Lecture 2-4: Honest Reports and Honest Appeals
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What Authority Is For
- Lecture 1-2: How Authority Is Misused
- Lecture 1-3: Unequal Power and Why Consent Is Not Enough
- Lecture 1-4: Authority and Accountability in Different Traditions
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, My Map of Power
- Lecture 2-1: Scripture and the Minister's Money
- Lecture 2-2: Pay, Gifts and Conflicts of Interest
- Lecture 2-3: Openness and Shared Control
- Lecture 2-4: Honest Reports and Honest Appeals
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Checklist for My Money
- Lecture 3-1: Dual Relationships
- Lecture 3-2: Sexual and Romantic Boundaries
- Lecture 3-3: Meeting, Messaging and Online
- Lecture 3-4: Family, Favourites and Friends in Ministry
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: My Boundary Statement
- Lecture 4-1: What Is Told to You, and Where Silence Ends
- Lecture 4-2: Records, Data and Gossip
- Lecture 4-3: Honesty About Yourself and Your Work
- Lecture 4-4: When Silence Becomes Concealment
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab, An Honesty Check
- Lecture 5-1: Not Standing Alone
- Lecture 5-2: Shared Oversight
- Lecture 5-3: Codes of Conduct and Personal Covenants
- Lecture 5-4: Tired, Lonely and Hurt: When Ethics Gives Way
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: My Web of Accountability
Money in a ministry travels along a road of words. A person gives because of something that was said: a report of what the work has done, a description of a need, a story of a life changed, an invitation to give. If the words are true, the money travels honestly. If the words are stretched, the money travels on a false map, even when every coin is later spent well.
This lecture is about those words. It does not repeat lecture 2-3, which was about who handles money and who can check. It asks a different question: is what we say to raise money, or to raise our standing, true? There are three common places where it is not. The first is the report: attendance, baptisms, conversions, people helped. The second is the need: how poor a community is, how urgent a project is, how sad a story is. The third is the appeal: how the asking is done, and what it presses on the person who is asked.
The lecture also treats a hard subject fairly: Christians teach giving in different ways, and the minister who asks, and who also benefits from what is given, is in a conflict of interest that has to be named.
What these 31 minutes give you
- Explain why Acts 5:1-4 is about a pretence and not about the amount, and why it must not be used to pressure people to give.
- Describe how reports, needs and stories can be inflated, and what an honest practice looks like for each.
- Explain why a hurting person's story is not material for an appeal unless that person freely agrees, and what else must be true.
- Say what makes an appeal press on the poor, and describe an appeal that leaves a person free.
- Describe tithing, almsgiving, free-will offerings and the teaching that giving brings material blessing, each in a form its holders would accept, and say what this course requires of every minister whichever is held.
Remember this: he who sows sparingly will also reap sparingly. He who sows bountifully will also reap bountifully. Let each man give according as he has determined in his heart; not grudgingly, or under compulsion; for God loves a cheerful giver." — 2 Corinthians 9:6-7
World English Bible
For we are not as so many, peddling the word of God. But as of sincerity, but as of God, in the sight of God, we speak in Christ." — 2 Corinthians 2:17
WEB
But a certain man named Ananias, with Sapphira, his wife, sold a possession, and kept back part of the price, his wife also being aware of it, and brought a certain part, and laid it at the apostles’ feet. But Peter said, “Ananias, why has Satan filled your heart to lie to the Holy Spirit, and to keep back part of the price of the land? While you kept it, didn’t it remain your own? After it was sold, wasn’t it in your power? How is it that you have conceived this thing in your heart? You haven’t lied to men, but to God.”" — Acts 5:1-4
WEB
The first passage is Paul's appeal to a community, and it is notable for what it does not say. The second is a short sentence about the integrity of speech. The third is the account of a married couple who sold land, kept back part of the price and presented the rest as the whole. We will read it with care, and only once.
1. Not peddling the word
Paul writes to the Corinthians:
"For we are not as so many, peddling the word of God. But as of sincerity, but as of God, in the sight of God, we speak in Christ."
The word translated "peddling" belongs to the market. It describes a seller who dilutes the goods, or who deals in the word of God as a trader deals in anything that will sell. Paul sets against it three things: sincerity, being from God, and speaking in the sight of God. The last means: as though God were watching, which in Paul's mind he was.
Nothing in the verse tells us that asking for money is peddling. Paul asked for money. What the verse names is something closer to adjusting the message to the market: saying what sells, shaping the word to what the hearer will pay for. A minister who reports a rise in numbers that did not happen, who describes a need as worse than it is, or who tells a story that is not quite true in order to open a purse, has begun to peddle. The vice is not in the asking. It is in the shaping of the words by the aim of getting.
2. Acts 5: a pretence, not an amount
The story of Ananias and Sapphira is often read as a warning to those who do not give enough. That is a misreading, and a harmful one.
The text itself says something else. A couple sold a piece of land. They kept back part of the price and brought the rest, presenting it as the whole. Peter says to the man:
"Ananias, why has Satan filled your heart to lie to the Holy Spirit, and to keep back part of the price of the land?"
"While you kept it, didn’t it remain your own? After it was sold, wasn’t it in your power? How is it that you have conceived this thing in your heart? You haven’t lied to men, but to God."
Look at what Peter says. The land was theirs. The money was theirs. Nobody forced them to sell or to give. They were free to give some, all or none. Their wrong was not in keeping part. It was in pretending: they wanted the credit of having given everything, and they lied to get it. The sin was a false report about their own giving, made in order to win standing in the community.
That is why the story belongs in this lecture. It is a story about a dishonest report of a gift, and it speaks to anyone, minister or member, who is tempted to be seen as more generous, more sacrificial or more successful than they are.
Two cautions are needed. First, the account is told in the earliest days of the community in Jerusalem and the severity of what follows has been understood in different ways by Christians. Nobody should draw from it that a minister may threaten a member who gives little, or may suggest that the Lord will punish people who do not give. A minister who uses Acts 5 to press members for money has read it backwards. Second, the story is a narrative about two people in one place, and it should not be turned into a rule for what a community must do to those who do wrong.
3. Reports: the numbers
A report is any statement of what a ministry has done: how many came, how many were baptised or confirmed, how many were helped, how many gave, how much was raised. Reports are not wicked. They are a way of being honest with the people who support a work. But numbers have a pull of their own. A larger number brings more support and more standing, and a smaller number brings the opposite. Here are the common ways in which reports bend.
- Rounding up. "About two hundred" becomes "over two hundred" and then "two hundred and fifty."
- Counting generously. Everyone who came once in a year is counted as a member. Everyone who raised a hand is counted as a conversion. A child who came to a meal is counted as a child reached.
- Choosing the best week. The attendance at a festival is given as if it were an ordinary Sunday.
- Leaving out the losses. A report tells how many came in and says nothing of how many left.
- Changing the way of counting. A report counts people one year and families the next, and the figure rises.
What does an honest practice look like?
- Count the same way each time and say how. "Adults and children present at the main service on the first Sunday of the month" is a number that can be compared. A number with no description can not.
- Report what did not work. A report that tells only of success is not believed by those who know better, and does not help those who give to decide wisely.
- Say "about" when it is about, and give a range if you are not sure.
- Let someone else look at the figures. A second person who has seen the count, as lecture 2-3 described, makes the report a community's report and not only the minister's.
- Do not report what a person feels as if it were an event. "Many hearts were touched" is a statement about hearts, and nobody can check it.
The same care applies to titles and credentials. Lecture 4-3 treats them in detail. Here it is enough to say that a report in which a minister's own standing is raised is one the minister should be least willing to write alone.
4. Needs and stories
When money is asked for a need, the description of the need is the heart of the appeal. It is also where the pull to exaggerate is strongest. A school with twenty children is described as a school for hundreds. A room that needs paint is described as in danger of collapse. A poor family is described as poorer than it is, or described in a way it would not choose.
Three rules help.
Describe the need as it is, and no worse. If a project is half funded, say so. If the need has partly been met, say that too. If you do not know the figure, say that.
Do not tell a story that is not true, even if it is "true in spirit." A composite story, in which several people are joined into one, should be called a composite. A story from long ago should not be told as if it were last week. Where a story has been improved in many tellings, check it before telling it again.
Never use a person's suffering without that person's free agreement, and then not carelessly. A photograph of a child in hardship, a story of a woman who was abused, the account of a man's illness: each belongs to the person it happened to. A person who is poor, sick or in trouble is not material for a campaign. Ask yourself: has the person freely agreed, knowing where the story will go, and could he or she have said no with no loss? If the person is a child, or cannot easily refuse, or lives in a place where saying no to a donor or a minister is difficult, the answer is usually to leave the story out, or to tell it so that no one could know who it is. The dignity of the person is worth more than the money the story might raise. A good report of need shows a community as having strengths and hopes as well as lacks, and does not make people look smaller than they are.
5. Testimonies of giving
In many communities, people tell stories of their own giving: "I gave all I had, and God opened a door." These can be moving and true. They can also be misused.
A testimony is an account of one person's experience. It is not a promise. A minister who invites such testimonies, or who tells them, should take care not to join the testimony to an implied rule: "Give as this man did, and you will receive as he did." The person who gave and then fell ill, or lost a job, or whose business failed, hears a different message from the one the storyteller meant. Nor should a minister use a testimony to make those who gave less feel small.
A rule of thumb: say what happened, and do not say what will happen.
6. Appeals that press
Paul writes to the Corinthians about giving:
"Let each man give according as he has determined in his heart; not grudgingly, or under compulsion; for God loves a cheerful giver."
The sentence has two halves. Each person gives according to a decision made in the heart. Not according to the minister's decision, or the group's, or the person next to them. And not grudgingly, or under compulsion. A gift given because one could not refuse is not what Paul is asking for.
This shows what an appeal must not do. It must not press. Pressure takes many forms, and some are hard to see because they are so common.
- Guilt. "If you loved the Lord, you would give." "Others have given more."
- Public display. Reading out names and amounts. Asking people to stand, or to walk forward, or to hold up a card, so that others see who gives and who does not.
- Fear. Suggesting that those who do not give will be cursed, or that the community will suffer, or that God will be displeased.
- A promised return. Telling people that a gift will return to them many times over, in money, health or success.
- Deadlines and urgency. A sudden claim that the need must be met tonight, so that there is no time to think or to talk with family.
- Asking those who cannot. Pressing people who have little, or who are in debt, or whose families depend on what they earn.
- Asking people who depend on you. A person who receives help from the church, or who is employed by it, or who is in your care, cannot easily refuse you.
An honest appeal has other marks:
- It states what the money is for and how much is needed.
- It states where the money will go and who will see that it does.
- It says that giving is free and that nobody will be thought the less for not giving.
- It makes no promise of material return.
- It is made in a way that those who cannot give are not shamed.
- It is repeated no more than is needed.
An appeal like this might sound as follows: "Our roof needs repairs, which we think will cost about this much. The church council has two quotes and will publish the account when the work is done. Anyone who wishes may give this month or next, in the usual way. If you cannot give, we are glad to have you with us. Pray with us about it." It is not as exciting as the other kind. It is much more likely to be trusted.
7. How traditions teach giving
Christians do not teach giving in one way. A minister in one tradition may serve people who hold another view, and a minister should describe all of them in a way their holders would accept.
Tithing. Many communities teach that a tenth of one's income belongs to God, often taken from the Old Testament. Some hold that it is binding on Christians. Others see it as a helpful measure and a starting point. Others hold that the Old Testament law does not bind, and that Christian giving should be generous beyond a tenth or more freely given. Each of these is held by thoughtful people.
Almsgiving. In Catholic, Orthodox and many other traditions, giving to the poor is a central act of devotion and discipline, often linked with fasting and prayer. The emphasis is on direct care for those in need, and often on giving quietly.
Free-will offerings. Many communities invite each person to give as they decide, without a set amount, in the spirit of 2 Corinthians 9:7.
First fruits and pledges. Some give the first of what they earn or grow, and some make a yearly promise of an amount. The first can be a mark of trust. The second can be a way of planning. Either can be turned into pressure.
Teaching that giving brings blessing. Some teachers, especially in some charismatic, Pentecostal and independent communities, teach that God promises to bless those who give, often in material ways. They point to passages about sowing and reaping, such as 2 Corinthians 9:6 above, and to stories in which a giver is blessed. Held in its strongest form, this is a teaching of faith and gratitude: that God is generous, that giving is an act of trust, and that those who give with open hands often find themselves cared for. Many who teach it do so carefully and give generously themselves.
This is a point where readers will not agree: whether Scripture promises material return for giving. Those who hold that it does say that God is faithful to those who trust him, and that faith should not be embarrassed to expect his goodness. Those who do not say that Scripture promises God's care and not a particular return, that the gift is not a trade, and that those who teach the other way place a heavy burden on the poor, whose misfortune can then be read as lack of faith. Critics also point out that the person who teaches it may also be the person who receives the gifts, which is a conflict of interest.
This course does not decide that question. It does not tell any community what to teach about giving, and it does not ridicule those who teach it differently. It requires three things of every minister, whatever he or she teaches:
- Do not promise a result that you cannot deliver. Do not tell a person that a gift will bring healing, a job, a house or a child.
- Do not let a person believe that their trouble shows that they gave too little. Poverty, illness and loss are not a verdict on someone's giving.
- Say openly where you stand. A minister who teaches that giving brings blessing, and who then receives the gifts, has a conflict of interest, and should say so and let others hold the funds, as lecture 2-3 described.
8. Three short cases
(An invented example.) An annual report. The leader of a small mission writes an annual report to those who support it from abroad. The number of people at the weekly meeting is given as "over a hundred." The leader knows that on the best day, at the festival, there were ninety, and that the usual number is about forty. He fears that the donors will stop giving if the number is small. What was crossed? He gave a number that was not true in order to keep support. What would a better path be? To give the usual number and the best number, to say how each was counted, to tell the donors honestly about what the work does among forty people, and to ask the donors what they would like to know. Those who give to a true report will stay. Those who give to a false one are giving to something that does not exist.
(An invented example.) A photograph. A children's programme wishes to raise money. Someone suggests using a photograph of a sad-looking child, taken in the programme, on a poster. The child's family has not been asked. What was crossed? A child's face is being used to move strangers, with no agreement. A better path is to ask the family, to tell them where it will be used, to let them refuse without loss, and to prefer an image that shows the work and not the child's hardship. Often a picture of the building, or of a group from behind, is as effective, and harms nobody.
(An invented example.) A pledge card. At a yearly festival, the leader asks each family to write an amount on a card and hand it to a steward in front of the group. The amounts are announced before the closing prayer. A family that earns little has written a figure they cannot afford, because they did not wish to be seen writing a small one. What was crossed? The public setting made the gift a matter of standing. A better path is to give cards to be taken home, to be returned privately at any time, to announce only the total, and to say plainly that no figure is expected.
9. What honest asking looks like
A minister who gives accurate reports, tells needs as they are, asks for money in a way that leaves people free, and says openly where he or she stands on teaching about giving does something beyond avoiding wrong. That minister builds a community in which people give because they believe, not because they were pushed. When there is a real need, such a community is more generous, and more willing to forgive honest mistakes.
The central claim of the course applies. Ministry ethics is the limiting of one's own power for the sake of the people who trusted you. A minister has the power to move people to give by words alone. Telling the truth, and leaving people free, is the plainest way of limiting it.
Diagram 1. Three places where words can bend
Diagram 2. Ways of teaching giving, described without ranking
| Teaching | What it stresses | A risk to watch |
|---|---|---|
| Tithing | A tenth as a measure or a duty | Becoming a rule that burdens those with little |
| Almsgiving | Direct care of the poor, often quiet | Giving may be treated as a means of and not of love |
| Free-will offerings | Each decides in the heart | An absence of any guide |
| First fruits, pledges | Trust and planning | Pressure through public pledges |
| Blessing for givers | God's generosity; faith and gratitude | Promise of return; the poor's trouble read as lack of faith |
In short
- Paul sets sincerity against "peddling the word"; the fault is shaping words by the aim of getting.
- Acts 5:1-4 is about a pretence of giving, not an amount; Peter says the land and its price were the couple's own. It is never a threat to use on those who give little.
- Reports bend by rounding up, counting generously, choosing the best week, leaving out losses and changing the count; count the same way and report what failed.
- A person's suffering belongs to that person; use it only with free agreement, and often leave it out.
- An honest appeal states purpose and amount, shows who checks, leaves giving free and promises no return.
- Traditions teach giving differently; whichever is held, promise no result, never read trouble as too little giving, and say where you stand.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| 2 Corinthians 2:17 | Not peddling the word: speak with sincerity, as in the sight of God. |
| Acts 5:1-4 | The wrong was a false show of giving, not keeping part; the gift was free. |
| A story of someone's suffering | It belongs to that person; use only with free agreement, or leave it out. |
| What every minister must do about giving | Promise no return, never blame the poor's trouble on their giving, say where you stand. |
One sentence to remember Money travels on words, so the minister's first duty in asking is that the words are true and the person is free.
This week's action Take one report, appeal or story you have heard or could give, and check it against the lists: is it true, is it fair to the person, is the giver free?
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- In Acts 5:3-4, what exactly does Peter say was wrong? What does he say about whether the couple had to give?
- Think of a report of numbers you have heard. Which of the five ways of bending (rounding up, counting generously, choosing the best week, leaving out losses, changing the count) might have applied?
- Why is a person's story of suffering not simply material for an appeal? What must be true before it could be used?
- Which of the seven ways of pressing in an appeal is the hardest to notice in your own community? Why?
- A minister teaches that giving brings blessing, and also receives the gifts. What can that minister do so that the teaching is not a conflict of interest hidden from the people?