Lecture 1-2: How Authority Is Misused
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What Authority Is For
- Lecture 1-2: How Authority Is Misused
- Lecture 1-3: Unequal Power and Why Consent Is Not Enough
- Lecture 1-4: Authority and Accountability in Different Traditions
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, My Map of Power
- Lecture 2-1: Scripture and the Minister's Money
- Lecture 2-2: Pay, Gifts and Conflicts of Interest
- Lecture 2-3: Openness and Shared Control
- Lecture 2-4: Honest Reports and Honest Appeals
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Checklist for My Money
- Lecture 3-1: Dual Relationships
- Lecture 3-2: Sexual and Romantic Boundaries
- Lecture 3-3: Meeting, Messaging and Online
- Lecture 3-4: Family, Favourites and Friends in Ministry
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: My Boundary Statement
- Lecture 4-1: What Is Told to You, and Where Silence Ends
- Lecture 4-2: Records, Data and Gossip
- Lecture 4-3: Honesty About Yourself and Your Work
- Lecture 4-4: When Silence Becomes Concealment
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab, An Honesty Check
- Lecture 5-1: Not Standing Alone
- Lecture 5-2: Shared Oversight
- Lecture 5-3: Codes of Conduct and Personal Covenants
- Lecture 5-4: Tired, Lonely and Hurt: When Ethics Gives Way
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: My Web of Accountability
Lecture 1-1 said what authority is for: building up the people entrusted to it. This lecture asks the opposite question. How does authority drift from that purpose?
It rarely happens in one dramatic step. More often a good minister, who really cares, moves a little at a time. A request for loyalty becomes a test of loyalty. A wish for order becomes a demand for control. A need for privacy becomes a habit of secrecy. Nobody sets out to misuse authority. That is why the signs need to be learned in advance, while there is still no one to blame.
This lecture names five common patterns, reads two Bible scenes in which authority was held to account, and reads with care the texts that are often used to say that ministers must not be questioned. It also gives a list of signs to watch for. The list is for noticing, not for judging. It is a set of questions to ask about a situation, never a way of passing a verdict on a person.
What these 30 minutes give you
- Name five patterns in which a minister's authority is misused: control, treating doubt as disobedience, loyalty tests, secrecy, and orders about private life.
- Describe what Eli's household and Nathan before David show about accountability.
- Explain, from the context, what "Do not touch my anointed ones" (Psalm 105:15) and David's refusal to harm Saul (1 Samuel 24) do and do not say.
- Use the list of signs as questions about a situation, without turning it into a verdict on a person.
- Say what a good use of the same power looks like in each pattern.
Now the sons of Eli were base men; they didn’t know Yahweh. The custom of the priests with the people was that when any man offered sacrifice, the priest’s servant came, while the flesh was boiling, with a fork of three teeth in his hand; and he struck it into the pan, or kettle, or cauldron, or pot; all that the fork brought up the priest took therewith. So they did in Shiloh to all the Israelites who came there. Yes, before they burnt the fat, the priest’s servant came, and said to the man who sacrificed, “Give meat to roast for the priest; for he will not accept boiled meat from you, but raw.” If the man said to him, “Let the fat be burned first, and then take as much as your soul desires”; then he would say, “No, but you shall give it to me now; and if not, I will take it by force.” The sin of the young men was very great before Yahweh; for the men despised the offering of Yahweh." — 1 Samuel 2:12-17
World English Bible
Yahweh sent Nathan to David. He came to him, and said to him, “There were two men in one city; the one rich, and the other poor. The rich man had very many flocks and herds, but the poor man had nothing, except one little ewe lamb, which he had bought and raised. It grew up together with him, and with his children. It ate of his own food, drank of his own cup, and lay in his bosom, and was to him like a daughter. A traveler came to the rich man, and he spared to take of his own flock and of his own herd, to dress for the wayfaring man who had come to him, but took the poor man’s lamb, and dressed it for the man who had come to him.” David’s anger was greatly kindled against the man, and he said to Nathan, “As Yahweh lives, the man who has done this is worthy to die! He shall restore the lamb fourfold, because he did this thing, and because he had no pity!” Nathan said to David, “You are the man. This is what Yahweh, the God of Israel, says: ‘I anointed you king over Israel, and I delivered you out of the hand of Saul." — 2 Samuel 12:1-7
WEB
He allowed no one to do them wrong. Yes, he reproved kings for their sakes, “Don’t touch my anointed ones! Do my prophets no harm!”" — Psalm 105:14-15
WEB
The men of David said to him, “Behold, the day of which Yahweh said to you, ‘Behold, I will deliver your enemy into your hand, and you shall do to him as it shall seem good to you.’” Then David arose, and cut off the skirt of Saul’s robe secretly. Afterward, David’s heart struck him, because he had cut off Saul’s skirt. He said to his men, “Yahweh forbid that I should do this thing to my lord, Yahweh’s anointed, to stretch out my hand against him, since he is Yahweh’s anointed.” So David checked his men with these words, and didn’t allow them to rise against Saul. Saul rose up out of the cave, and went on his way." — 1 Samuel 24:4-7
WEB
The first two passages show leaders who had to be answered, and what happened when they were or were not. The last two are often quoted to say that leaders may not be questioned. Part of this lecture reads them in their own settings.
1. Misuse is a drift, not a leap
Every kind of authority carries a temptation to use it for the one who holds it. A bishop can use a diocese. A pastor can use a congregation. A priest can use the trust of a village. A founder can use the loyalty of the first people who followed. A volunteer group leader can use the wish of teenagers to be liked. The temptation does not depend on the size of the group or on the tradition.
Most misuse begins in something good. A leader wants unity, so people who disagree are treated as a threat to unity. A leader wants to protect the church's name, so problems are kept inside. A leader has suffered for the work, and begins to feel that the work belongs to him or her. The motive is often sincere. This is why the usual question, "Does this person mean well?", is not enough. A minister can mean well and still be exercising control. The better question is: what is this authority doing to the people under it?
2. Five patterns
1. Control. Control means that the minister decides what other people may do, say, read, attend or think, beyond what the work of the community requires. A minister has a proper place in setting a church's teaching and order. Control begins where that place is extended to areas that belong to the person or to the family: what a member may read, who they may talk to, what they may ask.
Good use of the same power: the minister sets the order of the service and the content of teaching, explains why, and leaves personal decisions to the people who must live with them.
2. Treating doubt as disobedience. Every community needs a way to say, "We believe this," and every honest believer sometimes struggles with a question. Authority is misused when a question is answered not with an explanation but with a reproach: "Questioning shows a lack of faith." "A faithful person would not ask." The person who asked learns that questions cost something, and stops asking. The result is a congregation in which nobody says what they really think.
Good use: the minister welcomes the question, answers as well as he or she can, says "I do not know" where that is true, and sends the person to a teacher or a text where that would help. A faith that cannot be questioned has not been tested.
3. Loyalty tests. A loyalty test is a situation in which a person must show faithfulness to the leader (rather than to God or to the community's stated beliefs) in order to stay in good standing. It may be spoken: "Whose side are you on?" It may be unspoken: those who agree with the minister get the confidences, the tasks and the invitations, and those who ask questions are quietly set aside. It may be about people outside the group: those who left are described as faithless, and contact with them is discouraged.
Good use: loyalty is asked for to the shared faith and to the community's agreed purposes. A person can disagree with the minister, openly and respectfully, and still be honoured as a member.
4. Secrecy. There are good reasons for confidentiality. A person's private struggles, their health, their family trouble, are not for the whole church. This lecture is not about that. It is about secrecy that protects the leader: decisions that affect people are made where those people cannot see them; money, staffing or discipline are handled in a closed circle; reasons are not given. When the only people who know how a decision was made are the people who made it, nobody can check it. (Lecture 4-4 returns to the difference between keeping confidence and covering up.)
Good use: the minister keeps private what belongs to individuals, and keeps open what belongs to the community: how decisions are made and by whom, and how money is spent (week 2).
5. Orders about private life. A minister may offer wise advice on marriage, work, study, friendship or health. Advice becomes an order when it is given with the weight of the office or of God's name: "God does not want you to take that job." "You must not marry him." "You are not to see your family." The person who receives it may not feel free to say no, because refusing seems to mean refusing God. This is especially heavy for people who depend on the minister, such as young people, newcomers, or people far from home.
Good use: the minister gives counsel as counsel, says "this is my view, and the decision is yours," offers to pray with the person, and then accepts the person's decision, even when it is a decision the minister would not make.
3. Two scenes of accountability
The Bible does not hide the ways that the leaders of God's people have failed. Two scenes are useful here.
Eli's household (1 Samuel 2). The passage describes sons of a priest who took what they wanted from the people's sacrifices. The text names a "custom," an arrangement that had grown up, in which the priest's servant took meat before the offering was properly given, and if the worshipper objected, the servant threatened force. The text says plainly that "the sin of the young men was very great before Yahweh," and that the men "despised the offering of Yahweh." The abuse of a sacred role had spread to the point where the worship itself was brought into contempt. This was not a private failing. It was a failing in a system, and the people who suffered were the ones who came to worship.
The chapter says also that Eli, the father and the senior priest, spoke to his sons about what they were doing (2:22-25). His words were not effective, and a later passage says that he "didn't restrain them" (3:13). Scripture's judgement is on the sons, and also on the one who could have acted. For ministry ethics this is important. A leader's responsibility includes more than his or her own conduct. It includes what he or she does when someone under his or her care is misusing the office. Talking is not always enough. Sometimes the person with the authority to act has to act.
Nathan before David (2 Samuel 12). David was king. He had misused his royal power against Uriah and Bathsheba, and the prophet Nathan came to him. Nathan did not accuse him at first. He told a story about a rich man and a poor man's one ewe lamb, and David's anger was aroused against the rich man. Then Nathan said, "You are the man." The prophet then reminded David that God had anointed him king, and had delivered him from Saul.
Three things stand out. First, Nathan spoke from outside the king's chain of command. The text says that Yahweh sent him; he came as God's messenger, not as David's employee. Someone who stands outside the line of authority is able to say what those inside cannot. Second, the king did not silence him. David said, "I have sinned against Yahweh" (12:13). A leader who can hear this kind of word is safe in a way that one who cannot is not. Third, notice that God says to David, "I anointed you king." The same word that is used in other places to say that a leader is not to be touched is here used in the rebuke. To be anointed is to be given a trust. It is not to be put out of reach of question.
4. "Do not touch my anointed ones": reading two texts in context
Two texts are sometimes used to say that people must not question, criticise or report a minister. They deserve a careful and fair reading, once.
Psalm 105:15. "Don't touch my anointed ones! Do my prophets no harm!" Read the verses before it. The psalm is telling the story of Abraham's family, who "went about from nation to nation," when they were "a few men in number, yes, very few, and foreigners" in the land (vv. 12-13). It says that God "allowed no one to do them wrong," and even "reproved kings for their sakes." The saying in verse 15 is God's protection of a small, wandering, vulnerable people against the powerful kings who might harm them. Most readers understand the "anointed ones" here as those patriarchs and the people they led. In its own setting the psalm is a word on behalf of the weak, against the strong. It was not written to shield a leader from the complaints of the people. Used to silence a person who has been harmed, it says nearly the opposite of what it meant.
1 Samuel 24. David had good reason to flee from King Saul. In a cave, his men urged him to kill Saul, who had come in unaware. David cut off the corner of Saul's robe and then felt remorse. He said, "Yahweh forbid that I should do this thing to my lord, Yahweh's anointed." David refused to use violence against the king. Notice what he did next. He went out of the cave and called after Saul, told him plainly what he had done and had not done, and said that he had not sinned against Saul, "though you hunt for my life." He asked that God judge between them (24:11-15). David refused to take vengeance by force. He did not say that Saul was above question, and he did not stay silent about it. He spoke to the king, honestly, to his face.
Both texts have something to teach. Neither says that a minister cannot be questioned. Psalm 105 is about God's care for the vulnerable. 1 Samuel 24 is about refusing to take revenge by force, and it shows a person speaking truth to the one who holds power. Neither says that a person who has been harmed must be silent. A reading that makes them say so is not a reading of the text; it is a use of the text.
Using Scripture to close a conversation
When a verse is used to stop a person from asking, reporting or objecting, the question to ask is not "Is the verse in the Bible?" but "What did it say to the people who first heard it, and is that what it is being used for now?" A text that was given to protect the weak should not be turned into a shield for the strong.
5. Signs to watch for, and how to use them
The following signs are questions to ask about a situation. Taken singly, each can have an innocent explanation. A cluster of them is a reason to look more carefully, and to ask someone outside the situation.
| Sign | The question to ask |
|---|---|
| Questions are met with reproach | When someone asks "why?", does the answer give reasons or give a rebuke? |
| Who is "in" and "out" depends on agreement with one person | Do those who disagree still keep their place and their respect? |
| People who leave are spoken of as faithless | Can a person leave on good terms? |
| Decisions affecting people are made out of their sight | Who knows how this was decided, and could they say so? |
| Private choices are settled by the minister | Does the person feel free to say "no" without being told they are refusing God? |
| One person has no one above, beside or outside who can question them | Who could say to this minister, "You are the man"? |
| Those who report concerns are punished or isolated | What happens to someone who raises a worry? |
A word on how not to use the list. It is not a way to decide that someone is a bad person. A minister who shows some of these signs may be tired, afraid, inexperienced, or simply doing what was done for them. The aim of the list is to ask better questions, to look for structures that can check what is happening, and, for the minister, to look honestly at his or her own conduct. A person who reads this list and thinks only of someone else has probably not understood it.
If the signs point to harm. If a situation involves abuse, assault, exploitation or a minor, the matter is different. The safety and the voice of the harmed person come first. Protecting a leader or an institution is never the answer. Do not try to settle it alone. Speak with a safeguarding person (someone your church or group names to protect people from harm), a trusted senior in your tradition or a qualified professional, follow local law, and, if there is danger now, call your local emergency number. Week 6 treats this fully.
6. Two small cases
(An invented example.) A volunteer group leader and a conference. A small youth group in a city is led by a respected volunteer. Two of the older teenagers attend a gathering for young people held by another church, and enjoy it. When they come back, the leader says, in front of the group, "I hope you remember who prayed for you when you had nothing." The next week the two are not asked to help with the music, as they used to be. Nothing is said openly. The group learns that a connection outside is a risk. What was crossed: a loyalty test, set without a word of rule. The teenagers had done nothing wrong, and the leader's need to feel appreciated turned into a way of managing them. A better path: the leader says, "Tell me what you enjoyed. I am glad you went." He might then ask, "Is there anything the group could learn from it?" If he feels hurt, he says so to another adult, not to the teenagers.
(An invented example.) A founder and a marriage. In a small independent fellowship, the founder is asked by a young woman for her blessing on her engagement. He says, "I have prayed and God has shown me that this is not the man." She and her parents, who depend on the fellowship for work and housing, do not feel able to disagree. She ends the engagement. Later, she wonders whether the answer came from God or from the founder's own fears. What was crossed: an order about private life, given in God's name, to someone who could not freely refuse. A better path: he can offer his view as one view: "I have a concern, and I will tell you what it is. I may be wrong. The decision is yours and your family's." He can also say that, because the family depends on the fellowship, he will ask an outside adviser to speak with them, so that no one feels the answer is a condition of staying.
Neither case depends on a particular tradition. Each shows how a minister who means well can narrow a person's freedom, and what the same minister could have done with the same power.
7. A last word: the minister is the first reader
If you hold authority, the first person to apply this lecture to is you. Look at each pattern and ask: where could I be doing this without knowing it? A minister seldom sees his or her own drift. That is why Week 5 asks about structures, such as colleagues, overseers and written promises, and not about resolve alone. A good minister is not one who has never been tempted by control, but one who has arranged for someone to notice.
Diagram 1. Five patterns, and the same power held well
In short
- Misuse is usually a drift from good motives, so "Does this person mean well?" is not the test. Ask what the authority is doing to the people under it.
- Five patterns: control, treating doubt as disobedience, loyalty tests, secrecy that protects the leader, and orders about private life.
- Eli's household shows a leader who spoke but did not restrain. Nathan shows someone outside the line of authority, and a king who could hear.
- Psalm 105:15 protects a small, vulnerable people; David in 1 Samuel 24 refuses violence yet speaks plainly. Neither silences a person who has been harmed.
- The list of signs is for asking questions, not for judging a person. Where harm, abuse or a minor is involved, the harmed person comes first.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Five patterns of misuse | Control; doubt treated as disobedience; loyalty tests; secrecy that protects the leader; orders about private life. |
| Eli's household | A role used for appetite; the senior priest spoke but "didn't restrain" his sons. |
| Nathan and David | An outsider confronts a king through a story; the king says "I have sinned"; God's own word calls David "anointed" in the rebuke. |
| Psalm 105:15 in context | A word of protection for a few, wandering, vulnerable people, not a shield for leaders against questions. |
One sentence to remember Authority drifts from its purpose by small steps, so a minister needs someone placed to notice.
This week's action Choose one of the five patterns and write down one way you could fall into it without knowing, and one person who could tell you.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Why is "Does this person mean well?" not enough as a test of how authority is used? What question does the lecture offer instead?
- Eli spoke to his sons, yet Scripture says he "didn't restrain them." What is the difference between speaking and restraining, and what does it imply for a leader today who sees a colleague misusing authority?
- Nathan stood outside David's chain of command. In the place where you serve, who is in the position to say "You are the man" to the leader, and would the leader listen?
- Read Psalm 105:12-15 and 1 Samuel 24:8-15 again. What does each text actually say to the people who first heard it? How might it be misused today, and why would that be a mistake?
- Choose one of the five patterns. Where might a minister fall into it without noticing, and what practical step could help the minister be warned in time?