FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

FS102E Ministry Ethics and Boundaries: Power, Money, Relationships, Accountability

Lecture 5-2: Shared Oversight

Contents 31
FS102E Ministry Ethics and Boundaries: Power, Money, Relationships, Accountability
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Power Given to Build Up
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Power Given to Build Up
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Power and Spiritual Authority
  1. Lecture 1-1: What Authority Is For
  2. Lecture 1-2: How Authority Is Misused
  3. Lecture 1-3: Unequal Power and Why Consent Is Not Enough
  4. Lecture 1-4: Authority and Accountability in Different Traditions
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, My Map of Power
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Money and Gifts
  1. Lecture 2-1: Scripture and the Minister's Money
  2. Lecture 2-2: Pay, Gifts and Conflicts of Interest
  3. Lecture 2-3: Openness and Shared Control
  4. Lecture 2-4: Honest Reports and Honest Appeals
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Checklist for My Money
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Relationships and Sexual Boundaries
  1. Lecture 3-1: Dual Relationships
  2. Lecture 3-2: Sexual and Romantic Boundaries
  3. Lecture 3-3: Meeting, Messaging and Online
  4. Lecture 3-4: Family, Favourites and Friends in Ministry
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: My Boundary Statement
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Confidence, Information and Honesty
  1. Lecture 4-1: What Is Told to You, and Where Silence Ends
  2. Lecture 4-2: Records, Data and Gossip
  3. Lecture 4-3: Honesty About Yourself and Your Work
  4. Lecture 4-4: When Silence Becomes Concealment
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab, An Honesty Check
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Structures of Accountability
  1. Lecture 5-1: Not Standing Alone
  2. Lecture 5-2: Shared Oversight
  3. Lecture 5-3: Codes of Conduct and Personal Covenants
  4. Lecture 5-4: Tired, Lonely and Hurt: When Ethics Gives Way
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: My Web of Accountability
Chapter 6 · Week 6: When Wrong Comes to Light
  1. Lecture 6-1: Mistake, Violation, Abuse
  2. Lecture 6-2: Taking Responsibility
  3. Lecture 6-3: The Harmed Person First
  4. Lecture 6-4: Forgiveness, Restoration and Return
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab, A Plan for the Day It Comes

Jump to the key points ↓

29 min

A friend can ask a minister hard questions. A friend cannot do much if the answers are bad. For that, a minister needs oversight: a person or a body, other than the minister, that has the right to ask, to see, to correct and, if it must, to remove. In this course, "oversight" means that kind of authority. It is different from support, and different from friendship.

Every community of Christians has some arrangement for this, even if it is not written down. In some it is a bishop and a diocese. In some it is elders or a council. In some it is the members as a whole. In some it is a founder and a small group of friends. In some, especially in remote and poor places, it is almost nothing. Lecture 1-4 described the main shapes and the strengths and risks of each. This lecture asks a different question: whatever the shape, what makes oversight real, and what can a minister do who has little or none?

The answer will not make the traditions the same. It will give a short list of tests that any arrangement can be held against, and some practical steps for a minister who serves where no body stands above.

What these 29 minutes give you

  • Explain the difference between support and oversight, and state four things oversight does.
  • Read Acts 14:23, Titus 1:5-9 and Hebrews 13:17 fairly, noting that Hebrews 13:17 speaks of leaders who "give account".
  • Apply six tests to an oversight arrangement and recognise one that exists only in name.
  • Name the strengths and the limits of plural leadership.
  • Explain why a minister must not decide his or her own pay or discipline alone, and what a good process for a call or a dismissal contains.
  • Describe what can be built where there is no body above, and state a point on which readers will not agree.

When they had appointed elders for them in every assembly, and had prayed with fasting, they commended them to the Lord, on whom they had believed." — Acts 14:23

World English Bible

I left you in Crete for this reason, that you would set in order the things that were lacking, and appoint elders in every city, as I directed you; if anyone is blameless, the husband of one wife, having children who believe, who are not accused of loose or unruly behavior. For the overseer must be blameless, as God’s steward; not self-pleasing, not easily angered, not given to wine, not violent, not greedy for dishonest gain; but given to hospitality, a lover of good, sober minded, fair, holy, self-controlled; holding to the faithful word which is according to the teaching, that he may be able to exhort in the sound doctrine, and to convict those who contradict him." — Titus 1:5-9

WEB

Obey your leaders and submit to them, for they watch on behalf of your souls, as those who will give account, that they may do this with joy, and not with groaning, for that would be unprofitable for you." — Hebrews 13:17

WEB

Take heed, therefore, to yourselves, and to all the flock, in which the Holy Spirit has made you overseers, to shepherd the assembly of the Lord and God which he purchased with his own blood." — Acts 20:28

WEB

Shepherd the flock of God which is among you, exercising the oversight, not under compulsion, but voluntarily, not for dishonest gain, but willingly; neither as lording it over those entrusted to you, but making yourselves examples to the flock." — 1 Peter 5:2-3

WEB

Elders are appointed in each community, in the plural, with prayer. The qualities asked of an overseer are the ones other people can see over time. The writer of Hebrews says that leaders will "give account". Peter asks elders not to lord it over those entrusted to them.

1. Support and oversight

The last lecture described companions: a peer, a mentor, a spiritual guide, a counsellor. They can ask and advise. If the minister ignores them, they may be sad, but they have no power to act.

Oversight is the point at which a person or body can act. Four functions belong to it.

Appointing. Someone other than the minister decides who will be a minister here: who is called, ordained, sent, confirmed or accepted for a post. This is where the first check takes place, before any wrong has happened.

Supervising ordinary work. Someone with the right to ask how the work is going: the schedule, the teaching, the finances, the relationships. In some communities this takes the form of a visit, a report, a review or a regular meeting.

Receiving concerns. Someone to whom a member, a colleague or a child's parent can bring a worry about the minister, without going through the minister. Without this, a person who sees something wrong has nowhere to go.

Correcting and, if needed, removing. The ability to say "this must change", to set conditions, to suspend, and in the last resort to end a minister's work in a post or in the ministry. A body that has all the others and not this one can only advise.

A minister who has companions but no oversight has a half structure. A minister who has an oversight body that never sees anything real has no structure at all, as the next sections show.

2. What the Scripture shows, read fairly

Acts 14:23 tells us that Paul and Barnabas "appointed elders for them in every assembly". Two small details deserve attention. The appointment is of elders, plural, in each place, so the earliest picture of local leadership is not one person standing alone. And the appointment is made with prayer and fasting, and by others, not by the person appointed.

Titus 1:5-9 gives qualities for elders and for the overseer: "blameless", "not self-pleasing, not easily angered, not given to wine, not violent, not greedy for dishonest gain", "given to hospitality", "fair", "self-controlled". Every one of them can be observed by other people over time. A community can ask whether a person is easily angered or greedy for dishonest gain, and neighbours can answer. The passage assumes that a minister's character is the community's business. (Traditions differ on who may hold the office the passage describes. This lecture uses it only for the point that character is open to the view of others.) Notice also the phrase "as God's steward." A steward is a person who looks after what belongs to someone else and must answer to the owner.

Hebrews 13:17 reads: "Obey your leaders and submit to them, for they watch on behalf of your souls, as those who will give account." This verse has been used in two opposite ways. Some leaders have quoted its first words to demand obedience from those they lead. That reads half the verse. The verse says that leaders themselves "will give account", so accountability is built into it. It also gives the reason for the leaders' authority: they watch for the souls of others. It is an authority held for the sake of those who are watched, and answerable to God. A leader who uses the verse to silence questions has quoted it against its own second half.

How far the obedience in the first half of the verse reaches is a question on which traditions differ. The point of disagreement below touches it.

3. Six tests of real oversight

Any arrangement can be held against these six questions. They apply to a bishop and a diocese, to a council of elders, to a congregation's board, to a mission society and to a founder's circle of advisers.

  1. Independence. Are the people who oversee free of the minister's control? A board made up of the minister's relatives, employees or people who depend on the minister for favours is not independent, however sincere its members.
  2. Information. Do they see what is actually happening: the accounts, the schedule, the complaints, the way people are treated? Oversight that sees only what the minister chooses to report is oversight of a report.
  3. Access. Can a member, a colleague or a parent reach them without going through the minister, and does everyone know how?
  4. Willingness to act. Have they ever said no, set a condition, or asked for a change? A body that has never once disagreed has either found a perfect minister or a body that does not act.
  5. Written terms. Is it written down who can do what, how a concern is raised, how long a process takes, and what happens at the end? A rule that nobody can read can be changed by whoever is strongest.
  6. Protection of the one who raises a concern. Can a person raise a worry without losing a place, a job, a home or standing? If raising a concern is dangerous, people will stop doing it.

(An invented example.) A board in name only. A church has a board of three: the founder-pastor's brother, a long-time friend, and a member whose business the church uses. The board meets once a year to approve the accounts, which the pastor presents. No member has ever raised a concern, and no member knows whom to tell. Nobody on the board means harm. But the board fails the first, second, third and sixth tests. It has no independence, sees only a summary, cannot be reached without the pastor, and gives nobody protection. A better arrangement keeps the three friends and adds two people with no tie to the pastor, gives the accounts to the board before the meeting, writes down a way for any member to write to the chair, and records that a person who raises a concern in good faith will not be penalised.

4. Plural leadership: what it gives and what it does not

Acts 14:23 pictures plural leadership, and in most traditions it is the normal way of carrying oversight: a council, a session, a board, a chapter, a synod, a team of elders. It has real strengths.

  • More eyes. A single person sees from one place. A group sees from several.
  • Shared load. As Jethro saw, no one person can carry the whole.
  • Correction from within. A colleague can say "I disagree" at a table.
  • Continuity. When one leader is ill or leaves, the work does not fall.

It also has limits, and a lecture on ethics should say them plainly.

  • Diffusion of responsibility. When six people are responsible, each may assume that another has asked the hard question. A shared duty is easily a duty no one performs.
  • Group loyalty. Members of a leadership team often become friends. A team that has worked together for years finds it hard to say no to one of its own, and may be tempted to settle a matter "within the family" (lecture 4-4 returns to this).
  • A chair who controls. If one person sets the agenda, writes the minutes and decides who is heard, the group may be plural in number only.
  • A group that protects itself. A body can come to treat its reputation, or the reputation of the community, as the thing it exists to guard. In that case it has stopped being oversight of a minister and become the minister's defence.

A plural body is helped by simple rules: the minister is not the chair; the minister leaves the room when pay, discipline or the minister's own work is discussed; each member may put a matter on the agenda; minutes are kept and seen; and at least one member is outside the minister's circle of friends and family.

5. How much deference an office deserves, and who has the final word

This is a point where readers will not agree: how much authority a body outside the local congregation should have over the local minister, and how much the local people should have.

Some hold that real oversight needs authority beyond the local gathering: a bishop, a synod, a senior body. Their reasons are strong. A congregation may be too close to its minister, too divided or too dependent on him or her to act freely. A minister who has moved from place to place might be known only to the wider body. And the Church is not only local, so a local community should not be the last word about the ministry it receives.

Others hold that final authority belongs to the local gathering, or to its elders, who live with the consequences and know the minister. Their reasons are also strong. Distant authorities may not know the place, may be slow, and may protect their own institution. A local body can be quicker, closer to the people harmed, and more truly answerable to them. Those who hold the first view reply that a local body can also shield its own, as the section on plural leadership says. Each side knows the other's weakness.

Others again, in independent and charismatic communities, rely on the relationship between a founder, a network and the people, and say that formal structure can replace trust with procedure.

This course does not settle the matter and does not rank the traditions. It requires less than any of them requires: there must be some person or body other than the minister, with independence, with real information, with ways for others to reach it, and with the capacity to act. Where a tradition supplies that, use it. Where it does not, build it.

6. Pay, appointment and dismissal

Two parts of oversight are especially open to conflicts of interest.

Deciding the minister's own pay. A minister should not be the only person, or even one of the deciding persons, when his or her own pay, housing, allowances or expenses are set. A minister may supply facts (what the work involves, what the costs are). The decision belongs to others, who should leave the minister out of the room for it, and who should write down what they decided and why. Lecture 2-3 explained why, and the practice of handling money is taught in Church Finance in Practice: Budgets, Records and Safeguards (PT712E). In a very small community, where the oversight is the minister's neighbours, the same principle holds in a simple form: at least two others decide, and the congregation knows what the arrangement is.

Appointing and ending a ministry. Different traditions call, send, appoint and remove ministers in different ways: a bishop assigns, a congregation votes, a board hires, a founder invites. Whatever the way, a fair process has some common marks. The person knows what is expected. Concerns are put to the person in plain terms. The person can answer, and be heard by people who are not already decided. Reasons are written. There is notice and, where the matter allows, a chance to put things right. And someone other than the minister's relatives and close friends decides.

Employment and charity law differs across countries and regions, and it affects dismissal in ways this course cannot describe. Follow local law and the written rules of your community, and where a matter is serious, ask a qualified person.

A warning is needed here. Some matters are not ordinary disputes about a minister's work. If the concern is that a person has been harmed, or that a child or vulnerable adult is at risk, the aim of the body is not to settle the matter quietly, or to protect the minister, the community or its name. The harmed person's safety and voice come first (lecture 6-3 takes this up), the proper authorities are told as local law and the community's written rules require, and the body does not investigate or mediate alone. An oversight body that treats such a concern as a question of public image has failed at the one thing it exists for.

Conflict between a minister and a congregation, and how to lead through it, belongs to Leading Through Change and Conflict (PT714E).

7. Where there is no body above

Many ministers read this and think: there is no one above me. I am the pastor of an independent congregation, or I am the only worker in a mission, or I serve in a place where the denominational office is far away or has little interest. What then?

Oversight cannot be declared into being by the person who is to be overseen. A minister cannot say "I have appointed myself an overseer" and have achieved it. But a minister can put authority into the hands of others, in writing, and then keep to it. Several steps are possible.

Choose an outside adviser or small panel. One to three people from outside the congregation: an older minister from another place, a retired church leader, a respected lay person with experience of administration. Choose people who are not your relatives, not your employees, not dependent on your goodwill, and able to say no. At least one should have nothing to gain from your good opinion.

Write a with them. A short written agreement setting out what they may ask to see (accounts, the way you spend your time, any complaint), how often you will meet, whom a member may contact if they have a worry about you and how that person will be protected, what you will do if they ask for a change, and what happens if you refuse. A covenant of this kind is not a legal contract; it is a promise, and its force comes from being known. Lecture 5-3 treats covenants.

Tell the congregation. The adviser's name and a way to reach him or her should be known by the members. An oversight that nobody can reach is not oversight.

Give them something real to see. An adviser who is shown only a summary can do nothing. Agree that they will see the accounts, the pay arrangements and any concern raised.

Ask for a review. Once a year, ask the adviser or panel to hold a conversation with you and, if you are willing, with some members of the congregation about how things are going.

Decide in advance what refusal means. If you refuse their advice on a serious matter, the covenant should say what follows (for example, that the adviser will tell the congregation).

(An invented example.) A planter and a panel of three. A man has started a house church and is its only leader. He has no denomination. After a year, he asks two ministers from other towns and a retired teacher who attends a different church to meet him twice a year. He gives them the accounts, tells them his pay, and writes a one-page agreement that any member may write to any of them. At the first meeting the teacher asks why the pastor's rent is paid from the church fund without the members knowing. The planter had not thought it a secret; he had not thought about it at all. The members are told. Nothing wrong had happened, and now one thing less can.

This is not as strong as a bishop or a council with legal authority. But it is real if it is written, known and used. And it is much stronger than nothing.


Diagram 1. Four functions of oversight and six tests

Shared Oversight Someone other than the minister who can act 1. APPOINTING who is called, sent or accepted 2. SUPERVISING asking how the work is going 3. RECEIVING a concern, without going through the minister 4. CORRECTING conditions, pause, and in the last resort, removal Six tests of real oversight 1. Independence: free of the minister's control 2. Information: sees what is actually happening 3. Access: can be reached without the minister 4. Willingness to act: has said no before 5. Written terms: who can do what, and how 6. Protection for the one who raises a concern Apply the same tests to a bishop, a board, a council or a founder's circle. Limits of plural leadership Shared duty can be no one's duty. Friends find it hard to say no. Harm to a person is not a matter of public image The harmed person comes first.

Diagram 2. Where there is no body above: the steps

Step What it means
Choose One to three outsiders who cannot be pressed by you and can say no
Write A short covenant: what they may see, how often, whom a member may contact, what follows a refusal
Tell The congregation knows their names and how to reach them
Show The accounts, the pay arrangements, and any concern raised
Review Once a year, a conversation about how things are going

In short

  • Support can ask and advise; oversight can act. Oversight appoints, supervises, receives concerns, and corrects or removes.
  • Hebrews 13:17 says leaders "will give account"; used to demand obedience alone, it is quoted against its own second half.
  • Six tests of real oversight: independence, information, access, willingness to act, written terms, protection for the one who raises a concern.
  • Plural leadership gives more eyes and shared load, but it can spread duty thin, shield friends, and become a body guarding its own name.
  • A minister must not decide his or her own pay or discipline; a concern about harm to a person is never treated as a matter of public image.
  • Where no body stands above, a minister can place authority in the hands of outsiders, in writing, known and used.
Front Back
Four functions of oversight Appointing, supervising ordinary work, receiving concerns, correcting and if needed removing.
Six tests of real oversight Independence, information, access, willingness to act, written terms, protection for the one who raises a concern.
What this course requires of any arrangement Some person or body other than the minister, with independence, real information, ways to be reached, and the capacity to act.
Where there is no body above Outside advisers, a written covenant, members told how to reach them, real things to see, a yearly review.

One sentence to remember Oversight is real when someone other than the minister can see the facts, be reached, and act on them.

This week's action Write down who oversees your work or the work you know best, and score it against the six tests with a yes, a no or "not sure" for each.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Who, in the place you know best, can act if a minister goes wrong: ask, see, correct, and remove? Does that person or body pass the six tests?
  • Hebrews 13:17 asks for obedience and also says that leaders "will give account". How would you answer a leader who quoted only the first half?
  • State fairly the strongest argument for authority beyond the local gathering, and the strongest argument for local authority. What do you think each side is afraid of?
  • A leadership team has worked together for fifteen years. What can it do to keep the ability to say no to one of its own?
  • If you served where no body stands above you, which two people would you ask, and what would you show them first?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.