2. Lecture 1-2: How Authority Is Misused
  3. Lecture 1-3: Unequal Power and Why Consent Is Not Enough
  4. Lecture 1-4: Authority and Accountability in Different Traditions
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, My Map of Power
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Money and Gifts
  1. Lecture 2-1: Scripture and the Minister's Money
  2. Lecture 2-2: Pay, Gifts and Conflicts of Interest
  3. Lecture 2-3: Openness and Shared Control
  4. Lecture 2-4: Honest Reports and Honest Appeals
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Checklist for My Money
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Relationships and Sexual Boundaries
  1. Lecture 3-1: Dual Relationships
  2. Lecture 3-2: Sexual and Romantic Boundaries
  3. Lecture 3-3: Meeting, Messaging and Online
  4. Lecture 3-4: Family, Favourites and Friends in Ministry
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: My Boundary Statement
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Confidence, Information and Honesty
  1. Lecture 4-1: What Is Told to You, and Where Silence Ends
  2. Lecture 4-2: Records, Data and Gossip
  3. Lecture 4-3: Honesty About Yourself and Your Work
  4. Lecture 4-4: When Silence Becomes Concealment
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab, An Honesty Check
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Structures of Accountability
  1. Lecture 5-1: Not Standing Alone
  2. Lecture 5-2: Shared Oversight
  3. Lecture 5-3: Codes of Conduct and Personal Covenants
  4. Lecture 5-4: Tired, Lonely and Hurt: When Ethics Gives Way
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: My Web of Accountability
Chapter 6 · Week 6: When Wrong Comes to Light
  1. Lecture 6-1: Mistake, Violation, Abuse
  2. Lecture 6-2: Taking Responsibility
  3. Lecture 6-3: The Harmed Person First
  4. Lecture 6-4: Forgiveness, Restoration and Return
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab, A Plan for the Day It Comes

Jump to the key points ↓

28 min

Lecture 4-1 was about what a person says to you aloud. This lecture is about what you know, what you keep, and what you say about others when they are not in the room. A minister knows a great deal about people: where they live, what they earn, who is ill, who is divorced, who has left the country and who has not been allowed to enter it, whose child is in trouble, who has not paid a debt. Some of it was told in confidence. Much of it was simply seen, over years. None of it was given to the minister to be used for any purpose the minister likes.

Three things need care. One is the use of what you know. One is the keeping of it, in notebooks, phones, membership lists and shared files. And one is the talking about people, from the gentle form we call concern to the plain form we call gossip. All three are ways in which power over information can slide into misuse, and in each the person whose information it is has the least say.

This lecture does not give rules about data, because laws about personal information differ greatly by country and region, and some places have strong ones and some have none. It asks instead what a minister owes to the people whose information is held, and how to build habits that keep faith with them anywhere.

What these 28 minutes give you

  • Explain why information a minister holds about members is held for a purpose, and name some uses that go beyond that purpose.
  • Tell a prayer request from gossip using a few plain questions.
  • Name the risks of messaging groups and shared files, and the habits that reduce them.
  • Say what a minister can ask about keeping records, and why the answer depends on local law and on community rules.
  • Describe how to speak, and how not to speak, about another minister.

A perverse man stirs up strife. A whisperer separates close friends." — Proverbs 16:28

World English Bible

‘You shall not go up and down as a slanderer among your people. “‘You shall not endanger the life of your neighbor. I am Yahweh." — Leviticus 19:16

WEB

So the tongue is also a little member, and boasts great things. See how a small fire can spread to a large forest!" — James 3:5

WEB

And the tongue is a fire. The world of iniquity among our members is the tongue, which defiles the whole body, and sets on fire the course of nature, and is set on fire by Gehenna." — James 3:6

WEB

But nobody can tame the tongue. It is a restless evil, full of deadly poison." — James 3:8

WEB

For lack of wood a fire goes out. Without gossip, a quarrel dies down." — Proverbs 26:20

WEB

These verses do not forbid speaking of other people. They describe what speech can do: it can separate friends, endanger a neighbour, and spread like fire. They also show the other side: without a whisperer, a quarrel dies down.

1. Information is held for a purpose

A minister comes to know things in three ways. Some things are told in a conversation. Some are written down on a form: a membership card, a baptism or wedding record, a list of children and their parents, a record of what a family gave. And some are simply learned by being present: you notice that a man has not been at work, that a couple do not speak, that a girl is always alone.

Each of these was given or learned for a purpose. The woman who filled in the form wanted her child to be baptised. The family that told you about their debt wanted help. The man whose seat is empty did not tell you he was out of work; you saw it. The central idea of this lecture is a simple one: information a minister holds is held for the purpose for which it came, and for the benefit of the person it concerns.

This gives a test for any use. Ask: Is this the purpose for which I was given it? A phone number given so that the church could tell a family of a funeral is not given for a fund-raising message. A home address given for the visiting team is not given for a political campaign. A record of giving kept so that a person may have a receipt is not given so that the minister can judge who is faithful. A story told to ask for prayer is not given so that the minister can illustrate a point.

When the purpose differs, ask the person. If the answer is "no", the answer is "no". If you cannot ask, treat the silence as a "no".

2. What a minister often holds, and the temptations that go with it

Addresses, phone numbers and family details. These are needed for the work. The temptation is to share them: to give a member's number to another member who asked, to put a list on a notice board, to add a person to a group without asking. A small habit prevents much trouble: share contact details only with the person's agreement, and where it is the church's custom to publish a directory, make sure each person chose to be in it.

Income, debts and gifts. A minister who handles offerings, or who is asked for help with money, learns who has little and who has much. This is among the most easily misused of all information. It can be used to favour, to press, to pity or to gossip. Even a kind remark ("they are struggling, we should be gentle") carries the information outward. How giving is recorded, who may see the record, and how it is audited belong to Church Finance in Practice: Budgets, Records and Safeguards (PT712E); the point here is that no one should see more of these records than the work needs.

Family history. A minister may know that a marriage was a second one, that a child was born before a wedding, that a parent was in prison, that a family left their country in difficult circumstances. This history is the person's own. It is not part of the minister's stock of stories, and it is not to be brought forward when the person has not brought it.

Legal and immigration status. In many communities, especially among people who have moved to a new country, the minister may know who has the right papers and who has not. This is a very serious kind of information. A person without papers may fear that a word to the wrong ear could separate a family. The rule is the same as for every confidence, and heavier: do not pass on what you know about a person's status to anyone, and do not use it to control a person. If you are asked by an official, do not answer on the spot; take advice from a qualified person about what the law in your place requires and permits. Do not give legal advice yourself; point to a qualified person.

Health. A person's illness is theirs. A minister may visit the sick; but a visit is not a notice. Ask before telling anyone, and ask before putting a name on a list.

What you notice. What you see about a person's life is also a kind of information. The test is the same: is this mine to speak of?

3. Prayer request or gossip?

Here is a hard matter. Prayer is a good thing, and a request for prayer can be a form of gossip with a religious cover. Two people may say the same words. One is carrying a burden to God. The other is carrying a story from house to house.

A few plain questions help. A minister can ask them before passing something on, even under the name of prayer.

  1. Did the person ask me to share this, and with whom? If they did not, I do not share it.
  2. Is this mine to tell? If the matter is another person's (a neighbour's divorce, a child's trouble, a colleague's failure), then the person it concerns is the one who decides.
  3. If the person were in the room, would they be glad I said it? If not, I stop.
  4. What am I hoping the listener will do? If the answer is "pray", I can say, "Please pray for a member of our church who is facing something hard," and add no more. If the answer is "think badly of", I have crossed a line.
  5. Is there a better place to say it? A concern about a person's conduct belongs with that person or with the proper overseer, not in the whisper.

A general request such as "pray for a family in our church who are grieving" is almost always safe. Naming the person is not safe unless the person has agreed. Adding details is never safe, and adding a guess ("I think it is because of...") is worse.

4. Messaging groups and shared files

Messaging groups have changed how information moves. A minister may be in several: the leaders, the youth team, the choir, the prayer team, the whole congregation, the neighbourhood, the family. Each has its own risks.

  • Speed. A message cannot be taken back once it has been read, and a message sent in anger or in worry cannot be unsent in effect.
  • Screenshots and forwarding. What is written for six people can reach six hundred. Write in a group only what you would be willing to see repeated.
  • Who is in the group. A person added by someone else may see things they should not. A person who has left the group may still hold what was said. Check the list before you post something sensitive.
  • Names and photos. A photo of a person, especially a child, a sick person or a person in distress, is information about that person. Ask before posting. Where children are involved, local rules and a course on church safety (PT717E) apply.
  • The role of the one who runs the group. The person who started or administers a group sets its tone. If gossip begins, that person can say, "Let us take this off the group," and speak to the person privately.
  • Where it is stored. Phones are lost. Accounts are shared. A group may be on a service that keeps messages for years. Do not use a group for a matter that could harm someone if it were found.

A simple habit covers most of this: do not use a group for a person's private matter. Use a call, a visit, or a short private message to the people who need to know.

5. Keeping files and records

Ministers keep records: lists, notes of visits, minutes, baptism and marriage registers, files on staff, files on those who asked for help. This is not wrong; some records are necessary, and a church that keeps none may find it cannot protect anyone. But each record is a risk. The questions below are for any record.

  • Why do I keep this? For what purpose? If I cannot say, I may not need it.
  • How little can I keep? Keep what the purpose needs and no more. Keep facts, not judgements. A note that says "attended twice; asked about baptism" is safer than one that says "seems unstable".
  • Who can see it? A notebook in a bag, a file on a shared computer, a phone with no lock, a folder open to the whole team: each decides who may read. Keep sensitive notes where only the people who need them can reach them.
  • How long do I keep it? Some records must be kept for a long time by law or by the community's rules; some should not be kept past their use. The answer depends on where you are.
  • What happens when I leave? A minister who moves on leaves behind notes and lists. Who owns them? Who receives them? Records of private conversation should not simply pass to the next person; ask the community's rules, and where there are none, ask an overseer.
  • Whose are they? The records belong to the people they concern in a moral sense, even where the law treats them differently.

A note on law. In many countries there are laws about personal information: how it may be gathered, stored, shared and deleted, what people may ask to see about themselves, and what must be done if a record is lost. Some places have strong laws, some have weak ones, and some have none. Church records may be treated in a special way, or not. This course gives no legal rule, and it does not teach the detail of collecting, storing and deleting records, which a longer study of personal information in ministry would cover. It asks you to find out what applies in your place, from your community's written rules and from a qualified person. A minister who does not know whether such a law applies is not excused; the answer is to ask.

6. Speaking about another minister

Ministers talk about each other. Sometimes this is plain gossip. Sometimes it is a real concern. The lecture's rule here is not "never speak", because there are times when a concern about a colleague must be spoken, and silence would be a failure. Lecture 4-4 and lecture 6-3 are about those times. The rule is about the manner, the place and the aim.

The aim. Do I want the matter put right, or do I want to feel better, or win something, or lower the person in another's eyes? Speech aimed at repair is one thing, speech aimed at harm another.

The place. A concern about a colleague belongs first with the colleague, if that is safe, and then with someone who has authority to act: an overseer, a board, a trusted senior person. It does not belong with the congregation, with a member who has no part in it, or with a neighbouring church's members. Where the concern is about harm done to someone, the path is different: the harmed person's safety comes first, and the matter is taken to those who can protect and act. Do not take such a matter into the whisper network, and do not confront alone.

The manner. Say what you saw, not what you suppose. Say "I heard the minister say X on Sunday," not "He always does this." Say what you do not know. Leave out the adjectives.

The praise. Speaking well of another minister is also a part of the task. In a small place, where ministers compete for the same people, and in a place where one tradition looks down on another, it is a quiet act of integrity to speak honestly and kindly of colleagues, including those whose teaching you do not share. Honest disagreement can be stated without contempt. A minister who is never heard to say a good word of another soon teaches the congregation to speak the same way.

A word about predecessors

A new minister often hears stories about the one who came before, from people who were hurt, who were fond of the old minister, or who simply like to talk. Listening is right. Passing judgement is not. If something that sounds like harm is mentioned, it must be taken seriously and to the proper place, with the harmed person's safety first. If it is only a difference of style, do not let your first months be spent in judging someone who is absent.

7. Four small cases

(An invented example.) The address list. Peter, a church secretary, is asked by a member to hand over the list of all families with phone numbers so that she can send a message about her husband's new shop. He gives it. Some families did not agree to be on any list shared with members. What was crossed: the numbers were given for the church's own contact, and were used for a private business. A better path: offer to send her message on the church's behalf, if the leaders agree it is suitable, and keep the list in the church's hands.

(An invented example.) The group message. A women's leader posts in the whole-congregation group: "Please pray for Sara, whose marriage is in trouble." Sara had told her only in confidence, and had not been to anyone else. What was crossed: a private matter was put in front of a hundred people under the name of prayer. A better path: ask Sara first, in private. If she wishes the congregation to pray, let her choose the words.

(An invented example.) The file left open. A youth minister keeps notes about the young people on a shared computer in the church office, in a folder anyone who uses the computer can open. One note says that a boy "seems troubled at home". A volunteer opens it by chance and mentions it to the boy's friend. What was crossed: a record with a private judgement was kept where it could be seen. A better path: keep notes to what is needed, in a place only the right people can reach; where a worry about a child is serious, take it to the church's safeguarding person rather than leaving it in a folder.

(An invented example.) The new pastor and the old. Elena has just taken over a small church. At a lunch, an older member says, "The last pastor was a fraud, you know." Elena nods and says, "I have heard that too." What was crossed: she gave weight to a charge she knew nothing of, and made it a shared view. A better path: "If you have a concern about something that happened, I would like to hear it in a proper way. I will listen, and I will not repeat it." Then, if there is a real matter, take it to the proper authority.

8. What good looks like

It helps to end with a picture of the minister who keeps faith with information. This minister has a short, plain rule for each kind of information. When asked for a number, says, "I will ask them." Puts few names on lists. Keeps few notes and keeps them safely. Does not post a person's trouble anywhere. Is known as someone who "never repeats anything", and so receives more trust and not less. Knows the community's rules and local law on records, or knows whom to ask. Speaks of other ministers as he or she would wish to be spoken of. This minister is not silent. This minister speaks, but only what is theirs to say.


Diagram 1. Before you pass it on

Records, Data and Gossip Information is held for a purpose and for the person it concerns Five questions for any request or remark 1. Did the person ask me to share it, and with whom? 2. Is it mine to tell? 3. Would they be glad if they were in the room? 4. What do I hope the listener will do? 5. Is there a better place to say it? Six questions for any record Why do I keep it? How little can I keep? Who can see it? How long do I keep it? What happens to it when I leave? What do local law and my community's written rules say? Messaging groups can be forwarded cannot be taken back no private matters here ask before names or photos Speaking of a colleague aim: to put right, not to harm place: with them or an overseer manner: what I saw, not guesses and speak well where it is true Handle with most care immigration or legal status income and debts health family history, children's names If you would not say it in front of the person, do not pass it on.

Diagram 2. Prayer request or gossip

A prayer request Gossip under a religious name
Who asked The person, or someone they allowed Nobody asked
Who is named Only those the person agreed to The person, with details and guesses
What the listener is asked to do Pray Think about the person, usually with worry or judgement
If the person were in the room They would be glad They would be hurt

In short

  • Information a minister holds was given or learned for a purpose, and it is held for the benefit of the person it concerns. A different use needs that person's agreement.
  • A prayer request has a person's permission and asks the listener to pray. Gossip under a religious name has neither, and adds details and guesses.
  • A messaging group cannot take a message back. Do not use it for a person's private matter, and ask before posting names or photos.
  • Keep as few records as the purpose needs, keep facts rather than judgements, keep them where only the right people can reach them, and find out what local law and your community's rules say.
  • Speak of another minister with the aim of repair, in the proper place, saying what you saw, and speak well of colleagues where it is true.
Front Back
Why a minister holds a member's information It came for a purpose and is held for the person's benefit; a different use needs their agreement.
Prayer request or gossip? Did the person ask me to share it, with whom, and would they be glad to hear it said?
A messaging group Cannot take a message back. Keep private matters out; ask before names or photos.
Speaking of another minister Aim at putting things right, speak in the proper place, say what you saw, and speak well where it is true.

One sentence to remember Information is lent to you for a purpose, so use it only for that purpose and for the person it concerns.

This week's action Look at one list, file or group you manage, and ask the six questions about it; change one thing so that fewer people can see more than they need.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • What kinds of personal information does a minister in your place come to hold? Which of them could do the most damage if it were passed on?
  • Think of a time when a request for prayer reached you in a way that felt more like gossip. What made it so?
  • What habit could your leadership team adopt so that private matters are not placed in a messaging group?
  • What do you not know about the law and your community's rules on keeping records? Whom could you ask this week?
  • How would you respond if someone began to tell you a bad story about a minister who is not present? What would you say, and what would you do afterwards?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.