Lecture 2-3: Openness and Shared Control
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What Authority Is For
- Lecture 1-2: How Authority Is Misused
- Lecture 1-3: Unequal Power and Why Consent Is Not Enough
- Lecture 1-4: Authority and Accountability in Different Traditions
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, My Map of Power
- Lecture 2-1: Scripture and the Minister's Money
- Lecture 2-2: Pay, Gifts and Conflicts of Interest
- Lecture 2-3: Openness and Shared Control
- Lecture 2-4: Honest Reports and Honest Appeals
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Checklist for My Money
- Lecture 3-1: Dual Relationships
- Lecture 3-2: Sexual and Romantic Boundaries
- Lecture 3-3: Meeting, Messaging and Online
- Lecture 3-4: Family, Favourites and Friends in Ministry
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: My Boundary Statement
- Lecture 4-1: What Is Told to You, and Where Silence Ends
- Lecture 4-2: Records, Data and Gossip
- Lecture 4-3: Honesty About Yourself and Your Work
- Lecture 4-4: When Silence Becomes Concealment
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab, An Honesty Check
- Lecture 5-1: Not Standing Alone
- Lecture 5-2: Shared Oversight
- Lecture 5-3: Codes of Conduct and Personal Covenants
- Lecture 5-4: Tired, Lonely and Hurt: When Ethics Gives Way
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: My Web of Accountability
Lecture 2-2 asked what a minister does when his or her own advantage sits beside a decision. The answer was always some form of the same move: bring another person in. This lecture turns that move into a pattern for the way money is handled in a community.
The pattern has two parts. The first is shared control: no single person, and above all no minister alone, should hold all of the power over money. The second is openness: the people who gave, and the people who are responsible for the community, should be able to see, at a suitable level, where money came from and where it went.
Neither part rests on a suspicion that the minister is dishonest. Quite the reverse. In the passage we read below, Paul is a man whose honesty is not in doubt, and he arranges shared control all the same. The reason is that openness protects four people at once: the givers, who know their gift went where they meant it to go; the community, which can see how it is served; the work, which is not damaged by rumour; and the minister, who cannot be accused of what he or she had no chance to do.
What these 26 minutes give you
- Explain from 2 Corinthians 8 why a person of good character may still arrange for shared control of money.
- Describe the principle of "two people for money" and say why the second person should be independent of the minister.
- Explain why a minister should not set his or her own pay alone, and describe two ways in which different traditions share that decision.
- State fairly two views on how much of a minister's pay and giving should be made known, and say what this course requires.
- Describe what protects the privacy of donors, and what a minister must not do with giving records.
- Explain what makes an appeal for money honest, and what "money given for a purpose" requires.
We have sent together with him the brother whose praise in the Good News is known through all the assemblies. Not only so, but who was also appointed by the assemblies to travel with us in this grace, which is served by us to the glory of the Lord himself, and to show our readiness." — 2 Corinthians 8:18-19
World English Bible
We are avoiding this, that any man should blame us concerning this abundance which is administered by us. Having regard for honorable things, not only in the sight of the Lord, but also in the sight of men." — 2 Corinthians 8:20-21
WEB
A false balance is an abomination to Yahweh, but accurate weights are his delight." — Proverbs 11:1
WEB
The setting of the Corinthians passage is a collection of money for believers in need in another place. Paul, who is organising it, takes care to see that others who have the community's trust are appointed to travel with him. The proverb is about the market, but the principle is the same: honest weights are a delight to God.
1. Paul and the appointed companion
Paul is raising money from several communities for people who are poor in another region. He is about to carry it. He could simply say, "You know me; trust me." Instead he does something else. He writes that a certain brother, "whose praise in the Good News is known through all the assemblies," was "appointed by the assemblies to travel with us in this grace" (2 Corinthians 8:18-19). A person chosen by the churches themselves will go with him.
Then he gives his reason:
"We are avoiding this, that any man should blame us concerning this abundance which is administered by us."
"Having regard for honorable things, not only in the sight of the Lord, but also in the sight of men."
Notice three things.
First, the point is not that Paul might steal. It is that nobody should be able to blame him. He is protecting the work and the givers from a doubt, and himself from an accusation. The risk he names is one of reputation, and also of the truth: if the money is handled openly, the story told about it can be checked.
Second, he cares about what is honourable "not only in the sight of the Lord, but also in the sight of men." He does not say that it is enough to be right with God and that human opinion does not matter. In the matter of money, people have a right to see. A good conscience before God is not a reason to refuse to be seen.
Third, the companion is chosen by the churches, not by Paul. The second person is independent of the one who handles the money. That is the point of having one.
This is the shape we will follow through the lecture: a person of character who nevertheless arranges for others to see and share.
2. Two people for money
One of the oldest and simplest practices of care is that money is not handled by one person alone. When offerings are collected and counted, at least two people do it, and they are not close relatives of one another or of the minister. When money is paid out, more than one person knows. When accounts are kept, someone other than the person who keeps them looks at them.
This is not a technique for a large church only. A house church with a dozen members can do it in its own way: two members count together and both sign a note of the amount; a third looks at the note once a month. A rural parish with one priest can have two lay people who count, and a council member who reads what they write. A monastery or a religious community has its own ways of counting and checking, and its superior is not the only person who sees the books.
Who is a good "second person"? Not just any person. Look for someone who:
- is not dependent on the minister (not an employee, a close relative or a person whose position the minister controls);
- is trusted by the community;
- can say, without fear, "I do not think that is right";
- is not the same person every time, if the community is large enough to choose.
A minister's spouse or child is seldom the right second person, however honest, because they cannot easily be independent. That is not a judgement of their character. It is a recognition that people who share a household share an interest.
The protection runs both ways. A minister who is accused of taking money from an offering that he or she never touched is saved by the fact that two others counted it. A minister who has always handled money alone has no answer except "Believe me." The practice is a gift to the honest.
The details of how to count, record, bank, audit and report belong to Church Finance in Practice: Budgets, Records and Safeguards (PT712E). Here we are concerned with one idea only: that the minister is not the only person with power over money.
3. Not setting your own pay alone
The most important single case of shared control is the minister's own pay, housing and allowances. Lecture 2-2 named it as the sharpest form of a conflict of interest, because the minister would be both the judge and the one who gains.
Traditions arrange this in different ways, and each has strengths and risks.
- Where a wider body sets the scale (a diocese, a synod, a province, a religious order, an association), the minister does not set pay at all. Strength: the minister is not the judge. Risk: the scale may not fit the local situation, and the body itself should have openness about how it sets its scales and uses its funds.
- Where a council, elders or a board decides, the minister is not part of the decision, or leaves the room when it is made. Strength: the people who pay decide, in the open. Risk: if the council is chosen by the minister or made up of the minister's relatives, friends and employees, the council may only be a way of agreeing with the minister.
- Where the congregation votes, the minister's pay is a matter for all. Strength: wide consent. Risk: the minister may be embarrassed to be talked about; a large group may decide hastily.
- Where there is no body above the minister, which is common in new, independent and small communities, the minister may in practice be the founder, the leader and the treasurer all at once. This is not wicked, and it is common among sincere people. It is also a risk, because no one is placed to say no.
What can a minister in that last situation do? Build a structure for himself or herself. Invite two or three people who are independent, trusted by the community and not dependent on the minister, to form a small group that agrees the minister's pay in writing, reviews it each year, and sees the accounts. If nobody in the community is able to do this, ask a trusted minister from another community, or a qualified adviser, to take the role. The point is that someone other than the minister can say, "That is too much," or, if it is true, "That is too little."
It is worth saying that shared control works in the other direction too. Many ministers are underpaid, and a minister alone is often too shy to ask for a fair wage. A body that is responsible for the pay can say what the minister cannot say. A minister should not have to beg for what the work deserves. Shared control is a protection for the community, and also for the minister who is too modest.
4. How much should be known
This is a point where readers will not agree: how much of a minister's pay, benefits and personal giving should be made known to the whole community.
Some hold that the whole community has a right to know: the full amount paid to the minister, the housing, the allowances, and a summary of income and spending. They say that what is known cannot be whispered about, that rumour is more harmful than the truth, and that a minister who has nothing to hide should be willing to show it. They add that when people give, they have a right to know what their gifts support.
Others hold that the minister's pay and household affairs are a matter for the council, the overseer, or an auditor, and that publication to the whole community is neither necessary nor kind. They say that in many cultures a person's income is private, that publication can lead to comparison, envy and pressure on the minister's family, and that a trusted few can check what the many cannot understand. In some traditions the minister's accounts are seen by the bishop or the superior and not by the congregation, and this is part of the way that tradition shows accountability.
Both views take the same thing seriously: people should be able to trust that money is handled honestly. One does it by making it widely known, the other by making it known to a few who are independent and responsible.
This course requires less than the first view and more than nothing. It does not require that every detail be public. It requires that someone who is independent of the minister, and who can say no, knows and can check what the minister is paid, what he or she receives, and how the community's money is used; and that the people as a whole know the system under which this is done, even where they do not see every figure. A community that cannot answer the question "Who checks the minister's money?" has a gap.
5. Donors and their privacy
Openness about the community's money is not the same as exposing the people who gave it. Those two aims need care together.
Gifts are often made with a quiet hope that they will not be spoken of. The Lord's own teaching speaks of giving in secret: "so that your merciful deeds may be in secret" (Matthew 6:4). Others give more because they are recognised, and some people have reasons to keep their giving private for their own safety. A community that publishes the name of every giver, with the amount, can hurt the poor, who cannot give much, and can seem to rank people by their gifts. For these reasons, many communities keep individual giving private, while reporting the total.
Some communities allow the minister to see who gave what. Some do not, and keep the records with a treasurer or office. Customs differ and we will not say which is right. What matters is what the minister does with what he or she knows. If a minister knows who gives much and who gives little, three temptations follow:
- to favour the large givers, by listening more carefully to them or being slower to correct them;
- to press the small givers, by a sermon, a hint or a visit;
- to tell others, by a comment or a story that reveals a person's giving.
None of these is acceptable. If you cannot see the records without being pulled in one of these ways, it is wise to arrange that you do not see them, and that another person does.
6. Honest appeals, briefly
When a community needs money, someone must ask. Asking is not wrong. Paul asked, in this very letter. What makes an appeal honest? The next lecture treats it at length. Here are three rules that belong to openness.
State the purpose plainly. The people who give have a right to know what they are giving to.
Keep the money for the purpose stated. Money given for a roof is used for the roof. If the plan changes, because the roof was repaired for less or the need has passed, ask the givers, or the body that speaks for them, before using it for something else. This is the plainest sense of "accurate weights" in Proverbs 11:1: what the giver was told and what the community did must be the same.
Leave people free to say no, and do not make them feel that a refusal is a failure of faith. Lecture 2-4 returns to this.
7. Three short cases
(An invented example.) One counter. In a small church, an older member, trusted by everyone, has counted the Sunday offering alone for many years. He puts it in a bag and takes it to the bank on Monday. Nothing has ever gone wrong. One Monday he is ill, and the bag is found to contain less than expected. Nobody can say what happened. What was crossed? Nothing wicked, but the system rested on one person's honesty, and when a doubt arose nobody could show what was true. The better path would have been to have two counters, a signed note each week, and a monthly look by a third person. The change would have protected the old man most of all.
(An invented example.) A founder and a board. A pastor started a new church ten years ago. Its board has three members: the pastor's brother, the pastor's friend from childhood, and a member who is employed by the church. They meet once a year and agree whatever the pastor proposes, including a rise in the pastor's pay. Nobody has done anything wrong that we can see. What is missing? Anyone who could say no. The better path would be to invite two or three people who are independent of the pastor to join the board or to form a small advisory group, to put the pastor's pay and allowances in a written agreement reviewed each year, and to have the accounts looked at by a person outside the family.
(An invented example.) A good practice. In a rented hall, a congregation of about sixty meets under a minister who serves without pay and works as a driver during the week. Every Sunday two members count the offering and write the amount on a sheet, which both sign. Once a quarter a third member, who is a nurse, reads the sheets and the bank record and reads a short report to the congregation. The minister's travel costs, which the church repays, are written in the same report. Nobody has ever needed to doubt it. The minister says that this is a relief: "I never have to defend myself."
8. What this lecture asks, and what it does not
It does not ask for suspicion, or for complicated systems. It asks that money be handled in a way that does not depend on any one person being good all the time. That includes the minister, and includes the treasurer, the counter and the overseer. Shared control and openness are what remain when we admit that all of us are sometimes tired, tempted, mistaken or short of money.
It does not tell any community how to do this. A community can make it fit what it has. What it cannot do, if it takes the central claim of this course seriously, is leave a minister alone with the community's money, with nobody able to ask.
Diagram 1. Shared control and openness
Diagram 2. Who decides the minister's pay
| Where pay is set | A strength | A risk |
|---|---|---|
| A wider body (diocese, synod, order, association) | Minister is not the judge | Scale may not fit the place; the body needs openness too |
| A council, elders or board | The payers decide in the open | Council may be only a way of agreeing with the minister |
| The congregation | Wide consent | Embarrassment; hasty decisions |
| No body above the minister | Simple, direct | No one placed to say no; build an outside group |
In short
- Paul, whose honesty was not in doubt, arranged for an appointed companion so that no one could blame him (2 Corinthians 8:18-21).
- Shared control means money does not depend on one person being good. It protects givers, community, work and minister.
- A second person for money should be independent of the minister; a spouse or child is seldom the right choice.
- A minister should not set his or her own pay alone. Wider bodies, councils or outside advisers can share the decision.
- Traditions differ on how much is made public; the course requires that someone independent knows and can check.
- Giving records are never used to favour, press or tell; money given for a purpose is used for it, or the givers are asked.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| 2 Corinthians 8:20-21 | Paul arranged an appointed companion so no one could blame him, honourable before God and before people. |
| A good second person | Independent of the minister, trusted by the community, able to say no. |
| Pay | Never set by the minister alone; a body, council or outside group shares the decision. |
| The minimum on openness | Someone independent knows and can check; the community knows the system. |
One sentence to remember Money is safest in a community where it does not depend on any one person, including the minister, being good all the time.
This week's action Write down who counts, records and checks the money in the community you know best, and whether any of them is independent of the minister.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Paul says he wishes to avoid blame "not only in the sight of the Lord, but also in the sight of men." Why does a good conscience before God not remove the need for openness?
- In your place, who counts and records money? Is there a second person who is independent of the minister? If not, who could be?
- A minister who is also the founder and treasurer says, "Nobody has ever asked me to account." Why might this be a sign of risk and not of trust?
- State, in the strongest honest form, one reason a community might publish a minister's pay and one reason it might not.
- If you could see who gave what in your community, how would you guard yourself against favouring, pressing or telling?