Lecture 6-4: Forgiveness, Restoration and Return
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What Authority Is For
- Lecture 1-2: How Authority Is Misused
- Lecture 1-3: Unequal Power and Why Consent Is Not Enough
- Lecture 1-4: Authority and Accountability in Different Traditions
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, My Map of Power
- Lecture 2-1: Scripture and the Minister's Money
- Lecture 2-2: Pay, Gifts and Conflicts of Interest
- Lecture 2-3: Openness and Shared Control
- Lecture 2-4: Honest Reports and Honest Appeals
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Checklist for My Money
- Lecture 3-1: Dual Relationships
- Lecture 3-2: Sexual and Romantic Boundaries
- Lecture 3-3: Meeting, Messaging and Online
- Lecture 3-4: Family, Favourites and Friends in Ministry
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: My Boundary Statement
- Lecture 4-1: What Is Told to You, and Where Silence Ends
- Lecture 4-2: Records, Data and Gossip
- Lecture 4-3: Honesty About Yourself and Your Work
- Lecture 4-4: When Silence Becomes Concealment
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab, An Honesty Check
- Lecture 5-1: Not Standing Alone
- Lecture 5-2: Shared Oversight
- Lecture 5-3: Codes of Conduct and Personal Covenants
- Lecture 5-4: Tired, Lonely and Hurt: When Ethics Gives Way
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: My Web of Accountability
Soon after wrong comes to light, someone in the community will say, "We must forgive." It is a Christian sentence, and it is often said sincerely. But it hides three different questions inside one word. The first is whether the person who was harmed forgives. The second is whether trust can be rebuilt. The third is whether the minister may go back to a place of authority. These are three separate matters, with three separate owners, and the answer to one does not settle the others.
When they are mixed together, the one who has done wrong is usually the one who gains, and the one who was harmed usually pays. A congregation that says "we have forgiven him" may be saying that the minister is back in the pulpit. A minister who says "I have been forgiven" may be saying that the matter is closed. A person who was harmed may hear both as a message that their own pain is a delay.
This lecture separates the three. It also describes how some traditions deal with discipline and return, without judging them, and it takes up the hardest question: whether and how a minister who has done grave wrong may ever return to office.
What these 25 minutes give you
- Distinguish forgiveness, restored trust and return to office, and say who owns each.
- Explain what is meant by cheap forgiveness and why it harms.
- Describe, without ranking them, how different traditions handle discipline and return.
- State fairly two positions on whether a minister who has done grave wrong may return, and what this course requires.
- Say what the harmed person and the community need during this period.
Brothers, even if a man is caught in some fault, you who are spiritual must restore such a one in a spirit of gentleness; looking to yourself so that you also aren’t tempted." — Galatians 6:1
World English Bible
Be careful. If your brother sins against you, rebuke him. If he repents, forgive him." — Luke 17:3
WEB
If he sins against you seven times in the day, and seven times returns, saying, ‘I repent,’ you shall forgive him.”" — Luke 17:4
WEB
Sufficient to such a one is this punishment which was inflicted by the many;" — 2 Corinthians 2:6
WEB
so that on the contrary you should rather forgive him and comfort him, lest by any means such a one should be swallowed up with his excessive sorrow." — 2 Corinthians 2:7
WEB
Therefore I beg you to confirm your love toward him." — 2 Corinthians 2:8
WEB
Each passage is about a person who has done wrong and a community that must decide how to treat that person. Notice what each one does and does not say. None of them says that a person who has done wrong has a right to office, and none says that a person who was harmed must forgive on request.
1. Three different things
Forgiveness is the harmed person's letting go of a claim for revenge, and of the bitterness that goes with it. It is theirs to give, in their own time, or to give only in part. It cannot be ordered, scheduled or collected. A person may forgive and still decline any contact. A person may not be ready for a year, or for twenty, and this is not a failure of faith. It does not make the wrong smaller, and it does not require that anyone trust the person who did it.
God's forgiveness of the minister is a different matter. It is between the minister and God. The Bible teaches that it is real, and it is a comfort to a person who has truly turned from a wrong. But it does not settle what is owed to the people who were hurt, it does not remove consequences (lecture 6-1 saw this in David), and it says nothing about office.
Restored trust is the confidence that others place in a person once more. It is not a feeling that can be switched on by a sermon. It is built, slowly, by conduct that others can see, and it is given by the people who are asked to trust. A congregation cannot decide for a harmed person to trust again. A harmed person cannot be asked to be the one who restores the minister's standing.
Return to office is a decision about who may exercise authority in the community. It belongs to the body that holds the office: a bishop, a council, a synod, a congregation, a board or a religious superior. It rests on the safety of the people the office reaches, on evidence of change that has been checked, on the kind of wrong that was done, and on the voice of those who were harmed. The minister does not own it, and friends of the minister cannot decide it alone. Nobody has a right to an office. Ordination or a is one matter. The authority to lead a particular group of people is another.
One word, three owners
Forgiveness belongs to the person who was harmed. Trust belongs to those who are asked to give it, and it is earned by conduct that others can see. Office belongs to the body that holds it, and it is decided for the sake of the people it serves.
2. Cheap forgiveness
Cheap forgiveness is forgiveness spoken to make a matter end, and not out of a settled reckoning with what was done. It takes many forms.
A congregation announces that it has forgiven, and it asks that the matter not be mentioned again. A minister reads Psalm 51 aloud as if the psalm had already done the work. A friend says to the harmed person, "He has repented, and so you must." A leader says that only God may judge, in order to stop an inquiry. In every case the word forgive is used to close a door that someone else still has a reason to keep open.
Three harms follow. The harmed person is hurt a second time, because their pain is treated as a block to the community's peace. The minister is not helped, because a person who is forgiven without having faced what was done has not changed anything. And the community learns that wrongs by those in authority will be quickly hidden under a kind word.
3. Reading the passages
Luke 17:3-4. The order in the verse is rebuke, then repentance, then forgiveness. "If your brother sins against you, rebuke him. If he repents, forgive him." Forgiveness here is a response to repentance, and it is said of a person who repents. The verse speaks of forgiving a person who sins against you, and it is not a rule that a person in authority is restored to authority each time. The same teaching that says "seven times" does not say that the office is open on the seventh.
Galatians 6:1. Paul speaks of a person "caught in some fault" and of those "who are spiritual" restoring that person "in a spirit of gentleness", while looking to themselves. This is a call to gentle, humble care for a person who has fallen. The restoring here is a restoring of the person. It does not say that every restored person is restored to every place. A minister who has done wrong should be cared for, and the community should not abandon that person. Care and return are separate.
2 Corinthians 2:6-8. Paul speaks of a person who caused sorrow to a community and was disciplined by "the many". He says that it is now enough, and that the community should "forgive him and comfort him" lest he be swallowed up by excessive sorrow. Readers have long discussed who this person was, and the course does not decide it. What the passage shows is a community that carried out a discipline and then offered love to a person who was repentant. It is a hopeful picture. It is also a picture of a community that was wronged and a person who turned. It does not describe what to do when a leader has harmed a vulnerable person, and it must not be quoted as though it did. Note, too, that the passage speaks of a discipline already carried out; it does not say that the discipline should not have been given.
4. How traditions handle discipline and return
No tradition is described here as the best, and none as the cause of the problem. Each carries a way of dealing with a minister who has done wrong, and each has risks.
Episcopal communities (those led by bishops) place discipline with the bishop and the church's own courts or procedures. This gives a clear authority and a body of written law. The risk is that a bishop may be too close to the person concerned, or may weigh the community's name too heavily, and that a person without access to the system has no way in.
Catholic and Orthodox communities have their own church law. This law can place limits on ministry, suspend a priest or , and, in the gravest cases, remove a person from the clerical state, which means that the person may no longer act as a priest or deacon. Religious orders have their own superiors and rules. The details are in each community's own law, and they differ among communities. The risk is that a process that is internal and confidential may leave the harmed person without information or a voice.
Presbyterian and Reformed communities place discipline with a council of elders, and a wider body above it, which may suspend or remove a minister. The strength is shared decision. The risk is that elders are often friends, and a wider body can be far from the people affected.
Congregational communities place the decision with the members, usually through a meeting or vote. This gives the people a voice. The risk is that members may be divided by loyalty, and a vote can be a contest of popularity. The harmed person may not have a voice among the members.
Charismatic and independent communities may have a network of leaders, a team of advisers, or only the founder. Some have a process of restoration over a set time. The strength is speed and personal care. The risk is that, where there is no body above, the decision to return may be made by the person's friends, or by the person; and a fixed time can come to stand in place of evidence of change.
Communities with no outside office have no other body to turn to unless one is created. Lecture 5-2 described what can be built: an outside adviser, a written , an agreement in advance about whom to ask.
For all, the question is the same: Who decides, and who in the decision speaks for the people who were harmed?
5. Whether a minister may return
May a minister who has done grave wrong return?
This is a point where readers will not agree. Some hold that a minister who has abused a person in a position of trust should never return to pastoral office. They point out that the office gives access to people who are often in need, that a record of such harm cannot be sure to stop, that a return can tell every survivor that the harm cost the minister very little, and that there are many ways to live a life of faith and service that do not involve authority over others. Others hold that grace must have no limit and that Scripture shows restoration: a person who has truly repented and shown fruit over many years should not be shut out for life, and the community that will never allow a person to return has stopped believing in change. They add that not every wrong is the same, and that the response to a hidden sum of money is not the response to harm of a person. This course asks less of every reader than either side does, and it is firm about the minimum. No minister has a claim to return. The decision is made by a body outside the minister and outside the minister's circle of friends, in writing, after the voice and safety of those who were harmed have been heard and weighed. A return is never to a role that gives access to the people who were harmed, or to people who are in the same position of vulnerability, on the minister's word alone. Where a minister has harmed a child or has used office to exploit a vulnerable person, this course does not ask any community to consider return to a role of care for such people, and many readers will hold that no return is right. Where a community does consider any return at all, it does so under written conditions, with outside oversight, and with a rule that a concern from the harmed person or from anyone else is acted on at once.
Note two things about the minimum. It is a floor, and a community may rightly decide to ask for more. And it does not exclude care for the minister as a person. A person who has done grave wrong still needs help, still has a place in the community as a member, and still needs honest friends. Care for the person and return to office are two different things.
6. Cases
(An invented example.) A money violation. The pastor who used repair funds for heating, from lecture 6-1, told the council at once, repaid the money and accepted that for three years he would not sign payments or hold the keys to the account. A second person took over the treasury. The council wrote what it expected and reviewed it each year. After the review, the council decided that he might act as the second signer on small items, with a report to the council each month, and never alone. This is a return that is staged, written, decided by others, tied to the kind of wrong, and checked. It is not a return that is promised in advance or that depends on how much the congregation likes him.
(An invented example.) A request to "move on". A youth worker was found to have sent secret romantic messages to a teenager in his group. Church leaders told the family of the teenager what they were doing and handed the matter to the authorities that local law names. After some months a group of members came to the leaders. They said, "He has repented. He is suffering. We have forgiven him. It is time to let him teach the young people again." The leaders replied: "Thank you for caring for him. We want him to have a pastor and to keep his place among us as a member. We will not return him to work with young people, and we will not discuss it with you. The family's wishes come first, and the family is not asked to forgive on anyone's timetable." They made sure that someone cared for the youth worker, and someone else cared for the family. Forgiveness by others was kind, and it was not theirs to give on the family's behalf. Care for the person continued, and return to the role did not take place.
7. What the harmed person and the community need
The harmed person needs, in their own order: safety; to be believed; accurate information about what the community is doing; a voice in the process that is real and not for show; help that they choose, paid for if cost is a barrier; freedom from pressure to forgive or to meet the minister; and time. Some will want contact with the community, and some will not. Neither is wrong.
The community needs the truth, told in proportion and without identifying the person who was harmed; room to grieve and to be angry; a way for people to speak who feel their trust has been broken; and care for the families of both the harmed person and the minister, who are also hurt. A "service of healing" held too soon can tell people to stop feeling. The community's own work of repair can be long, and it should not be hurried by a wish to be at peace.
Diagram 1. Three things, three owners
Diagram 2. Care for the person, and return to office
| Question | Who decides | What it rests on |
|---|---|---|
| Does the harmed person forgive? | The harmed person, in their own time | Their own settled judgement; never owed |
| Can trust be restored? | Those asked to trust | Conduct others can see over time |
| May the minister return to office? | The body that holds the office, outside the friendship | Safety, checked change, kind of wrong, the voice of those harmed |
| Is the person cared for? | The whole community | Always, whatever the answer above |
In short
- Forgiveness belongs to the harmed person, trust to those asked to give it, and office to the body that holds it. One does not settle the others.
- Cheap forgiveness closes a matter with a kind word; it hurts the harmed person twice and does not help the minister to change.
- Traditions differ on discipline and return, and each has a strength and a risk. The question for all: who decides, and who speaks for the harmed?
- No minister has a claim to return. A decision on return is made by a body outside the minister's circle, in writing, after the harmed have been heard.
- The harmed person is never pressed to forgive or to meet the minister; the person who did wrong is still cared for.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Forgiveness | The harmed person's letting go of revenge; theirs to give, in their own time; never owed, and not a reason to trust or return. |
| Restored trust | Confidence placed again by those who are asked to give it, built by conduct that others can see over time. |
| Return to office | A decision of the body that holds the office, outside the friendship, resting on safety, checked change and the harmed person's voice. |
| Cheap forgiveness | Forgiveness spoken to end a matter; it silences the harmed person and leaves the minister unchanged. |
One sentence to remember Forgiving, trusting and returning are three separate things, with three separate owners, and no one can be made to do any of them on someone else's behalf.
This week's action Find out, for your own community, who decides whether a minister may return to office, and write one question you would want that body to ask first about the harmed person.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Say, in your own words, why "we have forgiven him" can be a harm when it is said by a congregation about a harmed person's case.
- In your tradition, who decides whether a minister may return to office after a serious wrong? Who speaks in that decision for the people who were harmed?
- Reread 2 Corinthians 2:6-8. What does the passage teach about a community's discipline of a repentant person? What does it not say?
- State the first position in the paragraph on return as its holders would most want it said, and then the second. Which did you find harder to state?
- What does the lecture mean when it says that care for a person and return to office are different?