Lecture 3-1: Dual Relationships
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What Authority Is For
- Lecture 1-2: How Authority Is Misused
- Lecture 1-3: Unequal Power and Why Consent Is Not Enough
- Lecture 1-4: Authority and Accountability in Different Traditions
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, My Map of Power
- Lecture 2-1: Scripture and the Minister's Money
- Lecture 2-2: Pay, Gifts and Conflicts of Interest
- Lecture 2-3: Openness and Shared Control
- Lecture 2-4: Honest Reports and Honest Appeals
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Checklist for My Money
- Lecture 3-1: Dual Relationships
- Lecture 3-2: Sexual and Romantic Boundaries
- Lecture 3-3: Meeting, Messaging and Online
- Lecture 3-4: Family, Favourites and Friends in Ministry
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: My Boundary Statement
- Lecture 4-1: What Is Told to You, and Where Silence Ends
- Lecture 4-2: Records, Data and Gossip
- Lecture 4-3: Honesty About Yourself and Your Work
- Lecture 4-4: When Silence Becomes Concealment
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab, An Honesty Check
- Lecture 5-1: Not Standing Alone
- Lecture 5-2: Shared Oversight
- Lecture 5-3: Codes of Conduct and Personal Covenants
- Lecture 5-4: Tired, Lonely and Hurt: When Ethics Gives Way
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: My Web of Accountability
A minister is rarely only a minister. The same person may be your pastor on Sunday, your landlord on Monday, your business partner in the market, your cousin at the family meal and your neighbour across the wall. Each of these is a real relationship, and each carries its own duties. The trouble begins when two of them meet in the same person, because what you owe in one role can pull against what you owe in the other.
This lecture is about those meetings. The ordinary name for them is dual relationships (also called multiple relationships): two or more roles held with the same person at the same time. They are not always wrong, and in many communities they cannot be avoided. What matters is that the minister sees them, says so to someone who can check, and puts limits around them.
The week's principle is the one on which the whole chapter rests: because the minister holds more power, closeness is the minister's responsibility, whatever the other person says. This lecture applies it to friendship, work, money, family and neighbourhood. Lecture 3-2 applies it to romantic and sexual closeness, lecture 3-3 to meetings and messages, and lecture 3-4 to the minister's own household.
What these 24 minutes give you
- Explain what a dual relationship is and why it can pull a minister's duties in two directions.
- Describe the common pairings (friend, employer, business partner, relative, neighbour) and say what each one risks.
- Use four steps (notice, disclose, consult, limit) where a dual role cannot be avoided.
- Explain how favouritism is a form of dual relationship and how Scripture speaks against it.
- Describe fairly how different traditions carry this question, without ranking them.
A man of many companions may be ruined, but there is a friend who sticks closer than a brother." — Proverbs 18:24
World English Bible
I command you in the sight of God, and Christ Jesus, and the chosen angels, that you observe these things without prejudice, doing nothing by partiality." — 1 Timothy 5:21
WEB
My brothers, don’t hold the faith of our Lord Jesus Christ of glory with partiality." — James 2:1
WEB
The first verse says that friendship is a real good, and that it is not all alike. The second and third say that the people who serve others must not act by partiality. Both belong to this lecture: the minister is not asked to have no friends, but to be fair to everyone.
1. What a dual relationship is
A role is a set of duties that comes with a place. A minister has the duties of care, teaching and trust. A landlord has the duties of a landlord. A friend has the duties of a friend: loyalty, and a wish for the other's good. When one person holds two roles toward the same person, there are two sets of duties, and sometimes they point in different directions.
Here is a simple example. A minister is also an employer. As minister, the duty is to care for the worker's soul and welfare. As employer, the duty may be to correct poor work, or to end the job when money runs short. If the worker is unhappy, where can the worker take that? The worker cannot easily go to the minister for comfort about the minister's own decision. That is the shape of the problem: one role takes away the place where the other role would help.
There is a second difficulty. The minister holds more power than the member, as lecture 1-3 explained. The other person depends on the minister for something that matters to them: their standing in the community, their place in the sacraments (the church's sacred rites) or in the they need, or simply the minister's good opinion. A second role added to the first makes that dependence greater, not smaller. A member who is also the minister's employee, tenant or business partner has more reason to say yes, and less freedom to say no.
A word about what this lecture is not. The rules for a counsellor or a pastoral counsellor who sees people in a regular counselling relationship are treated in Caring Within Limits: Ethics, Boundaries and Referral in Pastoral Care (PT723E). Here we speak of the minister's wider life.
2. Five common pairings
Minister and friend. Friendship is a gift, and the minister needs it. Ministers who have no friends are lonely, and loneliness weakens judgement (week 5 returns to this). The Book of Proverbs says that there is a friend who sticks closer than a brother, and the Gospel of John records Jesus saying to his disciples, "I have called you friends" (John 15:15). So the lecture does not say "have no friends in the congregation."
The risk is of a different kind. A friend in the congregation may hear things about the church that others do not. The friend may expect to be consulted, or to be forgiven more easily. Other members may feel that the friend has a door that is closed to them. And if the friend later has a quarrel with the minister, both the friendship and the pastoral relationship are in danger together. A good friendship with a member is possible if the minister keeps one rule: the friend receives no more of the church's attention, information or favour than any other member would.
Minister and employer or employee. A minister may employ a member (to clean, to drive, to mind a child, to repair a building), or a member may employ the minister's family. The risks are the ones named above. The member cannot easily complain, and the minister may find it hard to correct work or end the arrangement. A good practice is to put the terms in writing, to set pay by a fair standard that someone else can check, and to know in advance who the worker may speak to if there is a disagreement. Where the church itself is the employer, this is a matter of church finance and employment, which is the subject of Church Finance in Practice: Budgets, Records and Safeguards (PT712E). Employment law differs by country, and a minister should follow local law and ask a qualified person.
Minister and business partner. A business, a loan, or a shared property with a member is the clearest case, and week 2 (lecture 2-2) treats the money side. For this lecture, note only the relationship side. If the business goes badly, a member who owes the minister money must still sit under the minister's teaching, and the minister must still guard the member's confidence. Many ministers decide not to enter any business or loan with a member at all. Where it cannot be avoided, the four steps below are needed.
Minister and relative. A minister's brother, aunt or cousin may be a member of the congregation. A relative who is also a member can be a joy. The risk is that the relative is treated more favourably, or more harshly, than others, and that family disagreements are carried into the church or the church's disagreements into the family.
Minister and neighbour. In a village, a camp, a block of flats or a small island, the person you are caring for may live twenty steps away and see you in your yard. Neighbourliness is a good. It also means the minister is seen in daily life, and what is seen in daily life is part of the ministry (Titus 2:7-8, lecture 3-3).
3. When a dual role cannot be avoided
Some writers on ministry ethics speak as if every dual role should simply be refused. That advice suits a large church in a city, where there are many other people who can serve as a mechanic, a landlord or a friend. It does not suit many places where this course will be read.
Think of a congregation of migrants in a new country, meeting in a rented room. The minister is the one person who speaks the language of the newcomers and also knows how the offices and forms of the new country work. The minister may be the landlord's translator, the family's adviser, and the pastor all at once. Or think of a mission station with forty families, where the only shop belongs to the church's main donor. Or a monastery where the one in charge may also assign the work and hear the confession of the same brother or sister. In such places roles overlap not because anyone chose it but because there are not enough people.
In that case the question is not "how do I avoid it?" but "how do I carry it safely?" Four steps help, and they are the answer this course returns to:
The four steps
Notice. Say it to yourself: "I hold two roles with this person." Many dual roles go wrong because no one named them.
Disclose. Tell someone who can check: a fellow minister, an , a mentor, an overseer (a person with authority to supervise ministers), a trusted member of the leadership. The point is not a confession; it is that the arrangement is no longer known to one person only.
Consult. Ask that person: what could go wrong here, and what would you want in place? Also ask the other party, in the open: if the two roles ever pull against each other, what should we do?
Limit. Put boundaries around it: terms in writing; one thing at a time (do not add a third role); a person the other party may go to if they are unhappy; a date to review. If the arrangement begins to hurt the other person, end it, and let someone else take the role.
Notice that none of these steps needs a rule from a particular tradition. A bishop, an elder board, a congregation, a council of a monastic community, or a single trusted colleague can each do the checking. What matters is that someone does.
4. Favouritism as a dual relationship
When a minister likes some members more than others, there is a quiet dual role: friend to some and pastor to all. Favouritism is not only a matter of friendship. It appears in who is invited to the minister's home, who is asked to lead, who is visited when ill, who is believed in a dispute, and whose mistakes are overlooked.
Scripture is plain about this. In his letter to Timothy, Paul asks that the instructions be kept without prejudice, doing nothing by partiality (1 Timothy 5:21). The letter of James goes further, and treats partiality toward the rich or the well-placed as a failure in the faith itself (James 2:1). These verses do not ask that a minister love everyone the same, which no one can do. They ask that how the minister acts as a minister (who is chosen, who is heard, who is helped) not be decided by who is a friend.
A practical test: could I explain, in front of the whole congregation, why this person received this invitation, this role, this help? If the honest answer is "because we are close," the choice needs another reason, or another person making it.
5. How traditions carry the question
Traditions differ in what they say about these overlaps, and none of them is the villain.
In episcopal settings (those with bishops), a priest is often moved from one parish to another at intervals. This limits how deeply roots can grow in one place, and so limits some dual roles. The risk is that, when a priest stays long in a small place, the same limits do not apply, and the bishop is far away. In presbyterian settings (governed by elders), the elders themselves are often friends, family or colleagues of the minister, which gives knowledge of the place but can make checking harder. In congregational and independent churches, the members call the minister, and a minister who is also a close friend of the people who call may find it hard to hear a hard word from them. In charismatic communities, relationships are often close, informal and warm, which is a strength, and the closeness may hide the roles. In Catholic and Orthodox settings, a priest may be celibate or married, depending on the tradition, and the parish or the monastery is often his whole community; the roles of confessor, teacher, superior and friend can meet in the same person, and religious communities have long had their own rules about this. And in communities with no external office (a house church, a small mission), the minister may have no outside person to disclose to.
Each tradition has a strength and a risk. The strength of one is often the weakness of another. The course asks only that the four steps be done in whatever structure you have, and that, if you have no structure, you build a small one (an outside adviser is enough to begin; week 5 describes how).
This is a point where readers will not agree: should a minister have close friends inside the congregation at all? Some hold that the answer is no, or hardly. They say that the minister's first duty is to everyone, that a close friendship in the church is always an unfair advantage for one person, and that ministers should find friends outside the people they serve. This view protects the others, and it protects the minister from the loneliness of being judged by those who are also friends. Others hold that a minister who has no friends among the people is a stranger among them. They say the minister also needs to be known, that deep friendship is part of the life of a church, and that to forbid it makes the minister distant and cold, which is its own harm. This view protects the minister from isolation. Both are serious. This course requires less than either. It does not ask the minister to have no friends in the congregation, and it does not say it is always fine to have them. It asks that the minister keep the four steps (notice, disclose, consult, limit), that the friend receive no more of the church's attention than any other member, and that the minister also keep some friendships outside the congregation.
6. Two small cases
(An invented example.) The landlord who is also a member. A minister serves a church of recent migrants. The minister's flat is rented from a member, a kind man who also gives generously to the church. When the heating fails, the member is slow to repair it, and the minister does not like to press him, because he is a donor and a friend. Meanwhile another family complains about the same member's rent for their flat, and asks the minister to speak to him. The minister is stuck: pressing for the heating may offend a donor, and speaking for the other family means taking sides against a member.
What was crossed? Nothing yet. The risk is that the minister's silence, and the pressure the minister feels, now shape what the minister says as a minister. A better path: the minister notices the two roles, tells an elder of the church, and asks the elder to speak to the landlord about the other family. The minister asks the landlord, as a tenant, in writing and like any other tenant, for the repair. And the minister lets the church know that gifts from the landlord do not change how the minister will speak. The roles remain, and they are now limited.
(An invented example.) A good use of a close friendship. A minister and a member have been friends for twenty years. When the minister's name is put forward for a larger role, the member sits on the group that decides, and tells the group, before it meets, "I am the minister's friend. I will take no part in this decision, and I will answer any questions about it afterwards." The group notes this, and goes on without the friend's vote. Nothing was lost. The friendship was not a secret, and the minister received no favour. Because it was said out loud, everyone could trust the decision.
Diagram 1. Two roles, one person
Diagram 2. The four steps
| Step | What it asks | A sign it is not yet done |
|---|---|---|
| Notice | Name the two roles to yourself | You find yourself saying "it is nothing" |
| Disclose | Tell someone who can check | Only you and the other person know |
| Consult | Ask what could go wrong and what should be in place | You have decided already and only want agreement |
| Limit | Terms, a way out, a review date, no third role | There is no way for the other person to say they are unhappy |
In short
- A dual relationship is two roles held with the same person. The duties of one can pull against the duties of the other.
- Because the minister holds more power, a second role makes the other person's dependence greater, not smaller.
- In small and migrant communities many dual roles cannot be avoided. Four steps help: notice, disclose, consult, limit.
- Favouritism is a quiet dual role. Scripture asks for no partiality in how a minister acts as a minister.
- Friends in the congregation are not forbidden; they receive no more of the church's attention or favour than any other member.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Dual relationship | Two or more roles held with the same person, where what is owed in one may pull against the other. |
| The four steps | Notice, disclose, consult, limit. |
| Why a second role adds risk | The other person depends on the minister more, and has less freedom to say no or to complain. |
| A test for favouritism | Could I explain in front of everyone why this person received this role or help? |
One sentence to remember A second role does not remove the minister's duty; it makes the other person less free, so the care must increase.
This week's action List the dual roles you hold, using roles and not names, and tell one trusted person about the one that worries you most.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Name two roles you hold, or could hold, with the same person. What does each role owe? Where could they pull apart?
- A dual role is sometimes unavoidable. Which of the four steps (notice, disclose, consult, limit) would be hardest in your place, and why?
- Who, in your place, could you disclose a dual role to? If the answer is "no one," what could you do about that?
- Think of a time you saw someone favoured in a group you belonged to. How did others feel? What would have been a fairer way to choose?
- Read the paragraph beginning "This is a point where readers will not agree." Which position seems stronger to you? What would the other side say to you?